7 ms·
Lately, I've come to realize that the September 11 attacks actually destroyed America. In the grand scheme of things, the attacks themselves caused minimal dam
by enraged_camel 13y ago
Lately, I've come to realize that the September 11 attacks actually destroyed America.
In the grand scheme of things, the attacks themselves caused minimal damage and casualties. We're only talking about ~3,000 deaths and ~$30 billion damage.
But look at the aftermath. The Iraq War itself cost the USA $5 trillion, and another ~4,500 lives (American lives, that is. The total number of casualties is well over 100,000). At home, the PATRIOT Act enabled countless breaches of freedom, and the TSA has cost untold number of hours wasted at airports. And now this NSA bullshit.
All of this is beyond Osama bin Laden's wildest dreams. The guy just organized a couple of airplanes to be rammed into the WTC towers. Heck, he didn't even expect them to go down, and was pleasantly surprised when it happened. In light of all the freedoms America lost since then though, he must be dancing in his grave right now.
- tptacek 13y agoThis is an understandable but ahistorical perspective. There was a time not long ago when wiretaps weren't yet considered searches, and where voicing support for communism could get you dragged in front of a tribunal. The ideals of this country aren't an end-state; they're a goal that we will constantly struggle to achieve.
- danso 13y agoYeah, this cannot be emphasized enough. I know it was a long time ago, but how can anyone say that "Well, this country has truly fallen into a shithole" when, for about a hundred years, we were OK with enslaving an entire race of people, and justified it out of desire for economic stability? Ideals take time and perseverance...thank goodness for organizations like the ACLU and the EFF
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>how can anyone say that "Well, this country has truly fallen into a shithole" when, for about a hundred years, we were OK with enslaving an entire race of people, and justified it out of desire for economic stability? Well, looking at the number of prisoners we have, and the atrocious way we treat them, I don't think that part has changed very much, except in scale.
- einhverfr 13y agoKeep in mind that for all practical purposes, prisoners are in a position of involuntary servitude for the private gain of others (what is perhaps the simplest definition of slavery one can construct).
- jlgreco 13y agoToo add to what you are saying, here is the section 1 of the 13th amendment: "Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction." Slavery is straight up legal in America if you first secure a conviction. Anyone who pretends to themselves that we are not still openly using slave labor is absolutely delusional.
- einhverfr 13y agoRead "The Servile State" by Hilaire Belloc for where this is leading ;-) For lower classes, prison (and prison servitude) is becoming the safety net.
- tolmasky 13y agoAnd if you don't believe this or think its hyperbole, just remember that it's precisely why the 13th amendment contains the phrase "except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted"
- einhverfr 13y agoAlso note that for a segment of the population, that is the safety net too, just as Hilaire Belloc predicted in "The Servile State" (which he wrote in 1914).
- monsterix 13y agoVery well said. And here is that description of scale [1]: As of 2009 "The United States has the highest documented incarceration rate in the world." "The United States' incarceration rate is, according to 2009 figures, 743 persons imprisoned per 100,000 (as of 2009). The United States has 5% of the world's population and 25% of the world's incarcerated population." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_States#Incarceration_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_Sta...
- sillysaurus 13y agoThat's a fine-sounding statement, but unfortunately the September 11th attacks did destroy the America many of us grew up in. It gave the perfect excuse for unprecidented empire expansion into the Middle East, and expansion of domestic power far beyond anything balanced or reasonable, all in the name of safety. Which is to say, in the name of terror.
- tptacek 13y agoDuring the Cold War it wasn't simply the subtextual goal of the US to expand its influence in strategic regions but its outright goal; in fact, our problems in West Asia stem in large part from the Cold War and its idiotic attendant strategy of propping up despots to avoid Soviet communism. The Iraq War was a terrible blunder, but it pales in comparison to Vietnam, which inflicted horrible costs on the US but even worse costs on the Vietnamese and Cambodian people, whose civilian populations were carpet bombed with napalm. No plan survives first contact with the enemy. Speaking of which, if you're really ready to engage with the 20th Century, imagine what would have happened had the Soviets "won". Read about the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan. It will be another 100 years, at least, until we're no longer feeling the immediate aftershocks of colonialism.
