4 ms·
From my understanding she's a summer student at the Yat Li lab at UCSC.[1] This concept is not newly developed by this young student[2][3], it seems that she's
by haldujai 13y ago
From my understanding she's a summer student at the Yat Li lab at UCSC.[1]
This concept is not newly developed by this young student[2][3], it seems that she's just a summer student who used the labs work to submit to the Intel competition, this is actually a very common practice for high school students. As usual the media overstated her role, the work was not done in the 2.5 months she has off for the summer solely by her. That's not to say she might not be bright, but it's not her genius that developed this concept, although she may have contributed. In fact this work was first submitted for publication in 2010[3], long before she joined the lab in 2012[4][5].
[1]http://www.usc.edu/CSSF//History/2013/Projects/S0912.pdf http://www.usc.edu/CSSF//History/2013/Projects/S0912.pdf [credit: gizmo686]
[2]http://research.pbsci.ucsc.edu/chemistry/li/publications/2012_NanoLett_12_1690-1696.pdf http://research.pbsci.ucsc.edu/chemistry/li/publications/201...
[3]http://research.pbsci.ucsc.edu/chemistry/li/publications/2011_NanoLett_11_3026-3033.pdf http://research.pbsci.ucsc.edu/chemistry/li/publications/201...
[4]https://sites.google.com/site/yatliucsc/people https://sites.google.com/site/yatliucsc/people
[5]http://www.ucolick.org/~raja/hs/LIST2011.txt http://www.ucolick.org/~raja/hs/LIST2011.txt
Edit: Added reference showing she was not part of the Li lab in 2011. [5]
- earh 13y agoIntel Science Fair does more harm than good, since when it was the Westinghouse. It is one of the vestiges of privilege, where a bunch of rich (and a few lucky) kids get to hang out in a research lab and then write up the lab's work as their own, earning a branding of "genius" unavailable to the less privileged class. Why is it harmful, you may ask? Because every smart kid who didn't get handed a professional project to submit, and doesn't know the game, thinks that he/she is so much less smart/hardworking/creative/accomplished than these supposed geniuses, and is discouraged from continuing in science research. Lab experience is great for kids, and we should be expanding that experience to everyone, not using it as a tool to cement the position of the upper classes.