10 ms·
Feds reveal the search warrant used to seize Mt. Gox account
- pyre 14y agoIt's worth noting that at least a couple of exchanges have gone through the appropriate hoops with the US Federal government. I think the Mt. Gox thought that they were immune because they are based in Japan.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoPerhaps, except the questions they answered 'no' to are pretty much exactly what they do. I'm not sure what Mark was thinking they actually did when he answered those questions. Its interesting to me that typically this would be a simple "hey you filled out the forms wrong" kind of thing and the officers would go down and change their paperwork and correct any missing licenses, pay whatever penalties etc. This however is blown up as a 'big deal' which suggests that at least some folks would rather have you believe that the concept of bitcoin is illegal.
- vxxzy 14y agoAs I understand it, didn't Mt. Gox start as a place to buy and sell "Magic the Gathering" game cards? This would explain the "no" answers...
- discountgenius 14y agoBy May 2011 when the form was filled out, Mt. Gox had already pivoted to bitcoin.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThat is certainly a credible line of reasoning, assuming of course that the account was established while they were still doing that.
- killnine 14y agoAs I understand it, you have just less than 180 days to file fincen after your establishment. according to the article The entity established an MSB in may 2011 and signs of Dwolla dont start until Dec 2011... SO you may be onto something
- PeterisP 14y agoWhy do you think that 'typically this would be a simple "hey you filled out the forms wrong" kind of thing' ? I'd guess that every single such violation is prosecuted if detected - money laundering is not that rare, and in accounting/financial/company tax matters pretty much all mistakes (unless detected in pre-signing validation) are treated as punishable/fineable violations, not "correct your paperwork" matters. And as a company officer, there quite a few papers that you are required to sign where you may face jail if they're not true. Also, seizing/freezing any money-laundering or tax-evasion related funds is common practice - first ensure that the money isn't going away, and then release it when/if all the violations are cleared.
- killnine 14y agoThis is what I don't understand. Bitcoin/crypto currency is almost not even a factor for these exchanges that deal with both crypto currency and regular dollars. See, if you were only dealing in crypto currency, then yes, you could argue this is a grey area where there are still a lot of regulations to be laid out, which as a currency you may or may not land on the wrong side of the law. But when you are dealing with dollars and crypto currency, the crypto currency doesnt matter. there are already PLENTY of laws for being a currency exchange and money services business and the like. So there is no grey area here. It just so happens that in addition to your dollars currency exchange you also deal with crypto currency.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>And as a company officer, there quite a few papers that you are required to sign where you may face jail if they're not true. That sounds nice, but really, look at what you have to do before you actually go to jail as a "company officer"
- oijaf888 14y agoHSBC wasn't really prosecuted nor were the hundreds of billions of cash that they laundered seized, I think its very selective enforcement in many cases.
- axus 14y agoBack in May 2011, was Bitcoin really a currency? How should a dealer of World of Warcraft gold answer these questions?
- dtparr 14y agoIANAL, but from a practical standponit, I imagine if a WoW dealer both buys and sells WoW gold for a fiat currency, the government would want them to be equally as liable since that would also be an excellent way to launder or otherwise transfer money without oversight. The same would be true for any bi-directional virtual curency, really. Since Blizzard does this in Diablo 3, I wonder if they've gone through this process.
- venomsnake 14y agoThey use paypal for the outgoing transfers. Otherwise it is one directional. So I suppose paypal does the heavy legal lifting here.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- celticninja 14y agoThe response of No only became incorrect after the release of the FinCen document, these forms were completed before the FinCen report was released.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoThe United States Dollar, which the company in question accepted and transmitted based on customer instructions, was a currency at the time the forms were filled out.
- axus 14y agoIs there a person or business that does not exchange US Dollars for goods/services? Any reasonable person would understand it to mean exchanging for foreign currency. Mt.Gox does not transmit dollars (or euros, etc) from one person to another. Every transaction involves a trade of bitcoin for a currency, or returning the currency (of the original type) to the original account holder.
