3 ms·
Always tell them you are paying in cash. Take bill home and sumbit to insurance if you are lucky enough to have insurance. You just saved the system at least
by ck2 14y ago
Always tell them you are paying in cash.
Take bill home and sumbit to insurance if you are lucky enough to have insurance.
You just saved the system at least 75% of the cost.
- yitchelle 14y ago"if you are lucky enough to have insurance." This is one of the many sad points about the health system. Luck should have absolutely NO relation to whether you can afford reasonable health care. Reasonable health care should be available to Joe Blow who is earning minimum wage at your local city council and to Mr. Burns who is earning 20x more than Joe Blow.
- ck2 14y agoGreat news, they solved this in a very profitable way. In a few years it will literally be a crime to not have insurance. So cannot afford it? Not their problem - YOUR problem. Yay 'murica.
- anonymous 14y agoJust like the old law against unemployment back in what was known as the Socblock and the soviets ran the country. Too many people unemployed? No problem - being unemployed is now against the law and a criminal offence.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoThe nice thing about making something mandatory is that their is then outrage when people can't afford what they must have. Society can't ignore the problem anymore and must attack it head on. Can't afford insurance? Well, here is a subsidy, or why not just go on medicaid? Can't afford insurance and make $60K a year; well, maybe individual plans should be more affordable...single payer is looking more desirable. Oh, you make $100K a year and STILL can't afford insurance (let's say no family is involved). Well how the f*ck are you spending your money? Oh, you just don't want to buy it because you are young and invincible? That's not how insurance works. Yeh for America; they are finally catching up with the rest of the developed world!
- ck2 14y agoWhat about the unemployed who cannot afford the mandatory insurance - and won't get assistance unless they trek 20 miles across the county (without a car) EACH WEEK to prove they are still unemployed yet looking for work? Seem right? Basically they didn't solve health care costs, they just dumped the cost onto the entire taxpayer base, the same way walmart keeps low prices by keeping their employees on food stamps.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoLike I said: single payer begins to look good. We've fixed problem (A), that everyone should have health insurance. This is what we were able to get passed. Now we have problem (B): how to get everyone insured? The republicans fought tooth and nail against this because they know that viable solutions to problem (B) are very narrow, and Americans aren't going to want to go back to the have/have not insurance previous state. But ya, it sucks to have all this political intrigue and drawn-out plans, but that's what happens when the country is so divided on the issue.
- mapt 14y agoThe country is not divided on the issue. There are some very powerful people paying media organizations and elderly people who already enjoy single-payer healthcare to say that the rest of the population shouldn't have it, and conditioning political contributions on speaking out against it. http://pnhp.org/blog/2009/12/09/two-thirds-support-3/ http://pnhp.org/blog/2009/12/09/two-thirds-support-3/
- anonymoushn 14y ago> Oh, you just don't want to buy it because you are young and invincible? That's not how insurance works. In the US it does. It will be much more cost-effective for healthy people to pay the penalty each year than to buy insurance. When they need care, they can buy insurance at the normal rate, since it will be illegal to deny them coverage based on a pre-existing condition. This is more than a little bit like shopping for fire insurance after your house has burned down. The primary difference is that politicians have not spent great amounts of effort telling me that I should be entitled to place bets on past events relating to burning houses.
- olefoo 14y agoMr. Burns is falling down on the league tables then, CEO's should be earning at least 500 times the average workers wage http://go.bloomberg.com/multimedia/ceo-pay-ratio/ http://go.bloomberg.com/multimedia/ceo-pay-ratio/ Clearly he is undercompensated.
- rdl 14y agoThe weird thing about having an HSA is that because I pay essentially 75% of a lot of things out of pocket (as long as I'm below my deductible), it often makes sense for me to negotiate and "pay cash" rather than running through my insurance. And yes, the doctors, pharmacies, etc. drop the prices a lot. One of the weird things going on right now is that Doxycycline (a common antibiotic) has gone up in price 10-20x in the past couple months. A bottle which used to cost me $12 generic is now...$350! (due to a crazy FDA recertification process for the manufacturers) My local pharmacist laid in a huge supply at the old price, and when I told him I was on an HSA (and where he saw my insurance deductible of around $250), he sold me the prescription for cash for $30. Still covered for anything serious (essentially any ER visit, cancer, serious illness, imaging, etc.), but for anything else, I'm highly incented to negotiate like I would for any other product. Best of both worlds.