- sillysaurus 13y agoWhy are we comparing blunders with even larger blunders? It sounds like you're saying "this isn't that bad." Why, though? It's still very bad, and should probably be opposed, not justified. Can you help me get into your head a bit?
- tptacek 13y agoSay the NSA really is reading all of our emails, and that that's happening because of 9/11. That would be an enormous setback for civil liberties. But it wouldn't be indicative of a terminal condition; our country has weathered worse, and what's important (over the long term) is that our compass points towards liberty and that we keep struggling to go where it points us.
- MartinCron 13y agoOr, "if you stop watching Raiders of the Lost Ark halfway through, the Nazis win"
- newnewnew 13y agoIf we're going to discuss McCarthyism, we need to remember that the US government was riddled with soviet spies during the Roosevelt administration[1][2][3][4]. Communist spies outside of government were also instrumental to soviet espionage efforts, including the theft of nuclear technology[5][6]. McCarthy was responding to real threats, although my high school history class didn't talk much about them. Members of the Communist Party USA were instrumental in the Soviets obtaining weapons to destroy life as we know it and the lesson we take from the period is that McCarthy was a bad guy. McCarthy wrote a book arguing that the Soviet Union was the real winner of WWII[7], thanks to the help of willing US accomplices. Looking at the map of Europe before and after the war you have to admit the guy has a case. But who would read a book by Joseph McCarthy? [1] http://foseti.wordpress.com/2013/03/06/harry-dexter-white/ http://foseti.wordpress.com/2013/03/06/harry-dexter-white/, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Dexter_White http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Dexter_White [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_Silvermaster http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_Silvermaster [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perlo_group http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perlo_group [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alger_Hiss http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alger_Hiss [5] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_Rosenberg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_Rosenberg [6] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whittaker_Chambers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whittaker_Chambers [7] http://foseti.wordpress.com/2012/08/19/review-of-americas-retreat-from-victory-by-joseph-r-mccarthy/ http://foseti.wordpress.com/2012/08/19/review-of-americas-re...;
- einhverfr 13y agoEspionage efforts are one thing, but when people are jailed for "inciting rebellion" for the "crime" of distributing the writings of Karl Marx, the undeniable fact that there were lots of spies here (as we had lots of spies there) falls so far short of justifying the sorts of abuses that went on. The government argued that the Communist Party USA had no right to spread political ideas in the US, and targetted lawyers who dared to defend them. Whatever the extent of Soviet spying in the US (and it would have been extensive for obvious reasons, as with the other side), the McCarthy era was an assault on the foundations of democracy in this country. If you want to justify that because the threat is real, I suppose we should just give up on this whole Constitutional Rights thing....
- grandalf 13y agoHowever never before has there been such tremendous propaganda effort designed to conceal from public view policies that have been considered morally abhorrent for decades.
- tptacek 13y agoAre you fucking kidding me? No, that's not within 100 miles of the truth.
- grandalf 13y agocounterexample?
- tptacek 13y agoI'm going to with "Entire Vietnam War" on that. No, wait: how about the Sandinista war, which was so well concealed nobody even fucking knew it happened. You think terrorists drove us mad with fear, try actually reading some of the history of the 20th century and imagine what we would have done, in an era before our modern feeling of entitlement to privacy and to open dissent, when our enemy was vast, spectacularly well-armed, beat us into space, and had nuclear missiles pointed in our face. The compass points towards liberty, but sometimes we walk east, or west, or, during the Kennedy and Nixon and Reagan administrations, fucking south.
- grandalf 13y agoFair point. However the public actually dissented due to Vietnam, which indicates that the propaganda effort was unsuccessful. In today's world, consent has been effectively manufactured.
- tptacek 13y agoTwas. Ever. Thus. They protested Vietnam, and sometimes the National Guard mowed them down with assault rifles. The notion that protesters ended the Vietnam war is also ahistorical, a fiction designed to flatter the boomers.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoJust curious, has this whole issue led you to at least entertain the thought that CISPA might be worse than you previously thought? Or are your views on that unshaken?
