6 ms·
Reputation.com Loses User Passwords, Emails, and Addresses
- lucian303 14y ago"That said, pointing out to users that you don't have to tell them when you've been breached might not make you any friends." Well, one state is enough. The news would have gotten out anyway from the North Dakota customers. Otherwise, there is no doubt they would have kept it under wraps.
- jorts 14y agoIs there a reason why in all of these compromises that they never state the type of encryption used on passwords?
- dangrossman 14y agoBecause somewhere between 97% and 100% of the recipients of the message would only be confused by that information.
- whatshisface 14y agoConfusion, when followed by positive words, can make people happier sometimes. (Wow, I sure am glad they are so smart!) I don't really see a big drawback to inserting a few extra words, if those words might get reputable people to say that the bad thing that just happened wasn't really so bad.
- floody-berry 14y agoIt seems more likely that they don't realize it's even important until they get hammered for details on what they used. Some PR person asks an engineer and he says "Yeah, it's fine, we hash/encrypt the passwords.." and only after they eventually disclose what they were using and have it explained to them do they realize they screwed up.
- iancarroll 14y agoIt's gonna need some reputation defense now.
- lstamour 14y agoI'm always nervous when people say they've lost "encrypted" passwords. We need a "plain english" version of https://www.owasp.org/index.php/Password_Storage_Cheat_Sheet https://www.owasp.org/index.php/Password_Storage_Cheat_Sheet or at least issue a warning when you create a "password" VARCHAR in MySQL ;-)
- tptacek 14y agoI really hate that OWASP page (it's not as bad as it used to be --- that is, godawful --- and now it's just incoherent) and think we shouldn't be directing developers to it. If there's something "OWASP" (whatever that is) is truly bad at, it's cryptography.
- ineedtosleep 14y agoI usually rely on OWASP for general guidelines, but if that page isn't enough for you, what is? (not a rhetorical question) What should one look into in order to fill in OWASP's gaps?
- gcr 14y agoWhat things would you change?
- gcr 14y agoWhat's wrong with it?
- kijin 14y ago> issue a warning when you create a "password" VARCHAR in MySQL I put my salted and bcrypt'ed passwords in a CHAR or VARCHAR column named "password". Anything wrong with that? Should I change the name of the column to something like "hashed_password"?
- aptwebapps 14y agoThe name of the column isn't a problem, rather it's an opportunity to nudge the developer a bit. Or that's how I read the GP's comment.
- superflit 14y agoSo their reputation is lost?
- joshguthrie 14y agoWhen I first read the title, I thought they litteraly LOST their database contents.
- useflyer 14y agoIts absolutely flabbergasting when a company, which has the sole purpose of protecting customer information, allows this to occur. They've raised 4 major institutional rounds (their last $42 million), its discomforting that neither their team nor investors thought to secure their systems better than this.
- sneak 14y agomumble mumble invisible hand mumble
- skrebbel 14y agoI didn't get it.
- Hitchhiker 14y ago" That is a funny business because on a net basis, the whole investment management business together gives no value added to all buyers combined. That's the way it has to work. " - Charlie Munger ( http://ycombinator.com/munger.html http://ycombinator.com/munger.html )
- furqanrydhan 14y agoI worked there as one of their first engineer's, It's surprising to me that they've raised that much $, however the hack isn't. Incompetence is a word I use fairly when describing my time there...
- electic 14y agoThis is really bad for their reputation.
- brandon_wirtz 14y agoReputation.com has always been smarmy. It wouldn't surprise me if they sold the passwords and then claimed they lost them. (Really) For the things Reputation.com does you have to ask why they used encrypted rather than hashed passwords. Not that hashed passwords would make me super excited to be lost, but why did Reputation.com need to keep the password around? They don't really interact with accounts, and if they do those should be stored separately from the access to the site. So the message should have been "we lost users bank account passwords" or something along those lines. Because I know that Reputation.com is practically in the extortion business this password storing rather than hashing issue makes me think even less of them, which is difficult to do.
- tekacs 14y agoThe passwords _were_ salted and hashed (the article and e-mail screenshot both mention this). It's no s/b/...crypt but they don't seem to have been 'kept around'.
- tekacs 14y agoAaand having posted this, he reads the first comment on the page which states the opposite... in contradiction to the posted screenshot of the supposed e-mail. o_O
- chunsaker 14y agoI received and posted the email, and many others on twitter have also received it. Also, not sure we should take blog comments for the gospel before all the facts are out.
- just2n 14y agoAs a friendly tip, this isn't your YouTube comments page for why Node.js is stupid, so we'd appreciate it if you would take the few minutes of your time and read the article before jumping to conclusions or stating facts without credible sources.
- 14y ago
- bredren 14y agoThis article sort of glosses over the exact user data lost in the data breach: names, email and physical addresses. For users some, phone numbers, date of birth and occupational info. That is a lot of personal data to lose given Reputation.com's supposed to be opening a data privacy vault this year.[1] The founder gave interview to Fox March 1st describing Reputation.com's move into vendor relationship management.[2] Advocates for personal data vaults / VRM business model[3][4] like Reputation.com and Personal.com stress that personal data is mishandled today, especially by data brokers. Thus it must be particularly frustrating for Reputation.com to be directly involved in a data breach. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/09/business/company-envisions-vaults-for-personal-data.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/09/business/company-envisions... [2] http://www.reputation.com/reputationwatch/multimedia/michael-fertik-fox-markets-now-data-vault http://www.reputation.com/reputationwatch/multimedia/michael... [3] https://cyber.law.harvard.edu/projectvrm/Main_Page https://cyber.law.harvard.edu/projectvrm/Main_Page [4] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/13/technology/start-ups-aim-to-help-users-put-a-price-on-their-personal-data.html/ http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/13/technology/start-ups-aim-t...
- DigitalSea 14y agoLosing information on the scale these guys have is no doubt going to be bad for their reputation.
- pentarim 14y agoBad reputation
- xntrk 14y agoSeems like a good letter to send for a fishing scam. Call this number that has nothing to do with our company and give them more personal info to "watch your credit".
- Cherian_Abraham 14y agoIronic. More over, this is exactly why AirBnB should not become an identity store (asking their customers to become verified by scanning and sending their passport info). I do not trust them with my identity.