5 ms·
OK, I'll say it: this is not a very good program. Which is fine, because it's a sample program in a fairly silly ACSM article[1]. "The exercises selected shoul
by jacques_chester 14y ago
OK, I'll say it: this is not a very good program. Which is fine, because it's a sample program in a fairly silly ACSM article[1].
"The exercises selected should ... promote strength development for all major muscle groups of the body".
Then progressive resistance is required. Simply adding reps does not increase strength past initial accomodation.
"... create a balance of strength throughout the body ..."
Then drop the isometrics. Isometric exercises only produce strength increases in a limited range of motion close to the joint angle of the isometric exercise. And most of those studies were done with maximal voluntary isometric contraction -- ie pushing as hard as possible against an immobile object. Wall sits do not fit those studies.
"... adapted as necessary to increase or decrease exercise intensity"
Which can't be done with most of these exercises.
"To maximize the metabolic impact of the exercise, time should be sufficient enough to allow for the proper execution of 15 to 20 repetitions (15) of an exercise."
Which further breaks the link with strength.
" Individuals who previously believed that they did not have the time for exercise can now trade total exercise time for total exercise effort and get similar or better health and fitness benefits."
Given that the studies done on high intensity interval training were initially done with elite athletes, I'm not certain it shows that at all.
This is about as scientific as two guys spitballing over beer. It hasn't been tested as a program and the idea that you can achieve any kind of serious strength gain through high repetition circuit training is, frankly, a joke.
If you want to get stronger and improve cardiovascular condition, simple barbell exercises and running or swinging a kettlebell will do it better, for longer.
When I write programs for my trainees, I am apparently equivalently scientific. I too take the general principles I am taught and go through a process of exercise selection, exercise ordering, repetition and set layout, rest period selection and then sprinkle in modifications. I'll be right back, I have a scientific program for figure competitors I need to flog to the Wall Street Journal.
[1] http://journals.lww.com/acsm-healthfitness/Fulltext/2013/05000/HIGH_INTENSITY_CIRCUIT_TRAINING_USING_BODY_WEIGHT_.5.aspx http://journals.lww.com/acsm-healthfitness/Fulltext/2013/050...
- peterwwillis 14y agoThis has nothing at all to do with strength training. They specifically note in the cited article that this is to 'manage and expand their physical energy, prevent fatigue, and sustain engagement'. Simple barbell and kettlebell exercises do not address this in the least. (Well, kettlebell helps, but you're lacking a lot of lower-body plyometrics). And I don't see why you would argue against increasing strength at the joint angle. It's very important for people with the potential for joint pain or injury to strengthen supporting muscles around the joint. I agree that there's little to no science in the article. It seems like everything i've seen concerning athletic performance is based on cherry-picked ideas distributed by non-scientists.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> This has nothing at all to do with strength training. Their first criteria for exercise selection was to "promote strength development for all major muscle groups of the body". As for developing short term fatigue resistance (as opposed to straight up endurance), kettlebells are excellent. My favourite tool for such a job: compact, widely available, and evil. > And I don't see why you would argue against increasing strength at the joint angle. It's very important for people with the potential for joint pain or injury to strengthen supporting muscles around the joint. Because joints move through, and must support load, at a variety of angles. Being really really good at a particular 10 degree band is not very useful for most folk. > It seems like everything i've seen concerning athletic performance is based on cherry-picked ideas distributed by non-scientists. Well in their defence, sports science sucks. Like software engineering research and for the same reasons: small and biased samples, poor experiment design and not much funding to fix either.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>Because joints move through, and must support load, at a variety of angles. Being really really good at a particular 10 degree band is not very useful for most folk. This is so true it bears repeating. A lot of people who focus on limited joint angle strength end up injured when they work their muscles beyond the angles that they are trained for.
- peterwwillis 14y agoA lot of people don't ever get a trainer to show them the right way to do things and get hurt. The people who do learn the right way will find benefit in isometric training. Telling everyone to ignore it benefits neither group. It's certainly important to exercise muscles with a full range of motion, but even people who don't do isometrics hardly ever train to their full range. Watching people at gyms do push-ups, pull-ups, squats, lunges, hell even lat raises with only a specific range of motion is sad.
