3 ms·
FTA: In total, more than 670 U.S. passport holders gave up their citizenship [...]in the first three months of this year Not understanding how a fact like this
by ajross 14y ago
FTA: In total, more than 670 U.S. passport holders gave up their citizenship [...]in the first three months of this year
Not understanding how a fact like this even rises to the level of a sentence in a related article, much less the lede. Can someone please explain to me how a tax policy which has a net effect of reducing its tax base by 0.002% (rough guess, assuming I didn't slip a digit) is something worth talking about at all?
I mean, the IRS is going to lose more revenue to people upset with US food choices...
- _delirium 14y agoAlso worth noting: during that same period, around 165,000 formerly non-Americans naturalized as U.S. citizens. A 250:1 ratio of people joining to people disaffiliating ain't bad. Some countries have major problems with an exodus of qualified people and an inability to attract people to the country, but the U.S. is not really in that category. Quite the opposite: there are many qualified, intelligent people wanting to move to the country, but who are currently blocked by immigration law from doing so.
- obviouslygreen 14y agoThat's only an interesting counterpoint if those people more than counteracted the taxable assets/income of the ones leaving. I would not take that as a given.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoFor 165,000 * M >= 640 * N, N would have to me much greater than M. I think its a win. But this isn't accurate, the 165k who naturalized were probably already visa or greencard holders and paying taxes. A more accurate way to measure this is to look at how many visas that support employment are issued each year, which is probably greater than 165K.
- mech4bg 14y agoWhere do you get the 0.002% figure from? The number of people divided by the population of the US? If so, that's not a meaningful figure - you should be examining the tax they would pay compared to the tax base, which could be many times higher. The reason this is news is because it's incredibly wealthy and high profile people with a large amount of assets to tax that are giving up their passports.
- ajross 14y agoWith all due respect, the linked article should be examining that. You assert it "could be many times higher", which is fine. I assert, with equal justification, that the relevant expats are destitute receivers of the EITC and that the IRS revenue will increase. Wouldn't it be nice if someone out there, maybe a web site with journalists and stuff, might do that research for us and give us the results? I'm not saying there can't possibly be an issue worth talking about. I'm saying that this article isn't worth talking about.
- mech4bg 14y agoFair enough point - but they do mention some specific examples of people that obviously have a high net worth and have a _lot_ to lose by these tax laws. I assume that anyone giving up their citizenship has enough to lose to make that worthwhile. It would be good to examine exactly how much is being lost and whether it's _actually_ newsworthy, but I'm not sure how they can do that - AFAIK all they can go on is the number of people giving up their citizenship that is provided by the IRS. You'd need to figure out specific names, it'd be a huge undertaking. It'd be interesting to know though, and probably worthwhile for the government to investigate and monitor.