4 ms·
I'm not sure that I agree with the notion that "layered" adjectives don't require commas. "His battered old canvas fishing hat" certainly seems as though it co
by timr 18y ago
I'm not sure that I agree with the notion that "layered" adjectives don't require commas. "His battered old canvas fishing hat" certainly seems as though it could use a pause. But then, I tend to think of commas
as as indicators of verbal pacing more than strict grammatical constructs.
- twoz 18y ago"His battered old canvas fishing hat" Sans-comma Questions: Is it a battered old hat used for canvas fishing? Does he have two battered canvas fishing hats of which this one is the older of the two?
- tokenadult 18y agoPLEASE don't indent unless you mean to show code samples line-by-line.
- Zev 18y agoI don't think its that big of a deal in this case; it didn't cause the window to stretch (Unless your browser is < ~650px). And it was a good example to have laid out like that.
- jpd 18y ago> Is it a battered old hat used for canvas fishing? No, that would be his battered old canvas-fishing hat. > Does he have two battered canvas fishing hats of which this one is the older of the two? No, that would be his old battered canvas fishing hat.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- dxjones 18y agoIt was very interesting to read the hierarchy. I hadn't seen it before. In some case it may be more statistical than universal. For instance, even in the case of the old canvas fishing hat, what if it is both "battered" and "large"? Do we call it a battered large hat (which sounds odd, but follows the rule), or a large battered hat? (which sounds better, but then does "battered" take on the new role of material? Ah, the endless possibilities for quibbling grammarians. Still, it is nice there are such rules to fall back on to get it right most of the time.
- DougBTX 18y agoIf you add "old" to large battered hat, where would you put it? If battered comes after age, perhaps it is material, or at least not opinion.
- tierack 18y agoI used to think of commas as verbal pacing cues as well, but they have more in common with parentheses or semicolons in code. The rule I remember now is "Commas are for parsing, not rendering."
- timr 18y agoCommas are for both. There are few hard-and-fast rules for comma placement; mostly it's a matter of style. Unlike commas, there are only a few situations where semicolons are correctly used.
- jamesbritt 18y agoI was wondering what color "antique flame-red" was. Folks who study certain rules of grammar may tend to parse sentences differently than others. For example, assuming that adjectives modify the words they immediately precede. I bet most people assume "antique" is modifying "racing cars", and no one wonders what an antique Italian would drive. BTW, why couldn't one say "21 green large tables" and not be understood? It suggests that the defining quality is the color, not the size (i.e., not the red large tables, but the green large tables).