8 ms·
Stocks Plunge, Quickly Recover, on Fake Tweet
- chaz 14y agoYet another reason why Twitter needs two-factor authentication. The tweet, which said that there had been two explosions at the White House and President Barack Obama was injured, came after hackers made repeated attempts to steal the passwords of AP journalists. https://www.facebook.com/APNews/posts/10151407898286623 https://www.facebook.com/APNews/posts/10151407898286623
- kmfrk 14y agoTwitter were hiring engineers with this specific knowledge a long while ago. It must really be tricky for them to make it work, somehow.
- yetAnotherPW 14y agoSo called "two-factor" authentication on the internet pretty much means entering two different passwords. I've never seen anyone attempt anything more complicated than making people remember what ultimately amounts to yet another password. Certainly not on a free website. But even financial websites pretty much provide a dumb questionnaire list with challenges like "what was your first dog's favorite color?" to which you can choose any kind of text string as a response ("bark" for example). Does anyone honestly believe that these things provide additional security? It's like the TSA frisky-crotch-grope of authentication.
- johnl1479 14y ago> Does anyone honestly believe that these [two-factor auth] things provide additional security? It's like the TSA frisky-crotch-grope of authentication. Yes. Especially as time-based passwords, a-la an RSA token or Google's two-factor auth, since they require something you know (your password) and something you have (the token). They expire and regenerate every minute or so, can't really be remembered or predicted, require access to a physical device that displays the password, and near impossible to predict without information about the seed.
- kmfrk 14y agoI personally don't care about it all that much, since I hold about zero affluence and clout on Twitter, but it's a stupid hassle to stay on top of for celebrities and the people managing brands and politicians. I am a security zealot, and even I can't be bothered to have unique passwords on some - unimportant - websites. It is so easy to set up for a user, and I might as well just have it, if it means all my sites are represented in Google's TFA app on my phone. It's no hassle to use at all, as long as the sessions last for a few weeks.
- ketralnis 14y agoIt's not just two different passwords, it's one password that you know and another password sent to some physical device (usually a mobile) that you must be in possession of
- snowwrestler 14y agoWhat you're describing is not two-factor auth, it's more like a recovery question. Two-factor auth involves entering a temporary code along with your password. The temporary code comes via SMS or a special mobile phone app. Google, Facebook, and Dropbox are examples of free websites that offer this.
- betterunix 14y ago...or maybe we should not be relying on Twitter when we make financial decisions?
- dopamean 14y agoThis really is the right idea but it's unlikely that we're gonna get people to change how they take in their news and how they will react to it.
- devcpp 14y agoIf people with large pockets are dedicated enough to monitor Twitter, it must probably have proven efficient enough to justify doing it. I don't expect them to stop doing so until the fake tweets situation goes very big. And I'm sure Twitter will react with stronger authentication before it gets that bad.
- davesque 14y agoInteresting to think that having access to the twitter account for a major news source is like having a "big red button". I wonder if people won't be trying harder to gain access to things like this from this point forward.
- cube13 14y agoThe "Plunge" was a 1% drop in the DJI average. Concerning, sure, but not nearly as huge as the graphs make it out to be.
- jacquesm 14y agoIf you could repeat that trick it would be a bit like a combustion engine. Every individual explosion doesn't amount to much in terms of force but a long sequence will get your car up to speed quite nicely.
- emini_guy 14y agoFor day traders it certainly was a plunge.
- mmanfrin 14y ago1% is huge.
- tedsanders 14y ago1% is huge in an absolute sense, but small in the impact it has on any one person. And small relative to some other news-driven price changes. Fair?
- brown9-2 14y agoA better chart: https://twitter.com/charlesforelle/status/326746314232692737/photo/1 https://twitter.com/charlesforelle/status/326746314232692737...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Rimpinths 14y agoIt was a pretty big deal. I ran some queries against some intraday data of a proprietary market index (kind of a cross between the S&P 500 and Russell 2000) and it was the biggest one minute drop (at -0.56%) that I found within the past year. For comparison, here are the top 5 that I found since 4/23/12: (1) 4/23/13 @ 13:10: -0.56% (2) 8/1/12 @ 14:14: -0.45% (3) 11/29/12 @ 11:41: -0.44% (4) 6/20/12 @ 12:33: -0.38% (5) 12/31/12 @ 13:47: -0.35% As best as I can tell from the news on those days, (2) and (4) were related to Fed announcements and (3) and (5) were related to the fiscal cliff.
