9 ms·
CipherCloud used DMCA Takedown on StackExchange discussion of their cryptography
- greenyoda 14y agoNote that the answer below the question contains this link to the Google cache of the original article that was taken down: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:FYBbAFUycYQJ:crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/3645/how-is-ciphercloud-doing-homomorphic-encryption+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:FYBbAFU... There doesn't seem to be anything in there that looks like an infringement of anyone's copyright.
- ghayes 14y agoAren't DMCA takedowns required, under penalty of perjury, to assert a non-frivolous copyright claim? Is there any recourse for what appears to be clear abuses of the DMCA?
- dangrossman 14y agoThere is recourse against truly false claims made in bad faith, but it's not the penalty of perjury part. All you swear under penalty of perjury is that you are authorized to act on behalf of the owner of some copyright allegedly infringed (i.e. you're not filing a claim about someone else's work). Here's the actual recourse created by the bill: > (f) MISREPRESENTATIONS- Any person who knowingly materially misrepresents under this section-- (1) that material or activity is infringing, or (2) that material or activity was removed or disabled by mistake or misidentification, shall be liable for any damages, including costs and attorneys' fees, incurred by the alleged infringer, by any copyright owner or copyright owner's authorized licensee, or by a service provider, who is injured by such misrepresentation, as the result of the service provider relying upon such misrepresentation in removing or disabling access to the material or activity claimed to be infringing, or in replacing the removed material or ceasing to disable access to it. http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c105:6:./temp/~c105aLNxl3:e57148 http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c105:6:./temp/~c105aLN...:
- comex 14y agoNote that the EFF is trying to prosecute a case over this clause [1]. IANAL, but it seems to be hard to hold someone responsible for a bad DMCA notice unless they specifically knew that it was bad (rather than merely being sloppy and sending notices without adequately considering fair use). Whether that is the case for this notice could theoretically be found out through discovery. [1] https://www.eff.org/cases/lenz-v-universal https://www.eff.org/cases/lenz-v-universal
- JohnTHaller 14y agoTheir likely justification is the use of those image snippets which appear to come from their manual. Realistically, those small captures represent fair use (though I am not a lawyer so can't speak legally).
- ghayes 14y agoI assume it would fall under commentary[1], esp. as it's one a single image and it has literally been written over to show the material that the comment is referencing. [1] http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_and_Fair_Use_Overview/chapter9/9-a.html http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_and_Fair_Use_Overview/...
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI don't think it's on copyright grounds, I think it's on circumvention grounds.
- dangrossman 14y agoThe DMCA notice/counternotice system is only about copyright infringement. They wouldn't get one for the circumvention prohibitions; or if they did, it would be an illegal use of those notices.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoGood point.
- withoutthis 14y agoHere is an archived version of the Google Cached version: http://archive.is/5WWjb http://archive.is/5WWjb and here is a screenshot of it: http://i.imgur.com/bn2152S.jpg http://i.imgur.com/bn2152S.jpg
- ck2 14y agoI think "used" needs be replaced with the word "abused". It's appropriate here. With no penalty for false DMCA claims, it's a "stop us if you can" mentality. The real reason may have been the conclusion that "Ciphercloud is NOT doing homomorphic encryption" ? (but google cache still works)
- dangrossman 14y agoThe penalty for materially misrepresenting a DMCA claim is actual damages plus costs and attorney fees. That's automatic, written into the bill, unlike many other torts/crimes where you need exceptional circumstances to get attorneys fees in addition to the damages.
- ck2 14y agoSo years later you can get content restored? Are there lawyers who will take on cases for consignment only? It's a calculation that little people will not be able to take on the big people. This is why corporations have zero fear of incorrectly killing individual content on youtube, little chance of penalty and they can smother any attempt to fight them.
- dangrossman 14y agoNot years. It's back up ~10 business days after you file a counternotice or the service provider loses their safe harbor. The DMCA is designed so that disputed content is not taken down permanently without an actual injunction signed by a judge. YouTube is not responding to DMCA notices, it's given media companies direct access to take down content through their own system, and it can do this because it has no obligation to host your material for free in the first place, infringing or not.
- troels 14y agoBut surely neither is Stackexchange obliged to host any discussions online. So this content may never reappear - counterfiling or not.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- goronbjorn 14y agoWhen a company does something like this, whether or not the claims/criticisms are actually true, their actions tacitly imply that they believe that the claims are true. In other words, terrible PR/technical brand management.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danbruc 14y agoNow let the Streisand effect do its work... (I made a snapshot of the page from Google's cache only to discover that at least two others used the very same service within the last hour to do exactly the same...and there are a few services to snapshot web pages.)
