3 ms·
That wouldn't work. If you dropped something it would simply stay right next to you, even if you were accelerating - both of you are accelerating at exactly th
by ars 14y ago
That wouldn't work.
If you dropped something it would simply stay right next to you, even if you were accelerating - both of you are accelerating at exactly the same rate.
- Dylan16807 14y agoWhy? What's making it accelerate? I wasn't trying to talk about some kind of universal/aether acceleration. I meant you and only you should accelerate.
- ars 14y agoAnd how do you accelerate - do you have a rocket attached to your feet?
- Dylan16807 14y agoIt doesn't really matter. But there should be some mechanism. A rocket attached to your feet works quite well if you ignore the exhaust for purposes of reference. If you want a useful thought experiment about physics then you need to give reasonable physics tools. Otherwise you get something like "Pretend you are an inanimate green blob. You can't climb a hill, can you? Therefore climbing a hill is an illusion."
- ars 14y agoIf you have a rocket on your feet why do you need to drop something to figure out if you are accelerating? You can feel the pressure on your feet. The only type of acceleration that is undetectable is gravity - and gravity will effect the dropped object exactly as much as you.
- Dylan16807 14y agoGreat! You just simplified the experiment! Dropping something was only one idea, but feeling pressure is much simpler.