5 ms·
The Biggest Pivot in YC History
- pedalpete 13y agoAside from the nutritional benefits, I'm sure you guys have looked at the environmental benefits of soylent as well. I'd love to try the product (but I'm in Australia). I don't know about the biggest pivot, but I'd say it could be the biggest disruptive business, possibly ever. I've always envisioned a future where you'd eat a meal as a special social occasion, otherwise, get your nutrition from something like soylent (though I imagined a pill).
- arkitaip 13y agoThat sounds like a dystopia to me. EDIT: I have to concede that while the Soylent team's lack of health/nutrition expertise is worrying, the promise of their business is so important on a global scale that they deserve to get funded and further research their ideas. Very rarely do you see a startup operate in this space, even more rare one that could end up fighting world hunger.
- pedalpete 13y agoThough I agree it's a dystopia for some (I'm working on a cooking start-up, I love to cook), it also is a saviour to many, and possibly to the environment. I was thinking earlier today that if they are just capable of getting people to use soylent twice a day for a hurried breakfast before work, and for many (like me) who work through their lunchtime, that would have not only a massive market. The thing is, how much of this is just the right marketing. Meal replacement drinks have been around forever, and though the name says it all, we don't believe that the product is actually a replacement for our meals, rather it's an occasional helper to get us to the next meal.
- buro9 13y agoNutrition... I wonder what the core data looks like for what you need to consume, and how agreed upon it is. I've always read differing and greatly conflicting views on what a person should have as intake, obviously because it's very subjective and so many factors are being balanced (who's saying it, why, motives, height, age, activity levels, etc). The greatest part of this experiment that interests me is less about providing the product and more to do with determining the exact mix for someone.
- mherdeg 13y agoIf I remember right, another successful company which pivoted away from building wireless networks in developing countries was Meraki. Poor developing countries. I hope they get their ubiquitous wireless soon. (Alternately, I wonder what this project will pivot into: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1776324009/brck-your-backup-generator-for-the-internet http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1776324009/brck-your-bac... ).
- adlpz 13y agoThere has been a lot of criticism around here about this Soylent thing, and it's understandable: it's dangerous to trust your health to some guys without any medical or nutritional background. But I am really happy to hear they are getting YC support and funding, now they will be able to develop it further with good input from specialists. This could become something really big.
- ig1 13y agoDo you have a professional nutritionist who designs every meal for you, or do you rely upon restaurants and self-made foods ? With any diet there's risks, assuming it's not missing any major dietary component it's unlikely to be any unhealthier than your average fast-food diet.
- adlpz 13y agoWell, no. As during any week I eat from several different restaurants, grocery stores and supermarkets, with a large variety of products and cooking styles, it is largely more unlikely that I'm missing any important part of my nutrition. Soylent is a single product, from a single supplier, with a single ingredient list, for every meal, everyday.
- dpcx 13y agoWhy does everyone seem to think that Soylent is "for every meal, everyday"? Rob has stated several times that he still eats out with friends occasionally. Soylent is just his way of getting through food preparation ad nauseam. Also, it doesn't have a single ingredient list. It's been stated several times that the measurements would be modified according to each individual that would use Soylent.
- DanBC2 13y ago> Why does everyone seem to think that Soylent is "for every meal, everyday"? Because they're selling it as that. Perhaps Soylent could consider reading these threads and improving their website information? >Also, it doesn't have a single ingredient list. It's been stated several times that the measurements would be modified according to each individual that would use Soylent. This version of the product comes, I think, in just two forms, Male and Female. Ingredients are crucial. (Perhaps a legal requirement? I don't know about the US market.) Certainly a list of ingredients for the base product is possible. It'll be interesting to see how Soylent do the tailoring to each individual. It'll be interesting to see what information they use to do that modification.
- logicallee 13y agoWhy doesn't soylent just pivot to being a giant blender as a service company. Then you can just select what you want to eat: like a three-course meal, everything from soup to desert. Then they just blend all that up just-in-time and ship it out to you as one disgusting mush.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoA mechanical pre-digestor at-a-distance service. Interesting.
- zalew 13y agoso, let me get this straight: the backers bought a powder substance from a random guy on the internet, consumed it for a week, excitingly report less sleep, more energy, better mood, and come back asking for more...
