11 ms·
Snapchat, You've Made a Huge Mistake
- mrlase 13y agoYou've been able to see this online now for... a long time. Just go to http://www.snapchat.com/<username> http://www.snapchat.com/<username> and you can see it.
- cmelbye 13y agoI'm glad someone pointed this out. This feature has always existed. You didn't even have to do it through your web browser, Snapchat has always had a link within the app to view the profiles of your friends (including their "best friends").
- stopcodon 13y agoExactly, I'm not sure why this suddenly became news. Did nobody bother to tap a name in their friends list in the last 6 months?
- nemof 13y agoseems like http://www.snapchat.com/sexgod696969 http://www.snapchat.com/sexgod696969 is doing really well. on a related note. it would be amusing to trace all these relationships by scraping the site for common usernames and then following jumping down through their friends list.
- hnha 13y agoI assume this showed a big friends list earlier? they seem to have limited the display to 3 friends.
- seanponeil 13y agoThis feature has been around since launch I believe
- hydralist 13y agoyeah it has been at launch and it is brutal. does clearing your feed delete your top friends? they badly need a way to clear or disable top friends, otherwise using snapchat with the opposite gender is a jealousy-magnet-clusterfuck with significant others when they see it... speaking from experience
- bluetidepro 13y agoAs many have already pointed out in other comments, it definitely was already a feature. I would just add that I think the author still has a valid point, though, because this new update does bring a lot more light on that feature. I would say before this update, it was a pretty "hidden"/unknown feature. I wonder if more users will speak up about it in their reviews now that it's much more obvious to access that information.
- leephillips 13y ago"Facebook makes it extremely clear that they never give away this information" Not a quick learner, I'm afraid.
- Pxtl 13y agoExactly. They wouldn't give it away. They'd sell it at an exorbitant price. That's not giving it away.
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y agoI remember at one point there was a FB app that told you who spent the most time looking at your profile, then generated a photo and tagged people in it. Hilariously I was the top person on my GF's sister's one, not sure why. Not sure where they got the data for that...
- coreyja 13y agoPretty positive all the apps like this were either just random data or fake. I could be wrong, but I believe that none of these apps ever actually worked
- tylerhowarth 13y agoThis has been part of the product since launch. Not a huge mistake.
- jmathai 13y agoThis has been circulating in my mind for some time now. It seems to me that Silicon Valley is so obsessed with "home run" start ups that we've lost track of caring if they make our lives better. I'm not necessarily making a moral judgement on Snapchat but I do think it is something to consider. You can see the same mentality around Chatroulette. I realize the value of something is not concrete at first; Twitter comes to mind. I think we all agree that Twitter plays an important role in society today, yet that was unclear a few years ago. As a society, are we rallying behind an app that helps people engage in extramarital affairs as this post suggests? Without getting into morality, don't we agree that affairs impact not just the two participants but the families surrounding them? Are we simply justifying our obsession with "success" by attributing some theoretical benefit when the drawbacks seem obvious?
- jmduke 13y agoAs a society, are we really rallying behind an app that helps people engage in extramarital affairs as this post suggests? Without getting into morality don't we agree that affairs impact not just the two participants but the families surrounding them? I use SnapChat daily and its starting to cannibalize a lot of my other methods of communication: its fast, more personal, more affective, and a lot more fun to use. I only have ~forty SnapChat friends compared to the ~1200 on Facebook or ~300 phone numbers I have, and it makes it a lot more intimate: you're not gonna send a goofy face of yourself to that study partner from freshman Biology who you never talk to. (Honestly, it reminds me of what Path could be if Path wasn't so pretentious.) Oh, and email helps people commit extramarital affairs, too.
- jmathai 13y agoI'm sure there are useful scenarios like yours. But that alone doesn't magically make the app have a net positive impact. I'm not claiming it is positive or negative but rather something to consider. The comment about email isn't really logical. Crow bars help you kill people but that doesn't mean we should treat them the same way as guns. I'm sure there is a technical term for it (logical fallacy) but that's besides my point and I'm on mobile :).
