8 ms·
For some context, Mike Gunderloy (author of this article) is an extremely prolific rails activist and community member. This is not some random unknown making a
by swombat 18y ago
For some context, Mike Gunderloy (author of this article) is an extremely prolific rails activist and community member. This is not some random unknown making a fuss, it's a very well respected, very active, very productive member of the rails community making a pretty pointed statement and putting his money where his mouth is.
Some further background:
http://dyepot-teapot.com/2009/04/25/dear-fellow-rubyists/ http://dyepot-teapot.com/2009/04/25/dear-fellow-rubyists/
http://www.loudthinking.com/posts/39-im-an-r-rated-individual http://www.loudthinking.com/posts/39-im-an-r-rated-individua...
http://www.loudthinking.com/posts/40-alpha-male-programmers-arent-keeping-women-out http://www.loudthinking.com/posts/40-alpha-male-programmers-...
And, the slides themslves (NSFW): http://www.slideshare.net/mattetti/couchdb-perform-like-a-pr0n-star?type=presentation http://www.slideshare.net/mattetti/couchdb-perform-like-a-pr...
- michael_dorfman 18y ago...and before becoming a member of the rails community, Mike was an extremely prolific and valued member of the .NET community. Whoever gets him next should consider themselves lucky to have him.
- russell 18y agoUnbelievable. What kind of idiot makes a soft porn presentation in an age when nude calendars are banned from auto shops. I grew up when off color stories were ok with professionals so long as ladies werent present. It was ok to call women 'honey' and make suggestive remarks. I was glad to see that go, along with racist jokes. Women belong in every enterprise. If the screening process is passing women by because they are not technical ninjas or dont want to work 80 hour weeks or dont do so well in alpha male interviews, the group is going to suffer because it is going to miss out on a diversity of skills and viewpoints.
- jrockway 18y agoUnbelievable. What kind of idiot makes a soft porn presentation in an age when nude calendars are banned from auto shops? "The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man." Seriously, not everyone is that hung-up about sex. Anyway, it is amazing how much damage the community is doing to itself over a 20 minute presentation by one guy. If you resign your positions and spend pages and pages talking about it, you're just going to encourage others to do the same. This guy has power now.
- batasrki 18y agoThat's the problem here. The presentation itself may have been tasteless and offensive to some and quite the opposite to others. That's not at issue here. The issue here is that people who lead by example in the community have completely turned a blind eye to those who were offended. A sincere apology and a few words saying that some attention will be paid towards these things in the future would have sufficed. The arrogance of the prominent members is what's spreading these flames. They have said publicly that there's no problem here and that those offended should have just left. As Mike pointed out, some more serious stuff was said privately. So, everyone, please understand. It's not the slides themselves, it's the reaction after the controversy.
- plinkplonk 18y ago"The issue here is that people who lead by example in the community have completely turned a blind eye to those who were offended. " It is probably just me, but I hate these kind of group think coercion efforts. Maybe (just as a thought experiment, bear with me before reaching for that downvote button) are there circumstances in which "turning a blind eye to those who were offended." is the right thing to do? Just think about it for a few seconds. I am not sure anyone has a right not to be offended. Let me repeat that. No one has the right to insist that other people live in such a manner as not to give them the slightest offense.. If some of the people involved genuinely felt that "there is no problem" and other people say that "no there is a problem", and there is no consensus, then the best that can be done is to say, ok folks, each of you act according to what you think is right (and suffer any consequences therefrom) and we'll see who prevails. "A sincere apology and a few words saying that some attention will be paid towards these things in the future would have sufficed." This assumes that the apology needs to be made at all. For the apology to be "sincere" the person who is supposed to apologize has to feel he has done something wrong, and more importantly care that other people got offended. DHH for one obviously doesn't care what other people think, and I respect the man for being consistent in his beliefs and not backing down before people trying to lay some pc guilt trip on him. I am just a little wary of the "no one should be offended in any manner" idea. In the end, this is open source software. "Shut up and write code" is probably more useful advice than all this political correctness laden hand wringing. If people who didn't like the talk had just walked out, no one would know or care if some guy somewhere made some off kilter presentation. The "people who lead by example in the community" are as or more intelligent than the whiners and are just as free to make up their minds on whether to give any credence to the complaints or not. Some of the "leaders by example" seem to have concluded that they don't accept the validity of the complaints. So what? Don't they have the right to do so? If someone doesn't like the way Rails framework or "community" is progressing, they can fork it. Stop submitting patches or features. Don't use it. Write an alternative framework, possibly in another language. Just don't whine for blog post after blog post on what other people should do to conform to your notions of what is right. You wouldn't like it if other people forced their notions of what was right on to you and forced you to apologize when you think there is no reason to do so. Ok Thought Experiment over. Back to normal programming (pun intended). I just thought examining both sides of the issue is important.
- cjbos 18y ago"If the screening process is passing women by because they are not technical ninjas or dont want to work 80 hour weeks or dont do so well in alpha male interviews" Except for your last point there the others are pretty bad stereotypes. For example women have no trouble finding employment as lawyers or doctors which comes with 80hr work weeks... yet they are still vastly underrepresented in IT.