- jacques_chester 14y ago
- scotch_drinker 14y agoIt's true, a perfect training and exercise regimen will include increasing loads. But given the general sorry state of fitness and health I see daily on the streets, getting people to understand that ANY exercise, even as little as 7 minutes a day, is beneficial will go along ways towards making people healthier and stronger. "Then progressive resistance is required. Simply adding reps does not increase strength past initial accommodation." But initial accommodation for many people might be 6 months. I have trainees who struggle to squat past parallel for weeks or months, who can't do a Tabata cycle of more than 8 squats and who struggle to do real pushups after weeks of training. The base level of fitness for most people is so abysmal that getting them to understand the benefits of 7 minutes of high intensity exercise can be life changing. Sure, to be truly strong, you're going to have to eventually lift heavy weights but for majority of the people out there, a simple body weight routine will give them an amazing fitness boost. Any exercise is better than no exercise. For years, people have thought they needed to spend hours at the gym to lose weight when in fact, solid nutrition combined with short intense workouts can in fact lead to enhanced strength and fitness. When the baseline is so low, anything is helpful.
- jacques_chester 14y agoA key advantage of barbell and dumbbell exercises is that they can be progresively loaded in small increments. Bodyweight exercises tend to have larger jumps in difficulty. Most of the most popular weights programs for beginners are linear progressions. You literally add a fixed amount to each exercise, each session, until you can't. Folk are amazed at how quickly they can progress from struggling with a bar to squatting their own bodyweight.
- scotch_drinker 14y agoI totally agree with you. But I think of exercise programs like the described blog post as the gateway drug to real strength. For most people, the idea of getting into a strength program is intimidating in the same way that doing a waltz in front of 200 people is. But if you can get someone dancing in their kitchen, eventually they might turn to real lessons with real instructors. If I can get people doing 7 minute exercise routines in their living room, eventually they will see the results and want more which leads them to the next step, a true strength program.
- deepGem 14y agoTo add to the barbell exercise theory, I've found Mark Rippetoe's Starting Strength to be a great mathematical based source of strength training, focusing on full body barbell exercises.
- timr 14y ago"the idea that you can achieve any kind of serious strength gain through high repetition circuit training is, frankly, a joke." I guess the joke's on all the extremely fit, strong people who do yoga, then. (I've personally gained strength and muscle mass doing yoga, and when I looked at this routine, I saw most of the poses in a basic vinyasa class. Seven minutes is perhaps a bit aggressive, but the exercises do work. The notion that you can only get intensity with weights is the obviously silly one. All you really need for a good workout is your body, and maybe a mat.)
- enraged_camel 14y agoI'm sorry to tell you that you are terribly misinformed. Athletes get stronger with yoga, because improved flexibility helps them to do compound exercises with better form, and that allows them to activate the correct muscle groups for better leverage. In other words, they have the same muscle mass - they can just activate those muscles more effectively. This is most likely what happened to you, unless you were so unfit when you began yoga that even simple poses worked the hell out of your muscles.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- timr 14y agoIt's a bummer to be terribly misinformed, but I'll take my own muscle mass gains as a consolation prize. We can't have everything, I guess.
- enraged_camel 14y agoIt's good that you got stronger (for the reasons I explained). But unless you are doing some hardcore yoga, it is extremely unlikely that you actually gained muscle mass. (As proof, you can look at any long-term yoga instructor who wasn't muscular to begin with.)
- timr 14y ago
- evunveot 14y agoFrom the ACSM article: "Although HICT can be an efficient means by which to improve health and decrease body fat, it may be inferior to [sic] creating absolute strength and power, specific endurance, and other specific performance variables. If these are the goals of a program, as with competitive athletes, traditional programs may elicit greater absolute gains."
- mcgwiz 14y agoThanks for quoting. I'd like to add that the workout the blog post cited was the ACSM article's "sample workout" based on HICT (an efficient, common sense approach commonly used by personal trainers), that also required no specialized equipment.
- batiudrami 14y ago>Given that the studies done on high intensity interval training were initially done with elite athletes, I'm not certain it shows that at all. There was a study recently released of HIIT (8s sprint/12s relax on a bike) on overweight males, showing it to bt very effective [1]. Not that I pretend to know how this relates to this program in particular. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3375095/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3375095/