4 ms·
I wonder how common this is amongst retail investors: buying things they have no business buying. Whether it's an IPO or an options contract, there's a great de
by mikestew 14y ago
I wonder how common this is amongst retail investors: buying things they have no business buying. Whether it's an IPO or an options contract, there's a great deal of complexity behind many financial instruments, and just because your brokerage gives you the opportunity to pull the lever it doesn't mean you're qualified to do so.
On the other hand, it's hard to work up sympathy for the woman in the story. Yes, she wasn't privy to behind-the-scenes details. But it sounds like she put less research into her $200K "investment" decision than she did with the last car she bought. The Atlantic may have left out the details of her late-night scouring of web pages for information, but as a proxy for retail investors in general it's probably accurate.
Here's the only thing a retail investor needs to know about IPOs: FB isn't the exception, it's the rule. Buy an IPO on opening day and the vast majority of the time you're going to lose money. Why? (And I wish I could bold and underline this.) Because the IPO isn't to make you money. Stay the hell away from them unless you know what you're doing. And you probably don't.
EDIT: maybe I'm mis-remembering, but didn't the problem of mobile users and ad revenue come out before the IPO day?
- shawabawa3 14y agoThe article makes it sound like the only research she did was: > and came to know of the phenomenon known as the first day "pop." On the day that companies would debut on the stock market, the price would tend to shoot up before stabilizing If that is really the limit to her research, I'd have the same sympathy as someone who put their life savings on black and complained when it came up red. And seeing as investment 101 is "diversify", it seems very likely she really did put that little thought into it.
- binxbolling 14y agoHow much research are you obligated to do before purchasing stock, going into surgery, buying a house, or accepting a job? I've noticed that the answer to this from others is always "should've done more" whenever a victim (of luck, of poor planning, of circumstances, whatever) dares speak up. Did a group of people knowingly screw you over on your mortgage? Your fault. Did a group of people knowingly suggest surgery you didn't need? Your fault. Did a group of people knowingly conspire to screw your stocks? Your fault. Curious American pathology.
- twoodfin 14y agoI don't understand your argument. Who "knowingly screw[ed] over" this woman?
- VLM 14y ago10% of her losses were on the first day trading. No big deal. Most of her losses were later on while she tried to cash in on a big lawsuit as advised by : "Her son advised her to hold onto her shares until she either resolved the matter with Vanguard or the price bounced back." "Her son, who studied finance at UC Berkeley"
- purplelobster 14y agoLots of hindsight bias. There's always a grain of truth to it, but the overall American sentiment is that you and you alone are to blame for anything that happens to you (unless it happened to me, in which case it was bad luck). That's why Americans seem less understanding of poor people and tend to put rich people on a pedestal.
- VLM 14y agoIts a craftsmanship thing. Notice its her life savings, not just some random dollar amount however large or small. I have an uncle who could swing a 1/4 mil loss and laugh. They intentionally chose this woman because she intentionally in gross ignorance decided to blow away her lifes work. Its like an artist spending his entire life on an amazing sculpture, decades of toil and sweat, then blindly, idiotically, "eh, I donno, I'll just use this sledgehammer to trim the last little bit" and the whole life's work is gone, crumbled into ruin. Do we need sledgehammer control? More education? Can we blame the rich? How about more govt regulation? Nah, just fewer idiots with sledgehammers. Maybe the story will scare dumb people away from one dumb activity... probably into another dumb activity. Which brings up the next issue, the other part is fools will always find a way to be fools. This quote says it all "He kept asking me what was going through my head when I bought the shares" That was her life's crowning achievement. Not being awarded a doctorate, not a Nobel prize, just an empty head and its all someone elses fault... That money was going to be lost one way or another, in real estate, casino, or other scams. Most scams have really sleazy operators, at least the stock market scam is somewhat less sleazy than some bookies and some used home salespeople and the like. Not much less sleazy, but a little.
- campnic 14y agoIt is not the responsibility of the purchaser to know information which is purposefully withheld from them. From the article > Scott Sweet's multi-billion dollar hedge fund client flipped the stock at $42. His subsequent short made his firm its "largest profit of the year," Sweet said. There's "no way" a retail investor could have known about the lowered projections, unless he or she "had a friend at a multi-billion dollar institution," he added. Please explain to me, when information is withheld from the purchasers and only specific clients notified as to circumstantial and meaningful changes to the state of the offering, how anyone could ever "know what you're doing?' In fact, Morgan Stanley was actively misleading investors by continuing to adjust the specifications of the offering to make it look better. Analogy: If an automaker produced a new car which was secretly designed to become worthless (engine would fuse together) after 3 months and only told one rich people not to buy it, would that be fine? What if there come back was 'you could always open the hood and see our computer components which execute after 3 months, its not our fault you don't know what you're doing'
- UVB-76 14y agoMy understanding is that the information was not withheld from retail investors; rather, it wasn't actively disseminated to them, and the significance of the information impressed upon them. The reduced revenue estimates were public information; I recall reading about them myself before the IPO took place. If someone had put me in charge of billions of dollars and told me to take a position on the Facebook IPO, I would have shorted the stock, as many others did. The crux of the issue is that wealthy institutional investors had analysts at their disposal to point out the revised revenue estimates, and retail investors like Swaminathan didn't. Retail investors were ill-prepared for the IPO, and they got burned.
- campnic 14y agoThey're ill prepared to consume the information in the format its delivered (if it is delivered at all). Notice, the revised S-1 doesn't say the amount of the adjustment, you had to receive that from Facebook via another channel. So, it doesn't really have to do with special analyst job knowledge, it has to do with special treatment. I mean, "actively disseminated" seems a bit generous. They call 3 institutions to let them know meanwhile individual (notice i'm intentionally not saying "retail" because thats become some sort of in-crowd, brow beating, bullshit term for shaming regular, non-hedge fund investors) are left to read smoke signals. Its not that the institutional investors "had analysts at their disposal" its that the systems is built to make sure institutional investors and hedge funds get information others don't. You can say what you want, but the quote from the hedge fund manager seems much more clear then your opinion, and he's a domain expert who took part in the situation. >"There's "no way" a retail investor could have known about the lowered projections, unless he or she "had a friend at a multi-billion dollar institution," he added."
- revelation 14y agoI have no problem with retail investors buying stock because they believe in the company and have the patience to hold on to it. That can be a very good, low on stress investment. But trying to outsmart people living in Bloomberg terminals at their own game, buying on IPO and trying to dump it the same day? Her loss is no ones fault but hers.
- pnathan 14y agoDropping 1/2 of your life savings after retirement into a single nest egg is sort of a classic mistake; one of the textbook things Not To Do when you read any introduction to investing. It's one thing to get flummoxed by handling options and other derivatives; the common wisdom isn't so common there for the novice investor. But stocks are relatively well understood. :-/ It's a real bummer for this lady, and I hope she can figure out how to manage her losses without drastically affecting her life, BUT she committed a classic textbook error in stock trading.
- AJ007 14y agoWhen someone, rich or poor, makes a big bet involving individuals with a repeated history of deceit, that is greed.
- melling 14y agoI don't think the FB IPO was a normal IPO. http://www.businessinsider.com/exclusive-heres-the-inside-story-of-what-happened-on-the-facebook-ipo-2012-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/exclusive-heres-the-inside-st... NASDAQ had problems filling orders. People and institutions didn't find out their orders were filled until hours later.