12 ms·
What is the rule for adjective order?
- ColinWright 14y agoTo add to this, a quick search produces many pages that are saying more-or-less the same thing in more-or-less the same way. They differ a little in detail, and a lot in presentation. Here are some: * http://www.ucl.ac.uk/internet-grammar/adjectiv/ordering.htm http://www.ucl.ac.uk/internet-grammar/adjectiv/ordering.htm * http://www.learnenglish.de/grammar/adjectiveorder.htm http://www.learnenglish.de/grammar/adjectiveorder.htm * http://www.gingersoftware.com/grammarbook/adjectives/order-of-adjectives/ http://www.gingersoftware.com/grammarbook/adjectives/order-o... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adjective#Adjective_order https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adjective#Adjective_order * http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/1155/what-is-the-rule-for-adjective-order http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/1155/what-is-the-... * http://web2.uvcs.uvic.ca/elc/studyzone/410/grammar/adjord.htm http://web2.uvcs.uvic.ca/elc/studyzone/410/grammar/adjord.ht... * http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/susan/cyc/a/adj.htm http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/susan/cyc/a/adj.htm * http://www.myenglishteacher.net/adjectivesorder.html http://www.myenglishteacher.net/adjectivesorder.html * http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/english-grammar/adjectives/order-adjectives http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/english-grammar/ad...
- Evbn 14y ago"More-or-less", or "less-or-more"?
- twoodfin 14y agoFascinating. As a native English speaker, I was never taught this ordering, but swapping around the examples a bit emphasizes how "unnatural" any other ordering sounds. This paper linked in the comments is intriguing: http://www.lingref.com/cpp/wccfl/25/paper1473.pdf http://www.lingref.com/cpp/wccfl/25/paper1473.pdf
- Evbn 14y agoFolks keep saying a certain phrasing is "natural", but that is a funny word. It isn't innate/instinctive. Grammar comes from years of exposure to other speakers of language.
- twoodfin 14y agoThat's what the scare quotes around "unnatural" are for. But it's hotly debated whether grammar does indeed originate in "years of exposure to other speakers of language". Certainly some aspects of grammar are language-specific, but many appear to be universal, or close to it. From the paper I linked above: For example, adjectives that denote quality have been argued to precede adjectives conveying size, which in turn precede adjectives conveying shape, and so on, in all languages (5). Similar claims have been made for other adjective types, and the respective ordering restrictions are given in (6). This is one of the founding principles of today's dominant Chomskyan linguistics, perhaps best argued popularly in Stephen Pinker's The Language Instinct.
- Evbn 14y agoNot sure Chomskyan is dominant, but anyway, yes, an ability to be grammatical, is widely regarded as innate. Sort of like how every computer can compute the results of a Turing machine, regardless of the actual machine language or high level programming language glommed on top. Or perhaps to say that humans parse a sentence like a concatenative/stack language, but not an algol/C-like language. (Not saying exactly that, but saying that's the sort of statement that could get to the heart of it). Whereas "C vs Java" varies across cultures". That is, the low level hardware memory model is universal, but the shape of the structures on top are diverse. I would also highlight a distinction between universal grammatical rules that are key to "making any sort of sense at all" vs customizable rules that "disambiguate among multiple possible interpretations". That was put poorly, but bear with me. That is, SVO vs OVS is arbitrary, and could go either way, but members of each community need to agree. But number-color-object is nearly universal because color-number-object is uninterpretable as a concatenation of color with number object, unless a language specifically develops a concept of a color applying to more than one non-group entity. And here I speculate, but I can easily imagine a human language where an adjective before a number is understood to emphasize that all items are exactly the same color, or that the items are all connected with no other-color between them, like a "red 3 plates" understood to mean the plates are in a stack. Heck, I bet that if I were really good looking or famous and started using that pattern, it would spread
- corysama 14y agoWhen coding, I frequently find myself wishing that English used noun-adjective-adjective ordering. It works so much better for organizing sub-categories into nice, sortable, searchable trees. I sometimes try to use naa naming in my code, but it's a constant struggle to not accidentally fall back to aan out of life-long habit.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoFrench mostly does this, though there are a defined set of exceptions, i.e. adjectives for beauty, age, good/bad and size go before the noun. Of course, the exceptions also have exceptions: the placement of some adjectives that normally go before the noun depends on whether the meaning is literal or figurative.
- michaelochurch 14y agoWhat's even weirder is that some words have different meanings as pre-adjectives than post-adjectives. For example, I believe ancien means "former" in prefix position but "ancient" in postfix.
- Gmo 14y agoYes, a good example is with "grand": * un grand homme = a great man * un homme grand = a tall man Something which can be funny is when you want to talk about a great man who is tall (e.g. Charles De Gaulle)
- B-Con 14y agoYes! I actually think this way (not verbally, my thoughts have only a loose verbal connection). NAA makes so much more sense because you can continuously update your mental picture, rather than waiting for the end and then backing up to incorporate the previously parsed adjectives.
- acheron 14y agoThere's a song (I think the band is Mumford and Sons?) called "White Blank Page", which always reminded me of Tolkien's "green great dragon", mentioned in the second answer there.
