6 ms·
"The alternative - that we're the first civilisation, in the first universe - is virtually (no pun intended) absurd." As opposed to us simply being some other
by kstenerud 14y ago
"The alternative - that we're the first civilisation, in the first universe - is virtually (no pun intended) absurd."
As opposed to us simply being some other civilization on one of the other billions of habitable planets in that same "first" universe?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pdog 14y agoThen where are they?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- omegaham 14y agoIn a galaxy far, far away. My guess is that there are other civilizations out there, but they're suffering from the exact same problems as us - long distances, huge energy requirements, lots of time. If we can't get out to the stars, I can see why plenty of civilizations would be having trouble.
- CoffeeDregs 14y agoFirst off: why would you assume that we could interact with them? It appears to be phenomenally difficult to get from point to point in the galaxy/universe (see the recent trend in science-fiction to stick to a speed of light limited universe). If we come up with some fantastic energy source (see: ZPE), then I'll say that it's phenomenally slow so that no civilization would invest in doing it. If we come up with some civilization that would do so, I'd point out that it's phenomenally slow/difficult to send signals across universal distances. Rational folks think that non-solar-local interactions are probably not possible... Large brained rational folks think to look for solar-local artifacts of Kardashev-scale>1 civilizations (see: http://www.personal.psu.edu/jtw13/blogs/astrowright/2013/03/artifact-seti.html http://www.personal.psu.edu/jtw13/blogs/astrowright/2013/03/...). Recall that early explorers met Native Americans and called them Indians because they had misinterpreted distances, didn't know all of the continents, etc. We have a history of overcoming increasingly large distances with improved transport. This does not mean that we shall always do so. It may be depressing, but it may be the case that exponential curves in natural do not exist. We may live in a time where we understand that sigmoids rule the evolution of our world/civilizations... (And no the plural of Malthus is not proof of an exponential curves in nature...)
- adventured 14y agoWhere are they? They aren't 'there.' The obvious point is, we may very well be the first, or 10th. And that's precisely why 'they' aren't anywhere. And it's plausible that we're vastly underestimating how difficult it actually is to spread machines throughout the galaxy. I don't happen to agree with the notion that we'd have to see evidence by now if there has been other life. It's entirely plausible that a hundred other unique humanoids have existed on this planet, a billion or two years before we did, and that they all failed with minimum trace. We know for a fact that several variations have failed, so why not another 100? And if it's so difficult, then why not apply those odds to other planets? In five billion years our planet, which is very hospitable to life, has managed to produce one currently existing 'intelligent' life form (that can barely fly to the moon). That means it's extraordinarily rare even on our planet. By most measures, humans barely managed to survive, and we got lucky to so far avoid a wipeout event. The odds of life being generated in any given billion year time frame, on a planet that can possibly support it, and assuming the right conditions for intelligent life (eg that the planet doesn't get destroyed or altered by an asteroid etc), and on the reduction goes. I think spacefaring life is exceptionally rare, and it only gets X amount of time to potentially exist before the solar system or galaxy or universe crushes it. In short, I don't think there's enough time for intelligent life to span even a galaxy before being wiped out by nature. And why don't we see probes floating around? For the same reason Voyager will eventually be obliterated by rocks in space or gravity (and in the time scale of the milky way, it won't be a very long before that happens).
- adventured 14y agoThe odds are statistically equal that we're the first civilization and that we're the 5 millionth (in this iteration of the universe).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- paulhodge 14y agoI don't think this is true. Are we assuming that every universe has an infinite number of civilizations? It's impossible to have uniform probability across an infinite set of discrete probabilities, because every outcome would have a probability of 0. So with no other knowledge, it's slightly more likely that we are the first civilization than the 5 millionth. Of course it's tricky to talk about the "first" civilization in the face of relativistic time, but I'm assuming that there is some way to have an ordering of all civilizations.
- paulhodge 14y agoOops, should say "infinite set of discrete possibilities"
- namuol 14y agoAssuming there are very many civilizations in our universe, the odds that we're the first are tremendously lower than the odds that we're not. I think that's the point.
- visarga 14y ago> As opposed to us simply being some other civilization on one of the other billions of habitable planets in that same "first" universe? Yes, but if we are in a simulation we can almost answer the Fine-tuned Universe Paradox too, two birds with one stone. That is nice for Occam's rasor reasons.
- crusso 14y agoWe know absolutely nothing beyond this universe. We barely even know much about this universe. You can't meaningfully speculate about the nature of what (if anything) is dimensionally/physically/extra-universally "outside" of our universe. We don't even know what that means, much less if it exists or what the number/nature of it would be. Our universe may be a piece of candy floating on a chocolate river in another universe that flows eternally. It's all just make believe. Make believe can be fun, but let's not pretend that we're doing anything more substantial than what three year olds do when talking about space robots.