12 ms·
Your claims are a little surprising, at least from an American perspective. Our various welfare programs are so generous that our poor can (and often do) eat li
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Your claims are a little surprising, at least from an American perspective. Our various welfare programs are so generous that our poor can (and often do) eat like gluttons.
I was under the impression that UK welfare benefits are far more generous than those in the US - is that incorrect?
(Full disclosure - I've spent a grand total of 5 days of my life in the UK, most of it in zones 1-2 of London. I know virtually nothing about your situation, which is why I'm asking.)
[edit: citation on poverty and gluttony. I'm surprised that this is still a controversial fact.
http://www.mchb.hrsa.gov/whusa11/hstat/hshi/pages/210oo.html http://www.mchb.hrsa.gov/whusa11/hstat/hshi/pages/210oo.html
http://mchb.hrsa.gov/chusa11/hstat/hsa/pages/221oo.html http://mchb.hrsa.gov/chusa11/hstat/hsa/pages/221oo.html
]
- jiggy2011 14y agoThat depends, for the most part being on welfare doesn't allow for an extravagant lifestyle at all. Especially if you are a single person living alone. Job seekers allowance (the standard benefit for the unemployed) will net you around £50 per week. Out of that has to come all of your expenses including energy , food , travel etc. You may be able to get rent covered by separate housing benefits. Of course the right wing press will often print examples of families on benefit who are pulling in large sums of money from the taxpayer. I think in most cases these are cherry picked cases. You do of course get more money if you have children, so perhaps if one can produce enough children to benefit from economies of scale it becomes more likely.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>Job seekers allowance (the standard benefit for the unemployed) will net you around £50 per week. // Our family live on far less than that each per week after housing and we're working ... clearly we're not doing it right but it seems that is more than sufficient. Indeed my experience is that those I know on benefits can afford to live quite badly, wastefully.
- jiggy2011 14y agoHow do you budget for that? By the time I've used Energy/Gas + Internet + transport I've taken a huge bite out of that, not to mention food , phone etc.
- Evbn 14y agoIn the US, public transport is at least $20 per week, for a minimum commute. x2 for 2 wage earners. $1/day(!) per person is another $5 each. Replacing worn out clothes adds a touch. Water/sewer is ~$5/wk/person for very light use. Energy for light/heat/cooking is similar. That is bare minimum for survival.
- takluyver 14y agoThis is rather political. I think you can probably find something similar in both the UK and the US: some 'poor' people are getting enough money that they can afford to eat a lot of cheap, unhealthy food, while others genuinely struggle to get enough to eat. The difference in money isn't all that much when compared to factors like whether you have children, which area you live in, and which benefits you're getting. The right uses the former group to claim that welfare programs are overly generous, and can be scaled back. The left uses the latter group to claim that the safety net is barely adequate, and should be strengthened. I'm more inclined to agree with the left; I'd rather the safety net was a bit too cushy for some than that people went hungry. In the last few years, the number of people using foodbanks in the UK has increased dramatically, for instance. Of course, politicians regularly try to tweak welfare to reduce both extremes. But reality is too complex, and you always end up with some people not getting enough while others get more than they need.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoAt least among children (the only group for which I could find this data, see the citations I added to the post you responded to), this is not correct. The number of poor children who don't get enough to eat is virtually the same as the number of rich children who don't - about 5%. In the last few years, the number of people using foodbanks in the UK has increased dramatically, for instance. This does not mean people aren't getting enough to eat. The human body responds in very predictable ways to food consumption - do waistline measurements suggest anyone is lacking food?
- batemanesque 14y agovery much doubt that only 5% of poor children don't get enough to eat. citation?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIt's the same citation I added to my original post. You'd know this if you bothered to read the post you just responded to. http://mchb.hrsa.gov/chusa11/hstat/hsa/pages/221oo.html http://mchb.hrsa.gov/chusa11/hstat/hsa/pages/221oo.html
- illuminate 14y ago"Our various welfare programs are so generous that our poor can (and often do) eat like gluttons." Ah, the T-bone steaks and Cadillacs meme.
- thenomad 14y ago"Our various welfare programs are so generous that our poor can (and often do) eat like gluttons." This statement surprises me, as it contradicts a lot of what I've heard of poverty in the US. Do you have a citation or several I could look at?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI added a couple to the post above. The link with "women" in the title also includes data on men under the data tab. The gist - poor women are more likely to be gluttons than non-poor women, no big difference among men.
- thenomad 14y agoYou've added a couple of links on obesity. Nothing on "gluttony" or the generosity or lack therof of the US welfare program. Five minutes' Googling will make it abundantly clear that "they're fat because they have a moral failing" is a seriously unhelpful point of view. (For anyone interested - the phrase "obesity-poverty paradox" is a good place to start.)
- ceejayoz 14y agoYour citations show a link between poverty and obesity, not gluttony. If welfare programs were generous poor people might be able to afford fresh vegetables and other nutritious foods less linked with health issues, rather than the cheap, high-calorie, low-nutrition foods.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoObesity is a direct product of gluttony (i.e. eating more than you need). If the poor were really financially constrained, they would eat a smaller quantity of high caloric density foods. (There is one exception to this - tall muscular people. This is a known problem with BMI.)
- ceejayoz 14y ago> Obesity is a direct product of gluttony It's also a product of low exercise (common if you're scraping by with two minimum-wage jobs), depression (common when you're poor), eating (cheap) junk food instead of fruits and vegetables, etc.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoLow exercise doesn't cause obesity. Low exercise combined with high caloric intake does. I.e., eating more than you need. I successfully maintain a healthy bodyweight through periods of low exercise (typically resulting from injury). Right now I put in the effort to eat 4500 (reasonably clean) cals/day. When I'm unable to train, I cut it to 3000. People suffering depression may choose gluttony at a rate higher than others, but that doesn't mean depression causes obesity. Gluttony does. If a person were truly financially constrained, they couldn't engage in gluttony if they wanted to.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI think poor people often do eat calorie dense foods.
- thenomad 14y agoSorry, can I just get a clarification here? Are you saying that it's impossible to be malnourished and obese? If so, that's provably untrue.