6 ms·
Petition to release Cameron D'Ambrosio
- trustfundbaby 13y agoIt unfortunate, but the kid is an idiot. how you can post lyrics like that and not think it would set off alarm bells all over the place after a kid (right around the same age did something so terrible) just weeks before is beyond me. Hopefully he walks but I hope he finds the experience harrowing enough to learn a lesson or two about applying a little common sense to the concept of free speech.
- rasur 13y agoHmm, free speech in the USA seems to be quite a costly exercise these days.
- adventured 13y agoWhat we primarily have are hyper aggressive government prosecutors and a culture of militance at the Federal level that has spread to some state governments. Our government - $6.3 trillion in total expenditures (size of Japan's total economy) - is so massive it's effectively impossible to check its power or keep track of it. Nobody could ever afford to do so, and so the abuse of power sprawls.
- youngerdryas 13y agoI'm sure he'd be fine in Europe.
- derleth 13y agoUnless, of course, he "insulted Turkishness" in Turkey or insulted the Holocaust in Germany.
- jrockway 13y agoCan I read the other side of the story somewhere? I feel like I'm not getting the full truth.
- adventured 13y agoYou're getting the full truth. The story has been going around for a while now, and it was written about in his local paper. 1) He repeatedly posted anti-government statements on Facebook among other sites 2) He posted supposedly threatening rap lyrics invoking Boston and the White House 3) They arrested him for making terrorist threats This is what's known as a trial balloon. When fascists silence freedom of speech, they don't do it by rounding up millions, they do it by making a few public examples, and everybody else learns what not to say. Through this process it becomes extraordinarily easy to bring an entire population into compliance with new restrictions on speech, without actually altering any Constitutional amendments.
- betterunix 13y agoWhy are you so sure there is another side? How many times does the US government have to harass innocent people and ruin their lives before you are willing to accept that this sort of thing is happening every day?
- rayiner 13y agoBecause nearly every supposed story along these lines grossly misconstrues and distorts the underlying situation?
- betterunix 13y agoThat is only true if you believe that (a) our laws are just, (b) the police only ever make honest mistakes, and (c) that it is right to arrest anyone who breaks the law. In other words, you have to be so far down the right side of the political spectrum that anything short of a fascist tyranny would appear "leftist" by comparison.
- 13y ago
- dattaway 13y agoHis previous documented criminal history of physical violence was used as evidence.
- Bootvis 13y agoWhere?
- rasur 13y agoYou mean the biting claim in an 8th grade fight and a fight with his sister (who appeared in court in his defense for this current infraction) for which the Police were called (so, a domestic incident in other words). Yes, quite the terrorist - off to Gitmo with him! :-|
- dattaway 13y agoThis is the way the law works and should not be a surprise. He has an established documented history of harming people and the court failed to see a legitimate artistic merit of his case. Fortunately, he can take these arguments to the appellate court.
- gt7570 13y agoYour first claim was documented criminal history. Where is it Sherlock?
- ChrisAntaki 13y agohttp://youtu.be/-wbJTHkdBMc?t=38s http://youtu.be/-wbJTHkdBMc?t=38s From his rap: "Every day with a life of crime, and I'm always screwing up my life" Yeah!! That's pretty accurate.
- Blahah 13y agoPoor kid - his only crime was being a terrible rapper.
- aqme28 13y agoA lot of people on Reddit, etc... seem to be misinformed about what illegal free speech is, so here's some relevant case material: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio "Court held that government cannot punish inflammatory speech unless that speech is directed to inciting, and is likely to incite, imminent lawless action. ...In this case, the court found that Hess's words did not fall outside the limits of protected speech, in part, because his speech "amounted to nothing more than advocacy of illegal action at some indefinite future time,"[1] and therefore did not meet the imminence requirement." From Cameron's case: "The Methuen Chief of Police even stated: 'I do want to make clear he did not make a specific threat against the school or any particular individuals...'" Vague threats are not illegal.
- bradleyjg 13y agoBrandenburg lays out the incitement exception to the First Amendment. If I understand the allegations correctly (and that's made more difficult by the lack of the actual lyrics) the prosecution claims that the speech would instead be unprotected under the true threat doctrine. The leading Supreme Court case on that doctrine is Virginia v. Black 538 U.S. 343 (2003)[1], but unfortunately it's neither as clear nor quotable as Brandenburg. Here's the gist of the rule: "'True threats' encompass those statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals. The speaker need not actually intend to carry out the threat. Rather, a prohibition on true threats "protect[s] individuals from the fear of violence" and "from the disruption that fear engenders," in addition to protecting people "from the possibility that the threatened violence will occur." (internal citations omitted) [1] http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=US&navby=case&vol=000&invol=01-1107 http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=US...
