3 ms·
I appreciate your perspective, and I have not downvoted you. I disagree with some of the premises you've laid out and strongly agree with your main argument. Y
by 1123581321 13y ago
I appreciate your perspective, and I have not downvoted you. I disagree with some of the premises you've laid out and strongly agree with your main argument.
Your main argument is that Americans should not be upset about this because it's not actually oppressive, and the United States will not become oppressive.
I think this is wrong in two ways.
1. We should hold our government to a much higher standard than "oppressive." We should not even let them come close to it. I realize this is an axiom; why should we do that? Reasons like "because of the Constitution," "to protect people," "to keep the United States a place of refuge for oppressed people," are all good reasons, but I think the best is simply that it is evil to allow a good thing to be compromised or abrogated, so it is good to resist a compromising or abrogating force. I cannot justify this by logic (why anyone should be good or want good) but I cannot be persuaded otherwise, and thankfully, many other people are the same way.
2. Our government is already oppressive to certain people, and there is a chance that the list of people it oppresses will grow. Most of them are foreign but a few are already domestic. The systems being built today are designed to increase our capacity to treat people this way, so it is reasonable to expect more people will be treated poorly. Additionally, history provides ample examples of nearly utopic nations, including republics, that did go on to commit atrocities and reduce the quality of the lives of their own people. It is not a slippery slope to want to take precautions to avoid the same. But again, this is all secondary to point #1 above.