3 ms·
Interesting counter-point. But I don't think the two papers really attempt to describe/model the same reality - the world(s) of MUD is not quite the same as the
by e12e 14y ago
Interesting counter-point. But I don't think the two papers really attempt to describe/model the same reality - the world(s) of MUD is not quite the same as the modern world(s) of MMORPGS.
I've always seen Bartle's paper more as a guide for (MUD) game/world designers -- and I find the simplification of boxing player types is a useful model for that. By his own admission it isn't meant to be an academic paper -- and seeing more academic research is this area is welcome.
- rjsw 14y agoBartle's paper matches up with my memory of playing the original MUD, though it was rather a long time ago.
- saraid216 14y agoBartle explicitly states that the types are derived from the observation of MUD forum participants, rather than being a larger survey: even Yee's surveys have a better sampling since the data comes from a website catering to multiple games.
- shardling 14y agoRight, it can still be a useful design lens to think in terms of these basic types of interactions players will have in a shared world.