- DoubleMalt 13y agoWhile I appreciate the efficiency of this, I will happily stay a relic of the olden days, when we ate food not only for being able to hack the next day, but also took pleasure out of every meal. I am happy to spend a considerable part of my budget to procure groceries that have been grown in a sustainable way and meat from animals that were not industrially produced. I am also happy to spend considerable time preparing these ingredients into Dishes that are not only nutritious but also a good enjoyment for all senses. For people that otherwise get their food from budget Walmart microwave dishes or McDonalds and the likes, Soylent might be a good alternative. It is probably easy to add all kinds of spices to create the illusion of variation that is very important for most human taste buds.
- arkitaip 13y agoI share your worries but "I will happily stay a relic of the olden days, when we ate food not only for being able to hack the next day" has never really been true. It's only very recently -- say last 100 years -- that people in the West have been able to eat for pleasure on a more massive scale instead of eating so you don't starve or get enough energy to work. Things like meat or variety in diet were mostly reserved for the upper classes. Lots of people on the planet are still going hungry or even starving and for those people Soylent - provided it's actually cheaper and proven to be safe - could mean having access to regular nutritious meals for the first time in their lives.
- buro9 13y agoEpicurus might disagree with your assertion that the pleasure of eating is only a recent thing or the fare only of the rich. Although he's much misunderstood upon the layman as meaning luxurious foods and pleasures, it's understood he really meant to enjoy basic foods (usually grown in the communal garden) amongst friends. Soylent would be great for many reasons; third world, developing world, a trip to Mars. But I also share the thought that food is a pleasure and I won't want to give that up.
- KC8ZKF 13y ago
- avian 13y agoDoes anyone have a link to any article about their previous white space radio effort? I'm interested in learning more about their failure in that field and what were the hurdles he is referring to. I can't seem to find them on the YC summer 2012 list and their new nutrition thing is all that comes up in my web searches.
- JDGM 13y agoIt is not clear to me from the article their relationship with YC. It begins "YC accepted our original idea, to build affordable wireless networks for developing countries, for the summer 2012 batch", before explaining how that didn't work out and they moved to "working on a handful of projects. Sometimes collectively, sometimes independently". Then the article begins on Soylent and, aside from a few appearances from Paul Graham, YC isn't mentioned again (literally, I even used the find function to check I hadn't read too quickly and missed a crucial paragraph). From when "YC accepted our original idea" has everything these guys have done been under a kind of YC umbrella? Did they break away then re-establish with YC when Soylent started taking off? I have no idea how any of this works. Could someone fill in what is between the lines here please? On another note, I've enjoyed the passion and controversy of the Soylent topics on here and avoided commenting because someone has always said what I was going to - except they've said it hours ago and four people have made good rebuttals, and four more have made rebuttals to each those, and so on, to the point where I just want to drink it all in rather than join the noise. However, this part seems a new one on me: "Rob would simply go to the pitcher, shake it once, and pour a delicious meal for himself" Delicious? I was under the impression Soylent was either fairly tasteless or mildly unpleasant-tasting. Is it really delicious? In what way? Why? How?
- marknutter 13y ago> Delicious? I was under the impression Soylent was either fairly tasteless or mildly unpleasant-tasting. Is it really delicious? In what way? Why? How? It has quite a bit of sugar. Just go back and read the many articles that have been written by both the founders and the press.
- JDGM 13y agoThanks. I've just done a google and the only person I can find describing Soylent as 'delicious' in the first few hits is Rob himself, who even says "I'm not trying to make something delicious; there are already a lot of delicious things" - that's defending Soylent's taste in this Gawker article http://gawker.com/we-drank-soylent-the-weird-food-of-the-future-510293401 http://gawker.com/we-drank-soylent-the-weird-food-of-the-fut.... The piece contains the following: "Soylent tastes like the homemade nontoxic Play-Doh you made, and sometimes ate, as a kid. Slightly sweet and earthy with a strong yeasty aftertaste." "It tasted like when you're baking and you taste the ingredients even if there's not sugar or vanilla in there, you just have a compulsion to taste wet food." "My mouth tastes hot and like old cheese." "It tasted like someone wrung out a dishtowel into a glass." As a health food Soylent had my curiosity. As a 'delicious' food it has my attention. However, that attention appears to have been misallocated.
- jacquesm 13y agoFood is more than just nutrition, food is a way to share time with friends and family, to connect. To actually chew your food is good, not a waste of time, it also slows you down to the point where you appreciate the taste of it and the work that went into making it. You mess with such mechanisms at your peril. Eating is not about 'efficiency' unless you're an astronaut or a person doing a round-the-world flight in some exotic aircraft. I'm sure that in a world where people are all about getting the most out of their day and shaving off a few minutes by reading on their mobiles whilst in the toilet a thing like this might be popular. But I'd rather sit down with my family and/or a bunch of people and share a meal rather than to fuel up.
