6 ms·
Limiting Antibiotics in Animals
- Egregore 14y agoI don't understand, how people, who supposedly must be well educated in biology, allow antibiotics to loose efficiency by feeding them to animals.
- nopinsight 14y agoSelf - interest and short-term orientation. Improving your own animals' health increases your profits and cash flow now. The downsides are long-term and shared by many others. For regulators, the incentives might be skewed by lobbying and perhaps corruption.
- hispanic 14y agoUnfortunately, this is the way in which "market forces" fail us. When all motivations ultimately spring forth from ever-higher profits and market dominance, how can "doing the right thing" for society as a whole win out on a consistent basis? On the other hand, relying on regulators seems to be fundamentally flawed. Some of the domains that these people are regulating are highly specific, niche, and complex. Where is the government going to get people who are well-versed and experienced in these domains if not the industries being regulated? And, once you are a regulator, from where do you source alternative job opportunities if not the companies you are regulating?
- pyre 14y ago| Unfortunately, this is the way in which | "market forces" fail us. When all motivations | ultimately spring forth from ever-higher profits | and market dominance, how can "doing the right | thing" for society as a whole win out on a | consistent basis? Theory (aka fantasy): - The people running the company will be selfish and want to minimize the future risks to their offspring/descendents. - If the company uses a practice that is bad, all of their customers will just boycott / switch to a competitor. Reality: - The people running the company may not have any offspring and therefore not much riding on the future. - Most of these companies all use the same practices, so it makes boycotting hard. Switching to competitors that don't use these practices are more expensive (i.e. organic), and food is something that people need. - The detriments of certain practices may not be known right away, and stopping them later could lead to lower short-term profits (and maybe not even increased long-term profits, just betterment of society), and Wall Street doesn't like this because all Wall Street is concerned about is numbers going up or down (all other considerations are not considered). - Most people have issues with long-term thinking. Things that happen slowly over long time-spans don't seem to register.
- hispanic 14y agoAwesome points. > Switching to competitors that don't use these practices are more expensive (i.e. organic), and food is something that people need. I do agree that people see this as an impediment. However, people use this excuse way too often - as a crutch, in my opinion. We (Americans, in my case) spend a pitifully small percentage of our incomes on food: http://www.motherjones.com/blue-marble/2012/01/america-food-spending-less http://www.motherjones.com/blue-marble/2012/01/america-food-...
- pyre 14y agoI'd focus more on what the breakdown is for people below the median income. Obviously at a certain level, people can afford the more expensive, but the people in the lower echelons of society are the ones that are funnelled towards "what's cheap" when it comes to food choices. That's not even getting into whom the largest consumers are. I'll bet that there is a lot of interfacing between companies like McDonald's/KFC/etc where other corporate interests are attempting to push down prices. Then you end up with multiple layers of corporate interests that end up insulating the consumer. All of this can also be side-stepped (at least in this case) by moving to a vegetarian or vegan diet, but that's a large leap for some people and there are stigmas attached to it by some in society (i.e. 'dirty hippies,' etc).
- ars 14y agoI've heard that the vast majority of antibiotics that animals are fed are not of a type that has ever been approved for humans.
- gwt561324 14y agoYou're correct, feed grade antibiotics aren't used for humans. The use of antibiotics that are used in human therapy for feed grade antibiotics is already outlawed by the FDA.
- jimworm 14y agoWhile true, it is also irrelevant. All known antibiotics belong to a very small number of classes by their mode of action. Resistance genes often confers resistance to not just one antibiotic, but an entire class, for example mecA in MRSA. Therefore it is possible for a bacterium to develop resistance to all therapeutic antibiotics without ever having encountered the exact types. What's more alarming is that bacteria frequently exchange genetic material between species. Just because the resistance genes have not been discovered in a pathogen does not mean that the gene cannot be easily and instantly transferred from another species, and the chance of that happening is greatly increased if the environment is flooded with resistance genes due to selection by human use of antibiotics.
- gwt561324 14y agoJust because it hasn't happened yet is not a reason not to do something. A tornado hasn't wiped out my house yet, should I move because it might happen some day? Of course there is a risk associated with their use, but the estimated risk is miniscule. It's not even measurable yet. Let's worry about problems we can identify and solve rather than wasting time fretting about what may be.
- jimworm 14y agoIf by "risk" you meant the horizontal transfer of resistance, then I point you at genomic studies of horizontal gene transfer across bacteria. It happens with such regularity that the concept of a species cannot be naively applied to bacteria. https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=horizontal+gene+transfer+genomes https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=horizontal+gene+transfe...
- rlpb 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- cmaher 14y agoSmall daily doses of antibiotics act as a growth stimulant for animals. Bigger animals = more money, and there aren't any incentives in place to prevent farmers from killing the effectiveness of antibiotics.