- carbocation 13y agoMost of the comments are focused on the author's trivial mistake (when was this information surfaced: now, or at launch?). His substantive point is more valuable to bring to light. Perhaps the fact that there are top-users lists highlights the tension between what Snapchat says that people use it for (sharing brief moments with friends) vs what people actually use it for. In fact, I actually use Snapchat for sharing photos with friends, and I still would prefer that this network information disappear. The existence of a top list suggests that there is quite a bit of metadata retained long after the photos are (ostensibly) destroyed. It implies that the company is building a database that could be used to reconstruct an enormous network diagram.
- jmduke 13y ago> It implies that the company is building a database that could be used to reconstruct an enormous network diagram. It's actually fun and trivial to do this yourself with a spider: go to http://www.snapchat.com/username http://www.snapchat.com/username, mark 'best friendships' as followthroughs. A fun thing you notice pretty quickly is that the 'best friend' designation isn't one-to-one, prolific snappers will appear often in peoples' friends lists. I think a SnapChat API is likely on the way, and once they figure out a way to market this stuff to advertisers (hey, ten seconds of undivided attention towards an ad is probably worth more than thirty seconds of ignoring a commercial) they're going to have a whole new host of problems.
- bennyg 13y agoThat's the day I stop using it. If I get a few second ad every 4 or 5 snaps then I won't continue my usage of the app. I understand that good things that require monetary value to continue operating at scale need to have a way to make money, but advertising should be a last-resort option. We haven't even seen for-pay snaps yet (more seconds, more options like random clip-art to add in, etc). Advertising kills the product 9 times out of 10.
- dave5104 13y agoI'm on the opposite end there. I would never pay money for extra snap options. I'd much rather see ads if choosing between the two.
- niix 13y agoStop being sketchy and it won't be a big deal.
- roc 13y agoEric Schmidt, is that you?
- ErikAugust 13y agoNever downloaded or used Snapchat... but I know very clearly what some of the use-cases are. Clearly the solution is just to create a toggle for that feature in Settings. Boom... make your "being shady" user persona happy in a matter of minutes.
- minimaxir 13y agoYes, this was available on the website, but how often do Snapchatters use the web instead of using the mobile app? It's a reverse of Instagram's approach.
- lawdawg 13y agoIsn't this pretty much exactly what Google got in trouble for with the Buzz launch? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Buzz#Legal_issues http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Buzz#Legal_issues
- speeder 13y agoToday lots of posts on privacy... To those saying that if you have nothing to hide you should not have a problem with this, you are missing some points, and situations... For example, sometimes you do things that are controversial, but not necessarily wrong, or "sketchy", and you don't want the negative attention. For example, regarding the Verizon call list: What if people discover you have made lots of calls to KKK? They will quickly jump to conclusion that you are probably a neo-nazi, but maybe you was like that black guy that made a KKK documentary (I forgot the name, I saw in school many years ago, a teacher showed us) and interacted a lot with them. Or snapchat, what if you are exchanging photos with people with some other people dislike? You never had friends that hate each other? Or your mom that hate your girlfriend? Or your wife that hate your uncle? There are lots of situations where privacy is important, and beyond commiting crimes or being a anti-government rebel...
- jseliger 13y agoTo those saying that if you have nothing to hide you should not have a problem with this, you are missing some points, and situations... In addition, the idea that privacy is necessary to a full life and full persona has been addressed by an array of scholars and privacy experts; consider Decew's In Pursuit of Privacy: Law, Ethics, and the Rise of Technology as one good place to start.
- rschmitty 13y agoYour counter argument to verizon call list is: what if a black guy is calling the KKK? Not that I'm pro verizon, just that is a very poor example.
- samstave 13y agoI think he was trying to grab an example that would be easy to jump to conclusions about (calls to the KKK)
- pseut 13y agoIt's a poor example. If I were black, I'd be pretty unconcerned about the possibility of my friends and family thinking I'm a Klansman, no matter what my phone records say.