- michaelt 14y agoIf we rearrange the quote from the article: "Does your business accept funds from customers and send the funds based on customers' instructions (Money Transmitter)?" Most businesses accept funds from customers, but few outside the financial services industry transmit the funds based on customers' instructions (assuming refunds and gift cards do not count).
- celticninja 14y agoyes but you only become a money transmitter when they confirm that bitcoin is money, prior to that it could easily be considered a commodity the same as any other good, thus people were sending $ to buy a commodity. After FinCen changed the playing field they should then have required businesses dealign with BTC to update forms or resubmit, not go crazy shutting things down. but that is how the US govt works, without sense, just blunders in. Much like the DefenceDistributed issue, they come blundering in and make things more difficult for themselves in the long run.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoI'll tell you what they were thinking. They were thinking "OMG LIBERTARIAN PARADISE CYBERFUTURE I AM JOHN GALT."
- wmf 14y agoWhat he was thinking was probably that answering "yes" would cost tens of millions of dollars that he doesn't have, and thus would effectively put MtGox out of business immediately. This goes back to the FaceCash case; you can either ask to be regulated (in which case you go out of business immediately) or fly under the radar until you make enough money to become compliant.
- jeremyjh 14y ago>Its interesting to me that typically this would be a simple "hey you filled out the forms wrong" kind of thing Why do you think that? A currency exchange is a business for grownups. Grownups with lawyers and accountants who can fill in forms correctly.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI've got family members who work in the Justice system, my grandfather was a the US Attorney. It costs a lot of money to try and prosecute a case, the various enforcement agencies have budgets and there is incentive to not waste money on prosecutions that can be dealt with inexpensively. So when something comes up, you see if you can "resolve" it simply. So in this case the forms get updated, the Mt. Gox guys become registered as an MSB and go through the paperwork to meet the necessary standards, and if they can't they shut down. The enforcement interests of the state are served. Similarly if you are accused of violating a law the prosecutor will often offer you a plea deal of some form. This is effectively saying "Ok, let's assume I can prove all of this and your guilty and you will be fined and possibly go to prison. I'm willing to forego that lengthy process if you simply admit wrongdoing to this set of charges and accept this sentence for it." Of course sometimes the prosecutor has a different agenda and they want to "send a message" to people who might consider a similar path. This ranges from the small, police officers citing seatbelt violations, to the absurd like telling Aaron Schwartz he would spend 30 years in prison. A friend of mine who was registering his business as a consultant in Santa Clara county screwed up and put down his business as "consulate." He signed the document that said that was what he was trying to do, and not surprisingly it is illegal to represent yourself as a diplomat when you aren't one. But he didn't get a DHS agent throwing him down in the street, he got a call from the County clerk when the State Department returned the application saying essentially "wtf?" They had a laugh, he updated and amended the form and didn't serve any prison time. :-) Generally, its been my experience that "the man" isn't really out to get you. And maximizing compliance with the existing laws of the land trumps prosecuting every single violation. So skipping the first step [1] of just calling up and getting clarification seems unusual to me, given my experience with folks who prosecute people for a living. [1] This is an assumption on my part, for all I know they may have called and said "Did you really mean to say 'no' here? Looks like you should have said 'yes'." And he may said "I said 'no' and I meant it."
- 300bps 14y ago>I think the Mt. Gox thought that they were immune Well, as we stand in May of 2013 perhaps it's obvious that Mt. Gox should have identified themselves as a Money Transmitter and Money Service Business. Let's agree on two things though: 1. There's a fuzzy line as to who should have to get a license for this. For instance, the person that sold me Roman denarii for U.S. dollars on EBay might have to get a Money Service Business license with a strict interpretation of the law. 2. Literally two years ago in May of 2011 when Mt Gox filled out the forms, Bitcoin was not considered by most people to be a "currency". When most people think of currency exchange, they're thinking of U.S. dollars, Euros, Swiss Francs, British Pounds, etc. Is Parker Brothers responsible for registering as a Money Service Bureau because they exchange U.S. Dollars for Monopoly Money?