- tptacek 13y agoNo; the opposite. This is what para-legal surveillance looks like, not CISPA.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoHah, unbelievable. This is exactly what CISPA was for. How do you not see that.
- tptacek 13y agoDid you actually read CISPA?
- smsm42 13y ago>>> voicing support for communism could get you dragged in front of a tribunal I bet voicing support to a state-sponsored terrorist organisation with officially declared goal of violently overthrowing US government could get you into some trouble anytime. Especially if you work for government and have access to sensitive data.
- jacquesm 13y agoPeople tend to view things through the lens of their own life-time. So for someone who looked at the USA prior to 9/11 to look at it today and to conclude that a lot of damage has been done would be accurate. What it looks like a hundred years from now is something nobody can make a reasonable stab at. Chances are that by then this has healed and gotten better, chances are that it will get much worse. "This too shall pass" applies forever, and countries have been born and have disintegrated long before they managed to achieve their goals.
- smokeyj 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_flag#As_pretexts_for_war http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_flag#As_pretexts_for_war
- damoncali 13y agoDon't be so sure. This isn't over yet. Back in the day, the feds roamed about with orders to kill. Vigilance is the key. People freak out. Then we reign them back in.
- dylangs1030 13y agoYou're minimizing the 9/11 terrorist attacks. I don't want arbitrary or harmful laws enforced in the name of counter-terrorism anymore than you do, but don't act as though 3000 lives lost in a direct attack on our soil are insignificant by any measure. For all it's doing wrong, the NSA has a goal in mind to try to protect the American people. If its methods become cancerous that is one thing, but factor in the intentions here. They are not trying to ruin lives, even though their perspectives might be warped.
- sillysaurus 13y agoFor all it's doing wrong, the NSA has a goal in mind to try to protect the American people. If its methods become cancerous that is one thing, but factor in the intentions here. They are not trying to ruin lives, even though their perspectives might be warped. This idea is mistaken because nobody knows what their intents are. Your idea of "just trust them" isn't comforting; quite the opposite.
- dylangs1030 13y agoNo, no I don't advocate blindly trusting them. My point is that they are not comparable to enemies like Osama bin Laden.
- einhverfr 13y agoThey are not comparable to Osama bin Ladin. bin Ladin cannot do more than add a tiny increment to the risk that Americans go through every day in life. The government, however, by monopolizing violence, can then use that violence to take away anything that makes life good. A government that has lost accountability is far more dangerous than a terrorist organization. If you don't believe that, ask those who fled the Soviet Union, or who lived through Saddam's regime in Iraq.
- betterunix 13y agoOsama Bin Laden is dead, remember? Who is our enemy now? At what point is the war on terror over -- when do we declare victory? The problem here is that there is no end to this. It will drag on and on, with more and more freedoms lost as long as people continue to cower in fear like this.
- greenlander 13y agoYes, this times one thousand. The terrorists won this round.
- clicks 13y ago> Lately, I've come to realize that the September 11 attacks actually destroyed America. I'm not so sure about that. As I learned in another thread, for example, that NSA had been requesting phone records of __BEFORE__ Sept. 11: Former Qwest CEO Joseph Nacchio, convicted of insider trading in April 2007, alleged in appeal documents that the NSA requested that Qwest participate in its wiretapping program __more than six months before September 11, 2001__. Nacchio recalls the meeting as occurring on February 27, 2001. Nacchio further claims that the NSA cancelled a lucrative contract with Qwest as a result of Qwest's refusal to participate in the wiretapping program See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_for_NSA_spying http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_for_NSA_spying for more.
- nijk 13y agoBut in 2001 Qwest refused. Now refusal is illegal.
- newnewnew 13y agoSince Lincoln, we've been heading towards a more powerful, authoritarian, and centralized government. (many people would point to FDR, but an FDR is inevitable once you have a Lincoln). Since limited government lasted in America for less than 100 years, I assume it was an unstable state. I don't mourn its passing, it was inevitable. Instead I think of how to make better places to live, and technology to fight the authoritarians.
