8 ms·
A good article to help understand the massive afterhours movement: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/05/08/autos-tesla-idUSL2N0DO2IH20130508 http://www.reuter
by mikeyouse 14y ago
A good article to help understand the massive afterhours movement: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/05/08/autos-tesla-idUSL2N0DO2IH20130508 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/05/08/autos-tesla-idUSL2...
High-Level Summary:
There was a ton of short-selling interest on TSLA (due to expectations of a big earnings miss). Almost 27% of the 115mm shares outstanding are currently being borrowed by short sellers. TSLA has more short interest by percentage than 98% of US stocks. Everyone was really expecting the price to go down.
Tesla reported earnings today at $.12/share, and upped their forward guidance. The consensus earnings estimates were $.04/share, so TSLA greatly surpassed expectations.
To short a stock, you have to borrow a share from someone else, and then return that stock to them at a later date. Returning the stock is called 'Covering a short'. All those people who were betting against TSLA are now forced to pile back into the market to cover, but since so many shares were short to begin with, the number of people who have stock to sell is much lower than typical.
This results in a 'short covering rally' where there is a lot of demand to buy shares and a small supply. Econ. 101 takes over and you see a big spike in the price.
- revelation 14y agoShort levels have been that high for much of the existence of TSLA. Noone was expecting the price to go down with this announcement specifically. What you are describing is a short squeeze, and it's still unclear if that is indeed what we are seeing. Many shorts have been unwilling to cover, even when having to pay up to 85% lending rates for stock. A proper short squeeze would not only spike the price, it will make it explode; Volkswagen became the most valuable company in the world at a share price of 1k$ through a short squeeze (even if only for a short time). Remember also that a short squeeze depends on long investors not taking profit. It only worked in VW because the majority of shares were held by institutions unwilling to reduce their stake and of course Porsche, who manufactured the squeeze.
- mikeyouse 14y agoThe straddle on May 10 announcement was something like 15%.. people were definitely expecting some movement.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoElon Musk several days ago: EDIT: My mistake, this was said much longer ago (September 2012). I just read it recently. Thanks to batbomb for pointing this out. My apologies. “It’s doing pretty well actually given that we’re such a huge short position. In fact I think the short position may be as high as one can actually go. They literally hit the ceiling on the short position. The shorts are in it to the hills. I think it is very unwise to be shorting Tesla, it’s very unwise. There is a tsunami of hurt coming for the short." http://www.siliconbeat.com/2012/09/13/video-elon-musk-tells-fox-business-that-tsunami-of-hurt-coming-for-those-shorting-tesla/ http://www.siliconbeat.com/2012/09/13/video-elon-musk-tells-...
- batbomb 14y agoThat's several months ago. If it was a few days ago he'd probably be hearing from the SEC soon.
- MichaelApproved 14y agoWhy, is there a quiet period just before the release of earnings?
- vxNsr 14y agoI wonder, INAL but if he says something like that publicly then it's not insider trading to act on it, I would think anyway.
- MichaelApproved 14y agoBut OP isn't referring to insider trading. The comment was in regards to the timing of the information. The only time that I believe executives are restricted is during/after an IPO. Another issue is making sure that material information is disclosed properly. Elon was essentially hinting that they were going to have a really good quarter. That kind of information is material and would likely need to be disclosed properly to all investors at once. However, I believe disclosing that information has nothing to do with the timing of earnings release. A company can disclose any information it would like at anytime, so long as it does so properly. If I'm wrong, please let me know in reply. I'm very curious about whether I am making a mistake.
- ncavig 14y agoThis might be a stupid question, but as a Tesla stock owner, and (becoming more apparent ever day) naive investor, how do you find out this information and/or digest it so well? I'm mainly a google finance guy and had no idea so much of the stock was being shorted.
- mikeyouse 14y agoI own ~95% index funds, which makes most of my research pretty easy. For the individual stocks I do own, I like to follow the analysis on Reuters. Even just spending an hour/week reading the latest news does wonders. For Tesla: http://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/companyNews?symbol=TSLA.O http://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/companyNews?symbol=TSL... Investing around a short squeeze is out of your control, and I would argue, not worth worrying about. The price will bounce around like crazy and some people will make 30% in a day while others lose much more than that, but in the end, Tesla's price will reflect their ability to turn a profit in the future. If you feel like the future market cap of Tesla is larger than it is today (with all the usual time-value-of-money caveats), keep your money invested and don't waste your time fretting over the mayhem on Wall St.
- ajross 14y agoThe cynical answer is that you specialize in post-hoc analysis like this. Predictions, after all, can be wrong. :) This is true in general obviously, but investing specifically is filled with explanations like this that make sense only in hindsight.
- mikeyouse 14y agoI completely agree in most cases, however the Reuters article I linked was written earlier this week. Some market conditions necessitate a big swing in prices -- though guessing which direction prices will swing can be tricky. If you wanted de-risk your position, you could set up an option straddle or just sell your shares before the announcement and then buy them again next week.
