4 ms·
This will probably get downvotes, but this is one of those posts that just rubs me the wrong way. Your mileage may vary. I stopped short at the beginning of th
by pdonis 13y ago
This will probably get downvotes, but this is one of those posts that just rubs me the wrong way. Your mileage may vary.
I stopped short at the beginning of the second paragraph:
Every talk is for an audience, and it's the speaker's responsibility to say what the audience needs to hear.
Wait, what? Yes, every talk is for an audience, but that just means you have to know where your audience is coming from in order to communicate. You don't give a talk full of programming jargon to an audience of businesspeople that know nothing about programming except that they often need to hire programmers.
But to me, the second part of that statement sounds like something a con man would say. You say whatever it is you came there to say; whether it's "what the audience needs to hear" is irrelevant. (Of course the audience is presumably interested in what you have to say; otherwise, how did you get the speaking gig in the first place? But to me, a speaker who worries about "what the audience needs to hear" is not a speaker I will put much credence in. I want a speaker who will say what he thinks, regardless of its impact on me.)
Then there's this, later on:
one of the most powerful and important statements you'll ever hear...
Right now, today, we can't see the thing, at all, that's going to be the most important 100 years from now.
100 years? How about 10 years? Our inability to predict the future works on much shorter timescales than he seems to think. Why the emphasis on 100 years?
Oh:
I personally care about mattering 100 years from now.
As another commenter here pointed out, if your work still matters 100 years from now it probably means your field has stagnated. Even getting your tools for thinking to matter 100 years from now is a longshot; are you Einstein? Are you Shannon? Sure, those are ideals to aspire to, but the very nature of large numbers means most of us won't end up there.
I see the writer's general point, and I even agree with it: having better tools to think with can have a far greater impact than building one particular thing. But what's conspicuously missing from this post is any specifics on how to do that, or how to teach young people to do that.
Ok, done ranting. :-)
- ableal 13y ago> Ok, done ranting. :-) OK, I'll take it from here ;-). Me, I paused at these words: "the intent is always to influence" Well, yes, I suppose so. Except, perhaps, for the non-fools (actually Johnson said blockheads) who wisely spin entertaining stories for money. But the word "influence" always reminds me of a story that my mother recounted. Many moons ago, there was a bit of social and labor unrest around our parts, and there was a general workers assembly at the factory where she worked. One of the workers speaking at the meeting said his piece, and finished by remarking: "But this is just my opinion, and anyone who lets himself be influenced is a fool". That simple remark still gives me pause today, when I contemplate all the "influencers" busily emulating Genghis Khan, trying to insert their ideas into as many brains as possible.
- pdonis 13y agoI know I said my post would probably get downvotes, but I'm glad to find someone discussing instead of downvoting. Thanks. :-) I agree that the use of the word influence instead of inform is highly suggestive.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 13y agowhether it's "what the audience needs to hear" is irrelevant A charitable interpretation of his meaning leads to the same conclusion you have. Maybe what he means is "Every talk is for an audience, and it's the speaker's responsibility to say what the audience needs to hear so they understand the point"? 100 years? How about 10 years? Our inability to predict the future works on much shorter timescales than he seems to think. Why the emphasis on 100 years? Because he's referencing a talk given at the 100th anniversary of CalTech. Other than that, yes, I agree, it did come off as a bit pretentious. But I feel his point, he wants to work on things that matter to him, for the time frame he defines.
- pdonis 13y agoI feel his point, he wants to work on things that matter to him, for the time frame he defines. Yes, I get that that's his point--but he's not just saying he wants to do that himself, he's saying he wants to influence other people to do it. He's convinced it's so important that it's OK to skew the information he gives people in order to influence them. At least, that's what I read between the lines. (And btw, I'm not saying this is what he intended; I'm just saying that's how it comes across to me.) Btw, as I said to ableal, thanks for discussing instead of downvoting. :-)
- adw 13y agoWhy is persuasion such a bad thing? He's absolutely in the persuasion game. So is everyone else. I see it as him acknowledging that and saying "you know, this is a position of power, I have a responsibility to use it for good, as I see it". Other people have a responsibility for how they react, too, of course. No-one is an island. In particular, anyone who designs a user interface – which guides you to do thing A rather than thing B – is in the persuasion game. They're trying to shape your behavior for - hopefully - your own good. Blackhat UX is when the converse happens. Facts are the domain of pure math. Everything else is conditional.