- stevenbedrick 14y agoIn case anybody's interested, one of our (former) graduate students has done some really fascinating work on computational analysis of prenominal modifiers (adjectives, etc.). For example, her ACL paper from 2011: Mitchell, M., Dunlop, A., and Roark, B. (2011). Semi-Supervised Modeling for Prenominal Modifier Ordering. Proceedings of ACL 2011. http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/P/P11/P11-2041.pdf http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/P/P11/P11-2041.pdf
- xfs 14y agoInteresting conclusion from the paper: [...] for ordering prenominal modifiers, [...] a simple n-gram model outperforms position-specific models This seems to imply that adjective order can be better described with common phrases rather than a set of definite grammar rules.
- XaspR8d 14y agoThus the challenge of modern syntactic theory - to most it is clear there is some structure occurring, but attempts to quantify it are still beaten by rather naive statistical approaches.
- RyanMcGreal 14y ago> A big, modern brick house (NOT a modern, big brick house) Not unless it's a modern house with big bricks, anyway.
- michaelt 14y agoAnd "a modern, brick big house" is slang for prison.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI think you would hyphenate big-brick in that case, as, taken together, they are a single adjective of house.
- netcan 14y agoWow! My premature reaction was "Nonsense. You can't just make up rules no one knows and call them grammar" but then I noticed how unnatural changing the order feels. Amazing how we have these grammar rules in our head without knowing they exist.
- Evbn 14y agoThat's what linguistics is. Grammar is as natural as walking. Almost everyone does it, and no conscious understanding of the rules is required.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pekk 14y agoLinguistics is a lot more than just syntax.
- jonnathanson 14y ago"no conscious understanding of the rules is required" I hate to nitpick, but this is not entirely true. First, there is no innate, specific grammar or syntax in the human brain. Any given language -- even one's first language -- is learned. It's learned in stages, and true, one tends to pick up the rules by immersion before studying them consciously. But conscious study of the rules is extremely beneficial to improving one's understanding of, and facility with, a given language. To say that "no conscious understanding of the rules is required" is a little like saying "Kobe Bryant is a naturally born basketball genius." True, Kobe Bryant may have certain athletic gifts and mental wiring that enable him to exceed 99.999999% of the world at basketball skill. But he learned the rules of the game, just like everyone else. And he practices daily. In fact, he probably practices harder than many of his less talented peers. Even someone of his natural endowments couldn't have risen to his level without conscious and repeated effort. It's true that grammar and syntax start to seem natural and subconscious over time, especially as one improves in linguistic fluency. That's a good sign, in fact. But I've never met a writer who couldn't benefit from conscious study of the rules and fundamentals, even if only occasionally.
- dhimes 14y agoMy view: The more "important" the adjective is to the description, the nearer the noun it goes. I'm not sure where I learned this, but if, for instance, I'm trying to describe a building to somebody, and in my opinion the thing that will help him distinguish it is it's size, but it also happens to be red, I would say "the red big building." On the other hand, if the most important distinction is its color, I would say "the big red building."
- ColinWright 14y agoJust as a data point, to me, it doesn't matter which of those adjectives you think is more important, I think "the big red building" sounds much more natural than "the red big building." The latter sounds flat-out wrong to me.
- strictfp 14y agoEven if you stress 'big'?
- itsybitsycoder 14y agoWhat about: A: What building do I need to go to? B: The big one. A: Which big one? I see a red one and a green one. B: The red big building.
- ColinWright 14y agoI wouldn't say that. I've just tried saying out loud to a friend, and they also said it was weird. I would definitely say "The big red building," or even leave out "big" entirely - it's already been specified. It's worth knowing that I'm a pure mathematician, and I frequently come out with utterances that others find odd, purely on logical grounds. It's plausible that there are circumstances in which I would violate these rules/guidelines/suggestions/baseless musings/whatever. That's not one of them.
- pekk 14y agoWhy do we privilege individual judgements that something seems "weird," particularly when it would be perfectly understood? It's as if linguistics is often modeling syntactic rules which reflect something other than natural communication as it actually occurs.
- michaelochurch 14y agoThis is more opinion than fact, as someone who's written professionally but doesn't understand the grammar of his natural language at any deep level: I don't think there are rules, only guidelines, just as there are no firm rules on when to split an infinitive or end with a preposition (those are usually bad style, but there's nothing grammatically wrong with them, and sometimes they're right thing to do.) In fact, often there are semantic distinctions that ordering betrays, which obviates hard-and-fast rules: * "A vegetarian Russian lawyer", to me, suggests an attorney of Russian law who is also a vegetarian. * "A Russian, vegetarian lawyer" suggests a vegetarian lawyer of Russian descent. Ethnicity isn't as important as what kind of law is being practiced, so in this case it's looser-binding and farther from the noun. I tend to put appearance-related (especially size) adjectives earlier, because it replicates an order of perception. "Big red coat." First, you see something (~5 ms) large (a blob, until it's processed) and then color (~10 ms) comes in, and finally (~50 ms) you focus on its purpose-- it's a coat. Numbers always come first, for the same reason, even though the way we process small numbers (discrete, under 7) is different from the way we process large ones (continuous, 25+). Size usually comes second. However, there's an art to it, because presentation order also betrays order of impression. "Fat kids, of whom there were nine." You're focusing on them being fat, not how many there are. (You wouldn't say "fat nine kids" because that might suggest an age of 9.) It seems, to me, like the pattern for appearance-related, concrete adjectives is to go first-to-last by perceptual ordering ("big red bike") but to go least-to-most by importance ordering for abstract concepts ("the new great thing").
