9 ms·
Winamp’s woes: how the greatest MP3 player undid itself (2012)
- soulclap 14y agoI guess I am the only person in the world still using Winamp. Just feels odd when I listen to mp3s and can't look up the ID3 tags with alt-3. And I never felt the need for a 'library', 'database' or huge spaceship cockpit UIs either.
- coldtea 14y ago>And I never felt the need for a 'library', 'database' or huge spaceship cockpit UIs either. Probably because you never experienced them. There are things "you feel the need for" (e.g water in a desert) and things you have to use for a while to say "fuck, how did I do without those?".
- mpyne 14y agoI've experienced all types, never needed anything fancier than Winamp's playlist support + searchbar.
- yareally 14y agoWinamp also has a library built into it. Whether one chooses to use it is another thing entirely though.
- aerique 14y agoNo really, there's actually people who prefer more basic players.
- lurkinggrue 14y agoI tried iTunes over the years it was was far too annoying.
- smrtinsert 14y agoWinamp still kicks the crap out of every current music player.
- Nav_Panel 14y agoI personally think foobar2000's fairly excellent. Flexible as hell, both in UI and in functionality. Quick and doesn't feel bulky at all. It's honestly the piece of software I miss most when I'm on my Linux install.
- w1ntermute 14y agoYeah, I miss foobar2k too in Linux. I usually use Exaile.
- Sniffnoy 14y agoI just run foobar2k under Wine. It works pretty well.
- rmk2 14y agoIt has been named in this thread before, but you might not have seen it. I used to run foobar under wine, but honestly, deadbeef[1] works better from an integration point of view (global shortcuts, GTK etc.). [1] http://deadbeef.sourceforge.net/ http://deadbeef.sourceforge.net/
- w1ntermute 14y agoNever heard of deadbeef, but it looks promising. I'll have to give it a shot.
- Sniffnoy 14y agoThis looks interesting. I'll have to check it out, thanks.
- codygman 14y ago
- yareally 14y agoI still use it for the fact I can reduce its size down to about 1/8" of my screen[1] (on a 23" 1920x1200 monitor) and scroll through my playlist with my mouse scroll wheel while docked on the taskbar of my screen. No other player (windows, linux or otherwise) can do that as far as I know. [1] http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/901/winampm.png http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/901/winampm.png *edit: added link
- lurkinggrue 14y agoDrag and drop music into it and I am all set. I know where my music is and if I don't a quick search finds it.
- Osmose 14y agoMy primary reason for staying on Winamp is that most of the plugins for playing video game console music formats (NSF, PSF, GSF, 2SF, USF, VGZ, KSS, SPC, and others) are written for Winamp. I've found a few programs that play a few of the formats, but Winamp is the only one that plays them all. (Any player that fully supports Winamp plugins would be an adequate replacement, but I'm also happy with Winamp in general)
- soulclap 14y agoTrue, that's another good point. Talking of plugins for other music formats, the Oldsk00l MOD Player Plugin for Winamp provides much more accurate playback of Amiga MOD files than the built-in Winamp MOD player. Absolutely recommended and essential if you like Amiga (crack intro) chiptunes. Hasn't been updated in ages but still works fine for me. It also supports some other Amiga formats, you can find it at http://www.rift.dk/page.php?1 http://www.rift.dk/page.php?1
- degenerate 14y ago"Most of my plugins for playing video game console music" = ChipAmp. http://www.chipamp.org/ http://www.chipamp.org/
- carry_bit 14y agoThe reason why I use Winamp (and can't stand almost every other music playing program I've found) is because Winamp has the Nullsoft Signal Processing Studio DSP plugin. Being able to adjust the playback speed (affecting pitch and tempo), among other things, is a killer feature for me.
- lmm 14y agoAmarok 1 was better, but it's harder to get hold of than winamp :(
- klearvue 14y agoClementine
- lmm 14y agoDoesn't have all the functionality - it can't play TTA properly, there are limitations in its cue support, playlist/queue/search don't interact the same way they did in amarok.
- TillE 14y agoAmarok used to be my favorite music player by far. I still can't believe how much good stuff in the Linux world was destroyed by the transition to Qt4/KDE4. It's been like a five year development setback.
- shrikant 14y agoFwiw, the music library functionality in winamp (IMHO) remains the fastest and best I've seen and used in any media player. And I've used pretty much all of them.
