9 ms·
"...after devoting “substantial resources” in the case, FBI agents apparently have been able to decrypt one of the drives. The government argued that because it
by joezydeco 13y ago
"...after devoting “substantial resources” in the case, FBI agents apparently have been able to decrypt one of the drives. The government argued that because it had found “numerous files which constitute child pornography..."
So if they've found the evidence they're looking for, why keep pressing? Because they don't want to spend the extra effort to decrypt the rest and are looking for a plea bargain?
- DanBC 13y agoTo see if they can identify the victim and take protective action.
- 3825 13y ago>The government argued that because it had found “numerous files which constitute child pornography,” “detailed personal financial records and documents belonging to Feldman,” and “dozens of personal photographs of Feldman," Feldman therefore has “access to and control over” the set of drives. So if the FBI puts my bank statements (PDF) and my photos in a drive along with "some files that constitute child pornography", am I guilty as well? "We found three safes. We opened one of them and found some illegal things in it. We swear we didn't put them there. We also found some financial records and photos belonging to this guy. We didn't put those there either. Pinky swear!"
- DanBC 13y agoI'm assuming they would have taken forensic images of the drives, rather than the drives themselves. Tampering with evidence would be stupid. They'd go to jail, they'd risk all previous cases they've been involved in, etc. I guess it happens, but you need a lot more than "I bet they did it".
- yebyen 13y agoYeah, so I'm convinced that the FBI would not have done the tampering. Now show that no other person has had access to the drives' contents prior to their collection as evidence. He would certainly strengthen the case for that (his ownership and control of the data) if he was able to decrypt the drives himself.
- gamblor956 13y agoThey don't need to do that. The drives went from the defendant's house straight to the FBI evidence bag when they were picked up by the FBI evidence tech while searching his home. If the defendant wants to argue that someone hacked his computers and put the CP on his drive before the FBI took them, that is for him to argue. If he can't provide any proof of such (note that he is not required to provide proof), it is unlikely that the jury will believe such a defense.
- yebyen 13y agoYeah, you're right. I would like to know how they decrypted the drive though. "Substantial resources" does not say much. It could mean a lot of computing power, or just a lot of brute-force sleuthing to find the backdoor. What exactly should a third-party frame-up look like? In my mind, at least, how they came to be able to decrypt the drive could possibly lend some credibility to their claim that he owned it and was in control of it, and the remaining drives as well.
- rosser 13y agoTotally guessing, but the password is probably the weak point.
- yebyen 13y agoI would have guessed otherwise, if this guy is an IT pro, he probably knows to use a long and secure passphrase. I'll be surprised if someone who knows can say the password was the weak point. Maybe you're right, but... I'd think the most likely way to get in would be to find the passphrase had been cached somewhere, or the unencrypted key was accidentally copied somewhere onto a swap file from some shoddily built backup process that used up most of the RAM compressing files, resulting in that or some similar leak. Same as you though, I don't really have the slightest idea.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoBecause one hard drive still gives him a considerable degree of deniability. The court is essentially arguing that there is a threshold of suspicion beyond which it is OK to punish someone into admitting guilt.
- gamblor956 13y agoWell, no. The number of hard drives is irrelevant. They already have enough to prosecute him and put him away (effectively, for life, using a civil commitment regime). The purpose of attempting to compel the decrypting of the other drives is so that they can attempt to (1) identify new victims, (2) identify new predators, and (3) to identify new sources/trading sites for CP. From a legal standpoint the 5th Amendment is not an issue if decrypting the drives would simply reveal more evidence of the crimes already charged (because guilt is not a matter of the quantity of evidence but rather its persuasiveness). However, if decrypting those drives would yield evidence of uncharged crimes, it would be a 5th Amendment issue which would bar the use of any such decrypted evidence against this defendant...but not against other defendants. They already have him dead to rights, so they would be perfectly happy to acquire evidence they can't use against this guy if it means they can go after others CP collectors/distributors/predators.
- Anderkent 13y ago>The court is essentially arguing that there is a threshold of suspicion beyond which it is OK to punish someone into admitting guilt. Assuming actual guilt, of course, as decrypting the harddrives is not a confession if he does not have child porn there.
- lotharbot 13y agoThey've found some evidence. If they can find more, it makes their case stronger. It also could potentially allow them to either (a) identify and rescue a victim, or (b) identify and prosecute producers.
- rmc 13y agoThe (now) encrypted drives might have evidence that can be used to prosecute other people?
- lmkg 13y agoIt's part of the complicated dance that prosecution has to do to not overstep the bounds of the 5th Amendment's ban on compelled testimony. 5th Amendment protections means that if you compel someone to give you information, then that information and its immediate consequences are no longer court-admissible evidence. If there is any information that you don't want to "poison" with self-incrimination, you want to make sure that you can establish that information separately. So, if the court compelled the defendant to decrypt his hard drive, then the fact that that type of content was on his drives is a direct consequence, and therefore not court-admissible. However, now the existence of that category of content on drives under his control has been established independently. Therefore, the "cost" (in terms of information rendered inadmissible) of compelling decryption has been reduced considerably. (IANAL)
- btilly 13y agoMy guess would be that they want to see if they can find information which will lead them to other pedophiles. But as long as his personal liability hangs in the balance, the protection from the 5th should apply.
- jacquesm 13y agoThere's that, and another thing that CP hunters like about having large filesets at their disposal is that it allows them to compute new hashes/fingerprints of files to test against in future hauls. The bigger the net the bigger the catch with these guys, typically. Microsoft and a local forensic unit in NL (the NFI) did a license deal on photodna to do just that.