- _pmf_ 13y agoThis reminds me of this article[1] that nicely outlines that the social network graph is either useless (see Facebook; what good is the fact that I have added 10000 users as "friend"?) or creepy (now Snapchat, apparently). [1] http://blog.pinboard.in/2011/11/the_social_graph_is_neither/ http://blog.pinboard.in/2011/11/the_social_graph_is_neither/
- frasierman 13y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but hasn't this been there for a while? I know classmates who have been mortified when they find out that who they Snapchat with is public.
- josephjrobison 13y agoYea, it's been there for at least 8 months, when I started using it.
- ryandvm 13y agoI find Snapchat's charter fascinating. I say this as the author of a competing, and much less successful, product called Privy (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.appidio.privy https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.appidio.pr...). I wrote Privy with a very simple use case in mind. It was for sending messages that you never want to resurface. Privacy, of course, was paramount. After reading a few interviews with the Snapchat guys, I was amused that they always pitched it to be about temporal communications. They would downplay Snapchat as a secretive transport and talk about how it's more about sharing special moments. These new "un-private" features very clearly show that Snapchat is sincere about this use case. It simply never occurred to me that people might want to send temporal messages and that privacy around sending those messages not be absolutely critical. I don't know if I'm out of touch or what. Or maybe this is more of a natural selection thing for successful mobile messaging products. Obviously the network effect of a privacy-oriented app is by definition nonexistent. Trust me.
- ionwake 13y agoI do not know much about privy, but as a competitor - why do you feel snapchat was more successful?
- Ziomislaw 13y agoread the 2nd last sentence
- ryandvm 13y agoI think they were more successful because of marketing. Initially, Privy and Snapchat were fairly close to feature parity. I had never actually heard of them while I was developing Privy. And then about a month or so before I was ready to release Privy, SnapChat hit the TechCrunch lottery. After that they quickly became a media sensation. Being a side project, Privy wasn't able to compete. Especially after they started picking up funding. Once the Snapchat buzz hit full fever pitch I threw in the towel on development. I used to think that useful apps could sell themselves. I know a lot of developers have this mentality. Nothing could be further from the truth. I now have much greater respect for the value of good marketing.
- VuongN 13y agoIf you want to check out an alternative, our nCryptedCloud iOS has a secure camera that would encrypt the image (in memory) before it even gets to the device. Once encrypted, you manage access rights. You revoke access to anyone in the future that even if they have the image, without the privilege, the file is useless. You could also send a quick share (time-controlled SnapChat style) with anyone--pdf files too! It's free, check it out: https://www.ncryptedcloud.com/install/ios/ https://www.ncryptedcloud.com/install/ios/ (for non-us regions, just add: ?region=non-us to the URL). If you have question, just ask!
- itcmcgrath 13y agoAll seems very pointless when you can 1) Take a screenshot, or 2) take a photo of it. Once you give someone the ability to see or hear something, there is no guaranteed way to take it back. I say this because: "You revoke access to anyone in the future that even if they have the image, without the privilege, the file is useless"
- VuongN 13y agoEven the foremost thinker in security, Dan Geer (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Geer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Geer), once said: "...The most serious attackers will probably get in no matter what you do. At this point, the design principal, if you’re a security person working inside a firm, is not no failures, but no silent failures." In the same respect, you can't really stop people from taking screenshots or take a photo of... a photo. What we do is we put a watermark of the recipient in the image. This way, if that image get released anywhere, you knew who was the culprit and you can take further actions. No box is ever impenetrable, then the next best thing is to know when, what, why, whom of the penetration. I hope that helps. It is a difficult problem to solve, however, we have to do something! Thank you for your thoughts. -V.
- thiloberlin 13y agoA watermark won't help me with at an anonymous service like snapchat.
- ap0rnnstar 13y agoIs there a way to turn this off?
- bsg75 13y agoIf you are surprised a "free" service is collecting data, please lookup the word 'gullible' in the dictionary. Nothing is free kids.