- chatmasta 14y agoSome script kiddy just made a lot of money.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoSo that is a better hacking strategy than ddos'ing mt. Gox. Clearly if you can make the DOW drop 127 pts on demand you can figure out a way to profit handsomely from that. The simplest being to short a basket of stocks that are going to be affected and cover the shorts with buy orders. Harder to track than a 'one stock shock' as they say since by their nature DOW stocks are heavily traded and people are guessing all the time if they are going to go up and down. Spread $15 - $20M in shorts across the basket, cover them on a 15% net gain in proceeds and then shoot the canary.
- btipling 14y agoSEC investigates stuff like this. So not a better strategy. Who benefits from stocks like this is information available to investigators.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoUnderstood, but the SEC doesn't investigate every butterfly [1] transaction, and since you're spread wide its a lot more subtle. [1] Butterfly - a limited risk investment that exploits volatility see [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butterfly_(options) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butterfly_(options)]
- btipling 14y agoIn order to benefit they would have had to sell in very short time.
- neurotech1 14y agoTry FBI and Secret Service, along with 10 other agencies. Perhaps even US Cyber Command could get involved. If this is a trading strategy, its a really really dumb move.
- mynameishere 14y agoYeah, how often do prosecutions actually occur? The market is huge and trades can easily get lost in the noise. Was anyone arrested for trading prior to 9/11? The only way to figure out who was making trades on the expectation of this hoax would be to find the hacker, which probably means finding who controlled a botnet, which probably means convincing Russia to extradite someone. Good luck.
- error54 14y agoI think that any journalists that retweeted this should be unequivocally fired. After all the jumping to conclusions the news outlets did last week about the boston bombers and the subsequent apologizing for accusing innocent people, there's really no excuse for this.
- edavis 14y agoDid any journalists actually retweet this? I had a dozen journalists in my timeline all yelling "fake."
- endersshadow 14y agoGood lord, fired? For re-tweeting an AP tweet? You may want to do independent verfication, but hell, it's the AP. It's not like somebody set up an a AD account and tweeted it as a fake AP. I don't blame anybody for re-tweeting that. What is with people and wanting people's jobs over every little thing these days? In the land of Twitter and Facebook, you're not allowed to make an occasional honest mistake any more.
- error54 14y agoAn honest mistake is misspelling someones name. Retweeting that the President of the United States has been injured without taking 10 seconds to establish the veracity of story is just inexcusable and lazy journalism which could someday get people hurt.
- endersshadow 14y agoOh, get over yourself. If they re-tweeted it immediately, then went to get more info on it, found out that it was false, and then apologized/deleted it, who cares? It came from a particularly reputable source, so simply clicking one "re-tweet" button does not a fire-able offense make. I'm glad to know that you've never made an assumption based on authority, a minor mistake, or even taken a shortcut in your career, though.
- 14y ago
- kmfrk 14y agoIt was the Syrian Electronic Army who dun it: https://twitter.com/Official_SEA6/status/326746641451327488 https://twitter.com/Official_SEA6/status/326746641451327488.
- ceejayoz 14y agoAnyone can claim responsibility. Doesn't mean they actually were the ones to do it.
- runevault 14y agoWould be interesting to know how much of this reaction came from people reacting, and how much from the High Frequency apps reacting to the people reacting. I don't know if they have any way of figuring that out, but it would be interesting to learn.
- azmenthe 14y agoI'm sure some HF apps made a killing :)
- ISL 14y agoI expect some HF apps got killed, while other HF apps got paid. Events like this and the 'flash crash' make it look like HFT is a good thing, or at least harmless. The market is durable against people doing silly things, and rewards those who do sensible things in response.
- pnathan 14y agoI am writing a tool to scrape social media and do sentiment analysis on that to provide a signal to make stock recommendations. I plan to feed it into an actual trading system at some point. So the tweet would be integrated into the system, as would any reporting of it. :-/
- RaSoJo 14y agoNeat. Are you planning to expose any documentation on your tool? Would love to learn how you are approaching it.
- Iterated 14y agoI'm a finance guy who has been reading about NLP and sentiment analysis. Any introductory books on this subject that you'd recommend for a non-linguist interested in NLP and sentiment analysis? I'm well versed in python/R.
- pnathan 14y ago
- snptrader 14y agoThat was awesome.. I trade S&P Futures and just got 30 points in 5 mins on that.
