13 ms·
Tech companies, bristling, concede to government surveillance program
- chris_mahan 13y agoTwitter said no? I like twitter more!
- weisser 13y agoTwitter by nature is very public messaging platform and therefore this data is less private. I'd be curious how many DMs are sent compared to public tweets.
- Mystalic 13y agoThis is a lesson in the power of language. The companies involved and their denials of knowledge of PRISM were not lies, but clearly they were making it easier for the government to extract data for surveillance, under an unnamed program with specific point people in each company who were only allowed to talk to the government and not talk to their CEOs about the extent in which the government was extracting data. It may go even deeper. We just don't know. The thing that upsets me most is that I suspect nobody except for the whistleblower will take any real heat. I hope more will come forward with more details in the coming weeks, before the government makes an example of the whisteblower. Will this incident change user behavior? I doubt it. We're too dependent on these companies to cut them off en masse.
- ritchiea 13y agoI dunno, it sounds to me like the companies in question were being hit with a lot of government requests and they did the natural thing to take them seriously and make it easy for their employees to deal with: make an API for it and automate the parts of the process that can be automated. It is inevitable they are going to be hit with requests for information, they could dig their heels in on some things but ultimately they legally have to provide some of the information requested. They could have implemented APIs without any idea of how the NSA structured or code named the technology internally on the NSA's side. And I'm sure Google, Facebook, et al implemented whatever they implemented with little knowledge of how other companies were complying or not. What I imagine happened is that any company that took compliance seriously, likely for their own staff's benefit, as a side effect became a stronger asset to the NSA than companies like Twitter who resisted. And lastly, I'm not saying any of this is good. It just seems extremely plausible and not part of a massive conspiracy to give the NSA access to as much data as possible.
- Mystalic 13y agoI don't think there's a conspiracy here. Just bad decisions.
- glenra 13y ago> It just seems extremely plausible and not part of a massive conspiracy to give the NSA access to as much data as possible. Wait, why can't it be both of those things? What could the phrase "massive conspiracy" mean if it doesn't apply to a situation like this? "conspiracy" suggests a bunch of people were trying to accomplish a goal in secret, at odds with the interests of the general public. Yup! "massive" implies significant scale - that it was a LOT of people sharing a LOT of information. Check! I'm not seeing anything missing...
- ritchiea 13y agoSome things happen in secret but are not part of a conspiracy. Conspiracies require secrecy because they are unlawful or unethical. It is codified into law (which is public) that the US gov will make classified information requests like the ones presented to the companies in question. Automating the exchange of information that the government has announced will by law be exchanged is not a conspiracy even if the specifics of what information is exchanged and the mechanics of the exchange are a secret.
- _delirium 13y agoIn at least two cases, at Google and Facebook, one of the plans discussed was to build separate, secure portals, like a digital version of the secure physical rooms that have long existed for classified information, in some instances on company servers. Through these online rooms, the government would request data, companies would deposit it and the government would retrieve it, people briefed on the discussions said. If true, that would explain the very carefully worded language of both Google and Facebook that they did not give the NSA "direct access" to their servers.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 13y agoIn one recent instance, the National Security Agency sent an agent to a tech company’s headquarters to monitor a suspect in a cyberattack, a lawyer representing the company said. The agent installed government-developed software on the company’s server and remained at the site for several weeks to download data to an agency laptop. Uh, wow.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoSounds like...direct access.
- runn1ng 13y agoIn at least two cases, at Google and Facebook, one of the plans discussed was to build separate, secure portals, like a digital version of the secure physical rooms that have long existed for classified information, in some instances on company servers. Through these online rooms, the government would request data, companies would deposit it and the government would retrieve it, people briefed on the discussions said. So THAT is why all the responses repeated "direct access".
- mpyne 13y agoDoes this mean I was right? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5843051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5843051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5843029 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5843029
- rdl 13y agoProbably, although IMO this was pretty obvious from the $20mm budget. The only question was "is it a repurposing of the existing law enforcement API" or something slightly unique, and was it "Google/FB in the loop" or totally automated. NSA presumably wouldn't want most Google employees to know they're FISAing info on KSM. They may be willing to read in a few Google employees to handle turning over the data, though. There may be some special magic to hide the actual target from Google while Google still gets to review the order itself. (the name of the target is presumably non-meaningful to Google).