- leephillips 13y agoDon't bother. Contrary to popular belief, "gullible" is not a real word and is not in the dictionary.
- ParkerK 13y agoSnapchat has had the leaderboard / friends page since launch. How is this new? This has been like this for ages. Maybe I'm misunderstanding what OP is saying, but I don't understand why this is being addressed this late into the app's life.
- KathyMurphy 13y agoIf you are looking for snapchat for adults without the Best Friends feature check out www.ncryptedcloud.com The private camera function is much better than Snapchat because I can send my private photos to ANYONE not just someone who has Snapchat. The ability to watermark the image with the email or the phone number of my friends is WAY better than a notice that someone took a screen shot IMHO.
- csears 13y agoThis kind of spammy comment is not appreciated. Based on a quick read of your site, your product isn't even remotely similar to SnapChat. Why would you damage your brand by leaving misleading comments like this?
- glenntzke 13y agoI'm bothered by the tone and inclusive language of this post. Of course an inspection of one's private conversations is intrusive and will make them uncomfortable, but this isn't true for all: "We get incredibly offending[sic] when someone reads our text messages, but even if they never see the messages themselves we are still embarrassed the second they see who we are talking to." I'm not embarrassed by the people I communicate with - hell that would make my friends list on facebook a nightmare! And when you see my snapchat best friends, it's my girlfriend and 1 other guy and 1 other girl - my 2 top traveling friends. We use snapchat while on the road to share funny, temporal traveling moments that don't warrant setting up a real shot or publication. And it's a lot of fun. I suppose if you need anonymity for your snaps you shouldn't be sharing your username with those you trust. And you shouldn't be trusted, either.
- joshdance 13y agoI agree that Snapchat needs to be more forthright about what kind of information they store and what actually happens to the photos. But I kind of feel like if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry. If you do have something to hide, maybe it would be worth your time to find a different app.
- maddddddddddddd 13y agothis article is written from the perspective of "we"... who is "we"? you are NOTHING.
- Mitchella 13y agoIt appears as though the author is unaware that this feature has been here the entire time. This 'leaderboard' has always been accessible to anyone and everyone. In the past it was an out of app mechanism, I would have to go to the site and go to made up example url: snapchat/user/Mitchella to find the information but it would still show my 'score' and my 'most snapchatted to list.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- yefim 13y agoThere's even an easy way to explore your own (and others') snapchat graph: http://snapgraph.me/ http://snapgraph.me/
- lehrblogger 13y agoI disagree with etanz's post, and think it makes sense for Snapchat to make this feature more accessible (as others have pointed out, profiles have existed on the web for a long time). In particular, the people we communicate with is not "one of our tightest guarded secrets," especially among the teenage demographic. The term 'bff', for example, has meaning because teenagers like to declare their relationships publicly. Of course our friendships define who we are, and we use those friendships to express our identity in the same way we use fashion to express our identity. I doubt a large part of Snapchat's usage is for extramarital affairs and the like, and the company is probably happy to make the app less useful for that, and more useful for communication between friends. By making the top friends visible, if user A looks at user B's profile and sees herself as third in the list, and is jealous of the people in the first two spots, then the best thing for user A to do about it is... send more snaps.
- cwb71 13y agoInteresting that this would bubble to the top today in light of the Verizon FISA story. The White House and others defending the practice keep repeating “it’s just metadata.” Knowing exactly who you talk to, when, where, and for how long can expose a lot about you and be pretty incriminating!
- greenyoda 13y agoThis is a perfect example of what has been said about the recent revelation that the NSA is collecting the metadata for all phone calls (calling number, called number, etc.): you can learn a lot about a person just by knowing who they've communicated with and how often, without having to know anything about the actual content of the communication. If your girlfriend sees that someone with a female name she's never heard of is your number one Snapchat contact, that's probably all she needs to know.
- reddit_clone 13y agoHey, that's my Nana who likes to keep tabs on me!
