8 ms·
Back in the original dot-com bubble, I worked at a place that had the most amazing coffee machine I've ever seen. It was the size of a Coke machine and made ten
by smacktoward 14y ago
Back in the original dot-com bubble, I worked at a place that had the most amazing coffee machine I've ever seen. It was the size of a Coke machine and made ten thousand varieties of boutique coffee, most of which I'd never even heard of, all made to your specifications. It was incredible.
Then one day a guy came in with a hand cart, loaded the coffee machine on it, and rolled it away. A week later the layoffs started.
The lesson here isn't that there's something intangible or magic about free sodas or coffee. It's that when you used to give out free sodas and coffee, and then you stop, you're telling everyone in the company that business isn't as good as it used to be. Beverages are an easy thing for the bean-counters to get approval to cut, so when times get tough, they get cut first. But they're also a small line item, so while they're the first thing to get cut, they're usually not the last.
In other words, the free sodas are the proverbial canary in the coal mine. When they die, it's time to get out if you don't want to die with them.
This is why, when I visit clients these days, I make a point of going with them to their break room to get some coffee before our meeting starts. If their beverage situation has been upgraded since my last visit, they're doing well. If it's been downgraded, I know to be on guard for bean-counters coming after my relationship with them.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danso 14y agoIn the case of your company, it seems that the loss of the coffee machine was just the start of an impending death spiral (er...or am I judging too much from the preface of "in the original dot-com bubble")...but what about more moderate scenarios? Take, for example, Tumblr, which right now is a pretty big success. Just a month ago, they laid off their entire editorial team. Who knows if it was at all related to the Yahoo purchase, or if it was a decision made because Tumblr really need to cut expenses? But sometimes companies change course and cut because of ostensibly responsible financial concerns. In the case when an exciting company has to trim (but not just die), how should it handle the case of having a fancy coffee machine and possibly saving a job? It seems it would be a bit awkward if the company laid people off but kept all of its original ostentatious perks.
- avalaunch 14y agoThat's like saying it's be a bit awkward if they laid off a bunch of employees but kept all the salaries of the remaining employees the same. Because by removing the little perks they're trimming everyone's salary just a little. You're already asking your remaining employees to work a little harder to make up for the loss. No need to add insult to injury and ask them to do it for a little less as well. In a time of turmoil I'd rather keep as much as possible familiar.
- reeses 14y agoVery good point. This goes hand-in-hand with "cut deep so you cut once." You can't leave that sword hanging over the heads of individual contributors or they'll activate their network and start entertaining offers. Since the process of layoffs generally involves a rank-and-yank, the people who remain are precisely the ones who have the option of working elsewhere. They can generally (depending on the location) get an offer within a day.
- avalaunch 14y agoThat's also a really good point. I knew someone in that position and he didn't last much longer before bailing on the company. He had no problem getting new offers. Companies just see an easy line item savings without thinking of the impact on the employees they desperately need to hold onto. On top of any potential insult to the employees, the companies that do this are giving off a terrible impression. "OMG. They can't even afford free soda anymore. This ship is definitely sinking."
- umsm 14y agoI am curious about how much a coffee machine really costs. I don't think it can be that much to merit getting rid of it. People that try to save a few pennies usually waste much more elsewhere...
- gaius 14y agoExactly. The Coke that costs $1 in the store probably actually costs <10c if you buy in bulk! Let alone the $4 coffee from Starbucks!
- chimeracoder 14y agoIt goes a bit further than that - you're asking people to make the shift from a non-monetary transaction to a monetary (quantifiable) transaction. This shift is one-way; once you get people thinking in monetary terms, it's very hard to get them to stop[0]. Dan Ariely talks about this in Predictably Irrational, and he gives a great example of this involving an Israeli daycare center: http://www.npr.org/2008/03/31/89233955/dan-ariely-takes-on-irrational-economic-impulses http://www.npr.org/2008/03/31/89233955/dan-ariely-takes-on-i... [0] Of course, you could make the argument that this principle applies on a corporate scale, not just a personal one, which is the point of TFA - Ariely's study just happens to focus on the individual.
- JaggedJax 14y agoHere's another example of the perils of going from free to paid and why many U.S. WWII soldiers still resent the Red Cross: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/07/13/156737801/the-cost-of-free-doughnuts-70-years-of-regret http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/07/13/156737801/the-cost...