- salvadors 14y ago> I guess I am the only person in the world still using Winamp. Well, one of the 30 million people still using Winamp.
- lurkinggrue 14y agoSame here. It does playlists well and that's all I need.
- eksith 14y agoEvery promising technology/company that gets gobbled up by the bureaucratic mega fauna enviably end up being re-chewed and strewn about as piles of dung (to be burned to repel mosquitoes). AOL's problem is that it's a corporation first, a product/service creating, maintaining and selling entity second. Oh sure, the execs may think they're "creating and maintaining" a product/service, but their mindset is "how do we make money out of X"; not "how can we provide the best X we can and make money out of it". Once any entity defines its existence by finding means of validation for said existence rather than innovation and inspiration, it's doomed to mediocrity and, later, collapse.
- illuminate 14y ago"AOL's problem is that it's a corporation first" Isn't its main problem today that it's a content farm operated by new-age antivax no-signal-to-noise peddler Arianna Huffington?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- eksith 14y agoHa! Yes, that too. Of which I'm sure they were thinking how to make money off of first, not how the hell to increase quality afterwards. Kinda like what happened to Java after being inherited by Oracle when they bought Sun.
- gingerlime 14y agoAnother anecdote: ICQ was the very, or at least one of the first instant messaging applications, and acquired by AOL in the late 90s "for US$287 million in cash up front and $120 million in additional payments over three years"[1]. It was a huge story in Israel at the time. The company is still there, but I don't know a single person who still uses it today. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICQ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICQ
- antiterra 14y ago
- losethos 14y agoI think VMware will want to be fixing that, what do you think? Now, that they know my friend, Mr. God! MOTHERFUCKERS! God says... sacrifice, and threshing instruments and other instruments of the oxen for wood. 24:23 All these things did Araunah, as a king, give unto the king. And Araunah said unto the king, The LORD thy God accept thee. 24:24 And the king said unto Araunah, Nay; but I will surely buy it of thee at a price: neither will I offer burnt offerings unto the LORD my God of that which doth cost me nothing. So David bought the threshingfloor and the oxen for fifty shekels of silver. 24:25 And David built there an altar unto the LORD, and offered burnt offerings and peace offerings. So the LORD was intreated for the land, and the plague was stayed from Israel.
- beefsack 14y agoFor those on Linux or Windows, Audacious is a beautiful audio player heavily inspired by Winamp 2.x, both visually and mechanically. It supports Winamp Classic skins out of the box, and comes with quite a nice one as stock. Screenshot: http://community.linuxmint.com/img/screenshots/audacious.png http://community.linuxmint.com/img/screenshots/audacious.png Homepage: http://audacious-media-player.org/ http://audacious-media-player.org/
- yareally 14y agoI might be willing to switch if it can do a minimal interface[1] like Winamp does (depending on the skin). That's what keeps me on Winamp the most. edit: Awesome, it does[2] (if you switch to the winamp classic skin). Just need to find how to minimize it to the tray so it doesn't show in the taskbar and get switching between tracks with the mouse scroll wheel working. [1] http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/901/winampm.png http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/901/winampm.png [2] http://img211.imageshack.us/img211/6972/audacious.png http://img211.imageshack.us/img211/6972/audacious.png
- beefsack 14y agoIf you go to preferences, and look at the plugins tab (I believe in the general plugins section) you'll see there's a plugin for a system tray icon. After enabling, you can hide to the system tray by clicking the system tray icon. Most useful plugin IMO.
- yareally 14y agoOh thanks. I was hoping it would just remove the app from the taskbar and keep the player still on the screen (like winamp). Not quite the same, but it can probably be tweaked in the source.
- brickmort 14y agoThis is the best discovery I've made all week! Winamp was always my go-to application because it was so compact and less clunky compared to Ttunes. Now that I use linux, Its like i have winamp again. Thanks for sharing!
- KwanEsq 14y agoI've never understood why media players in particular feel they have carte blanche to completely ignore any attempt at integrating with the system look and feel. I never really got along with WinAMP due in no small part to that.
- alok-g 14y agoOn the contrary, when Winamp came, I found it full of innovations that could not have been there if they were to follow the system look and feel. It was great to see the old ways broken to make an interface well-suited to the application at hand. I still admire and use Winamp to this day.