- richcollins 14y agoDoes your business accept funds from customers and send the funds based on customers' instructions (Money Transmitter) Seems like this is more applicable (although still a stretch) as they receive USD and then forward them on to BTC sellers.
- reeses 14y agoDon't forget the vouchers for traditional currencies that could be exchanged without any conversion into bitcoin. Those were often leveraged to get around the banking latency, but would just as easily been used as a (slow) way of paying for illicit goods or for obfuscating layering in an ML scheme.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> Literally two years ago in May of 2011 when Mt Gox filled out the forms, Bitcoin was not considered by most people to be a "currency". But the US dollar has been considered a currency for a long time (longer, in fact, that the "Money Transmitter" rules at issue in the warrant have been in place), and certainly before May 2011. And that's the currency whose transmission is at issue in the warrant. Further, the issue is not incorrect forms filled out in 2011, but unlicensed money transmission business continuing to be conducted into 2013.
- jack_trades 14y agoYeah, but those are just questions on paper! They after me lucky charms! When you sign a legal form, especially tied to a business, you might want to consider the ramifications of how you complete the form. You probably should legal up prospectively if it deals with money and currencies. This is not surprising for MtGox. Their platform, communications, and, now, essential business acumen all perform at the same unprofessional level. I guess it's back to trading cards then, eh?
- illuminate 14y ago"Yeah, but those are just questions on paper! They after me lucky charms!" Don't Libertarians preach contract supremacy?
- scott_karana 14y agoSomehow I'm not surprised that Mt. Gox was completely unlicensed as a "money transmitter", and that they denied involvement in such on their bank account questionnaire. For once this at least seems like a legitimate takedown.
- ctdonath 14y ago“Did you really think we want those laws observed?" said Dr. Ferris. "We want them to be broken. You'd better get it straight that it's not a bunch of boy scouts you're up against... We're after power and we mean it... There's no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren't enough criminals one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws. Who wants a nation of law-abiding citizens? What's there in that for anyone? But just pass the kind of laws that can neither be observed nor enforced or objectively interpreted – and you create a nation of law-breakers – and then you cash in on guilt. Now that's the system, Mr. Reardon, that's the game, and once you understand it, you'll be much easier to deal with.” ― Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged And when the evidence is presented in a stark, context-free, spin-managed manner, casual observers tend to agree with the charges. There was no question the feds would take an interest in Bitcoin with desire to take it down, and duly analyzed all paperwork from that perspective until they found an excuse to. Require enough paperwork, and somewhere a sufficient transgression will be found.
- ubernostrum 14y agoYes, the government is the most evil thing in the history of evil, there is no such thing as a justified law, and this is just the parasites trying to leech off of and get power over the brilliant Galt-like geniuses whose intelligence was so inestimably massive that they apparently consciously filed a legal form that said "oh, that thing that we do and advertise that we do? Of course we don't do that".
- javert 14y ago> Yes, the government is the most evil thing in the history of evil, there is no such thing as a justified law, I agree that the quote is overblown in this context, but your argument is a strawman. Ayn Rand made strong intellectual arguments in _support_ of government and the rule of law, in contrast to anarchists and various flavors of libertarians.
- Groxx 14y ago>As part of the account opening process, Wells Fargo required Karpeles and Mutum Sigillum LLC to complete a "Money Services Business (MSB) Accounts, Identification of an MSB Customer" form. That document was completed on May 20, 2011 and identified Mutum Sigillum LLC as a business not engaged in money services. Were the FinCEN rules in effect on May 20, 2011? I see this on the "Guidance"[0] released in March (starting the "background" section): >On July 21, 2011, FinCEN published a Final Rule amending definitions and other regulations relating to money services businesses ("MSBs").4 Among other things, the MSB Rule amends the definitions of dealers in foreign exchange (formerly referred to as "currency dealers and exchangers") and money transmitters. Separately, since the guidance was issued, there seems to have been wide-spread confusion / misinterpretation. If they ignored it after this was issued, then they obviously were in violation, but before? How do ambiguous-interpretation cases get handled? [0]: http://fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/html/FIN-2013-G001.html http://fincen.gov/statutes_regs/guidance/html/FIN-2013-G001....