- LanceH 14y agoI would say at least as important is that the sodas disappeared without any input from the people using them. It's a cut of a very small benefit, but it is still a cut. To do this without any prior discussion from the people receiving the benefit will only be taken badly.
- YZF 14y agoI'm not sure market norms vs. social norms apply here (as long as money isn't explicitly mentioned) but it's definitely a shift in the relationship. The "free" stuff is a signal that the company cares about you and when it's taken away you feel like they no longer care. The other thing that happens here is loss aversion. Losing that "free" coffee or soda is painful.
- geon 14y agoThe relevant text: A few years ago, they studied a day care center in Israel to determine whether imposing a fine on parents who arrived late to pick up their children was a useful deterrent. Uri and Aldo concluded that the fine didn't work well, and in fact it had long-term negative effects. Why? Before the fine was introduced, the teachers and parents had a social contract, with social norms about being late. Thus, if parents were late — as they occasionally were — they felt guilty about it — and their guilt compelled them to be more prompt in picking up their kids in the future. (In Israel, guilt seems to be an effective way to get compliance.) But once the fine was imposed, the day care center had inadvertently replaced the social norms with market norms. Now that the parents were paying for their tardiness, they interpreted the situation in terms of market norms. In other words, since they were being fined, they could decide for themselves whether to be late or not, and they frequently chose to be late. Needless to say, this was not what the day care center intended.
- 7Figures2Commas 14y agoBack in the original dot-com bubble, I worked at a place that, when it was time to flame out, flamed out so fast that management didn't even have time to empty out the break room. I think seeking to understand the financial state of a company is smart for both employees and consultants, but the assumption that "upgraded beverage selection" unequivocally equates to "doing well" is naive. Frankly, in my experience, a young company adding a bunch of perks is just as likely to be living beyond its means as it is to be doing very well financially, but that doesn't really matter. As a consultant, you don't mitigate the risk of not getting paid by asking about the soft drink selection or looking at the lunch menu. You mitigate risk by diversifying your client base, negotiating favorable payment terms and watching receivables like a hawk. All things you should be doing anyway regardless of the client or the state of the client's break room.
- goostavos 14y agoI think you're reading a little too far into what the parent post said. I can't speak for him, but I'm fairly sure he's not saying that the state of the breakroom is a valid, tested, and factually accurate rule for determing company state. I'm pretty sure that he's saying it's more of a rule of thumb.
- MrFoof 14y ago>The lesson here isn't that there's something intangible or magic about free sodas or coffee. It's that when you used to give out free sodas and coffee, and then you stop, you're telling everyone in the company that business isn't as good as it used to be. I had a client take cost-cutting to such an extreme, they no longer provided paper cups for employees to drink water. In theory they could've halted the water deliveries, but that was too probably obvious an indicator. Sadly, them cutting the paper cups fooled a lot of their employees, in which they genuinely didn't think things were that bad. Anecdotally, the ones who thought nothing was wrong with cups being cut were the ones that were laid off weeks later.
- theorique 14y agoSadly, them cutting the paper cups fooled a lot of their employees, in which they genuinely didn't think things were that bad. Anecdotally, the ones who thought nothing was wrong with cups being cut were the ones that were laid off weeks later. Makes sense. The ones who didn't parse out the puzzle were probably the employees of lowest relative IQ and savvy, so they were probably the least valuable ones.
- StavrosK 14y agoHindsight bias. What if the GP told you he was lying, and that the people who didn't notice were the last ones to get laid off, because they were so absorbed by their work that they didn't have time to notice the cups? Does that make more or less sense than the alternative?
- theorique 14y agoAlso a possibility. Perhaps the people laid off were the most intelligent but least politically connected because they were focused on their work to the exclusion of water-cooler chatter.
- LowKarmaAccount 14y agoI remember when Harvard, which had a $25.6 billion endowment at the time, stopped offering free breakfasts for upperclassmen (this was 2009, I don't know if they have reinstated it). It was a big deal at the time; it even made the New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/09/education/09harvard.html?ref=us http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/09/education/09harvard.html?r...
- trhtrsh 14y agoIt wasn't free. Meal plan is a line item on the student bill.