- eclipticplane 14y agoBack in WinAmp's rise, the "system look and feel" was stagnant and stale. WinAmp (and other media players) tend to be small on-screen; they are rarely full screen apps. They should play my music and get out of my way. System styles and UI are rarely designed for "small form" applications that need to pack a lot of features into a very small, non-descript space. WinAmp's themes went above and beyond, of course, but those were at the user's discretion.
- J_Darnley 14y agoI usually agree with you. I can't stand most programs that don't use a native Windows interface. Even GTK ones can annoy me. However, Winamp is the one exception I actually like. Perhaps partly because you aren't forced to use a horrible, brightly-coloured, sparse interface that many of them get. Utilities that get forced upon you with device drivers are usually the worst at this.
- forgottenpaswrd 14y agoExcuse me? Winamp was one of the the better programs at integrating with the OS that I had know. it had this thing called skins that made the player look whatever you wanted it to be, including the system look and feel, if you wished. In fact , if you used a Windows OS theme, you will soon discover that Winamp native interface was much much better at what it did than Windows native(native Windows Media witch Winnamp outlook could emulate was atrocious and super bloated).
- hkmurakami 14y agoI remember finding out the story of WinAmp's creator (Justin Frankel) making a winamp plugin that basically "blocks" AOL AIM advertisements after his company had been acquired by AOL. Just hilarious. Frankel has programmed a Winamp plugin that blocks out the advertisements in AOL's AIM instant messaging program. The ad areas are currently used to advertise AOL features; install Frankel's plugin and they're replaced by plain white boxes. Start playing a tune in Winamp and the boxes turn into a graphical display that changes with the music. Even better, Frankel released the software on a hidden page on a server belonging to Nullsoft, and thus to AOL. The description of the software made no mention of its AIM-modifying effects, though the name of the plugin is AIMazing. http://techreport.com/news/1211/winamp-creator-nullifies-aim-ads http://techreport.com/news/1211/winamp-creator-nullifies-aim...
- moxie 14y agoYes! I remember this happening but wasn't able to find any reference to it. I remember that I was already impressed he'd taken someone else's MP3 player, put a GUI in front of it, and sold it to AOL for hundreds of millions of dollars. But when I saw Nullsoft immediately release the AIM adblocker after being acquired by AOL, I knew they were truly amazing.
- jamesaguilar 14y ago$86 million.
- csense 14y agoToo often, bigcorps acquire successful smaller companies, then try to micromanage them in ways that negate the attributes that make them successful. If you've bought a goose that lays golden eggs, why would you mess with it? Just collect the gold every day and shut up. You'd think they'd learn to act like a shareholder and keep their hands off day-to-day operations, just stepping in to support the acquiree when its management asks for help that the parent's in a good position to provide, like expansion capital or coordinated marketing. Of course, all of this is predicated on the acquisition's actually laying eggs consistently -- the parent corp needs to make it clear that they'll come in with a heavy hand of micromanagement, or disband the acquired business unit altogether, if its financial performance is bad enough. All of what I've said so far only applies when the acquirer's primary target is the revenue the acquiree is generating; it doesn't necessarily apply to companies that are acquired for specific assets such as talent, branding, or technology.
- res0nat0r 14y agoI absolutely love Winamp and have been using it since it came out. All of my upgrades / new installs are always the minimal package without any bloatware crap. I love the small UI footprint that I can minimize at the top of my screen and not block anything else I'm viewing. I think I've been using this skin for about 8 years now: http://customize.org/winamp2/skins/6307 http://customize.org/winamp2/skins/6307
- aluhut 14y agoI'm happy with my winamp...2.95 I never needed more from a mp3-player. I have a small streamrip plugin installed for years now. This is the only "special" feature in it. For everything else, I use a different programm and it was never a problem.
- swatkat 14y agoI was using WinAmp in its 1.x and 2.x days. When WinAmp started to bloat, I switched to Billy [0], an ultra-fast and minimal player. Nowadays, I stick to VLC as I no longer have Windows on my personal laptop. [0] http://www.sheepfriends.com/?page=billy&subpage=billy_comparisation http://www.sheepfriends.com/?page=billy&subpage=billy_co...