- joahua 14y agoWhile it would be great if the FDA did something about this, there are probably global dimensions to this problem also. Presumably antibiotics are used globally against strains of disease that spread quite merrily from country to country. I'd assume epidemiology is not domestically constrained: the antibiotic/agricultural practices of one nation impact all others. I have no idea what is standard practice for domestic agriculture in my own country. Things I think I "know" about agriculture are distorted through the prism of American cultural influence - documentaries like Food Inc., are writ large in the imagination even where these are only concerned with domestic affairs. What resources exist that document antibiotic use on a global basis?
- pyre 14y agoFeeding the animals antibiotics constantly also 'increases yield' because the animals grow larger. You think that the head of any agriculture company is going to sign off on something that decreases yield? We've got quarterly profits to think of! Think of the profits that we would lose! </sarcasm>
- sev 14y agoAnimal research/experimentation is a misleading, conglomerate driven force that makes us all believe it is the only/best way to do biological and medical research for the benefit of humans. The reason it is conglomerate/pharmaceutical driven is because these organizations must rely on animal experimentation to get funding. What affects an animal has for the most part no relationship to how it affects a human Yes, there are relatively few instances where how something affects humans is the same as how it affects an animal, but leaving that up to chance as we do research is absolutely not the way to do this! PCP, which has a violence inducing affect on humans is sometimes used as a horse tranquilizer. Not only are humans biologically, physiologically different than animals, but each animal is biological/physiologically different from one another. Due to the fact that animal experimentation/research for the most part (relatively speaking) has not had positive results, researchers started to rely on more extreme methods, such as injecting human DNA into animals so that the animals become more human when they do their research. This causes bacteria/virii which normally would not have been able to penetrate a human, to learn through animals being used as a human DNA surrogate, and therefore becoming stronger and knowing how to attack human cells. Hence the topic of this article and antibiotics becoming less and less effective. edit, references: 1. Lethal Medicine (Documentary) Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iYOTH_krTk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iYOTH_krTk Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KF3yn4-9obw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KF3yn4-9obw Part 3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8Rp9xxW2yc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8Rp9xxW2yc Part 4: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ld8F9yhUb4M http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ld8F9yhUb4M 2. http://www.livescience.com/7962-human-dna-injected-animals.html http://www.livescience.com/7962-human-dna-injected-animals.h... http://www.nbcnews.com/id/7681252/ns/health-cloning_and_stem_cells/t/scientists-create-animals-are-part-human http://www.nbcnews.com/id/7681252/ns/health-cloning_and_stem... -In 2004, researchers looking to study viral infections injected human blood stem cells into pigs. The unexpected result: pig cells, human cells and some that combined bits of both developed in the pigs' blood. -In 2005, researchers created a flock of sheep with bits of human organs growing inside of them, part of an effort (alson carried out in pigs) to eventually create human organ factories. -Some lab monkeys pack a human form of the Huntington's gene which allow scientists to investigate the development of the disease. -There are mice with human-like livers that allow studying the effects of drugs.
- 14y ago
- crikli 14y agoThere is such a preponderance of FUD about how livestock are cared for that it boggles the mind. People that have never once talked to a farmer or rancher have these huge opinions about how food "should" be produced based on some bullshit they saw in an article or some agitprop documentary. In this instance the inference is that livestock are just fed mountains of antibiotics indiscriminately. Are you kidding me? Why would anyone do that? While not as expensive as meds for humans, veterinary medications are not cheap and no operator is going to waste money treating a whole herd unless it is absolutely necessary. Furthermore, take some time to read up on the FDA website about how livestock production is regulated. It is far from the free for all that is so frequently represented. If you are interested in a very educated and thorough perspective on how livestock are cared for at a feedyard, check out this blog by a Dartmouth educated operator in Nebraska: http://feedyardfoodie.wordpress.com/ http://feedyardfoodie.wordpress.com/ On a semi-related note, can you name the product that was responsible for the last three E. coli outbreaks here in the States?
- LaGrange 14y agoActually, a lot of those "people" are, at least in my social circle, actual veterinary doctors and agriculture technicians. As for large-scale farmers, this is a debate against their economic interest, boo-hoo. And there's economic reasons for feeding livestock antibiotics, and at least in legislations I know anything about it's only illegal for "organic" farming (though it does require veterinary supervision — but it doesn't have to be for health reasons unless it's "organic"). And if you really want to speak about regulations in US, an appropriate page is one Google away: http://www.fda.gov/AnimalVeterinary/GuidanceComplianceEnforcement/GuidanceforIndustry/ucm216939.htm http://www.fda.gov/AnimalVeterinary/GuidanceComplianceEnforc... Notice the wording about "voluntary", and it's 2012. It was actually developed due to that "FUD" you're writing about. Note "Increase production by making the animal gain weight faster and by improving the animal’s ability to convert the food it eats (improved feed efficiency)."