- rayiner 13y agoIt should be noted that it's not the feds holding this kid, it's the police of his small-town Boston suburb. See: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/03/cameron-dambrosio-bomb-threat-boston-terrorism_n_3204149.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/03/cameron-dambrosio-b.... "Police learned of the threats after a student alerted a school official, the Herald writes." "'When we're just recovering from what occurred in Boston, to make a threat and use what occurred in Boston to enhance your threat, is extremely alarming for us,' Methuen Police Chief Joseph Solomon said at a press conference after D'Ambrosio was apprehended." Also: http://www.eagletribune.com/local/x326078366/Judge-Hes-a-threat http://www.eagletribune.com/local/x326078366/Judge-Hes-a-thr.... "Cameron D’Ambrosio was in Lawrence District Court yesterday in a suit, tie and shackles for a hearing to determine whether and how he could be released from custody after being arrested May 1." Not that it excuses the local police department's actions, but small-town shit like this has always happened. News of it just moves at light speed now thanks to the internet.
- Steko 13y agoOh no, white kid from the suburbs too? Time to get outraged.
- im3w1l 13y agoI think the statement implicit in your post definitely sounds plausible, but is it true? Can you point to an individual from another group being given similar treatment for similar action, where people did not become outraged?
- Steko 13y agoAre you asking me if there are other people who: (1) make random threats against the POTUS or the WH or other public figures or places (2) aren't actually a clear and present danger to carry out those threats (3) that still get the full monty by secret service/fbi/local cops/prosecutors (4) don't get to the top of HN Yes, there are probably a lot of people like that. And everyone says the same thing about most of those people, "Christ, what an idiot". Now I don't want to trivialize that this kid is clearly innocent and the victim of some injustice. I certainly don't think he "deserves it". But there's lots bigger injustice in the world to get outraged about and I think threads like this make decent platforms for calling the HN community out over it's blinders.
- kunai 13y agoI get two inferences from this: A) The people of this society are turning into safety-obsessed, overly politically correct weaklings or B) The two sides of the political spectrum exist to distract us while they both behind the scenes exist to remove our freedom Unfortunately, I'd have to say I think both A and B are true.
- derleth 13y agoThe first part is nothing new, and the second part is standard conspiracist pseudo-thought, which is also nothing new.
- betterunix 13y agoYou missed (C): That the overwhelming majority of politicians in power right now sit on the same side of the political spectrum, and that the debate has not been two sided for a very long time.
- derleth 13y agoOnly if you insist on applying the European spectrum to American politics. The thing to keep in mind, and this is absolutely critical, is that Europeans cannot vote in American elections. Therefore, the center of American politics, where practically all American politicians sit, is not in the same place as it is in Europe.
- shawndumas 13y agoonly one party believes that an unborn human has rights and protections under the law regardless of whether or not the respective mother wants them. only one party believes that two adults in love can be married under the law regardless of whether or not the respective people are of the same sex. if nothing else just those two diametric positions seem to indicate an important and meaningful distinction between the two parties.
- btilly 13y agoEven such an obvious litmus test as this is imperfect. According to polling data, over 20% of Republicans self-identify as pro-choice and 34% of Democrats as pro-life. There are plenty of Republicans who support gay rights. In fact did you know that the end of Don't Ask, Don't Tell stems from a lawsuit about the matter filed by gay Republicans? Yes, I know that Obama publicly takes all of the credit for that one, but the bill that he pushed for took effect on September 20, 2011 while Log Cabin Republicans v. United States forced an end to enforcement on July 6, 2011. There is no simple litmus test. Each party is a coalition of people with enough common interests that they prefer one tent over the other.
- mxnakqozlsjannl 13y agoDisgusting, also, how can anyone not see how all this shitty things your government does tends to make people like it even less? maybe breeding more 'terrorists'? That's the most recent terrorism problem, no? American citizens turning against their own country or something? I've got to be honest on one thing here, I don't plan on shutting my mouth about how much I think this things are terrible, and I guess I must also not plan to set foot around there anytime soon, would I get locked up for hearing "Paris - Bring it to ya" and posting it to my Facebook? I certainly COULD, apparently, so I won't be going there... before, I thought it would be nice to know California, where most of my favourite bands come from, go to the Burning Man, do a road trip and know the country and all the famous places but I'm giving those up.
- marcamillion 13y agoI am sorry....I feel no sympathy. People need to understand that words have meaning. Just because 'free speech' is protected by the constitution doesn't mean that you can (and should) say any crap, at any time, without thinking about the consequence. When you say stuff like: fuck a boston bombing wait till you see the shit I do, Imma be famous for rapping and beat every murder charge that comes across me. Let's take a step back here, and assume for a minute that he REALLY was planning something - and not just talking tough. If he did it, and he posted this stuff on Facebook, and the FBI didn't do anything about it.....what would the fracas be then? The FBI is incompetent....they knew he would do it, yet they did nothing, etc, etc, etc. It's really a lose-lose for them. They can either take preventive measures, or do nothing in the name of 'free speech protection' and risk the chance that this latest bozo is actually going to follow up with action. Kudos to the FBI for taking this seriously and showing people you can't just say crap like this without any consequence. Living in a free society comes with a cost. Not saying that a recent terrorist event was "nothing" is one of those costs. It's simple really. Also, if you think you aren't living in a free society, try moving to Saudi Arabia, many countries in Africa, Cuba, Bolivia, many S. American countries, many eastern european countries, etc.