- lucian1900 14y agoThat still sounds like a terrible deal to me. In the UK, I pay around 10% of my salary for national health care and get free care for any problem I might have (and so does my girlfriend, of course). Medication is always exactly £7 (or similar, it might have changed slightly recently) regardless of what it's for.
- rdl 14y agoSo my coverage is maximum out of pocket per year $5-7k. It's very reasonable to assume HN readers make more than $50-70k/yr, so that's better than 10% of income for the same coverage. (I also think the top US care, if you are in the right place, is better than the top NHS care, but only for cancer or very rare diseases; for everything common they're comparable, but NHS covers everyone, so the average quality of care in the UK is better than the average in the US (rather, the 25th percentile care in the US is horrible, whereas the 25th percentile in the NHS is pretty comparable to any NHS care) (and, with an HSA, if I spend less than $3-5k/yr, I get to put that money pre-tax into a Roth IRA equivalent retirement account. I generally spend $200-1000/yr on medical care, so this tends to work out well for me; I don't think I've ever spent more than $1500 in a year. A lot of employers will just give you that money (and pay your premium) if you pick an HSA plan vs. a PPO plan, since it saves them approximately that much in premium) I'd be willing to pay some premium to cover everyone in the country vs. just myself, and to ensure I would have full coverage regardless of income. I don't think I'd want to pay a flat 10% on all of my income without limit for that, on top of taxes, though. (although, between medicare and 3.8% obamacare surcharge on income and capital gains, it's already nearly 10% up to 100k) In addition to HSA, what I'd really like is truly universal minimum standard of care -- not quite where the NHS is, but maybe 20% of that -- to cover preventive and "very cost effective" treatments. The problem is while the NHS is able to use QALYs in making decisions, I don't think the US government would be so rational; we'd end up over-covering dramatic diseases and under-covering less dramatic diseases. I don't believe a $500k intervention for an indigent old person with limited benefit should be paid by taxes, since that same $500k could cover childhood immunizations or preventive care for 5-10k people.
- mapt 14y agoThis is the precise opposite of how it works for a lot of people in the US. I've been on both sides of this, with two incidents a few days apart on either side of student insurance expiring. Hospitals charge uninsured people a ridiculous amount, then mark it down anywhere from 50-98% (Yes, I had a bill that was adjusted 98%) based on negotiations with insurance companies. Uninsured people get hit with the full, absurd inflated costs as bills. They then have the privilege of begging the hospital for a markdown or a payment plan (turned down completely in my case as an unemployed graduate student because I couldn't afford my own place and lived with parents). The bills don't show up for anywhere from three weeks to three months, and there is no indication of what is owed until they end; Nobody's able to tell you on command what things cost before 'coding' things at their leisure. One hospital visit that does any nontrivial diagnostic work may incur dozens of separately billed "services" running through different providers and individual doctors. That begging the hospital for a markdown only applies to them, three-quarters of the others won't accept anything short of the full amount. I thought this system was a bad compromise, but then I got sick. The system is absolutely ridiculous, the victim is given an open-ended debt("If we think of anything else you owe us we'll call you", & "No, we can't give you an itemized bill for 'services'") in dozens of segments with little room for argument or inspection, and threatened monthly with destruction of his financial livelihood. Don't support single payer healthcare? Try a major acute illness on for size and see if your opinions change. This system of "insurance", whatever it was supposed to solve, is utterly broken unless you happen to be healthy. PS: My state is apparently recognized as one of the best in the nation on this topic, I can only imagine what it's like in North Dakota. A lot of people's lives have been ruined by a medical system that makes it downright impossible for the average person to tolerate getting sick. PPS: I think of hospitals as somewhat predatorial now because this will fall worst on an honest, ignorant, unemployed person who attempts to pay his debts - the way one is advised by financial experts to deal with it is to either declare bankruptcy, or make small monthly payments, an option which appears nowhere on your bills (which demand payment immediately), and which the hospital will not either volunteer or agree to when requested. Token payments above some undefined percentage of the debt will prevent them from sending the bill to the collections agency. So if you know this, a major illness might be roughly equivalent to an unexpected student loan, but with the stress of destroying one's health and future health insurance. If you don't, or if you acquire a chronic illness which requires extended care, you acquire a permanent black cloud raining down acid on your financial future.