7 ms·
Today I am throwing out the newspaper I was saving from the day after Obama was elected and all the electronic newspaper front pages from around the world I was
by ck2 13y ago
Today I am throwing out the newspaper I was saving from the day after Obama was elected and all the electronic newspaper front pages from around the world I was saving from that day are being deleted from my hard drive. I've lost all pride.
I am utterly disgusted with this administration. Any good he has done is wiped out by being far worse than Bush with the domestic spying and whistleblower prosecutions.
How are we any better than China - because we at least eventually find out? Because people don't get disappeared off the street?
You remember that feeling of incredible relief when we saw Bush finally being flown away in the helicopter on his last day? Well that feeling is going to be deja vu in a couple years.
I just hope the next president doesn't try to do a one-up like Obama did to Bush. Obama's library/museum is going to be even more hypocritical than Bush's.
- throwaway2048 13y ago>Because people don't get disappeared off the street? dont worry, the legal frameworks are in place for that to start happening too.
- adventured 13y agoGive it two or three presidencies, and it could very well be an actual thing that happens here. You don't have to disappear a lot of people, just enough to get the word out. Putin doesn't have to kill a lot of people with polonium-210, just one or two public cases does the trick. The future looks obvious: don't fight the state, don't disagree with the state, or else. It's a fascism model, very similar to what Russia currently has (how ironic is that end result?!?). We have the widening rich / poor issue and oligarch class to go with it (which is very common under highly industrialized fascist nations).
- jw_ 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maher_Arar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maher_Arar Yes, he's Canadian, but still.
- sfjailbird 13y agoI don't usually do this but... > Because people don't get disappeared off the street inside the U.S. Fixed that for you.
- rosser 13y agoPlease don't make this about one party or one president. It's not. This kind of behavior goes way, way beyond partisan politics, and to reduce it to that is to abdicate pretty much all of your agency or ability to do anything about it, not least because partisan politics is more about apportioning blame for problems than it is finding solutions to them. Getting all, "Thanks, Obama!" over what the NSA was up to long before he was elected — if not before Bush was elected — is giving the people who actually did this, and are still doing it, a complete pass.
- ck2 13y agoThe president has the sole power to go the media every single day and say "this is wrong". He also has the power to bring to light any bill that is put on his desk for signature. Obama grew everything Bush did. The TSA, the NSA, all have become far bigger and more "powerful" under Obama. I'm not an idiot, I know congress is as much at fault. He is at fault for not fighting it - it's his job as president of this country.
- dylangs1030 13y agoThat's not the point. While we should hold everyone involved - even peripherally - responsible, it's not appropriate or productive to compare Obama to Bush. We need to frame the objection as, "This is wrong!" not, "This is worse than/just like $OTHER_PERSON." It's implicitly partisan.
- clarkmoody 13y agoThe very core of his entire agenda has been to expand the scope, size, and power of the government in all directions. I'm glad this particular issue finally got your attention. I'm not giving Bush a pass here, either. He tarnished the name of the Republican Party -- the party of Abolition, Civil Rights, Reagan, freedom, etc. -- and grew government with the best of them. Maybe the behavior of these last two administrations will wake the people from their stupor and cause them to realize that the God-given liberties described by our Constitution have been under assault for quite some time.
- anigbrowl 13y agoHe tarnished the name of the Republican Party -- the party of Abolition, Civil Rights, Reagan, freedom, etc. I never cease to be amazed at the uncritical association of Ronald Reagan with freedom. Take a good look at the graph below, especially the labels on the axes. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/US_incarceration_timeline-clean.svg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/US_incarc... I don't want to get into a political derail because a) I see the larger point you're attempting to make and b) Reagan was extremely effective in advancing US itnerests and thus pretty successful in that aspect of his job, but in my view he treated freedom very much as a transferable commodity rather than a universal grant.
- rhizome 13y agoI imagine these people laying in bed at night or having a scotch in the library, saying "...endowed by their Creator my ass."