- dragonwriter 14y ago> Were the FinCEN rules in effect on May 20, 2011? It doesn't really matter, because while the form is referenced, the alleged crime supporting the warrant isn't incorrectly filling out a form on May 20, 2011, it is conducting unlicensed money transmission business.
- iblaine 14y agoWhy tell Mt Gox what they are doing wrong when you can fine them instead? Seems like the American way.
- qdog 14y agoCurrency trading laws and regulations seem to pretty clearly state what they were doing wrong. This seems to be a shortcoming of MTGOX itself, not a direct attack on bitcoin. MTGOX's claims of compliance in the US seem to be hogwash at this point.
- thedeepself 14y agoSort of. But why was the bank (1) ASKING about the line of business instead of determining it (2) revealing client bank records to the government?
- mindcrime 14y agoWhy tell Mt Gox what they are doing wrong when you can fine them instead? Seems like the American way. Just because the Government say it's "wrong" doesn't mean it actually is.
- claudius 14y agoWhy not remind this guy that it is against the law to kill people when you can put him into prison instead? Ignorance of the law is no excuse, and it is doubtable that this is even a case of ignorance.
- nikcub 14y agoFunny, in the profile of Mt Gox in The Verge[1] they said: > Mt. Gox estimates it costs $25 million in the first year to become fully compliant in the US. But considering a regulator could potentially swoop in and seize funds if a violation were found, it’s worth it. I called bull[2] on that figure when that post was published. The other reason i've stayed away from Mt Gox is despite their claims of compliance, they aren't listed on the Californian DFI website as a registered money agent[3] When that article was posted I also emailed Mt Gox, since I couldn't find them in any registry as an authorized money transmitter, to ask them where that $25M was spent. The response I got was: > Unfortunately, our financial statement is yet to be available. Once it is available and we have the permission to publish it from management, we will release this. [1] http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/1/4154500/mt-gox-barons-of-bitcoin http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/1/4154500/mt-gox-barons-of-bi... [2] https://twitter.com/nikcub/status/321418917803327488 https://twitter.com/nikcub/status/321418917803327488 [3] http://www.dfi.ca.gov/Directory/money_transmitters.html http://www.dfi.ca.gov/Directory/money_transmitters.html
- MacsHeadroom 14y agoMoney Transmitters have to post a $25 Million security bond in order to be licensed across the entire U.S. That is were the $25 Million would go. But MtGox never spent that money nor claimed to spend that money as of yet. To my knowledge, they have never made any claims of compliance. They have only said that they plan to become compliant some time this year.
- nikcub 14y agoThey imply in the article in The Verge that they have spent it, or are going to spend it. When I asked them straight up in an email they didn't say that they didn't spend it, only that they wouldn't disclose where[1]. Anybody reading that article in The Verge would conclude that they have spent the money. That whole article was about assuring people that Mt Gox was safe. At best they were not straight forward and transparent, at worst they lied. Not what I want from a company who is asking me to trust them with my money. Frankly I am shocked that their setup in the USA for Dwolla transfers was nothing more than an ordinary Wells Fargo business account. [1] The email would have been the perfect time to respond with 'well, we haven't actually spent the money on compliance, but we plan to'
- ig1 14y agoIt's important to note that regardless of whether bitcoin is a currency or not, the specific question on money transmission was "Does your business accept funds from customers and send the funds based on customers' instructions". This means it doesn't matter if bitcoin is a currency or not. If your taking money from one fiat currency account and moving it to another fiat currency account on customer instructions you can fall into the money transmitter classification. It's also one of the (many) reasons that if you're running a marketplace startup you don't want to run an intermediately account that does pass-through for the transactions but instead use a service like Paypal X or Balanced which complies with relevant money transmission laws.