- jaibot 13y agoRight, I think the Soylent people mostly agree with you. The thing is, they say, most people aren't having 21 emotionally enriching delicious meals a week. Sometimes you are just eating to get things done, and that's where you throw in a soylent and then stop thinking about it. Beautiful artwork is important, but sometimes you just want to paint a wall white so you can get on with doing other important things.
- mike_esspe 13y agoDo you share every meal with friends? How do you arrange the invitations? It seems, that soylent is for time, when you eat in solitude, and for me it's the majority of my dinners.
- jacquesm 13y agoI eat every meal with at least one other person, and usually with at least three and if I were to be alone and thought about eating as 'fuelling up for the next round' I'd slow down and take out my phone to invite someone to have dinner with me. Friends are always welcome to eat at our house, and to stay if they want to. Plenty of HN'ers have already found out that that is not idle talk.
- marknutter 13y ago
- brudgers 13y agoAs I type this I am eating, for breakfast, a sausage biscuit. I am unlikely to switch to Soylent. Now that you know my opinion, should I pretend to believe I have made you smarter? Maybe we can pretend to have made each other smarter together by expressing the same opinion. Who gives a fuck if I am in the target market segment? The important lessons of Soylent are applicable beyond the specifics. They scratched their own itch, they're shipping, they're gaining the traction needed to build a clear brand, and above all the founders were not so in love with the contents of their own heads that they failed to recognize failure nor seize opportunity. Sure it's not a product that contains interesting ideas expressed as computer code. Ain't the point. What matters is not the operands but the implementation of the operands. Good luck to the Soylent team. Maybe you will convince me to be a customer, but no hard feelings if you forego wooing me.
- weisser 13y agoIt was Warren Zevon who shortly before his untimely death from cancer said, "Enjoy every sandwich." Only one aspect of our eating habits should be the nutritional value. Enjoyment of your food and the people you eat with are also very important. Very interesting post - I know many people will eat this product right up.
- DanBC2 13y agoSoylent have some fierce competition. Liquid feeding is not new. Many companies do it already. Liquid feeding for developing world also isn't new. There are a number of foods developed especially for that market. Here are some of the competitor products: (http://ensure.com/ http://ensure.com/) Ensure (https://www.nutricia.co.uk/fortisip// https://www.nutricia.co.uk/fortisip//) Fortisip (http://www.complan.com/ http://www.complan.com/) Complan (http://abbottnutrition.com/brands/abbott-brands http://abbottnutrition.com/brands/abbott-brands) Abbott Nutrition Brands These are big companies. They have dieticians and nutritionists working for them. They have established manufacturing channels sorted out. They supply a known, quality product to a variety of sources. They have existing contracts with big customers. They have expertise in selling to healthcare markets. Note also the caution they use when describing their products - they don't claim that these are suitable for anyone. They certainly don't suggest that you stay on a liquid diet if you don't need it. They strongly suggest doctor's supervision. Soylent claim to be interested in the developing world markets. About 20% of the world live on less than $1.25 per day. (http://povertydata.worldbank.org/poverty/home) http://povertydata.worldbank.org/poverty/home)) And the main ingredient of Soylent is water, supplied by the user. About one billion people don't have access to clean drinking water. (http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/mdg1/en/index.html http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/mdg1/en/index.htm...) The World Food Program and UNICEF have some information. (https://www.wfp.org/nutrition/special-nutritional-products https://www.wfp.org/nutrition/special-nutritional-products) -- see how cheap they're aiming for? It's your body, and what you do with it is up to you. But Soylent are being irresponsible by selling this product as "safe", for everyone, as "tested", when it hasn't had any testing, and we don't know that it is safe, and we do know that it is not safe for everyone. And this is the company selling most of the ingredients for these various nutri-stuffs (http://www.dsm.com/en_US/foodandbeverages/public/home/pages/ingredient-vitamins.jsp http://www.dsm.com/en_US/foodandbeverages/public/home/pages/...) Good Luck and everything, but I don't think they have any clue what they're doing, or who the established competitors are. (Using secondary account because I'd set noprocast a bit too long)
- marknutter 13y agoWhy doesn't anyone post stuff like this when other startups are trying to disrupt well established industries?