- Perceval 13y agoAlmost none of that growth comes from changes to federal law. It's almost entirely state and local laws. During the 1980s it was the War on Drugs, but during the 90s it was three-strikes and zero tolerance laws. The best work on "the carceral state" being done right now is by a UPenn professor, Marie Gottschalk. Check out her books.
- pico303 13y agothe party of Abolition, Civil Rights, Reagan, freedom, etc. Reagan? You mean the President that secretly sold weapons to a "terrorist" state to buy weapons for another U.S.-sponsored terrorist group, knowing full well it was an impeachable offense? The one that raised payroll taxes on the middle class to pay for tax cuts for the rich and tanked wages? The guy that deregulated banks and cause the savings and loan crisis? The President that generated huge budget deficits (3x Carter's) to fund Reaganomics? The one that claimed credit for destroying the "Evil Empire" when most analysts were saying the USSR had been in decline since the 1970's. That Reagan? He's definitely a credit to the Republican Party.
- clicks 13y agoEarlier this year I was talking to a European friend presently living in China, who is pretty passionate about human rights issues, privacy policies, freedom, and so on. He said he wouldn't ever set on American soil, because he couldn't be arsed going through the mess of immigration policies and aggressive surveillance and all that. I remember I there and then called him up on it: that's not so, China is way more of a police state than America. I remember he replied something to the effect of "The difference is, the Chinese people pretty much know about it -- it's an open secret, and they're fine with it, they've accepted it -- Americans aren't even aware what's happening to them". That was that, but I thought still America is better: unlike in China where if you have any hopes of making it big as a company you pretty much need to play buddy-buddy with the government and accept that the gov't will exercise some control where it suits them. Turns out I'm wrong here too, seeing as Verizon, Facebook, Google, Dropbox play buddy-buddy with the gov't here as well. This raises an interesting question: to make it big as a company, and not yield to whatever gov't requests ask of you, is it possible to for a company to survive here in America?
- rosser 13y agoProbably not. Just look at Qwest.
- clicks 13y agoInteresting, I never knew about this. For those who want to read up: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_for_NSA_spying http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_for_NSA_spying In May 2006, USA Today reported that millions of telephone calling records had been handed over to the United States National Security Agency by AT&T Corp., Verizon, and BellSouth since September 11, 2001. This data has been used to create a database of all international and domestic calls. Qwest was allegedly the lone holdout, despite threats from the NSA that their refusal to cooperate may jeopardize future government contracts,[10] a decision which has earned them praise from those who oppose the NSA program.[11] ... Former Qwest CEO Joseph Nacchio, convicted of insider trading in April 2007, alleged in appeal documents that the NSA requested that Qwest participate in its wiretapping program _more than six months before September 11, 2001_. Nacchio recalls the meeting as occurring on February 27, 2001. Nacchio further claims that the NSA cancelled a lucrative contract with Qwest as a result of Qwest's refusal to participate in the wiretapping program I've gotta say, although it sounds conspiratorial to question the validity of the allegations, recent events do make one think if there's more to the story of the charges and how they were brought about.
- weland 13y agoI used to live in a (now ex-)communist country, where state authorities blatantly breaching citizens' privacy and spying on their every activity was pretty much usual. You're in great error thinking this has something -- anything -- to do with a president in particular, or with a few people at the top of the decision-making chain. It doesn't. My own country changed two dictators (and a handful of "democratic" regimes afterwards) without this matter being solved. It's a combination of two things: * A large block that supports such decisions and even actively pushes for them. The elected President will only be there to implement them for two terms at most, but the people supporting them have no cap on their term. Since two presidents from two different parties (it doesn't help that they're basically the only two parties you have...) did similar shit, it's only safe to assume that either both parties have such groups, or that the groups who are supporting them aren't affiliated to any party in particular. * Woeful lack of alternatives from your voters and, quite possibly, misinformed voting (although the second is something I can only intuitively state, as I don't live in the US). The people who deal in power are greedy; if they had any reason to believe this kind of stuff would have their asses bust out of office, they'd stop doing it. However, my own experience tells me what they feel is that this kind of crap actually ensures their continuous tenure in their offices. Also, while we would all wish everyone realized how dangerous this is, the sad truth is most people don't care, or don't realize the atrocity of it. We are a minority; a handful of well-educated people who can think for themselves and who can fully grasp the intrusiveness of such surveillance. Most people simply don't realize enough to care that "the State" (whatever the hell that is) knows who they were calling and when -- after all, who in the world has time to sift through all those pages of phone calls, eh?