- mindcrime 13y agoAlso, if you think you aren't living in a free society, try moving to Saudi Arabia, many countries in Africa, Cuba, Bolivia, many S. American countries, many eastern european countries, etc. Just because other countries are less free hardly proves that we are living in a free society. Maybe there is no free society on Earth? Kudos to the FBI for taking this seriously and showing people you can't just say crap like this without any consequence. I can't even begin to understand this mindset. In fact, it makes me a bit sick to hear somebody talk this way. But I suppose you think that if we all just sit back in the shadows, embrace fear, behave and do as the all mighty benevolent government tells us, then everything will be alright.
- marcamillion 13y agoI know it's an unpopular thing to hear....but freedom is a relative concept. You are only as free as compared to someone/something else. The world is a rough place, and is not a utopia. The fact is, people want to hurt the Western freedoms that many take for granted. Ignoring it, doesn't make those dangers go away. I am not defending everything the gov't does in the name of security, but the fact is that these challenges are not easy. They are doing the best they can. If they didn't act on it, and this kid did in fact do something, we would be having a COMPLETELY different conversation now. The reason these things are so tricky is because many of these attacks happen by 'lone wolves' which are almost impossible to stop. So as I said, this could have gone the other way - at which point I am sure you would be cursing the FBI for incompetence.
- greenyoda 13y agoPrior discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5748053 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5748053
- QuantumGood 13y agoThreats can be hard to parse because for the speaker, the point can be a very emotional self-expression, rather than some kind of accuracy of intent. One interpretation is: I'm going to do something insane that will make the news. It may involve the White House, and it will be worse than the Boston bombing. There will be multiple murder charges against me. Or: I'm going to publicly murder people in a fashion worse than the bombing. The last Facebook lyrics before he was arrested: I’m not in reality, So when u see me [bleeping] go insane and make the news, the paper, and the [bleeping] federal house of horror known as the white house, Don’t [bleeping] cry or be worried because all YOU people [bleeping] caused this [bleep]. [Bleep] a boston bominb wait till u see the [bleep] I do, I’ma be famous rapping, and beat every murder charge that comes across me! The whole alternate interpretation (it's an insufficiently specific threat, and primarily rap braggadocio) hinges mostly on the interpretation of the inclusion and placement of the line "I’ma be famous rapping." The problem is that the kid is clearly talking about himself killing people. The whole rap perspective doesn't fix that sufficiently, especially as Rappers talk about and threaten real murders, as well as merely "bragging" about them. It certainly seems likely that he's merely trying to "sound like a rapper" rather than threatening actual harm, but the words don't really absolve him of the threats contained therein. It is difficult to parse legally: 1. Legal: It lacks imminence (Brandenburg) 2. Illegal: It does communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence (Virginia v. Black) 3. Legal: It is not directed to a particular individual or group of individuals (Virginia v. Black) 4. Illegal: The speaker need not actually intend to carry out the threat...a prohibition on true threats...protect[s] individuals from...fear...disruption...[and] the possibility that the threatened violence will occur (Virginia v. Black) If there was a middle ground legally for people who's intent was less harmful than their speech it would benefit this kid, but how would you prove that? And it would muddy the law's ability to fight against true threats.
- davorak 13y ago> It certainly seems likely that he's merely trying to "sound like a rapper" rather than threatening actual harm, but the words don't really absolve him of the threats contained therein. It is difficult to parse legally: It did not seem that hard to parse, but I am not a lawyer. > 1. Legal: It lacks imminence (Brandenburg) No deadlines, so nothing showing anything soon. "I’ma be famous rapping," but first he needs to be a famous rapper which suggest no time soon. > 2. Illegal: It does communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence (Virginia v. Black) Threats in the lyrics are no different then threats and comments in many rappers famous and non-famous and more often then not seem non-serious( are not carried through, evidence of planning is lacking etc.) > 3. Legal: It is not directed to a particular individual or group of individuals (Virginia v. Black) He only mentions the white house, no specific individuals or groups. If he had mentioned individuals or party or a subcommittee it seems like it would still fall under political free speech which in general is heavily protected because it is supposed to at the root or a foundational pillar of the US's democracy. >4. Illegal: The speaker need not actually intend to carry out the threat...a prohibition on true threats...protect[s] individuals from...fear...disruption...[and] the possibility that the threatened violence will occur (Virginia v. Black) I see no evidence in the rap lyrics I have read that he was trying to cause disruption in the government or to change a group or individuals actions through threat. > If there was a middle ground legally for people who's intent was less harmful than their speech it would benefit this kid, but how would you prove that? And it would muddy the law's ability to fight against true threats. Normally in the US, at least, you do not have to prove some one's innocence. The state has the burden of proving guilty.