7 ms·
It is interesting to me how on HN there seems to be a disproportionate number (say relative to the general population) of Singapore fans. They pop up randomly a
by rdtsc 13y ago
It is interesting to me how on HN there seems to be a disproportionate number (say relative to the general population) of Singapore fans. They pop up randomly and often. Say something negative about Singapore, sure enough, they'll chime in.
It is very strange. I don't care much for Singapore and don't usually think about it outside of HN. Much like I don't think about Peru or Qatar or Sweden. But the subject does come up on HN and sure enough there is a long series of arguments pro and against Singapore's political, economic and social setup.
Ok so they have canning, that's brutal, they don't mind executing people, but so do we in US apparently. The defense usually praises its economy and laws.
Now in this case with banning news related to homosexuality, I wonder how will the "enlightened" Westerners going to defend it, while also keeping up with the appearance of being modern libertarians. I tried playing devil's advocate and a plausible argument, but I couldn't. I thought of using religion as context (like say "it offends the religious sensitivities of the majority"), but it seems Singapore is a hodge podge when it comes to that http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Singapore http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Singapore.
Anyway just pointing out the (meta?) topic of Singapore is an an interesting phenomenon here. Still not sure why. Is it just me that noticed it?
- latch 13y agoEvery country creates bad laws: CISPA, HADOPI... Every country infringes in freedom of the press and freedom of speech. The individuals laws/acts can't be defended, just like the country/system as a whole can't be judged on them alone. If there really is a pro-SG movement on HN, it's probably just reactionary. We think people think SG is some brutal dictatorship, so we're hyper-defensive (sensitive?). I'm surprised this surprises you...it's pretty common. Muslims are quick to point out not all muslims are terrorists, catholics that they aren't all pedophiles, whites that they aren't all bigots...
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoAh, you are exercising the first rule of the wumao party: 1. If someone criticizes your country, just point out how no country is perfect to deflect the criticism. SG is a dictatorship, it is well known that the Lee family have been running it as their own little fief for awhile now by controlling the press so they can continue to win elections. The dictatorship is completely benevolent, non-brutal, and very business-oriented, so the people tend to be relatively happy (not free but rich!). Honestly, I'm not sure real democracy would have worked given the context SG is in. But that still doesn't excuse reality.
- Volpe 13y agoThat's a pretty rude response to a fairly moderate comment. So what's wrong with the dictatorship if it is "completely benevolent, non-brutal, and very business-oriented"? I realize that "all asians may look the same"[1], but Singapore isn't China[2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bigotry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bigotry [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoSingapore is most definitely what China aspires to become. I bring up the Wumao tactics because they apply almost verbatim here: the common "criticism of criticism" in Asian countries is to assert that you can't criticize unless you somehow are perfect. Since perfection doesn't exist, all criticism is therefore unwarranted. Dictatorship is an unideal form of government in general, but sometimes can be the best of other possible evils. One would hope that Signapore could move towards being a real free society much more quickly than it is, but perhaps they have another 50 years to go or so. As for your bigotry comment, it is unjustified.
- crdoconnor 13y ago>I bring up the Wumao tactics because they apply almost verbatim here: the common "criticism of criticism" in Asian countries is to assert that you can't criticize unless you somehow are perfect. Since perfection doesn't exist, all criticism is therefore unwarranted. This is some pretty heavy racial stereotyping. Most of the "defenders" of Singapore here are probably white immigrants. Like me. I'm not saying you can't criticize unless you're perfect. It just sounds like that because I'm unfavorably comparing what you (probably) assume to be a Democracy - the United States with Singapore. Not because I think that Singapore isn't often authoritarian, or that it should be free from criticism, but rather because your claims that it's a dictatorship are pure, unadulterated (and probably racist) bullshit.
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago
- donaq 13y agoThis. Even though I am Singaporean, I do not consider myself pro-Singapore. In fact, I would like to leave at some point. However, I occasionally find myself... not defending Singapore, but opposing its detractors because the criticisms leveled are either inaccurate or unfair. For example, saying that littering in Singapore will get you caned is grossly inaccurate, and comparing it to regimes like North Korea is grossly unfair, kind of like forum moderators accused of being Nazis is unfair. Regarding the issue in the OP, I would not even attempt to defend it. It sucks and is typical of the sort of stuff the government pulls that makes me want to leave.
- rohshall 13y agoI completely agree with you. I live in SG too and I love the government for all their efficiency, clean corruption-free, intellectual approach to managing the country, but hate it when they still have draconian measures like this to control the criticism. I find them stupid in this case, because most Singaporeans are happy with PAP and they will elect them anyway even if criticism is allowed.
- tellarin 13y agoI have lived in Singapore and still have many friends there. That's one of the main reasons for me to submit this article. I really liked the place, but for the complete control on media by the government and for this kind of measures to both stop criticism and "assure a peaceful society". I'm really not sure if PAP would have the support it does if people could freely criticize it. Another interesting related effect has also to do with how Singaporeans see themselves in relation to creativity and spontaneity due to the way things are structured there.
- ValentineC 13y ago> I'm really not sure if PAP would have the support it does if people could freely criticize it. From another perspective, I think it is a harmful anti-democratic cycle that the PAP has enough voting power in Parliament to effectively amend the Singapore constitution without debate [1], and to implement regulations such as this without opening it up to prior public debate. Other forms of democracy have their shortfalls as well. First-past-the-post, at least in my opinion, needs to be replaced. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Singapore#Amendment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Singapore#Amend...