- noomerikal 14y agoAfter reading this, I am getting a bit nostalgic thinking about winamp and napster back in the day. I can't believe 15 years has passed. IMHO winamp was one of the best pieces of software developed over that timespan. On a sidenote - timely piece as AOL Music just shut its doors - http://www.mediabistro.com/fishbowlny/aol-music-shuttered-staff-laid-off_b81451 http://www.mediabistro.com/fishbowlny/aol-music-shuttered-st...
- pootch 14y agoEvery commenter on this thread is a fking loser. WINamp has been dead for years and will never come back.
- saejox 14y agoI use VLC. It has a playlist, that's enough for it to satisfy my mp3 needs.
- noonespecial 14y agoAhh Winamp and the summer of '97. The first MP3 player I found that could play in real time on my AMD 486DX4-100, allowing me to put an MP3 player in my car. A great big joyride of inverters, regulators, monochrome 16 shade plasma screen and trackball. And girls, looking away from their jock boyfriends and saying "You just choose it on the screen and it plays!? There's hundreds of them, they're all on here?!"". It was like driving around a time machine from the future. Nullsoft, the leading edge of the shockwave that turned geeky cool.
- Daiz 14y agoI personally switched to foobar2000[1] years ago and never looked back. Some of the big reasons back then were gapless playback and proper unicode support (I have quite a bit of Japanese music in my collection), and the fact that it doesn't do anything unnecessary (like try to be a video player at the same time) - it plays (and manages) music, and does it very well. It has served my music player needs ever since - it's really rock-solid and still actively developed to date (and it's very customizable). [1] http://www.foobar2000.org/ http://www.foobar2000.org/
- chjj 14y agoIf anyone is interested, see deadbeef for the linux equivalent of foobar2000: http://deadbeef.sourceforge.net/ http://deadbeef.sourceforge.net/ (But personally, I use MOC: http://moc.daper.net/ http://moc.daper.net/)
- RexRollman 14y agoOn Linux, I prefer the MPD/ncmpc for music. I love the idea of decoupling the player and the interface. On Windows, it's Foobar2000 all the way.
- prezjordan 14y agoHow do these compare to VLC? Is VLC not actually a good audio player?
- tripzilch 14y agoIt does the job just fine for just about any format, but playlist management in VLC is pretty awful, IMO. edit: I'm using WinAmp for my MP3s, but I might take a look at foobar2000 as well
- quattrofan 14y agoI use Winamp now but only because of its support for FLAC. I hate its UI, its far too messy and complicated with all kinds of windows that can be docked, undocked etc. Its unfortunate the developers have never understood the concept of "less is more".
- looki 14y agoWell, I don't want to sound like an evangelist, but foobar2000 plays FLAC just fine, with gapless playback and whatnot and the interface is quite the opposite of Winamp's.
- quattrofan 14y agoHmm, thanks will check it out, I'd not seen that one before!
- quattrofan 14y agoOk well an initial install I like that its a lot simpler than WinAmp, but one major problem is an initial scan of my local music library and it only found 784 songs when in fact I have 4733 showing in winamp. Now they are a mixture of mostly FLAC but some MP3 and WMA, also a lot of in sub-folders. Does it not handle sub-folders do you know?
- looki 14y agoIt definitely handles subfolders. I'm not sure what the problem is, to be honest. All I can think of is wrong settings in the "Media Library" preferences.
- lurkinggrue 14y agoTurn off all those extra windows. Go to the classic skin. You can default it to a less is more interface.
- ciucanu 14y agoI still use it with classic skin.
- lurkinggrue 14y agoSame here. Just want a simple drag and drop play list.
- ciucanu 14y agoI still use it with classic skin.
- totoe 14y agoyou remember the geiss plugin? awesome memories! http://www.geisswerks.com/geiss/ http://www.geisswerks.com/geiss/
- sehugg 14y agoDon't forget AVS (Advanced Visualization Studio). Good old software rendering, and programmable: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tka07_LC534 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tka07_LC534
- GlennS 14y agoI kept using Winamp for long after it got rubbish because it was the only thing you could use http://www.milkdrop.co.uk/ http://www.milkdrop.co.uk/ on.
- xtracto 14y agoAnyone remembers MusicMatch Jukebox? The first versions where quite good. Specially the capability of ripping to MP3. Today, two media players I like in Windows is: MusicBee ( http://getmusicbee.com/ http://getmusicbee.com/ , quite fast last time I tried) and MediaMonkey (previous versions where good, current versions became bloated).
- lurkinggrue 14y agoI still use winamp.