4 ms·
You certainly want to market this as being for a "digital elite", at least for the time being. And its best for technology professionals to maintain that type
by ilaksh 14y ago
You certainly want to market this as being for a "digital elite", at least for the time being. And its best for technology professionals to maintain that type of attitude as long as possible where the belief is that these types of jobs require very rare intelligence and skillsets.
But I think that the realities of the situation are going to eventually change the cultural attitudes towards high tech workers. For the vast majority of high tech jobs, vocational training is not only much more economical, but also vastly more effective. (I would even go so far as to say that vocational training/apprenticeship activities are more effective at teaching more conceptual and abstract concepts that one might consider to be part of a traditional academic program, but thats not my main point.)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocational_education http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocational_education
- auctiontheory 14y agoThere's no question that vocational training is more effective for a "job." But is vocational training adequate for a "career" that spans 40 or 50 years? And what are the options for un-degreed vocationally-trained people in their 30s or 40s who realize that the track they chose at 18 was the wrong choice for them? I don't know what the answers are. But let's at least ask the right questions. (I realize that Germany and some other European countries do an excellent job of vocational training.)
- voidlogic 14y ago>>But is vocational training adequate for a "career" that spans 40 or 50 years? Not only that, but is vocational training adequate to create citizens equipped with the skills and knowledge to make them capable of analyzing the policy decisions voters in a modern democracy must consider? Some people will claim the traditional college system has failed in this regard, but they are confusing failure with lack of perfection. I'm sure not every citizen needs to go to college to have these skills, but I think most do, and this is especially important in regressive regions of the country.
- goldfeld 14y agoExactly what I was thinking. For a digital elite, it seems this new wave of avoiding college will be breeding increasingly narrow and specialist elites, shallow but for one deep focus. The statement in the article about "learning critical reasoning by thinking about product features" sounded like a joke, and frankly, the companies getting this smart, cheap labor [sic] seem to be the most to benefit, not the careers of these youths nor society as a whole. What it does to stifle creativity and innovation (where social-local-deals is exactly a symptom of stifled creativity) in the long term remains to be seen, because at least for me my biggest breakthroughs have come from being in contact with wildly different disciplines.
- ilaksh 14y agoI think the lack of breadth of knowledge and skills in vocational training is a good counterpoint. That is probably one of the biggest problems with skipping the traditional college track. Maybe there is a middle ground that would provide a useful general education at a reasonable price as well as practical up-to-date training with leading edge skillsets and knowledge. Maybe one way to improve education would be to start by incorporating more individualized (probably largely computer-assisted) instruction starting with young children, so that people could advance both their broader as well as more specialized skills and knowledge at their own pace. That would help many who are held back at times by group instruction as well as people who need to slow down for certain subjects. Maybe there is also room to tune curriculum to provide less depth in certain areas that aren't related to one's chosen specialty. For example, I only completed about two years of college, but I remember getting through what seemed to be quite an enormous amount of chemistry knowledge and exercises. I feel that I may not have understood some of the fundamentals quite as well as I wished and that I went into much more depth in some areas of chemistry than was necessary. I also think that I spent too much time memorizing facts and practicing techniques because the field and curriculum hadn't fully incorporated modern computer tools. Another idea for changing educational institutions: institutionalize life-long learning. I feel that even though things change on the leading edge of science and technology so quickly that vocational training and apprenticeships are much more effective and realistic approaches to gaining the most practical skills and knowledge, there is so much information available in so many fields, and new information being generated every day, that it makes no sense for an education to be "completed" at any set point. And now that we have so many internet-based tools for education and communication there is no reason for it to stop when people leave the campus.
- nijk 14y agoVocational training costs less than 0.25 of college costs. So you can get retrained every 10 years in a new skill.