- mholkesvik 13y agoI'm now getting 404 errors for the web profiles: http://www.snapchat.com/username http://www.snapchat.com/username ...but I was building a crawler for fun and have been making tons of requests - the other pages seem to be working just fine. Anyone else having trouble? Did Snapchat do the right thing and shut down user profiles?
- micahroberson 13y agoIt appears they did!
- mholkesvik 13y agoNope - looks like it's back online, at least for me. I think the response is just timing out, perhaps a heavy traffic issue.
- giologist 13y agoI deleted my SnapChat because of this.
- dylangs1030 13y agoI don't personally mind people seeing information like this about me, but I can see why it's a bit of an invasion. I just learned who gets the most snapchats from who on my friends list. I think a lot of people will either love or hate this. Love this because they're exempt from the downsides and they have juicy details on their friends. Hate this because their own details are now public.
- midas 13y agoIf you login to Facebook, go to the search bar and type in the letter A, you will see a list of your friends whose name (first/middle/last) starts with an A, but it's sorted based on who you are most likely to be looking for. I don't know exactly how they determime this since it could be based on so many factors like messaging, profile viewing, searching, photo tagging, shared events... even pokes! It's spooky accurate and yet Facebook goes out of their way to never mention this kind of thing: they don't want us to realize how well they know us!
- beachstartup 13y agoso in other words, it causes drama, which will generate more user activity.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoCan someone explain to me how Snapchat photos are considered ephemeral? Anyone can capture data at the endpoint and persist it. E.g. I can take a screenshot of a photo sent to me, and it will be in my iPhoto archive forever. I can share it from there to my entire contact list. What am I missing? Please educate me.
- ddt 13y agoIt tells the sender if you screenshot. It's not enough to prevent it from happening, but it adds a pretty big social incentive not to do so.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoHow reliable is that? I can't imagine the snapchat app can know if some third party app grabs an image of the screen and does not notify it that a screenshot has been taken. At the most basic level you can use one phone to take a photo of another phone. If the object is to expose an embarassing photo, that may be enough resolution to accomplish the end. I really think it is impossible to secure the data once it is on a client.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoHow reliable is that? I can't imagine the snapchat app can know if some third party app grabs an image of the screen and does not notify it that a screenshot has been taken. At the most basic level you can use one phone to take a photo of another phone. If the object is to expose an embarassing photo, that may be enough resolution to accomplish the end. I really think it is impossible to secure the data once it is on a client.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoHow reliable is that? I can't imagine the snapchat app can know if some third party app grabs an image of the screen and does not notify it that a screenshot has been taken. At the most basic level you can use one phone to take a photo of another phone. If the object is to expose an embarassing photo, that may be enough resolution to accomplish the end. I really think it is impossible to secure the data once it is on a client.
- lnanek2 13y agoBack when huge companies were being made thanks to viral games on Facebook, the CEO of Arkadium came and gave a talk at the NY Gaming Meetup. He said, do some potential users get annoyed with all the gifting and invites and requests for help? Sure! But those are not the users that are going to get your viral coefficient over 1 (each user brings in more than one other user) and trigger geometric growth. So even if you miss out on some users because you write a game that is very social, you are still doing the right thing, because the social users are the one who make you a hit. Same thing here. Are a few privacy minded individuals like the author going to abandon the service? Sure. Are they worth as much to the company as users that will revel in social graphs and drag friends in? No way. Is it a mistake to add social graphing in this case? No it isn't.
- shuzchen 13y agoSomeone could write a horde of snapchat bots that'll spam you when you follow them (and a local client to chatter back), thus pushing your real "bestfriends" off the top list.
- gcb0 13y agoGmail did exactly the same thing. Remember the circles(?) privacy snafu?
- jwatte 13y agoI was quite upset that the author seems to think people have a right to deceitful behavior and that society should support secrecy. In fact, the hiding of information and duplicit behavior always aims to benefit the actor at the expense of everyone else (rather than being win win.) This is the definition of anti-social! If everybody had perfect transparency, it'd happily give up my privacy, because it would benefit society (you, me, us all) tremendously!