15 ms·
This is huge. I've held out on Android development for many reasons, but my visceral hate for Eclipse is one of them. I know I've been able to use IntelliJ befo
by untog 14y ago
This is huge. I've held out on Android development for many reasons, but my visceral hate for Eclipse is one of them. I know I've been able to use IntelliJ before now, but Eclipse was Google's example in tutorials, etc.
Now I'm very excited to make an Android app.
- ddw 14y agoSame here. Can't wait to give this a shot.
- k3n 14y agoI thought Google was pretty heavily invested in the Eclipse ecosystem, I think they use it quite a bit internally (at least from what I can gather). Perhaps those efforts were more in the interest of supporting the community of developers which use their API's, though. I also hate Eclipse, even though I've tried my hardest to overlook its shortcomings. I'll leave it at that so as not to delve too far off-topic.
- wsc981 14y agoEarlier this year I wrote my first Android app using Eclipse. After finishing the project, I decided I hated Eclipse enough to not waste any more time on the platform. I don't really like the Java language either, it somehow feels 'old'. But recently discovered Xamarin[1] and later this year will try to write an Android app again, but this time in C# using Xamarin Studio. I think it's a great alternative for Eclipse, though I will definitely check out Android Studio as well, if it's going to be free. [1]: http://xamarin.com http://xamarin.com
- dodyg 14y agoIt is going to be free since it is based on IntelliJ Community Edition. This time around try use Kotlin(http://kotlin.jetbrains.org/ http://kotlin.jetbrains.org/) instead of Java. It offers 100% compatibility with Java and it works nicely with IntelliJ. I wrote this fully fledge news app using Kotlin/Java https://github.com/dodyg/AndroidRivers https://github.com/dodyg/AndroidRivers
- davesims 14y agoIntelliJ 12's Android support is vastly superior to Eclipse, in addition to being just a better Java IDE overall. I'm now very curious to know just how different Android Studio will be from IntelliJ. I'd guess it's going to something akin to the difference between JetBrains' RubyMine and Ruby/Rails plugin support inside IntelliJ -- same overall functionality with better UX integration for the domain.
- dmiladinov 14y agoEven the community edition[1] supports android development. Just point IntelliJ at your android sdk installation folder, and you're off to the races! [1]: http://www.jetbrains.com/idea/features/android.html http://www.jetbrains.com/idea/features/android.html
- suyash 14y agoBut I think this version is not the same as Android Studio community edition.
- dmiladinov 14y agoYou're right, it isn't. This post[1] from JetBrains helped clear the situation up for me. [1]: http://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2013/05/15/intellij-idea-is-the-base-for-android-studio-the-new-ide-for-android-developers/ http://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2013/05/15/intellij-idea-is-t...
- yareally 14y agoIf you switch the preview released today[1], it's nearly the same as Intellij (even the build numbers almost line up at 130.xx). I just prefer the Intellij preview for some of the features one cannot get in the Android focused IDE Google previewed. [1] http://blogs.jetbrains.com/idea/2013/05/intellij-idea-13-early-preview-is-out/ http://blogs.jetbrains.com/idea/2013/05/intellij-idea-13-ear...
- suyash 14y ago
- pmelendez 14y agoI share your visceral hate for Eclipse, let's see if this IDE would solve that :)
- ihuman 14y agoWhy does everyone seem to hate Eclipse? I've been using for a while and I can't find reasons to dislike it.
- mey 14y agoI use Eclipse extensively personally, but the one thing that drives me nuts about it is it's general speed. Conversely I'm so well versed it in I don't have a strong desire to replace it at the center of my work flow. Just been getting better/faster machines over the years.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- smrtinsert 14y agoThey took a step back with the CSS theming disaster which seemed to slow down the UI dramatically. Other than I have never hated Eclipse. It's very productive for Java development. That said I use SublimeText for every other language...
- mey 14y agoFor quick edits I will turn to jEdit or vim. I've also been giving LightTable a try and enjoying the early stages.
