6 ms·
It occurs to me this incident is going to get drones in use at public events asap. Because if you had several drones circling for 24 hours before the event wit
by ck2 14y ago
It occurs to me this incident is going to get drones in use at public events asap.
Because if you had several drones circling for 24 hours before the event with high resolution and night-vision cameras, you could trace every single person on each of their timelines before the event.
Awesome tool for when crime happens but what do we do when it's guaranteed to be abused?
- intended 14y agoWell CCTVs, or even older technology like finger prints, could be used to reduce crime, while also resulting in abuse or a reduction in privacy and freedoms. Its always been the job of society to be rational about this and look at the cost of further infringement upon your liberties vs the marginal utility offered by a tool which enhances crime fighting ability.
- ck2 14y agoCCTV isn't going to trace you coming from your home, where you stopped along the way, how fast you went to each point and where you got out. Drones can circle a city for days and with high resolution sensors can not miss a thing. This isn't just a more advanced CCTV, it's a near-infallible machine.
- baddox 14y ago> CCTV isn't going to trace you coming from your home, where you stopped along the way, how fast you went to each point and where you got out. Why not?
- beedogs 14y agoDo you really want a non-sarcastic answer to that? Use some common sense: CCTV cameras aren't ubiquitous. There are gaps in coverage all over the place.
- zepolud 14y agoYou've obviously never visited London.
- zimpenfish 14y agoNah, I reckon there's at least 150yds between my flat and a commute into the centre of London (~8mi) where there's no camera coverage. Possibly even 200yds!
- vidarh 14y agoAnd yet if the police wanted to trace you, they'd face utter hell of figuring out who operates what camera (mostly private businesses monitoring their own premises or immediate surroundings; sometimes local councils or agencies such as TfL; very occasionally a police force), get them to agree to hand over tapes (or get a court order), assuming the tapes have not already been deleted, and that the camera worked at the time. Repeat for pretty much every camera, and fan out every time they can't see you... While we're on camera most of the time in London, we can be pretty confident that the sheer hassle of obtaining footage and cost in processing them keeps the police from abusing it all that much...
- abstrakraft 14y agoUse some common sense: There are gaps in drone coverage all over the place.
- kaolinite 14y agoDrone coverage can adapt and follow specific targets, that's the difference.
- FooBarWidget 14y agoHow do you follow a specific target, if you don't know who the target is until after you've analyzed the recordings?
- anigbrowl 14y agoCCTV isn't going to trace you coming from your home, where you stopped along the way, how fast you went to each point and where you got out. Yes it is, that's quite common in Britain, or at least London, because CCTV coverage is so dense there. To turn your argument inside out, drone deployment is temporary whereas CCTV deployment tends to be permanent.
- vidarh 14y agoCCTV coverage in Britain is dense, yes, but it's exaggerated greatly. The vast majority of them are low quality privately operated cameras that are not networked in any way, and with varying degrees of retention - all the way down to no retention at all. It is incredibly hard for the police to trace someone based on CCTV even after the fact - even after the 7/7 bombings it took an immense amount of manpower to stitch together the movements of the bombers. So while in theory, yes, you could be traced that way, in reality police often don't even bother gathering CCTV tapes from the cameras they know cover a relevant area unless it's for particularly serious crimes and they lack other evidence because of the cost involved. In the central core of London, it's a little bit different in that there are sections that are well covered by police operated CCTV, but even then "well covered" usually means that operators decide what to focus on and zoom in on, so ongoing coverage of a specific location might be spotty.
- regularfry 14y agoAbout 8 years ago I had a chat over drinks with a guy responsible for a large part of Westminster Council's CCTV deployments. His take then was that the only limiting factor preventing total surveillance (which, as I recall, he viewed as a good thing) was bandwidth. Next up was storage. Next was the software to integrate the feeds and make them human-comprehensible. None of these problems will last very much longer, in the grand scheme of things.
- vidarh 14y agoWestminster is "special" in that it is very dense, has a lot of violence compared to its affluence (due to the amount of nightclubs and bars etc) coupled with a massive amount of high priority buildings, and the combination of that means that it has far more government controlled CCTV than pretty much anywhere in Britain outside of City. Westminster and City are probably the two small parts of London where there'd be a reasonable chance of "total surveillance". But even Westminster is also chock full of CCTV dead zones due to the narrow streets and complicated building facades with lots of nooks and crannies - it might be "easy" to get coverage of people moving along the streets in Westminster, but incredibly hard to eliminate opportunities for people to hide away.
- r0s 14y ago> near-infallible machine. Here is where the discussion jumps the shark.