- rubbingalcohol 14y agoHere's one. DMCA claim is bullshit. This is fair use: http://static.rubbingalcoholic.com/images/temp/ciphercloud.png http://static.rubbingalcoholic.com/images/temp/ciphercloud.p...
- sergiotapia 14y agoGoogle cache of question in...question (lol): http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:FYBbAFUycYQJ:crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/3645/how-is-ciphercloud-doing-homomorphic-encryption+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:FYBbAFU...
- danbruc 14y agoThat looks really horrible and I am somewhat tempted to write and publish a GreaseMonkey script that does bad things to CipherCloud protected pages...
- sergiotapia 14y agoWhy would you (or anyone) deliberately try to hurt a company? Just because their tech is not 'on par'? Please think about how it would hurt that company and the employees (and their families!).
- danbruc 14y agoWhy would a company (deliberately) try to sell a false sense of security to anyone whose knowledge of cryptography is not 'on par'? Please think about how it might hurt these customers and their employees (and their families!).
- mappu 14y agoIt's not about deliberately hurting a company; if it's possible to make such a script, it will be made. Period. The question is: do you want the script publicly available, or in the hands of your adversaries without anyone knowing? There's a third alternative: fix the problem.
- puivert 14y agoExposing charlatans is commonly accepted. Elsewhere in the thread it was implied they hold peoples medical data (hipaa).
- qb45 14y ago
- pi18n 14y agoWe should start a collection of these kinds of stories as case studies in why laws allowing any entity to legally compel removal of content are ripe for abuse. DMCA as a law isn't even that ridiculous or reprehensible; it mostly offers protection for websites that have user-submitted content. And yet here we are. The damages clause needs to be strengthened if we wish to continue having free speech on the internet.
- CodesInChaos 14y agoEFF has a collection of DMCA abuses: https://www.eff.org/takedowns https://www.eff.org/takedowns
- tzs 14y agoMore comments are on the duplicate (now dead) submission [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5579615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5579615
- plumeria 14y agoJust have someone put it on wikileaks?
- plumeria 14y agoOr snapshots in a torrent file...
- smartwater 14y agoBefore takedown: http://imgur.com/8r9cDxS http://imgur.com/8r9cDxS
- patrickyeon 14y agoIn a situation like this, who files the counter-claim(s) to get the content restored? I would SE as an organization cannot, as they are the safe harbor in this case, but it sounds like the takedown notice wasn't specific enough for the relevant users to know what they can leave up. Does each user involved need to counter-claim so that SE can put the question and answers back up? Can one user claim that nothing on the site was infringing and have that be enough to protect SE?
- moxie 14y agoWhat's interesting is that there is a whole ecosystem of companies like CipherCloud that do the minimum required to provide solutions for those interested in "compliance," not "security." My sense has been that their customers are predominately those bound by things like HIPPA or PCI, who want to use cloud services, but can't do it with a straight face unless they can say they're "encrypting" their data. What their customers want isn't security; it's the minimum required that will allow them to use salesforce.com. Incriminating details on StackExchange aren't a problem because their customers don't already know CipherCloud is insecure, they're a problem because it would make it harder for customers to say they're in compliance with a straight face.
- DanBC 14y agoIs it really that simple? Or is it that crypto is difficult and buyers have no knowledge and thus are wide open for people selling snake-oil?
- pyre 14y agoIt can be both. There are going to be companies that are serious about actually protecting their customers (but don't have the technical know-how to be an informed customer), and there are companies that see these laws/rules (PCI, HIPPA) as hindrances to cast aside with the least possible effort.
- moxie 14y agoOn some level, the fact that compliance regulations exist is an indication that security is not a priority for many of the entities that it applies to. Certainly snake-oil is a problem, but I think this particular area is one where buyers are most concerned about being able to effectively claim that they made what seemed like reasonable efforts.
- iuguy 14y agoI've mirrored Emil Vokstrom's mirror[1] here[2] and I encourage HNers outside of the US to do the same and post here. [1] - http://lajm.eu/emil/dump/ciphercloud-security.html http://lajm.eu/emil/dump/ciphercloud-security.html [2] - http://securitybookreviews.eu/ciphercloud/ http://securitybookreviews.eu/ciphercloud/
- anoopelias 14y agoJust listen to Cryptography I in coursera. Never ever, use your own algorithm for encryption. Always use tried, tested and known algos. And don't even change it one bit (literally!). Only the key remains secret.
- PeterisP 14y agoIf something can be destroyed by the truth, then it should be. If a crypto company abuses DMCA to fight this, then they deserve the Streisand effect. You should send the materials to someone in a free country where DMCA doesn't apply and speech is still free, and they can host the documents and discussion.
