4 ms·
The implication that there is some central figure behind this giving these companies scripts to read meets the most common flaw of governmental conspiracy theor
by slg 13y ago
The implication that there is some central figure behind this giving these companies scripts to read meets the most common flaw of governmental conspiracy theories. It requires the government to be simultaneously incredibly competent and incompetent. If the NSA was able to keep this project under wraps for so long with the number of people involved, I think they would be smart enough to at least slightly alter the words of their puppets, after all this is supposed to be the area of their expertise.
- electic 13y agoThings done in haste tend to look like this. It is almost absurd to think that every company mentioned somehow came up with the same statement by chance.
- corresation 13y agoWe've had this same conspiracy appear a number of times. It isn't chance that their statements look similar: You can be absolutely sure that each looked to the other for some sort of direction, and once that came they followed the leader simply because it makes sense. Even excluding that, really how many variations could there possibly be? Someone said you did something illegal. Say "no I didn't do something illegal, and everything I have done has been above the board and transparent". Do the same thing to twenty people and you would get remarkably similar statements, because a response can only come in so many forms.
- samstave 13y agoWe see Eglin's sockpuppets all the time on reddit, they are actually pretty easy to spot.
- jlgreco 13y agoThe airforce base has sock puppets?
- brymaster 13y agoI think he's talking about this: http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/mar/17/us-spy-operation-social-networks http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/mar/17/us-spy-oper... and citing this http://blog.reddit.com/2013/05/get-ready-for-global-reddit-meetup-day.html http://blog.reddit.com/2013/05/get-ready-for-global-reddit-m... where it shows: Most addicted city (over 100k visits total) Eglin Air Force Base, FL
- stfu 13y agoThat's news to me. And it would also explain why the spy scandal is pretty much a non-story on Reddit. At the moment all there is on the front page are 2 stories on Greenwald and some "collecting anti surveillance arguments thread". I guess after their role in promoting the anti-SOPA movement they got some "special attention.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- samstave 13y agoBasically, yes - its been confirmed that they have a shit-ton of traffic to reddit from Eglin, and the rumor is the HBGary scandal is related to this as they do a lot of online "sentiment shaping" from there.
- adventured 13y agoYou're wrong, it does not require that they be incredibly competent, not in the least. It requires that they coordinated with the companies PR departments in the process of setting up the program. The companies asked: what if the shit hits the fan, or this comes out in the public, what do we say? And the government had a simple, boilerplate answer for it. You wouldn't even have to work with the PR dept, just one single person. Either a special rep in PR for government matters, or just the CEO himself. It would take 5 minutes to put together a generalized script for the CEO to follow in the event this hit the public news. This (the PR response) would be extraordinarily easy to coordinate, and it would take just one conversation at the point the program was signed on to by the companies. And when this all became public, the company could also easily then call up the US Government and ask them what to do (and more than likely, the NSA could call them and tell them what to do).
- criley 13y agoIf that was the case, then why are the CEO's putting their personal names on the line? It's trivially simple for an expendable PR person or lawyer to go on the blog and make an "official" statement ghostwritten by the NSA/etc. But that's not what happened. Larry Page and Mark Zuckerberg posted using their accounts, and if it wasn't them, it was ghost written and borrowing their name and reputation (ie, they own it). So, the CEO's are intentionally lying and intentionally attaching their names what could be the biggest lie they tell in some time. Seems very stupid, why would they do that? Why not sacrifice a scapegoat? PR departments are full of useful scapegoats. The Government forced them to reply personally to bolster credibility? But now we're back into the laughable conspiracy area again. Or of course, they're telling the truth. For all we know, these companies reached out to each other, not the government, on the response.
- slg 13y agoLet me be more clear. The part that requires competence is everything up to the leak. Given the scope, keeping this quiet is no small task. It isn't just keeping the people who know about this from talking. It is also preventing other people from finding out. Depending the way they theoretically got this data, that could stretch from keeping this hidden directly in the code base at Facebook to hiding huge amounts of traffic emanating from Facebook's data centers. Remember a lot of these tech companies helped recognize and locate likely Chinese sponsored government hackers in the past. If someone is doing something they aren't supposed to, a lot of people are going to find out about it. The part that requires incompetence is everything that has happened today. The NSA's job is intelligence. They are the experts in connecting dots, reading between the lines, seeing how random events might be a sign of something bigger, and whatever other cliches you want to throw in here. Yet they are an organization that doesn't know that having people reading from nearly identical scripts will make people think they are reading from nearly identically scripts?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 13y ago>The implication that there is some central figure behind this giving these companies scripts to read meets the most common flaw of governmental conspiracy theories. It requires the government to be simultaneously incredibly competent and incompetent. Which is exactly what governments are. Extreme resources, very smart people, and very idiot people, incompetent bureaucrats, messy cover-ups, all co-exist, all the time. What did you thought they were? Incredibly competent XOR incredibly incompetent? (Only the first would be a conspiracy theory, whereas only the second would be gross underestimation). >If the NSA was able to keep this project under wraps for so long with the number of people involved, I think they would be smart enough to at least slightly alter the words of their puppets, after all this is supposed to be the area of their expertise. You've never seen badly (or too fast) done spin work? Not to mention, why would the NSA care to spend too much effort to how those things were phrased? If you think it matters, I'm afraid, you give the American public too much credit. It's not like it's gonna get suspicious by such small and peripheral signs. Listening to and accepting bad arguments, BS excuses, fake promises, and shit from politicians if what people are doing all their life. And it's not even like they're gonna do anything about the core situation with regards to privacy. It's just the "hot topic" of the day, to be forgotten for some BS next week. You surely don't expect some kind of revolt of anything? If that was to be, it would have been at the other 20 similar media expositions or against the horrible laws that have been passed openly.
- louthy 13y ago> If you think it matters, I'm afraid, you give the American public too much credit. Not just the American public. This is blanket spying on the people of the world. Now that might sound less problematic for Americans who want to see those pesky terrorists brought to justice, but it also allows the NSA to build up profiles on everyone. US border security is already a nightmare, god knows what they can do with this kind of information. Ever searched for torrents on Google? Your next trip to the States might be interesting. It seems also they could be sharing this data with other national security agencies, which is where this gets really scary: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-22813893 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-22813893 Global Big Brother. Personally as a user of Gmail, Skydrive, GDrive, Dropbox, Facebook,... I find this incredibly disturbing. I will be doing whatever I can to remove my dependency on any service hosted in the US.
- saraid216 13y ago> The implication that there is some central figure behind this giving these companies scripts to read meets the most common flaw of governmental conspiracy theories. Oh come on. We all know that it's Agent Phil Coulson of SHIELD that's doing this. "This isn't my first rodeo," he said.
- jetti 13y agoIsn't the standard denial required of NSLs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter)? Could it be possible that the NSA is using an FBI trick to remain legal and quiet?
- sheri 13y ago> The implication that there is some central figure behind this giving these companies scripts to read meets the most common flaw of governmental conspiracy theories. Isn't that the definition of a government conspiracy?
- bobsoap 13y agoIt's actually quite conceivable that there was a first-line response memo crafted by a NSA/government official, that was sent out to the companies in question. What the NSA might not have expected is that the receivers decided to stick to the template so closely. It's even possible that the companies coordinated their press releases for the very purpose of raising questions. We shouldn't assume they are all isolated from one another. It's far more likely that there is some form of communication going on between them, or at least between the high officials. In essence, this looks very much like a coordinated effort to rebel against a gag order without actually crossing the line and putting oneself in jeopardy. Read between the lines.