- brandoncarl 13y agoA few points of warning to the creators of Soylent: 1. Chewing is important. It helps trigger the brain to stimulate the digestive process. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7568724.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7568724.stm 2. "Meal time" appears to be an important social construct. For example, the single strongest predictor of school achievement scores was the frequency and duration of family meals. http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/handle/2027.42/73393/j.1741-3737.2001.00295.x.pdf?sequence=1 http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/handle/2027.42/73393... 3. Scientists are just now discovering the importance of bacteria in food consumption. Bacteria can be difficult due to the need for some of them to be refrigerated. NYT ran a great article recently on the problems with baby formula (arguably an infant-stage competitor :)). http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/19/magazine/say-hello-to-the-100-trillion-bacteria-that-make-up-your-microbiome.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/19/magazine/say-hello-to-the-... 4. Finally, getting the right mix of nutrients can be fairly difficult. I was surprised to find the "dark side of antioxidants". Thus far, in the studies I've read, it has been extremely difficult to "beat" a "whole" foods diet. http://bigthink.com/devil-in-the-data/the-dark-side-of-antioxidants http://bigthink.com/devil-in-the-data/the-dark-side-of-antio... No kickbacks, but the best "drink" I've found in this arena so far has been Xymogen's i5: https://www.xymogen.com/products/product-detail.aspx?pid=78 https://www.xymogen.com/products/product-detail.aspx?pid=78. I use it for reasons alluded to below in background. Background: wife is a food and travel writer. Some major life hurdles have required us to study and be extremely cognizant of what we eat.
- marknutter 13y ago1. So click your teeth together a few times while you drink Soylent. Or better yet, chew some gum afterwards! 2. Don't replace your family dinners with Soylent then. Just replace the meals you typically eat alone. Problem solved. 3. Don't replace every meal with Soylent. Only the ones for which the preparation is inconvenient for you. Again, problem solved. 4. Getting the right mix of nutrients is difficult whether or not you're drinking Soylent. I would argue most, if not all people are deficient in one nutrient or another. Adding Soylent to your diet would probably ensure (no pun intended) that you'd get more nutrients than you do now, not less.
- coopdog 13y agoSoylent is a much better name for a nutritious food drink, it's almost like they meant it from the beginning http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Sp-VFBbjpE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Sp-VFBbjpE
- bradfa 13y agoSo what's to come of the white space networking work? At $70 BOM cost, it failed, but at $15 BOM cost it might succeed. Why not put the work into the public domain and let someone else do good with it?
- gms 13y agoDoes Soylent take care of fibre intake?
- DanBC2 13y agoYes, it has some grams of fibre. I'm not sure what form the fibre is in, or how much. It's on their website somewhere.
- Ecio78 13y agoPreviously on HN (same blog post): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5746287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5746287 Their big "campaign" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5745707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5745707
- marknutter 13y agoIt seems I'm late to the thread but I want everyone to realize that you don't need to drink Soylent or any other meal replacement solution for every meal. Attacking the idea of meal replacement on that assumption is attacking the straw man. The founder of Soylent only replaced every single meal of his to test out the product, not as a recommendation for how it should be used. If you enjoy preparing every meal you eat, or eating social for every meal, Soylent isn't for you so save the specious criticisms. If you do, however, get annoyed by having to prepare certain meals and wish you could just get the food into your belly immediately without the work on occasion, then Soylent or some other meal replacement drink is a great solution. It's not going to kill you, or mess up your health, or do any of the many terrible things people have been warning about in every thread having to do with Soylent. It's going to perhaps save you some time and give you a few essential nutrients you may not have been getting otherwise. That's it.
- DanBC2 13y ago> It's not going to kill you, or mess up your health How do you know?
- marknutter 13y agoGive me a break. People have gone on crazier diets for a lot longer than this guy has and not died. Steve Jobs famously went on an all fruit diet for years and did not die as a result. There are people out there who literally eat nothing but McDonalds for breakfast lunch and dinner and it takes decades for them to die. We are more resilient than you're giving us credit for.
- DanBC2 13y agoSo you don't know? Yet you're happy for them to sell it as safe for everyone, as providing optimal nutrition, as bring people to perfect health, as being tested, when we don't know if any of that is true? (And we know the tested part is a lie).
- 13y ago
- waterlesscloud 13y agoIs this really being flagged? Come on, HN.
- alok-g 13y agoHow is this a pivot? This is closing of the old shop and opening a completely new one.