- DanBC 14y agoI haven't seen the DMCA notice. I think the screenshots are the things being DMCAd. If so, they clearly fall under fair use. Someone should issue a counter notice. And get them put back up. What's interesting to me is what happens if StackExchange put these back up, and then the cryptocompany sends a DMCA to SE's hosts.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoIsn't it the same thing then? Just send a counter-notice to SE's hosts? Of course, that doesn't stop all of Stack Exchage from being down for "10 business days" in the meantime. Should be interesting to see the public response to that if it actually happens.
- rubbingalcohol 14y agoSituations like this really highlight how out of step the DMCA is with peoples' right to free speech and fair use. DMCA takedowns put too much compliance burden on individuals who are unaware of or intimidated by the counter-notice process. At the very least, there should be more stringent requirements for legitimate takedown claims and stricter penalties for abusing the process.
- jimktrains2 14y agohttp://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/3645/how-is-ciphercloud-doing-homomorphic-encryption http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:crypto.... Has a version from Apr 12, 2013 15:33:47 GMT.
- acd 14y agoFreedom of speech must include that random company x cannot take down your internet discussion using some strange acronym as an excuse. Encryption and security does usually not get any better by pretending its secure and not letting anyone dig around the solution.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- npsimons 14y agoEncryption and security does usually not get any better by pretending its secure and not letting anyone dig around the solution. Indeed. Schneier has some excellent discussion on this topic, singling out closed source encryption as always eventually being cracked, and the security world's consideration of open source as a pre-requisite for security: http://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram-9909.html http://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram-9909.html I've never understood how anyone with at least an ounce of intelligence can claim that something is more secure just because it's closed source.
- mleach 14y agoPutting the merits of their technology aside, I've had numerous unpleasant experiences working with the CipherCloud Founders as both a Salesforce Partner and Customer. They use fear tactics to scare prospects into believing a) their data is unsafe in the cloud and b) their competition uses inferior encryption algorithms. This DMCA takedown is unfortunately just another of their "just try and stop us" tactics.
- volokoumphetico 14y agolong story short, stackexchange didn't want to lose a potential ad sale. It's not good for their business to have users question products advertised on stackexchange network.
- CodesInChaos 14y agoNow stackexchange forwarded the DMCA notice to the involved users. http://meta.crypto.stackexchange.com/q/250/180 http://meta.crypto.stackexchange.com/q/250/180 CipherCloud claim copyright infringement on the three images used to evidence the posts. They also claim that certain statements in the posts are false, misleading defaming. While some statements look indeed wrong, others (in particular the determinism claim) are clearly evidenced in screenshots. They hint that their actual product might use different encryption from the demo video.
- DanBC 14y agoDid CipherCloud get Google's permission to use the GMail logo on their website? Or Microsoft's permission to use the MS Office 365 logo?
- jared314 14y agoI wonder if doing something similar to Ciphercloud, using a homomorphic encryption library like libScarab[0], would actually make it secure. I guess I still don't understand what Ciphercloud does. [0] https://hcrypt.com/scarab-library/ https://hcrypt.com/scarab-library/
- betterunix 14y agoFHE is far too slow for any practical use. In a few more years, things might be different, but for now anyone marketing a practical FHE solution is probably lying.
- jared314 14y agoI'm still trying to find performance numbers that prove it impractical. Otherwise, it just sounds like a problem that could be mitigated by clustering.
- betterunix 14y agoHere are some results from a research team that has been on the forefront of FHE implementations; note that this has been improved on significantly since last August, but you are still looking at minutes of computation for relatively small functions: http://www.iacr.org/cryptodb/archive/2012/CRYPTO/presentation/17-1-Smart.pdf http://www.iacr.org/cryptodb/archive/2012/CRYPTO/presentatio... Also, throwing "clustering" at every problem is misguided. Not all problems are easily parallelized: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-complete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-complete
- jared314 14y agoDon't forget Amdahl's law and Gustafson's law on the limits of parallelizing when the problem isn't P-complete. Either way, I disagree with your conclusion that it is misguided.
- caf 14y agoThe original question and answers has been put back up, without the CipherCloud screenshots. http://crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/3645/how-is-ciphercloud-doing-homomorphic-encryption http://crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/3645/how-is-cipher...
- a3n 14y agoSo wrong answers (assuming they're wrong) and speculation are now speech that can legally be suppressed? You can't say anything that's wrong or a guess?
- CodesInChaos 14y agoDMCA'd CipherCloud discussion on stackexchange online again (minus images). The Copyright part of the notice only covered the images and stackexchange apparently didn't consider the text part of the posts a ToS violation. I expanded my analysis, but you'll need to check the original material for evidence since the embedded images were subject to the notice. http://crypto.stackexchange.com/q/3645/180 http://crypto.stackexchange.com/q/3645/180