- intended 14y agoThis isn't about CCTV vs Drones. This is about forensic and surveillance technology advancement vs civil liberties, the expectation and right to privacy, and the abuse of new powers. > ..tool for when crime happens but what do we do when it's guaranteed to be abused? Law enforcement would love to be able to record all phone calls and keep comprehensive videos of every event. Going backwards, people have argued for having people fingerprinted by default vs only when being processed during a criminal investigation. In each case, it is the acceptance that while the tools are valuable, we draw the line saying that : "Yes, the marginal utility of having 1 drone flying or 1 or a 100, vs their impact and chance for abuse is something we are uncomfortable with." The question I suspect that is worth looking at, which I don't have data for, is the value of increased CCTV/Monitoring technology in solving crimes. I'd rather offer a Stradivarius to someone who can get the most out of it, vs someone who can occasional hit the right notes from it.
- Kequc 14y agoThis is the part I don't understand is that in almost any way you look at it CCTV are a benefit to the masses. An example of one benefit to having CCTV spread out over downtown is that you can relieve some police presence and spread them out to places that aren't. Another benefit would be that crimes committed in downtown would be recorded forcing criminals to wear masks rather than relying on the shock of the incident to make the victim forget details about the perpetrators features. If you have criminals walking around wearing masks then they can be quite easy to spot. Another benefit would be in the case of this bombing. When I first heard of the bombing I was pretty interested, I wanted to know who put the bombs there, when and then who they were and what their problem was. I figured well they'll pull up CCTV and we'll all know what happened. Instead police are being relied on to manage all of it in the moment. It isn't a violation of freedom to be filmed in public, that's completely legal. People just start getting up in arms about it when it's a service offered by the american government for some reason. Any private individual is allowed to film for who knows what reason.
- deepvibrations 14y agoSo the world you want to live in is covered in CCTV and people being monitored everywhere? Sounds like a 'trust nobody' world, 1984 style... Don't you think it's about time we set about looking at why people commit these crimes and tackling these problems at the roots? Why not try and PREVENT these things from happening rather than acting after people have committed crimes by locking them up, which often only serves to create a life-long criminal rather than helping in any way.
- bcoates 14y agoThe number of drones you'd need to do that for even one localized event would be huge, and hugely expensive. London's much denser and more economical CCTV network has been a giant boondoggle by everyone whose job doesn't depend on declaring it a success.
- ck2 14y agoMilitary has multi-GIGApixel sensors on drones. They can watch huge portions of a city at one. It would only take several drones to watch the entire city from altitude. https://www.google.com/search?q=argus-is https://www.google.com/search?q=argus-is The ARGUS-IS can stream up to a million terabytes of data and record 5,000 hours of HD footage per day. It can do this by the 1.8 gigapixel camera and 368 different sensors all housed in the ARGUS-IS.
- bcoates 14y agoIf I'm going to be living in this surveillance society future, do I at least get an app that navigates me to the nearest open parking space?
- ChrisNorstrom 14y agoI'm sure the government will allow consumer applications like self-driving cars to be rerouted around traffic jams, nearest parking spots. The same thing has already happened with GPS.
- davman 14y agoI really wanted to build this... a small fleet of drones that would find the nearest parking space to my house when I leave work in case there is a football match on and my street is blocked. Unfortunately I imagine it's illegal to fly drones with cameras above city streets. :(
- brokenparser 14y agoYour imagination has it wrong.
- slg 14y agoPlaying devil's advocate, what are the guaranteed abuses if drones are used in this context? You could certainly make a slippery slope argument, but at a huge event that is taking place in public there can be no assumption of privacy. Is a drone any different in this context than any other type of camera?
- cb18 14y agoIs a drone any different in this context than any other type of camera? uh yeah... Cameras have a focal point, a drone creates a kind of panopticon.
- slg 14y agoI am not sure I follow you on this one. It isn't like the type of technology used in drones can't be used in stationary cameras. A drone is simply a flying version making it ideal for short term deployments like surveillance on an annual sporting even like the Boston Marathon.
- foobarqux 14y agoDrones are now being designed for long term and essentially permanent deployment.
- davidw 14y agoDavid Brin's "The Transparent Society" talks about this. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004P5O37W/?tag=dedasys-20 http://www.amazon.com/dp/B004P5O37W/?tag=dedasys-20 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Transparent_Society In short, the idea is to allow lots of watching, because it'll help reduce and solve crime, but also radically increase the watching of the watchers.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kokey 14y agoI believe an arms race between authorities and citizens when it comes to surveillance will also be a good thing. The thing we need to protect against is if governments make this kind of competition illegal, e.g. they can have CCTV cameras monitoring the front of your house, but you're not allowed to.
- r00fus 14y agoThe watchers will not be watched. They've read Brin and Orwell, and have learned. They pass legislation, or ignore existing laws when it's one of them that's threatened. Examples abound. Corruption is rife.
- cb18 14y agoAwesome tool for when crime happens False Premise -- Crime doesn't happen on a set timetable. So how do you determine when it should or shouldn't be in use? For something like this, and most crimes(if not all) I don't see how a drone really helps all that much anyway. The standard procedures work well enough. Crimes like this are generally "solved." The goal, however, should be to prevent them. When something like this does slip through the cracks though, it's important to "Keep Calm and Carry On," not get all bent out of shape and fuck up your society.
- Havoc 14y agoDo you think drones would have changed the outcome?