- epoxyhockey 14y agoI am also a novice investor, but the # of shares that are short are actually listed on the details pages of many online stock sites, for example: http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=TSLA+Key+Statistics http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=TSLA+Key+Statistics Shares Short (as of Apr 15, 2013): 30.70M Shares Outstanding: 114.52M EDIT - I guess this is more relevant: Short % of Float (as of Apr 15, 2013)3: 49.20% EDIT #2: Congrats on the gains today! :-)
- rdl 14y agoTSLA options are also super weird and sketchy; around the expiration of the long-dated calls in January each year, there seems to be some magical push to drive the stock price lower for 1-2 days; then after the expiration, when I've been pushed out of the money, the price rebounds substantially. I gave up on TSLA options and am sticking to being long the stock.
- dojomouse 14y agoYou don't need to wait until expiry to sell. There is a lot to be said for options if you use them carefully. Yes, risk is higher with high leverage and a narrow portfolio. But returns can be also. I think the line about risk adjusted returns being higher in index funds is 3 parts inexperienced investors trying to pick stocks without doing their homework and 7 parts experienced investors trying to convince inexperienced investors to provide mindless liquidity for them to work against. I prefer to make my own buy/sell decisions, and so far it's given me a FAR higher average return than any index fund.
- rdl 14y agoWell, it was also around earnings, so I wanted to wait for earnings (which turned out good) and the pop from that.
- pyoung 14y agoWithout quantifying the risks involved with your trading strategies, it is impossible to say whether you are beating the risk-adjusted returns of an index fund. Additionally, I am pretty sure index funds, even without risk adjustments, have been proven to be better investments in the long term than any actively managed strategy. And this holds regardless of the experience of the investors. There are always going to be a few exceptions to the rule, but most of the people getting rich in wall street are doing so because they are taking a cut of other peoples money (management fees), not because they are genius investors. Also, with actively managed strategies, it only takes one or two bad bets to wipe out years of gains, and due to natural biases, individual investors tend to under-report/weight losses and over-report/weight the gains. As such, we always tend to hear how other investors are making a killing on a certain stock or trade, but we rarely hear from the losers, which distorts our perceptions of risk and returns (so far, I have seen a handful of people talk about their Tesla stock holdings on this thread, but I have yet to see a single person talk about haw bad they are getting cleaned out because they shorted the stock).
- jcnnghm 14y agoI can't imagine this not squeezing. The short interest would take 7 days at 4 million shares a day to cover [1], and is about 45% of the float, assuming people haven't been covering for the last couple of weeks. Many of the shorts were opened when Tesla was trading around $40. I am really interested in seeing the updated short interest data from Nasdaq, which will be released tomorrow. If those numbers still show big short interests, expect big banks to hammer the stock up. I sold some shares for a little over $70 after-hours. [1]: http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/tsla/short-interest http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/tsla/short-interest
- changdizzle 14y agoGreat explanation - I (sheepishly) have invested a lot of money in $TSLA and have heard about the short squeeze but don't necessarily understand it, and this explains the movement - thanks!
- JoeH 14y agoI purchased a fair number of TSLA when they IPO'd, for a bit lower than the actual IPO price of $17. A little over a year ago, my brokerage offered to borrow my shares at 4% annual interest (paid on a monthly basis). I was told that I would retain the ability to trade the stock at any time, but I gave up my shareholder voting rights while the stock was "loaned" out. I had never heard of that happening to small individual investors like me, and at that time I looked into it and learned that this was typically done because there was a lot of interest in short sales for the stock and there wasn't enough borrowable stock to cover demands. I renew the loan agreement on a monthly basis and in March 2013 I was offered an increase from 4% to 6% interest for the loan of my shares, indicating that short-sellers were very eager to get their hands on TSLA stock. I'm curious to see if today's activities cause my June offer to drop my interest rate or if the offer just expires altogether. I would guess that at minimum I'll see a lower interest rate.
- revelation 14y agoJust to offer perspective, the interest to borrow shares of Tesla as of 2nd May was 46.10%. It was 85% as of 26th March.
- pyoung 14y agoWhat?!!! Just so I get this straight. In order to short the stock you have to pay an annual interest rate of 46% of the stock value? I realize most shorts are probably only in it for short term, but that is still pretty insane.
- olympus 14y agoNot sure if you're joking or not, but I'll offer a quick explanation. Interest in this context does not mean interest on a loan, but rather how many people are interested in shorting the stock. The 46% short interest meant that almost half of Tesla's stock was shorted. To put it another way, 46% of Tesla's stock was loaned out from various parties to sell to other various parties. This is a bad thing for the short sellers because they now have to pay more for their borrowed stock than they got for selling it in the first place. It's like owing more for your car than the car itself is worth.
- steveplace 14y agoSweet, I was quoted in that article. Seeing short squeezes in TSLA and GMCR aftermarket.
- pfortuny 14y agoHedge fund managers and traders will try time and again to convince people that their job is not 'gambling'. They are having a tough time, though. Some of them are really not gamblers but man, there are so many many of them willing to play with other people's money. As long as they have zero-risk (zero responsibility, that is), they will gamble on.