- cromwellian 13y agoSo basically, PRISM is just a system for negotiating electronic dead-drop locations to pick up data when companies are compelled by an NSL to archive and copy an individuals data? If it were done by printing out the data and dropping a physical box in a pre approved location, would be be as scandalous? What are we to believe PRISM is now? Is it a) a firehose feed that allocates arbitrary, indisriminate, ad-hoc querying over large swaths of user data in cloud datacenters? or b) is it an automated system for sending out National Security Letters, and the polling dropbox locations for compliance, and then importing the data into some centralized government intelligence repository? a) is an absolute outrage, there should be rioting in front of congress and the whitehouse b) is pretty much just making delivery of information they are compelled to legally deliver more efficient. Although if I were these companies, I'd make it as painful as possible by printing all of the information requested on sheets of paper in Comic Sans and mailing it USPS.
- spydum 13y agoIs mailing hard copies more secure? I tend to think of phone calls and hard copies as less secure.
- c0nfused 13y agoI don't particularly mind the security implications of the technique. However, It certainly is less convenient if you are the recipient.
- Achshar 13y agoIt's easy, we encode encrypted audio data in binary, print out the 0s and 1s on an eco friendly paper and send the bundle off in mail. It is pretty secure since they will be the only one with private key.</s>
- msabalau 13y agoJust because the system described in the article exists, is there any reason to believe that it is PRISM? Couldn't PRISM be something the NSA is doing in addition to this?
- 13y ago
- spydum 13y agoMaybe it is just me, but could PRISM just refer to secure portals where data that was summoned from a FISA request (either as spartan as access logs, or as deep as emails, depending on provider), could be securely delivered upon collection? It doesn't have to describe the actual COLLECTION system, just the exchange between government and corporation. As someone has just mentioned, a secure Dropbox. Just as if they had a legitimate search warrant for details, you would hope they had a secure way of providing that information to the requesting agency.
- aiiane 13y ago> The data shared in these ways, the people said, is shared after company lawyers have reviewed the FISA request according to company practice. It is not sent automatically or in bulk, and the government does not have full access to company servers. Instead, they said, it is a more secure and efficient way to hand over the data. That sounds to me like PRISM is in fact just a name for an overall consistent system of routing data from specific individual requests.
- richardowright 13y agoSomething still doesn't add up for me on this. 1. How does this explanation relate to the slide that the US is the World's Telecommunication Backbone? The only explanation I can think of is that Google, etc... were only providing information for servers that were physically in the US. 2. How does this prism name relate to the program? To me, the prism name seems more linked to fiber optic cable than to this sort of data monitoring. Perhaps it's an allusion to splitting the data stream and reflecting it to the NSA.
- leoc 13y agoYes, the second slide from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/politics/prism-collection-documents/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/politics/prism-...; sounds more like this http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/16/us/16nsa.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/16/us/16nsa.html doesn't it? > Officials would not discuss details of the overcollection problem because it involves classified intelligence-gathering techniques. But the issue appears focused in part on technical problems in the N.S.A.’s ability at times to distinguish between communications inside the United States and those overseas as it uses its access to American telecommunications companies’ fiber-optic lines and its own spy satellites to intercept millions of calls and e-mail messages. Maybe the second slide in the WaPo selection refers to the wiretapping operations, the third and later ones reproduced by WaPo refer to the "FISA API" operations involving Google, MS, Facebook etc. and the transition between the two topics is in the omitted slides between 2 and 3.
