4 ms·
I'd rather see something essentially a ramjet-in-a-tube, similar to UW's RAMAC space cannon launcher. Essentially, a long tube filled with correct mixtures of
by rdl 13y ago
I'd rather see something essentially a ramjet-in-a-tube, similar to UW's RAMAC space cannon launcher. Essentially, a long tube filled with correct mixtures of natural gas and oxygen, where a double-cone shaped projectile is accelerated through external (railgun?) means into the breech, and then the compression of gas detonates it right behind the projectile, accelerating it like a ramjet at constant acceleration. For a shuttle, you deaccel by running in reverse from midpoint. It'd be like $100 in natural gas to send 100 people from SF to LA at mach. You'd have to build a low-pressure 1-4m diameter pipeline, totally something we know how to do already for water pipes and natural gas pipelines.
If I had $50mm (or access to that level of capital), I'd probably build one as a LEO satellite launcher. Put 20kg satellites into LEO, full of Ka-band gear, for $100k each, several times a day, 365 days a year. On the side of a mountain in Kenya/Ethiopia/Somalia.
- venomsnake 13y agoHow do you brake this thing in normal operation? How do you break this thing during emergency? Edit: Fixed typo
- sounds 13y agoI think his proposed business model (a satellite launch service) would not concern itself with braking. If you needed to abort, your only chance would be after launch. So this would probably not be useful for human cargo.
- Groxx 13y ago>I think his proposed business model (a satellite launch service) would not concern itself with braking. I didn't interpret it that way: >It'd be like $100 in natural gas to send 100 people from SF to LA at mach.
- sounds 13y agoOk, fair enough. I wasn't taking that sentence very seriously. I suppose he could try to get people to ride it, especially if he only operated out of a country where the regulations were lax enough. No way he could do that in SF or LA though.
- Groxx 13y agoYeah, it's a little off-the-cuff. They definitely sound more interested in launching satellites (an interesting system for doing so, to be sure). I'm biasing it towards people-oriented since this is all anchored by a hyperloop article.
- rdl 13y agoYeah, it's really two separate things, but related. 1) Satellite launch using a 1-10km long, 1m diameter tube on the side of a mountain in Somalia. Conventional RAMAC. Small impulse, long push from natural gas ramjet in the tube, potentially an atmospheric rocket stage, and a circularizing rocket (probably liquid fueled, using liquid fuel to fill the void spaces around deployables to deal with the 1000-5000G acceleration). This is just a matter of financing and implementation, I think -- the basic engineering and science is pretty sound. I think this could actually be <10G, and thus suitable for humans, if you had an 8-9m diameter tube. The peak acceleration goes down with longer/thicker tubes. For a 155mm, it's about 50k G. An iPhone is fine at 5k G; potted boards are fine at 50k G (we have artillery rounds which have satellite receivers, guidance, etc.) 2) A long tube, continuous, designed on the same principle. Mag rail gun to start, natural gas in the tube for ramac (continuous or maybe intermittent), and air bearings, and then either reverse-ramac or just steadily increase density to brake. Doing this for passengers is maybe possible. I'm not sure if the engineering works out at all.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Groxx 13y agoWouldn't you have to re-fuel the tube each time? Presumably this would cost more than $100... and how would this work in reverse to slow down? I would think (probably incorrectly, since I know next to nothing about it) that a ram-based system would inherently have combustion primarily behind whatever tightest-seal exists that's bringing the gasses up to combustion temperature, since doing so would also mean the expansion pushes forward against that seal. Or does simply sealing a bit better cause combustion in front of the seal?
- rdl 13y agoActually I didn't think as much about how to do deacceleration correctly; you wouldn't be able to just flip it around and do ramjet-style, you'd have to use a progressively more sense fluid to fill the tube, which would create a lot of heat. You could still do braking over a hundred miles, progressively, though. The main goal (vs. a regular cannon) would be to spread the impulse over a long acceleration area, not all at once like with an explosive-powered gun. People would probably be happiest with <1G.
- abcd_f 13y agoDo you realize how impossibly loud this is going to be?
- rdl 13y agoThat's why, for satellite launch, it would go in the Horn of Africa. Maximum volume is at the muzzle, and would pretty much require an exclusion zone of maybe 10 miles out, and would be deafeningly loud for another 50 miles. Mountains would be ideal for this.