- joshuak 14y agoMtGox took the position, and legal argument that they where not trading a monetary instrument of any kind, and at least early on that was a plausible argument (although probably not a winning one) because they characterized bitcons as a product or commodity. I do not have to qualify as a money transmitter if I buy and sell bags of rice even though one could possibly use that as a mechanism to "send funds based on customers' instructions". In fact other then the merchant services I cannot send money to another Mt Gox user, but the bitcoin client provides that functionality and Mt. Gox does not control the client. They shot themselves in the foot a bit when they started adding merchant services. Nevertheless I think they technically answered the questions correctly given the legal position they where taking that bitcoins are not a monetary device but a commodity. IANAL but I play one on TV, and they may still have some traction on that argument since bitcoin is only recognized as a currency by popular opinion not by legal decision.
- krupan 14y agoDoes anyone know how, say, coinbase answered those questions when they opened their bank account? (half joking here)
- iguana 14y agoDoes anyone have a list of current bitcoin exchanges, and the licenses they hold? Is Coinbase safe? Is BTC-E?
- rossmiller 14y agoHere is the link to the website to check if a company is registered as an MSB. Yes, Coinbase is registered as an MSB http://www.fincen.gov/financial_institutions/msb/msbstateselector.html http://www.fincen.gov/financial_institutions/msb/msbstatesel...
- rdl 14y agoInteresting that the MTB/MSB laws where what they used to go after e-gold a decade or so ago. E-Gold got used by customers even sketchier than anything I've seen BTC used for -- I used to think of it as the carder currency, but it was also heavily used in the CP world, I think. They really hated e-gold, but chose to use the MSB laws against it. I know the e-gold guys tried to go out of their way to be as compliant as possible, too. They were fundamentally pro-liberty/pro-gold people, not involved in the "sketchy" business, and had been fully cooperating with authorities as much as they could (e-gold was not really about anonymity as much as "honest money"; they had bank-level KYC requirements for accounts at some point, although initially they had none.). The interesting question is whether fully KYC/etc. compliant Bitcoin businesses will be allowed to register as MSBs, or if there will be artificial roadblocks put up. One issue is the global pseudonymous network that is Bitcoin once it leaves a KYC-compliant site, but that isn't too different from either a KYC-compliant bank that pays out physical cash or one which sends SWIFT wires to overseas banks with more lax KYC requirements (or issues prepaid debit cards).
- il 14y agoSome carders used e-gold, but because most of the major fraud gangs operated out of Eastern Europe/Russia, the dominant carder currency was generally WebMoney. e-gold was actually incredibly popular for online gambling and participating in HYIP(short term Ponzi schemes). Not exactly the most squeaky clean activities, but not exactly terrorism or whatever else the feds used to shut down e-gold.
- rdl 14y agoWebmoney got big after e-gold, iirc. (I was a consultant to e gold and was working on a digital blinded token currency backed in egold at the time in Anguilla). My memory that far back is kind of hazy, though. The HYIP stuff was amazing. I don't remember it being so popular for gambling. The other gold currencies which turned out to be scams (osgold, etc) were super lulzy too.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoI wonder if HN user thinkcomp had anything to do with this. It says that it was done based on information from an informant, and he's been harassing everyone touching money without a license. This has to be the first thread about money transmission that he hasn't posted in. https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=thinkcomp https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=thinkcomp https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5398074 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5398074 Edit: He also just filed his lawsuit against virtually every VC and payment startup, including Dwolla. http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/05/lawsuit-names-slew-of-venture-capitalists-payments-startups/ http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/05/lawsuit-names-slew-of... http://www.scribd.com/doc/139975904/Aaron-Greenspan-lawsuit http://www.scribd.com/doc/139975904/Aaron-Greenspan-lawsuit The timing, and the previous comments made by him directly referencing this issue and Mt. Gox is very suspicious.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoAaron (aka thinkcomp) certainly has a issue with this stuff given his FaceCash experience. As to whether he was involved or not is sort of irrelevant though isn't it?