- abarringer 14y agofascinating charts here documenting the incident. http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4176.html http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4176.html
- RaSoJo 14y agoAre these so called high frequency trading algorithms being fed Twitter/Soc Med information? Not sure if pure human intervention could cause such a large drop in so short a time period. In which case, hacking multiple relatively smaller information sources, rather than larger govt. or banking sites could provide very high upsides with much lower risks.
- john_b 14y agoThat is my hunch as well. HFT algorithms do exist which trade primarily on news feeds, and given the relative ease of harvesting Twitter data, there has to be more than just a few HFT bots that reacted to this.
- uptown 14y ago"Are these so called high frequency trading algorithms being fed Twitter/Soc Med information?" Yes - Some are. Absolutely.
- micheleg 14y agoYep, that becomes the huge problem with automatic trading programs. Our financial system is becoming a joke that can easily be gamed. This type of thing will continue to happen!
- kasey_junk 14y agoThere are automatic trading strategies that trade based on news events. Opinions on them are pretty mixed as none of the published ones show consistent returns above luck levels. What is more likely is that human traders reacted to the tweet and caused microstructure changes that were amplified by algorithmic trading activity causing the rapid sell off. But then on the flip side those same algorithmic trades brought the price back to it's correct level just as quickly. This is essentially a no harm/no foul event where the only people impacted are the game players.
- seeingfurther 14y agoWe posted a chart of what the sentiment reaction and recovery looks like on our twitter feed. https://twitter.com/KredStreet/status/326758648737038338 https://twitter.com/KredStreet/status/326758648737038338
- freehunter 14y agoIs that really an infographic? Seems to me to just be a regular graph with callouts.
- seeingfurther 14y agoYes you are correct. Edited the text. Not sure where my brain is this morning. It's still pretty cool to see the data, no?
- lutusp 14y agoThis isn't just a hacker stunt, it's a great way to make money: 1. Acquire a large hedging position that cashes in if the market should fall. 2. Hack AP's Twitter account and post an alarming bogus news item. 3. Wait 15 minutes. 4. Sell your position. Now -- who can say this isn't the real reason behind the hack?
- RaSoJo 14y agoThe perpetrators would have had to have short the entire Dow to make a profit on this piece of news as it did not focus on any particular stock or sector. And they would have needed to exit really fast to make their bundle. It could have been an HF app designed to act purely on this kind of situation though
- derefr 14y agoInstead of shorting high, they could have just bought a bunch of index funds right in the trough. When "everything" goes down, "everything" is going to go back up. Conveniently, you wouldn't have to hold any positions in advance, so you'd appear to just be a player who figured out the non-veracity of the news quickly and took advantage of it to beat the market. You'd also not have to sell right away--you could hold onto the positions indefinitely, if you liked. The only problem is predicting the exact inflection point of the drop (i.e. the best time to place the buy order)--but I have a feeling people might be "predictably irrational" in this, and fake-news stories about easy-to-verify facts might have a regular/well-known half-life. This is classic "insider trading", just applied to a whole market instead of an individual stock. The only advantage of shorting in this case, I think, is if you didn't have the capital to actually make the money you wanted--you could do the shorts naked.
- danielweber 14y agoThat would only be a 1% gain, hardly worth jail time. You would need to be playing options to make a 1% swing worth it.
- lutusp 14y ago
- enjo 14y agoIf you're interested in how this works from a behavioral standpoint, this is a very interesting study: http://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc5130/m2/1/high_res_d/dissertation.pdf http://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc5130/m2/1/hi...
- vikram360 14y agoCould this be the effect of some kind of automated opinion/sentiment based trading?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gregPC 14y agoThe White House was attacked? I better sell my Apple stock forthwith!
- AznHisoka 14y agoHow is investing in stocks not a glorified form of gambling? When you buy a stock, and it goes down in price a few months later, the experts tell you to buy more of it as it goes down, because it'll probably go up in the future. When you gamble $5 on a blackjack hand, Martingale experts will tell you to gamble $10 on the next hand, and then $20 on the next hand again if you lose the $10 hand. Both are gambling.
- AnIrishDuck 14y agoNot sure if serious. Investing long in e.g. the DJIA isn't gambling by any stretch of the imagination. That's not to say there aren't plenty of other transactions that may blur the line a little more. Hell, entire options markets exist to make a commodity out of risk.