- gwt561324 14y agoYou missed the part earlier in the article where it says that is not considered judicious use. Also, you should understand what types of antibiotics are used in feed versus those that are used in treatment. The feed isn't some concoction of all antibiotics available on the market, and most food animal antibiotics aren't used in humans.
- LatvjuAvs 14y agoAnimals, healthy ones, are able to produce enormous defensive mechanisms to counter many illnesses. Nuff said.
- HSO 14y agoWhat an unfortunate name to have in this field! ________________________ And for Pete's sake, I do note that I agree with her wholeheartedly on the substance. It's just the name that struck me out of left field ;-)
- DanBC 14y ago> I am astonished by the letter from Bernadette Dunham, the director of the Food and Drug Administration’s Center for Veterinary Medicine, especially since she told a House committee on April 9 that she was unsure how antibiotic resistance develops. I've posted this before, but some people may have missed it. "Defeating the superbugs" (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01ms5c6 http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01ms5c6) has a segment showing bacteria developing resistance to antibiotics. (http://v6.tinypic.com/player.swf?file=24goih4&s=6 http://v6.tinypic.com/player.swf?file=24goih4&s=6) (Sorry about the lousy host; YouTube's content sniffing detects this as BBC property and blocks it.) They have a slab of jelly. The jelly has sections of differing strength of antibiotic. There's a section with no antibiotic, then 10x, then 100x then 1000x. (They cannot dissolve any more antibiotic into the jelly at that point.) A time lapse camera shows the bacteria growing, and developing resistance to each section. It's an excellent bit of video.
- zackzackzack 14y agoThat was easily one of the best bits of video I've seen in a long time. That explains a lot of science really well. Thank you!
- raverbashing 14y agoI wonder if this can be used to develop useful traits in bacteria. For example, develop bacteria that can digest some pollutants.
- dredmorbius 14y agoThat's the principle behind selective breeding. It and genetic engineering are pretty much exactly how such traits are developed.
- jballanc 14y agoDepends. In many cases of antibiotic resistance, the actual "resistance" is a matter of degrees. For example, Penicillin interrupts the cell walls of bacteria, so in Gram negative bacteria it is only active in the periplasm. Some forms of Penicillin resistance work by metabolizing the Penicillin before it can do its thing. Other forms work by simply pumping the Penicillin out of the periplasm. The former mechanism requires a specific enzymatic activity. The later usually just requires tuning the pre-existing pumps that maintain the environment of the periplasm to be more specific to Penicillin or pump faster over all. In fact, most "multidrug resistance" genes are simply pumps that can exclude drugs from the insides of bacteria in general. But really, this is just the shortest of short answers. If you want to know more about how these things can evolve, you should read about Richard Lenski's long-term experiments: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_exp...
- jballanc 14y agoWhere I live, fruits and vegetables are ridiculously cheap, and meat is rather expensive. For example, apricots (which are just now in season) are $2.50 per pound. When the height of apricot season kicks in, the price will come down to around 50¢ per pound. But if I want a steak I can expect to pay at least $12 per pound. I take a certain comfort in the notion that this price difference reflects the true cost of producing meat. Likewise, everything is locally sourced because there isn't really any other option, so everything taste fresh. Produce is only available when its in season, but this adds a fun sense of anticipation as the seasons change. That's one point of view. The other point of view is that feeding antibiotics to cattle improves yield. Transporting produce long distances ensures that it can be grown where conditions are best, and flying fruits in from Chile means that supermarket customers can find what they crave even in the middle of winter. The US has a long tradition of asking "can we?" not "should we?" Sometimes, as with the Apolo mission, this is a very good thing. Other times, as with the issue addressed here, it can be rather bad. Edit: Also, as I always do when this topic comes up, I'll point to this extremely useful list on Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_antibiotics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_antibiotics . This battle is occurring on two fronts: the bugs are becoming more resistant, and we're having an increasingly hard time finding new weapons to fight them off.
- gertef 14y agoA pound of steak does not have the same level of water content or nutritional value of a pound of apricot, so that comparison is not meaningful. Cost per pound of each nutrient is a relevant comparison. Dried apricots cost $5-$10/lb. Does that make them overpriced compared to fresh apricots?
- jballanc 14y agoIt was not my goal to compare apricots to steak, but rather the price of apricots here to the price in the US contrasted with the price of meat here to the price in the US. The US has optimized the production of meat such that the price is artificially low, but at what total cost?