3 ms·
Round manhole covers, or if Feynman applied for a job at Microsoft
- DavidSJ 18y agoThat doesn't sound anything like Feynman.
- eli 18y agoThat's because it's not.
- joe_the_user 18y agoI have seen man hole covers that were in the shape of other curves of constant width!! as in the rotary engine shape he describes. Reminds me of the convex solids class I took at UCLA years ago. Boy, I always wanted to say that! If only I could pull one of those interviews.
- Luc 18y agoWhere did you see those manhole covers? Its seems a bit over-the-top to manufacture a manhole cover in a weird shape when round or rectangular will do.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- mynameishere 18y agoThis was the test page when they turned the internet on for the first time.
- tptacek 18y agoYou are my new hero.
- mynameishere 18y agoActually, that joke is extremely old too.
- tptacek 18y agoI searched for it and didn't find it. But, OK. You're not my hero anymore. (wow, tough room).
- dfranke 18y agoActually, this was: http://www.w3.org/History/19921103-hypertext/hypertext/WWW/Link.html http://www.w3.org/History/19921103-hypertext/hypertext/WWW/L...
- ilitirit 18y agoI was asked this once during an interview. After I gave several lengthy possible explanations, the interviewer was basically speechless. The previous question was much more interesting. I was asked to estimate the number of piano tuners there were in my city. I got it right, and it turns out it was one of the the class Fermi questions http://mathforum.org/workshops/sum96/interdisc/classicfermi.html http://mathforum.org/workshops/sum96/interdisc/classicfermi.... Still, I'm not really a fan of these types of questions. Chances are any curious person who spends a lot of time on the net would have come across them some time or another.
- sho 18y agoOne would actually think round manhole covers have several disadvantages to offset their one purported strength. For example, it would be more difficult to attach a hinge or locking mechanism. Also, the grip hole would not be guaranteed to be in the same alignment every time - if you were using a machine to raise the cover, you might have to manouevre the machine into incovenient angles to properly access the grip, according to the whim of the previous team who replaced the cover. With a square lid, the alignment could be standardised to the most convenient position for machine access. Also, assuming the bars in the ladder are straight, which AFAIK they always are, placing a ladder in a round hole wastes space. Feynmann's answer about the cylinder being the strongest structure against compression is true but one wouldn't expect this to be a critical factor at typical street-access depths. Maybe if you were going down 50m or more, but even so, dirt is hardly as effective at exerting pressure as a free-to-move liquid.
- swombat 18y agoWith a square lid, the alignment could be standardised to the most convenient position for machine access. Small quibble, but most of those manhole covers and such are placed where they are because someone built some kind of tunnel there a hundred years ago (for whatever reason, from sewage to water to anything else). The layout of the streets then often evolves largely independently of the position of the manhole covers, thus resulting in some "interesting" placements of manhole covers, sometimes not all that accessible (though I guess it depends on how strict the local regulators are on the architects who design the new layout).
- sho 18y agoAh yes, like so many things it is probably for "legacy reasons". And needless to say really old manhole tunnels would definitely tend to be round, especially if they were constructed out of shaped stones, where the shape of the structure is an important contributor to its integrity.
- something 18y ago>Also, the grip hole would not be guaranteed to be in the same alignment every time it is if it's in the center.
- farout 18y agohe definitely would be a microserf then
- joshwa 18y agoblogspam: original is here: http://www.sellsbrothers.com/fun/msiview/#Feynman http://www.sellsbrothers.com/fun/msiview/#Feynman
- anamax 18y agoI suspect that Feynman wouldn't have limited himself to two dimensions and would have noted what the presence of the lip means.
- johnbender 18y agoThe only thing worse than this is the trivia questions: Q: "When using function x does it pull from the thread pool or create a new thread" A: Don't care, will google
- cperciva 18y agoThis isn't trivia. Creating a new thread is expensive; so understanding the difference can make a huge difference in performance. Saying "I can google this if I need to" is a cop-out: Yes, you can google if if you realize that it matters, but if you don't know the answer you're probably not going to realize that it matters.
- eli 18y agoI see what you're saying, but in practice I see no correlation between people with great recall of arcane functions and syntax and good developers. And the question wasn't, "What's the difference between pulling a thread from the pool and spinning up a new one?" That's a pretty good question, if you're going to be doing programming with threads.
- tjr 18y agoI don't have any meaningful statistics on this myself, but I always found this passage from The Jargon File interesting: Another trait is probably even more important: the ability to mentally absorb, retain, and reference large amounts of ‘meaningless’ detail, trusting to later experience to give it context and meaning. A person of merely average analytical intelligence who has this trait can become an effective hacker, but a creative genius who lacks it will swiftly find himself outdistanced by people who routinely upload the contents of thick reference manuals into their brains.
- Retric 18y agoThe cost of someone trying to upload huge quantities of trivia is a failure to update when systems change. Consider the cost of creating and maintaining high quality comments vs readable code.
- endtime 18y agoFor what it's worth, I'm interning at Microsoft this summer, and none of my interviewers (6 or so) asked questions like this. Most of the questions had to do with arrays of integers, with one linked list question and 1-2 C string questions.
- kul 18y agoFeynman would have more fun with this question.
- twopoint718 18y agoThis reminds me about the story where Feynman is being interviewed by a psychologist. He answers each question in a way that is both perfectly reasonable yet would cause the psychologist to become increasingly concerned.
- quantumhobbit 18y agoThat story was in "Surely you are Joking Mr. Feynman".
- twopoint718 18y agoThanks. I was looking for a "search in book"-type link but couldn't find it. There are some excerpts on e2 that I found, but not of the passage that I was thinking of.
- zandorg 18y agoAnd there's a subtle joke at the end - that he's given a MARKETING position rather than a programming one!