- danso 13y agoIf I'm reading the OP correctly, then, based solely on what they've reported, it seems that the denials made by FB and Google were not only truthful, but sincere (as opposed to being either weaselly or outright dishonest or both)...Here's the key passage: --- > * “The U.S. government does not have direct access or a ‘back door’ to the information stored in our data centers,” Google’s chief executive, Larry Page, and its chief legal officer, David Drummond, said in a statement on Friday. “We provide user data to governments only in accordance with the law.”* Statements from Microsoft, Yahoo, Facebook, Apple, AOL and Paltalk made the same distinction. But instead of adding a back door to their servers, the companies were essentially asked to erect a locked mailbox and give the government the key, people briefed on the negotiations said. Facebook, for instance, built such a system for requesting and sharing the information, they said. The data shared in these ways, the people said, is shared after company lawyers have reviewed the FISA request according to company practice. It is not sent automatically or in bulk, and the government does not have full access to company servers. Instead, they said, it is a more secure and efficient way to hand over the data. Tech companies might have also denied knowledge of the full scope of cooperation with national security officials because employees whose job it is to comply with FISA requests are not allowed to discuss the details even with others at the company, and in some cases have national security clearance, according to both a former senior government official and a lawyer representing a technology company. --- The NYT is talking only about FISA requests, which are a secret process but, as far as everything reported about that process has said, targets individuals. Moreover, when FISA is used on Americans, it's a process that involves a court-approved warrant. So you can argue that FISA is wrong or that it is administered with a rubber stamp (and in my opinion, yes, this is most definitely worth scrutinizing, and it has been for however many years it's been put in place), or that no ethical company should ever comply with a FISA request...but that's not the same ballpark as what's being alleged with Verizon or with PRISM. The point about these companies making it "easier" by creating a systematic delivery process, such as a "lockbox", to send over the requested data is an interesting detail, but kind of a non sequitur. Either FISA is OK or it is flat out wrong...what does it matter which digital process is set up to fulfill that request?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- revelation 13y agoWow, one second of unconcentrated reading, and a bunch of weasel words fly right through the blood barrier into your brain. They opened discussions with national security officials about developing technical methods to more efficiently and securely share the personal data of foreign users in response to lawful government requests. Really, NYT? More securely? And the users, they are all foreign? And all the government requests, deemed lawful from the outset? Come on, at this point, are they even trying with the balanced reporting thing? Tech companies may be bristling, but the NYT is surely lodged in the government wing.
- enraged_camel 13y agoLately, I've come to realize that the September 11 attacks actually destroyed America. In the grand scheme of things, the attacks themselves caused minimal damage and casualties. We're only talking about ~3,000 deaths and ~$30 billion damage. But look at the aftermath. The Iraq War itself cost the USA $5 trillion, and another ~4,500 lives (American lives, that is. The total number of casualties is well over 100,000). At home, the PATRIOT Act enabled countless breaches of freedom, and the TSA has cost untold number of hours wasted at airports. And now this NSA bullshit. All of this is beyond Osama bin Laden's wildest dreams. The guy just organized a couple of airplanes to be rammed into the WTC towers. Heck, he didn't even expect them to go down, and was pleasantly surprised when it happened. In light of all the freedoms America lost since then though, he must be dancing in his grave right now.
- tptacek 13y agoThis is an understandable but ahistorical perspective. There was a time not long ago when wiretaps weren't yet considered searches, and where voicing support for communism could get you dragged in front of a tribunal. The ideals of this country aren't an end-state; they're a goal that we will constantly struggle to achieve.
- danso 13y agoYeah, this cannot be emphasized enough. I know it was a long time ago, but how can anyone say that "Well, this country has truly fallen into a shithole" when, for about a hundred years, we were OK with enslaving an entire race of people, and justified it out of desire for economic stability? Ideals take time and perseverance...thank goodness for organizations like the ACLU and the EFF
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>how can anyone say that "Well, this country has truly fallen into a shithole" when, for about a hundred years, we were OK with enslaving an entire race of people, and justified it out of desire for economic stability? Well, looking at the number of prisoners we have, and the atrocious way we treat them, I don't think that part has changed very much, except in scale.
- gasull 13y agoI've posted this a few times, but I'll do it again: Why aren't we all using Bitmessage already? https://bitmessage.org https://bitmessage.org https://www.youtube.com/embed/t_dTotavJZ8 https://www.youtube.com/embed/t_dTotavJZ8
- graue 13y agoWhy aren't we already? It's new, unproven and most of us haven't even heard of it yet. A quick glance at the website suggests you have to install a native program, which, compared to a web app, adds friction, makes it harder to use and requires trusting the authors with full access to your computer. There isn't a mobile app. OS X support is "only lightly tested". And, even if none of that were the case, the most important reason we aren't using it already is because the people we want to talk to aren't using it, either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect
- gasull 13y agoBitmessage is open source. https://github.com/Bitmessage/PyBitmessage https://github.com/Bitmessage/PyBitmessage
- gasull 13y agoI'm more upset about Larry Page trying to deceive the public than about Obama. I trusted Google. I feel betrayed.