- rhizome 13y agoI have a conspiracy theory that the Republicans fielded such sure-losers as McCain and Romney specifically so that these continuations of policies would legitimized through the lens of bipartisanship.
- weland 13y agoAs I said above, I don't live in the US, so I can't claim to have a reasonable grip on the important discussion themes (I am slightly more informed on the actual problems on the agendas, but those play little part in the election game), but my two cents on this issue is that, after Bush's term, anyone fielded by the Republicans would have been a sure-loser. It also didn't help that, in a country whose social inequity wounds are opening again, the Republican fielded an annoying dick like Romney. On the other hand, I can't suspect people like Mitt Romney or Sarah Palin of being smart enough (or of not being blinded by their sheer arrogance) of being able to dodge a puppet role. In fact, if I were an evil overlord and had to choose a set of figureheads to deploy as autonomous, but ultimately manipulable characters for my puppetmaster role, I'd choose people like them. It's scary that folks also seem to vote for people like them, though.
- Ihmahr 13y ago"How are we any better than China - because we at least eventually find out? Because people don't get disappeared off the street?" Perhaps this doesn't happen that much within us borders, but it routinely happens to others, including EU citizens. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khalid_El-Masri http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khalid_El-Masri
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bertm 13y agoLooking back at the Petagon Papers I found this quote: "[t]he security of the Nation is not at the ramparts alone. Security also lies in the value of our free institutions. A cantankerous press, an obstinate press, an ubiquitous press must be suffered by those in authority in order to preserve the even greater values of freedom of expression and the right of the people to know." - Judge Judge Murray Gurfein declining to issue such an injunction against the publishing of the Pentagon Papers.
- rayiner 13y agoHow are we any betteer than china? Because there is a huge fucking difference between monitoring information flowing over networks and censoring it or using it to supress political opposition? What ridiculous hyperbole.
- clicks 13y ago> Because there is a huge fucking difference between monitoring information flowing over networks and censoring it or using it to supress political opposition? Monitoring information is arguably a light form of suppression, isn't it? When someone is being monitored they get worried, they're more conscious about their actions. It has a chilling effect. I don't think finding parallels between the two is an exercise of ridiculous hyperbole.
- rayiner 13y ago> Monitoring information is arguably a light form of suppression, isn't it? Not if it isn't widely known.
- jessaustin 13y agoI think that horse has left the barn.
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoI never mistook Obama for a progressive, but I did make the mistake of taking him for a principled conservative. It turns out he is none of the above.
- charlieok 13y agoThe worst part is we had no real choice, at all. In Bush's case, at least he could say, “I'm the tough-on-terrror candidate. In the tradeoff between security and liberty, I favor security.” That's how he was positioned. By electing him, it was understood at some level that this is what we as a country were choosing. Obama took the other side of this argument. A vote for him was a vote for favoring the liberty side of that tradeoff. His actions in office are a clear demonstration that we can't translate our widely held preferences into implementation through the mechanism of our election system.
- pjzedalis 13y agoRemarkable to me that people consider Republicans the oppressors of freedom and the Democrats the liberators.
- dm2 13y agoPretend for a second that your advisers give you two options. Secretly sign bills to allow the gathering of data regarding US citizens from indirect sources, or allow a terrorist attack to happy under your watch as Commander-in-Chief. You don't have all of the information. The big picture regarding cyber-security and national security in general is very complicated, please lets work together to come to a logical solution rather than blame one political party or candidate. Policies are never perfect, especially when you involve a technology as new and complicated (technically and ethically) as the internet. Most people are fully aware of the ability of the US government to spy on all communications. How can you expect the NSA, which has the mission of protect the US security systems and provide foreign intelligence, to have limits on it's information sources? Is the real concern whether or not the FBI and other agencies have full access to the data the NSA collects? Patriot act might have allowed them to have more access.