- einhverfr 13y agoBut is unlimited government fundamentally authoritarian?
- zanny 13y agoI'd argue yes, because with unlimited government you can continuously apply more government to solve problems, but because the only people who could rescind government are those elected into the positions of ruling government, and more government gives you more control, influence, and power, it is directly antithesis the best interests of those in power to actively reduce the influence of the government they rule.
- einhverfr 13y agoAdditionally you have the problem of cascading intervention. Every use of more government power both solves problems and creates them, and those new problems require more government power to solve, until you have so much invested effort the next step causes the whole thing to collapse ;-)
- smky80 13y ago> All of this is beyond Osama bin Laden's wildest dreams Just putting this all in a bit of perspective: This is some character that, after those two buildings were hit by planes and three buildings collapsed into dust, we were shown a picture of and told he did it. He released a few Tupac-style mixtapes, we fought a few wars to go get this guy and his friends, and then we were told ten years later we finally got him and his body was dumped somewhere in the ocean. But we're still fighting those wars.
- gasull 13y ago9/11 destroyed the Western World. European countries have followed the US and now they're less free than they used to be. Is there a single country that is reasonably free and where freedom is increasing instead of decreasing?
- joelrunyon 13y agoEstonia. Seriously [1]. 1. http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking Lots more too.
- dirtyaura 13y agoThat list is a total joke. Norway is below UAE where you get several years of jail for concensual sex between adults. EDIT: it's a list measuring economic freedom so it's clearly not relevant to discussion about PRISM.
- ryguytilidie 13y ago"The Iraq War itself cost the USA $5 trillion, and another ~4,500 lives (American lives, that is. The total number of casualties is well over 100,000)." Honestly I feel like the most understated danger in all of this is the 95,500 non-American deaths presumably caused by Americans. I imagine that each of those 95,500 or so has a family and many people who are angry and looking for revenge. It's pretty incredible that we have done all of this in the name of "safety" and have simply gone out of our way to recruit hundreds of thousands of people who want to kill Americans. Utterly amazing how modern human logic works.
- zanny 13y ago> Utterly amazing how modern human logic works. It isn't logical, its emotional. There is no logic in imperialism given historical evidence against it.
- einhverfr 13y agoSure there is logic. We are talking about destroying America. We are talking about us and therefore the rest gets omitted. If we want to talk about what the blowback will be from the Iraq war, then the rest of that is very relevant though.
- adventured 13y ago9/11 was just convenient. It could have been anything large enough. The politicians in power were and are rotten to the core, all they needed was an opening. To quote the political axiom: never waste a good crisis (or tragedy). They rarely do.
- arcadeparade 13y agoOver 1 million people were killed in Iraq, with 1 in 4 dead, injured or a refugee.
- iterationx 13y agoHow did OBL get NORAD to stand down? You haven't realized anything.
- sneak 13y agoI used to think this. I don't entirely disagree. But: > “The American of today, in fact, probably enjoys less personal liberty than any other man of Christendom, and even his political liberty is fast succumbing to the new dogma that certain theories of government are virtuous and lawful, and others abhorrent and felonious. Laws limiting the radius of his free activity multiply year by year: It is now practically impossible for him to exhibit anything describable as genuine individuality, either in action or in thought, without running afoul of some harsh and unintelligible penalty. It would surprise no impartial observer if the motto “In God we trust” were one day expunged from the coins of the republic by the Junkers at Washington, and the far more appropriate word, “verboten,” substituted. Nor would it astound any save the most romantic if, at the same time, the goddess of liberty were taken off the silver dollars to make room for a bas-relief of a policeman in a spiked helmet. Moreover, this gradual (and, of late, rapidly progressive) decay of freedom goes almost without challenge; the American has grown so accustomed to the denial of his constitutional rights and to the minute regulation of his conduct by swarms of spies, letter-openers, informers and agents provocateurs that he no longer makes any serious protest.” That was written by H. L. Mencken in 1920. I think about things like the Japanese internment camps the US set up during WW2, and I imagine that it must've always been pretty fucking bad. Destroyed though it is. I left everything behind to move somewhere better. It's tough, but it's worth it.