- rosser 13y agoNo, it's not just you. I'm genuinely curious to see how HN's pro-Singapore members will respond to this — particularly, as you observe, the ones who are otherwise ostensibly very libertarian.
- jerf 13y agoWhat exactly does a libertarian supporter of Singapore look like, I wonder? Isn't Singapore sort of the opposite of a libertarian country? Are you sure such a beast exists? It seems like "libertarian" in the last six months is being used more and more often as a contentless slur on HN. Not even with the standard stereotypes from those who disagree (selfish, greedy, etc.), I mean just flat-out content-free, no apparent understanding that it is a word with some meaning (even if ultimately as fuzzy as any other major political label). "What about Singapore?" seems like a decent challenge to a libertarian. (I'm just using that observation that that is a fair, nontrivial question to further my main point. It's not a request for 150 messages providing a libertarian critique of Singapore; I've got one, thanks.)
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThere are real libertarians on HN, it is mostly a belief in a niche economic system that is mostly the opposite of communism. But many people are confused about the word, and a lot of young disillusioned Republicans have latched onto the movement without truly understanding its principles. I always get giddy when a libertarian on reddit points Singapore out as the kind of country they want to live in: low taxes, high economic freedom! But that's only because they don't realize its an actual police state! (whereas we could argue that the USA is only partially a police state) They then move onto talking about Hong Kong...
- jlgreco 13y agoThe go-to response to criticism of Singapore, if you don't immediately concede the discussion, seems to be "It isn't like other places that you are use to. It is very different."
- 13y ago
- naithemilkman 13y agoAs a Singaporean who reads HN almost everyday for the last couple of years, I can't say I've seen Singapore related topics pop up so often. I had a feeling this particular issue might come up though.
- yen223 13y agoAs a Malaysian who reads HN almost everyday, Singaporean stories appear way more frequently than Malaysian stories :)
- oh_sigh 13y agoit's perfectly possible that there are not really that many singapore defenders on the internet, but that the government/hardcore singapore supporters proactively search for stories about singapore and positively comment on them. I forget the exact name, but pro-Zionist peoples have a similar program which basically prompts them with a small button on their desktop, which automatically upvotes pro-israel stories, or downvotes anti-israel stories on social media sites.
- jlgreco 13y agoNo, nearly all of the people that I have seen support Singapore on HN are active contributors who comment on a wide variety of issues. Also, you are probably thinking of the JIDF: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Internet_Defense_Force http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Internet_Defense_Force
- oh_sigh 13y agoHmm, the JIDF may have been what I was thinking of, but as I recall, there is some kind of desktop program which streamlines the user registration/"upvoting" feature on any arbitrary website(perhaps by just making you solve the captcha, and automating the rest), which broadcasts relevant stories to pro-zionist netizens computers to instantaneously upvote or bury. I wasn't trying to suggest that all pro-singapore commenters fit that mold, but that that possibility may explain why pro-singapore responses appear disproportionately in any article or comment involving singapore.
- olalonde 13y ago> It is interesting to me how on HN there seems to be a disproportionate number (say relative to the general population) of Singapore fans. Because libertarians can appreciate certain aspects of a country's policies without actually being in agreement with all of them? Personally, I am not a fan of Singapore's social policies but I do admire its mostly laissez-faire economic policies. I believe other HNers might admire Singapore for its excellent math/science education system. I would guess that most HNers would disagree with its censorship policies.
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago> Because libertarians can appreciate certain aspects of a country's policies without actually being in agreement with all of them? The question is which aspects are separable and which ones are not. It would be just as simplistic to say that Singapore's economic liberalization could be separated from its repressive social policies. > I believe other HNers might admire Singapore for its excellent math/science education system. They definitely test well but creativity can be lacking (there are many exceptions of course).
- ValentineC 13y ago> I believe other HNers might admire Singapore for its excellent math/science education system. >> They definitely test well but creativity is lacking. I should add that many Singaporeans are still stuck in the "school > big MNC job > build connections > (possibly) venture out and do business" mentality. It doesn't help that mandatory military service conditions Singapore citizens to take orders from higher-ranked authority figures without questioning them.
- olalonde 13y agoApart from the military service bit, the two comments above could apply to almost anyone that isn't deep into the Silicon Valley echo chamber. People who are not "stuck in the school > big MNC job > build connections > (possibly) venture out and do business" are outliers, not the other way around. Asians in general probably exhibit that mentality more often because Asian countries are relatively poor or were so at most a generation ago. When you are poor, it's tougher to take big risks as you don't have a family/friends/house/bank account to fall back on if you fail.
- jacques_chester 13y agoIn ordinary politics, everything is collapsed into "good" or "bad" and taken as a lump sum. Sides are formed largely by historical accident and their policy mix varies from year to year. However, everything the other team does is bad, everything my team does is good. You can, if you wish, choose to think about these matters as if policies matter individually and collectively; rather than simply saying Team A Good, Team B Evil. So, for example, I admire Singapore's relatively low taxes and business-friendly administration. I can fear and detest their stultifying social policies. See? That wasn't so hard. I like that Australia has one of the best records of reform from the 80s through the 90s. And I hate that it basically stopped in the early 2000s. See? That wasn't so hard.