- davedx 14y agoSame here. I was disappointed when I bought a brand new Macbook Air last year though only to find hitting cmd-s then switching to a different tab "loses" the save if you do it too quickly (among other general slowness). It's amazing how over so many years with massive hardware increases it doesn't seem any more responsive.
- karlshea 14y agoI've used JetBrains' products in various forms (IntelliJ IDEA, Resharper for Visual Studio, and PhpStorm) for a long time, but every couple of years I was also exposed to Eclipse (Aptana Studio, and one or two other installs that I forget what they were for). Eclipse just feels clunky and not very well designed. Like they forgot to find someone to do UX work. Plus the workspaces concept is really stupid, and the versions I was using couldn't open a file if it wasn't inside a workspace.
- smrtinsert 14y agoThis is pretty crazy considering the huge investment Google has made into Eclipse to create the SDK there. There is also a significant community investment in using Android with Eclipse. Eclipse once you get rolling is amazing, and most importantly its free which is a big deal especially to cash strapped individuals and businesses. What will happen with the existing Eclipse SDK? Also what about GWT? Splitting the IDE communities is bold. So many questions though.
- ben1040 14y ago>Also what about GWT? Is GWT still even a thing they care about? It seems like they're pushing people towards Dart and Angular at this point. I/O last year was seriously thin on GWT, and it looks this year like there's only one session, which got misfiled in the schedule under "Google Wallet." https://developers.google.com/events/io/sessions/331474237 https://developers.google.com/events/io/sessions/331474237
- chii 14y agothat's sad to hear, i quite like gwt. but ATM gwt is quite feature complete, except for bugs.
- vidarh 14y ago> This is pretty crazy considering the huge investment Google has made into Eclipse to create the SDK there. What's pretty crazy is that they were insane enough to base it on Eclipse in the first place, seeing as it's probably the only IDE that so many people hate so intensely. I'm a Linux user primarily, use OS X at work, and detest Windows, yet I'd pick Visual Studio ca. 1999 over Eclipse any day. I'm an Emacs user, yet I'd switch to Vim in a heartbeat if I had to pick between Vim and Eclipse. I suspect you will find quite a lot of people with similarly strong hate for Eclipse. It's a trainwreck. Though in slow motion, as Eclipse never seems to do anything fast.
- nevster 14y agoIt's probably because the Community Edition of IntelliJ didn't exist when they started doing their Android tooling. Eclipse was more dominant back then. That's slowly been changing (thank goodness!)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ojiikun 14y agoAndroid apps are actually an extreme pleasure to code in vim/emacs and build from the commandline. The shell debugging tools are very nice, too. Eclipse doesn't really add that much to the experience other than setting up the initial required files.
- davesims 14y agoAgreed! Not many people do this that I know of but it's a great option. I use a vim/tmux environment, but I use IntelliJ for a lot of the Java heavy-lifting. Let's face it, it's hard to match IntelliJ's autocompletion, auto-import, etc. inside of vim. I do use the vim bindings though. Looking forward to porting my ant scripts to gradle.
- bitwize 14y agoI've gotten by with Emacs and the command line tools. Full disclosure, I'm the author of this game: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.parodycheck.rboots&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.parodychec... I'm hesitant to give up Emacs just to write for Android, but even so I might give this new gizmo a try.
- p_l 14y agoCould you describe your workflow/emacs.d ? I've been thinking of going with Emacs for Java coding for some time, but JDEE always seemed to be missing something (and some of the newer options tended to eat hilarious amounts of resources or required maven)
- bitwize 14y agoI really don't have anything special installed for Java. I code Java much like I code C, and don't have the advantage of IntelliSense or similar. Android makes this sort of coding easy, because it supports a relatively "small and focused classes" coding style -- much like Java in the 1.0.x days. Compare to, say, J2EE, where you HAVE to have an elaborate IDE just to wrangle the complex classes and all their interrelationships.