- gasull 13y agoThis is the important bit: Google, Microsoft and Twitter publish transparency reports detailing government requests for information, but these reports do not include FISA requests because they are not allowed to acknowledge them. Yet since tech companies’ cooperation with the government was revealed Thursday, tech executives have been performing a familiar dance, expressing outrage at the extent of the government’s power to access personal data and calling for more transparency, while at the same time heaping praise upon the president as he visited Silicon Valley. So Larry Page and Zuckerberg are just deceiving the public because they are ignoring FISA requests. I'm so outraged right now.
- JumpCrisscross 13y agoSystematically using private companies to spy on foreigners and further the state's security regime. Hmm, sounds like what the U.S. was recently castigating China and Huawei for.
- leoc 13y agoMeanwhile, http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonathanhall/2013/06/07/washington-post-updates-hedges-on-initial-prism-report/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonathanhall/2013/06/07/washingt...; "Washington Post Updates, Hedges on Initial PRISM Report"
- unreal37 13y agoHuh? "Each of the nine companies said it had no knowledge of a government program providing officials with access to its servers, and drew a bright line between giving the government wholesale access to its servers to collect user data and giving them specific data in response to individual court orders. Each said it did not provide the government with full, indiscriminate access to its servers." Tech companies do not allow widespread open access to their data. They respond to legal requests that come from FISA for records on individual users. Huge difference.
- leoc 13y ago> They respond to legal requests that come from FISA for records on individual users. We were reassured about the 'individual users' part by the tech companies yesterday. And yet: > FISA orders can range from inquiries about specific people to a broad sweep for intelligence, like logs of certain search terms, lawyers who work with the orders said. What's the truth here?
- moskie 13y agoCan someone sum up the actual evidence for the claim that PRISM, or something like it, exists? What do we have besides a PowerPoint presentation? And what are the sources for the claims in this article? > In one recent instance, the National Security Agency sent an agent to a tech company’s headquarters to monitor a suspect in a cyberattack, a lawyer representing the company said. The agent installed government-developed software on the company’s server and remained at the site for several weeks to download data to an agency laptop. > In other instances, the lawyer said, the agency seeks real-time transmission of data, which companies send digitally. I would like to know the source of this information, and to be presented with evidence that it is true.
- andrewfong 13y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but this seems like an overreaction. The specific allegation is that companies have set up "digital version of the secure physical rooms that have long existed for classified information, in some instances on company servers." Why is this a problem? Do we honestly except companies to print out paper copies of digital data just to inconvenience government agents who ultimately have a legal right to that data? I understand wanting to narrow the scope of the data available, but no one has put forth evidence yet that Facebook is periodically giving the government the equivalent of an SQL dump. Unlike Verizon, they appear to be producing limited information in response to a specific request on foreign nationals.. Streamlining this process doesn't raise the same issues for me as does the Verizon order.
- MetaCosm 13y agoEffectively what these companies are trying to do via stronger and stronger denials is prove a negative... which of course is borderline useless. Regardless of the truth, to PROVE they were not involved is impossible. For those companies called out but not involved (as the Post walks back its language), it has to be an exceptionally frustrating experience.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vijayboyapati 13y ago"SAN FRANCISCO — When government officials came to Silicon Valley to demand easier ways for the world’s largest Internet companies to turn over user data as part of a secret surveillance program, the companies bristled. In the end, though, many cooperated at least a bit. Twitter declined to make it easier for the government. But other companies were more compliant, according to people briefed on the negotiations. " Twitter is heroic. Shame on Google, Facebook and all the other state-stooges
- buo 13y agoI haven't seen mentioned here that Intel is one of the companies mentioned. I find this particularly worrying: if the hardware itself is compromised, it's game over.