3 ms·
Exactly. Just because it's "illegal" doesn't mean it can't be done -- just as, just because what the government asks is "legal" (??!?) doesn't mean it has to be
by bambax 13y ago
Exactly. Just because it's "illegal" doesn't mean it can't be done -- just as, just because what the government asks is "legal" (??!?) doesn't mean it has to be complied with.
"What will happen?" is an excellent question that is not even asked. Certainly not everything is an acceptable risk; if Larry Page seriously believe he would risk spending the rest of his life in prison for publishing national security letters, then sure, we'd all do the same.
But is this the case? How do we even know if nobody's testing it?
Besides, why can't Google or Facebook be a little creative, and (for example) declare that the only way they'll be able to send information is by fax...?
That's kind of what HN is doing (it will only accept DMCA requests via fax or regular mail).
- threeseed 13y agoBecause CEOs need to act like adults not petulant little children. You obey the law. Period. And if you don't agree with it you lobby directly or encourage your users to do so.
- wavefunction 13y agoNot if the law is immoral, but run along little authoritarian.
- bambax 13y agoThe whole business model of Silicon Valley is based on not obeying the law. It's called "disrupting", and how it works is "let's break laws and regulations we disagree with until they're either changed or recognized as obsolete". This is how Uber works, or AirBnB... but not only. Facebook or Google routinely ignore European privacy laws. Twitter ignores European laws about free speech (which you and I may consider "bad" laws, but which are laws nonetheless). So why is it that suddenly everyone hides behind the "law"?
- chii 13y agoyou don't have to obey the law, you choose to obey. When you decide to not obey the law, you also decide to face the consequences. When the law doesn't sit well with you, you should indeed choose to not obey, then fight the consequences.