5 ms·
Most people that spend their full salary do never put more than 20$ of gas at a time. At the end, they spend around the same amount than others, but they seem t
by ams6110 14y ago
Most people that spend their full salary do never put more than 20$ of gas at a time. At the end, they spend around the same amount than others, but they seem to prefer to go the gas station many times instead of just filling up the tank.
When gas prices are volatile this actually makes sense. It's the same principle as "dollar cost averaging" when you buy stocks. Purchase a fixed dollar amount, and you end up buying more when the price is low, and less when the price is high, which is what you want to do. Therefore when I buy gas I stop at $25 unless I have a coupon or I'm somwhere that prices are significantly lower than where i normally buy (prices vary by $0.50--$0.75/gal within a 50 mile radius).
- bsims 14y agoThis is a fair point, but more often than not people living paycheck to paycheck aren't as familiar with dollar cost averaging and are probably just buying in $20 amounts because that's how much cash they have at that time. The OP also said it was based on 5+ years worth of data which probably means it is less about gas price fluctuations and more about buying habits.
- uvince 14y agoI apologize for being dense, but what data exactly is the OP crunching here?
- jerf 14y agoInternal private data. We don't know exactly what it is and he can't say. Really, in the end, this is little more than a moderately well-sourced anecdote.
- uvince 14y agoThanks jerf, I have no idea why this made the front page. Clearly I have a lot to learn.
- Vivtek 14y agoIt has a pretty graph at the top and the guy presumably really did crunch real data, so it gets upvoted. Also it's Brazilian, so it gives you a little taste of 21st-century BRIC economics. Hits a lot of buzzers.
- coldtea 14y agoThat would a case of people doing this to counter volatile prices if people also took advantage of the quite low gas prices they chance upon to fill it their car up completely. But what the article says is that they don't put more the $20 at a time, period. Such a behavior wouldn't see any advantage given volatile prices, because in the end you end up paying the same (you pay lower at some times, higher at other). Which is the article points too: that they see the guys doing that end up paying the same amounts as the guys filling it up normally. So it's not the volatile prices that get people doing that, it's perhaps a false idea of saving money, or that they infact do not have that much lying around and try to get to the end of week accounting for any emergency.
- DucktourDreams 14y agoThe writer of the article acts so far removed from how poorer people live s/he doesn't realize why they spend small amounts on gas, but it's just a ruse. For those to whom it's actually not familiar, here's some insight into how poor people spend money on gas: Poor people share rides a lot. They borrow small amounts of money from each other a lot. They take turns paying for things depending on who has money at that time. They mix bartering with payment. They do all of these methods simultaneously. e.g. "I'll give you half of that six-pack and a ride on Tuesday and Thursday if you pay for the gas to get us to work today." It's much easier to arrange these payments around small amounts than to ask for $80 to fill up a truck's gas tank. Furthermore, having a full gas tank is a disadvantage because 1. you are no longer liquid and 2. you are no longer able to extract payment from others for rides. BTW, I find this article and the one it references to show little or no concern for the actual people involved. The real reason for this articles is obvious: They're pushing for access to that juicy consumer spending data and using "helping the poor" as a thinly-veiled excuse. They have the chain of causality reversed. It's not poor people's habits screwing up the economy with credit card companies creating the possibility for recovery. It's increased prices^Wusury by credit card companies grinding the economy down, draining peoples' wallets prematurely. Why do CEOs of credit card companies continue to demand continued income? Just because they can? With 1 in 7 people on food stamps, must they keep pushing? Can't they just declare victory and play golf the rest of their life? Why push harder and harder to squeeze more and more out of the middle and lower classes?
- josephlord 14y agoAlso if the probability that your car is going to breakdown before the tank is empty is significant it doesn't make sense to fill up. At a certain point the fuel may be worth more than the car.
- acgourley 14y agoThe scrap value of a car is several hundred dollars, a street legal car that runs is always at least a grand.
- lacksconfidence 14y agosadly it depends on location, i understand that a 'street legal running car' in the rust belt can go for $250.
- btgeekboy 14y agoThis has another benefit as well - you're not burning more gas just to carry around gas that you're going to use later. If you had a 20 gallon tank and put 7 gallons in at a time, that's 13 gallons (x 6 lb/gal) you are carrying around needlessly - 78 pounds at its peak.
- csense 14y agoOr as xkcd puts it, "a fundamental and central problem in rocket science: Fuel makes you heavier." [1] [1] http://what-if.xkcd.com/21/ http://what-if.xkcd.com/21/
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 14y agoAn interesting idea, but I would be amazed if even 1% of the population took that into consideration. I'd never even though of that before. Besides, a car weighs about 2500 pounds (more in the case of a van or SUV). That 13 gallons would only increase the weight of the vehicle by 3%. I'd be willing to bet you would get more fuel efficiency by just slowing down 3 mph than you would get from keeping your tank only partially filled.
- sliverstorm 14y agoIt has a downside too. When your tank is full of gasoline, due to gasoline's tendency to absorb water, the walls of the tank are not exposed to air or water. This helps prevent rust. When your tank is empty, the walls are exposed to water vapor and air, and can rust.
- yen223 14y agoAnother downside: if your tank is always half-full, you'll need to burn more fuel making more frequent stops at the gas station.
- tpainton 14y agoBeen there done this. As a college student, when I only had $20 to my name didn't spend 50% of my capital on gas. I spent enough to make it to the party.