- LowKarmaAccount 14y agoTrhtrsh, you have been hellbanned as of this [‡] comment. I'm not really sure why; HN might have changed their algorithm for banning, or you might have been banned for a bad submission. [‡]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5687245 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5687245
- t2d2 14y agoI started putting my resume out when the free soda ended too. funny thing was my old boss got angry when I mentioned that as one of the reasons I wasn't happy any longer. He said they didn't take it away they just stop providing it. for the life of me I cannot tell what the difference is.
- marshray 14y agoMaybe your old boss thought you still had them?
- sxtxixtxcxh 14y agomaybe it's implied that the soda wasn't ever meant for you...
- mynameishere 14y ago"Take away" implies taking something that's your property to begin with.
- pyre 14y ago"Free Soda" is a perk of the job. That perk was removed. It was 'taken away.' In the end, it's academic to quibble over whether or not the free soda was 'discontinued' or 'taken away.' It doesn't really matter. Free soda is no longer there, and this upsets him. His boss arguing the correct wording isn't going to make him happier.
- ebrenes 14y agoI'd even go so far as saying his boss arguing with him over the correct wording is another red flag that you're not being listened to.
- pyre 14y agoCould just be his boss being reactive/defensive/'touchy' over the subject. I'm sure that this wasn't the only developer that was upset with it.
- ronaldx 14y agoFacilities being carted away can be an extremely urgent signal to employees - the signal of "we didn't pay our bills last month" :(
- timr 14y agoThere's a big difference between cutting soda because you're flaming out, and cutting soda because the company hired "professional management". The former is penny stupid, but the latter is pound dumb. Unless you're filling swimming pools with soda or something, drink and snack expenses are rounding error on the salaries of your people. If it comes down to the free drinks, something else is broken. The real tragedy is when idiot bean-counters take over, and start imposing these sorts of nit-picky cost-controls because "that's what big companies do". It takes a strong leader to stand up for company culture, because these sorts of issues often look like they're too small to be worth a fight. You grow to 200, 500, 1000 employees, and before long, you have to go out of your way to pull the Senior Bean-Counter for Drink Expenses aside and tell him to back off. That's when the bad stuff happens.
- __--__ 14y agoI'm not management, but I've had it described to me like this: cutting soda, while it may be insignificant and certainly isn't going to change a damned thing money-wise for the company, makes the management feel better about the situation. It makes them feel like they're doing something and something is better than nothing. It's also a CYA tactic. If the CEO wants to hold somebody personally accountable, the CFO can say "look, we did everything, we even cut back the soda!" Diversion warning: it's surprising to me how many management decisions get made solely to make people feel like they have control in a situation where they actually have no control. It's the same mechanism the government exploits when making decisions about the TSA.
- michaelfeathers 14y agoAnother canary example.. if you ever go to an small independent restaurant and they start using grocery store cheap napkins at the tables when they hadn't before, chances are its days are numbered.
- DanielRibeiro 14y agoIt is always sad when these things happen, but it is not surprising. Many startups spend so much time optimizing for survivability, that they don't optimize for happiness[1, 2]. And that makes sense in the beginning. As Ben Horowitz said[3]: If you don’t have winning product, it doesn’t matter how well your company is managed, you are done But as companies grow, that is not enough. Ben Horowitz complements[4]: Why even bother with management if that is the case? But the truth is: there are several things that are very important: 1: if you get into trouble, and if you have bad management, your company will probably die. Like the people will just quit, they are not bonded to it, the don’t like working there, they never liked working there, and that is that, it is a wrap. ... 2: if you succeed at building a company that everybody just hates working at, what have you done? You just made a whole lot of people a whole lot more miserable in their lives. [1] http://tom.preston-werner.com/2010/10/18/optimize-for-happiness.html http://tom.preston-werner.com/2010/10/18/optimize-for-happin... [2] http://www.justin.tv/startupschool/b/272031754 http://www.justin.tv/startupschool/b/272031754 [3] http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=sqI7fa04atc#t=3662s http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v... [4] http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=sqI7fa04atc#t=3698s http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v...
- julesbond007 13y agoA sure giveaway is to monitor the job board of the company. If they are bullish, they're constantly posting jobs and you can tell exactly what area of the company is growing or shrinking.