- pdonis 13y agoWhy is persuasion such a bad thing? Because it's extremely difficult to set out to persuade someone of something and not give them a skewed presentation of the issue about which you are trying to persuade them. (IMO it's actually impossible, but just "extremely difficult" is sufficient for this discussion.) And as soon as you skew your presentation of the issue, no matter how you rationalize it in terms of "it's for their own good" or "I've spent a lot of time and effort on this, I know more than they do", etc., etc., you're still, at the end of the day, substituting your judgment for theirs. IMO that's never a good thing. "you know, this is a position of power, I have a responsibility to use it for good, as I see it" Why is it a position of power? Who gave it to him? And why did he take it, instead of saying, "No, I'm not going to take this power and try to use it for good. That never works. Go look up the facts and make up your own mind." Bottom line, I simply don't accept that it has to be that way--that somebody has to have power, and so the best we can do is hope they'll use it for good. I get that it's human nature to let things be that way, I get that the alternative--that everybody makes up their own mind, period, no exceptions--is scary to many people (not to mention that it would basically break our entire media culture). But that doesn't make it right. anyone who designs a user interface – which guides you to do thing A rather than thing B – is in the persuasion game. They're trying to shape your behavior for - hopefully - your own good. Again, I get that this point of view is rampant--it basically defines Apple, for example--but that doesn't make it right. (And yes, I know that Apple does this because its customers pay for it. That doesn't make it right either.) Just to be clear, I'm not saying that I expect things to change any time soon. I labeled my OP as "ranting" for a reason. :-) Facts are the domain of pure math. Everything else is conditional. Really? Gravity is conditional? The way a microchip works is conditional? Or more to the point: is "anyone who designs a user interface is in the persuasion game" conditional? You didn't make it sound that way.
- jbrennan 13y ago>Every talk is for an audience, and it's the speaker's responsibility to say what the audience needs to hear. > >Wait, what? I don't think he means what you're inferring. I don't think he's trying to skew anything or anyone, but instead emphasizing for all of his talks, he's trying to present a message in a way the audience should understand it. It's not about deceiving any more than a beginner's programming book (with simplified examples) deceives a beginner. It explains what they need to know, on their terms.
- pdonis 13y agoSee the other comments downthread. If he had used the word "inform" instead of "influence", for example, I might buy your interpretation. But "influence", to me, means he's taking it upon himself to decide what to present based on "what the audience needs to hear", instead of deciding what to present based on the subject matter--what needs to be presented to enable the audience to understand. Yes, this is a judgment call: as I said in my OP, your mileage may vary. But that's how I read it.
- espeed 13y agoBret is trying to get people to see what he sees because he knows it will lead to a leap in humankind's ability to transfer knowledge. He sees a way to amplify the world's ability to learn and understand. This transformation in how to design and present content will accelerate learning by making the impenetrable accessible. He's making this his life's work, and it's clear he has spent countless hours pondering and working it. A hallmark of a genius is a rare and valuable perspective -- a unique mental model -- that has been built up over time through long periods of deep contemplation. As a result, these rare and valuable perspectives enable you to see what few (if any) have seen before. Bret sees a lever that will amplify human understanding, and he knows how to get there. The difficulty is transferring his mental model to others because the gaps in understanding are often too great. We might get a glimpse of what he sees, but it will be only a sliver until we have explored what he's explored from every angle and have reconstructed the model in our mind. Part of the challenge is showing others how to get to this golden lever, but the first step is to others to recognize its significance so they are inspired to begin the journey. This is what he meant by influence. However, inspiring others to take action can be hard when they begin with only a fuzzy notion of what he sees. But notice the premise of his talk is about providing a solution to this problem. By fundamentally redesigning our interfaces to knowledge, it will be easier for one to transfer their mental model to others -- he states this premise at the beginning. His talk provided a glimpse into what's possible -- to help people snap out of fixed mindsets and point them toward a path beyond incremental improvement. The examples he provided weren't the end game -- they are just the beginning -- meant to whet our appetite. Seeing his work and watching his presentations, you feel his passion and know he lives with these ideas ruminating in the back of his mind everyday. He has explored them farther than almost anyone else in the world. Shinichi Mochizuki is another recent example of someone exploring an idea and following it out to a place no one else can see. Mochizuki spent years working on a proof for the ABC conjecture (http://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2012/11/03/abc-proof-too-tough-even-for-mathematicians/o9bja4kwPuXhDeDb2Ana2K/story.html http://www.bostonglobe.com/ideas/2012/11/03/abc-proof-too-to...). Mochizuki posted four papers for the proof on his website, but he has yet to publicly engage the mathematics community. During this process, he invented his own language -- he was in a mathematical world no one had seen or conceived before -- so his papers have been impenetrable to the world's top mathematicians. The gaps in understanding are too great. When Bret said he decided to present on "what the audience needs to hear", I suspect he's starting slow by giving them a glimpse of what he sees, rather than trying to distill everything into an hour talk. He's trying to influence people to think beyond their preconceived notions of what's possible. He's trying to get them to think different -- to inspire their work by illuminating a path that leads to transformative understanding.