4 ms·
Really? If someone was indiscreetly peering over your shoulder to check out your package, you would let them know that it made you upset? Excuse me good sir, I
by freehunter 14y ago
Really? If someone was indiscreetly peering over your shoulder to check out your package, you would let them know that it made you upset? Excuse me good sir, I do believe you are offending me?
Where I come from, that's more than an indiscretion. We're not talking about a locker room.
- potatolicious 14y agoSo... "where you come from" what is the bar at which felony assault is justified?
- freehunter 14y agoWell felony assault consists of intentionally causing severe bodily harm to someone or attacking an elderly person or child. A single blow to the face would generally not be felony assault. However, I would consider cornering me in a bathroom and sexually harassing me to be just cause for self defense.
- tptacek 14y agoA quick Google search for "felony assault for punching" suggests your comment might be inaccurate.
- Mz 14y agoWithout having to google, I can tell you that at what point something gets defined as a "felony" varies from one state to another. (I used to pay accident claims. Some policies specifically did not cover injuries that were incurred in the commission of a felony. I had to write a denial based on that clause. We first had to research if the event in qhestion was a felony in the state in question.)
- arrrg 14y agoViolence without immediate danger is never morally ok. It is vile and barbaric.
- Nrsolis 14y agoBy whose moral code? Yours? Society lays out the rules by law. And society judges when those rules have been breached. I think people forget that they have to live in a world where people other than themselves might have a different idea of what constitutes an acceptable response to distinctly discouraged behavior. Is a woman who is being filmed naked against her will unjustified if she smacks the guy doing the filming when she learns of the violation?
- arrrg 14y agoYes, by mine. I thought this was a pretty uncontroversial view. Self defense and not one millimeter more.
- freehunter 14y agoYou know what's vile and barbaric? Sexual harassment. Just because it's easier to see your broken nose than it is to see how traumatized a victim of sexual harassment is doesn't mean violence is immediately wrong. What you're arguing is for blaming the victim.
- pavel_lishin 14y ago> What you're arguing is for blaming the victim. Telling the victim to not automatically respond with disproportionate violence is not "blaming the victim". If he'd said, "if you don't want pictures of your dick on the internet, don't pee at Google I/O," then you might have a point.
- freehunter 14y agoListen to yourself, man! If someone peeked their head under a stall, would it be disproportionate violence to push him back out with your foot? Seriously, sexual harassment is not a light crime. It does serious damage to the victim's mental state. There's no way of knowing if the perpetrator is going to take things further. If you want to state here right now that you feel that violence as a way to stop an ongoing act of close-quarters sexual harassment is a disproportionate response, then that's fine. But don't be surprised if other people in your society don't agree. And yes, violating someone's privacy to see them naked when they obviously don't want to be seen is sexual harassment. Filming that takes it to the next level.
- coopdog 14y agoWell legally they'd be perfectly within their rights to tape you telling them off. And if you got violent they'd have all the evidence they'd need to press charges, conveniently backed up into the cloud.
- Nrsolis 14y agoSee, there is where you are wrong. There are NUMEROUS statutes that prohibit the surreptitious filming of people where a reasonable expectation of privacy exists. I think a bathroom qualifies. And I think you'd have a hard time getting a jury to convict someone of punching another guy in the nose for filming them in the bathroom. Honestly, do you think the VERY FACT that he has a camera running at the time he gets punched by the guy he was filming wouldn't be prima facie evidence that he was in-fact filming in a private place? Cloud or not? I'm willing the guy who is looking at a sex-offender charge and life-long pervert registration is willing to avoid pressing charges just to make the whole thing go away.
- potatolicious 14y ago> "And I think you'd have a hard time getting a jury to convict someone of punching another guy in the nose for filming them in the bathroom." No, that conviction will be a slam dunk, because there's video evidence of it. You'll also score a simultaneous conviction for running afoul of peeping tom laws, because filming in a bathroom is as you mentioned illegal in many jurisdictions. The only winner here is the prosecutor. The fact that party A was violating the law before party B assaulted him does not nullify party B's crime. The law doesn't really work that way. The bar for justifiable use of violence is legally high.
- Nrsolis 14y agoHeh. Wanna bet? You seem to have a quaint notion of how the justice system works. Video evidence? Probably wont be surpressed by defense. Probably wont be contested because it's obtained as the result of an illegal act. The jury will probably not agree with the defense that the video represented the first stage of an attack by people who film attacks to gain notariety in the Internet. Probably. If you agree to post your bar number from any US state and the range of cases you've defended, I'd be willing to hear your counterargument.