2 ms·
So I'm thinking that one could start a "journal of obscene and salacious comments, potentially defamatory remarks, flames &c." in which we review statements aca
by pbhjpbhj 14y ago
So I'm thinking that one could start a "journal of obscene and salacious comments, potentially defamatory remarks, flames &c." in which we review statements academically for their values - offensiveness and such. The Journal will of course be electronic enabling any person to submit for review a remark of their choosing.
Once submitted Section 6(5) gives anyone the right to "the publication of a fair and accurate copy of, extract from or summary of the statement or assessment" and this duplication of the a reviewed submission to our journal receives privilege.
S.6(6) obviously stands against the actions of the Journal but proving malice in a statement seems difficult especially when it has been submitted for academic reasons.
Or maybe not ...
- rlpb 14y agoYour journal would only be academic if a judge says it is academic. It doesn't matter that you call it academic; I doubt any judge would agree. So you would not have any defence.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>It doesn't matter that you call it academic; I doubt any judge would agree. // It does rather hinge on the meaning of the term. As I understand it judges can be lead by caselaw, general definitions in other acts or if not so well defined the normal common usage meaning. The term "academic" seems unlikely to be well defined in legislation and the common usage is vague. Similarly I suspect "journal" has a pretty broad definition. Is the "Journal of Weird-Ass Shit" an academic journal (http://tuvalu.santafe.edu/~moore/jwas.html http://tuvalu.santafe.edu/~moore/jwas.html)? There might be a definition in the tax code somewhere? A judge is there to apply the law, not to rewrite it if it's not precise enough to gain a conviction. The judge is there to find how the law _as written_ determines the legality of an act. Do you not think vernacular English language usage in conflict and socio-political impact of uncensored speech is a legitimate area of research?