- ColinWright 14y ago> This is more opinion than fact ... Can you provide evidence of this? Given the number of places I've found pretty much exactly the same thing being stated, I'd love to see evidence to the contrary. Thanks.
- bane 14y agoAny study of Linguistics will tell you that any known and repeated structure in a language is the observation of custom not of rules. There is no Congress of Languages that passes a Law of Tongues, no first principle of language that requires things to be conjugated this way or ordered in this way. Language is a temporary contract between the speaker and the listener. A protocol that if I use these sounds in this way, I have a pretty good notion that information will be transferred to the listener. Over time, as needs change, the contract changes and what I need to say to transfer information changes. More importantly, I have to keep track of several contracts because not all listeners have signed the same one! This is called code-switching, and it's why I talk to my boss differently than to my much younger niece than to my mechanic. Language prescriptivists don't seem to understand that and will refer to their favorite dictionary and grammar guide (usually published sometime between the 18th and 19th centuries and written by people of the same ilk trying desperately to coax order from chaos) as if they contained the great laws handed down from the God of Languages and will try and convert the World by force to sign the contract that they think all the world should be on. There are no rules in language, only guidelines.
- kelvin0 14y agoMost irrelevant HN post ever? Please stop wasting everyone's time.
- tmoertel 14y agoHow about this rule? Order the modifiers to maximize the product of their successive restrictive effects. For example, we would prefer "great green dragon" to "green great dragon" because ([_] - [great _]) * ([great _] - [great green _]) is greater than ([_] - [green _]) * ([green _] - [green great _]), where the notation [x _] denotes the expected number of substitutions admitted by the hole (_) in the context x. Note that this ordering rule seems to do the right thing for the obvious corner cases. For example, we would prefer "modern brick house" to "brick modern house" because, in the second ordering, [brick modern _] is about the same as [brick _], making the second term in ([_] - [brick _]) * ([brick _] - [brick modern _]) tend toward zero, making the preference score for "brick modern house" also tend toward zero. EDITED TO ADD: Just to be clear, I'm not claiming that this is the rule we actually use when we're putting words together. I'm claiming that this is the "true" rule, to the extent that anything can be said to be true in human communications. What we do in our heads works out to be an approximation: We (1) choose the modifiers that we think we need and (2) order them so that none seems wasted. For example, when describing a modern brick house, we know that "modern" and "brick" have to go somewhere, but putting "modern" after "brick" makes it impotent, so we put it before. By avoiding these "zeroes," which ring hollow to our inner ear, we make every word earn its place and indirectly seek the product-maximizing ordering.
- smackfu 14y agoWouldn't that imply that substituting in a different adjective of the same type (color / size) could change the order? But in practice, that doesn't seem to be the case.
- B-Con 14y agoPersonally, I've always mentally preferred an ordering with the noun first followed by increasing levels of restrictiveness. In my head, that's how I think. I then have to translate that into proper English grammar. It makes sense to me because I'm providing as much detail as necessary, but giving as much detail up front as possible. For example, when saying "the [adjective_detailed], [adjective_general] [noun]", what if the last word were lost? Then you'd have no idea what the phrase was about. And for the listener, you start with the most useless of detail and have to remember it, applying it to more useful of information as it comes in, and you have no idea what's being spoken about until you've heard the end. So then you have to backup and apply the adjectives once you've actually heard the noun. It makes (IMO) bad structure for parsing. Conversely, with the most general detail first, you drill down to the necessary level of detail as you speak, and continuously describe something the listener already heard.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jpwagner 14y agoa similarly fascinating topic: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expletive_infixation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expletive_infixation
- contingencies 14y ago[ok, so not strictly on adjective order, but i felt like sharing] HOMAGE TO THE SYNONYM (On reading of Dhana~njaya's Namamala in K.A. Nilakanta Sastri's A History of South India) Kovalam Beach, Kerala 12th June 2011 I felt it strange to read today some news of writers past, Their time was one of heterogeneity; sectarian views surpassed. [Though sectarianism has now taken hold; and offered much up to Shiva. Jains, Buddhists and Ajivikas: all gone, save bits in literature.] The passage that stirred interest, perhaps it's not of note, But an ancient `lexicon of synonyms' - what type of person wrote? Well in those times of philosophy, many literate were courtiers Those commissioned men could run amok; quite different to what's taught here! [Though of freedoms known back in the past, we've not yet lost a single; For words remain like cocktails; a great joy to mix and mingle.] To reflection's fruit: the synonym, it's sacred to the core, Turning misconceptions of inequitability, it's something of a door. It has been said, with few against, that language has a mid: "The verb to be" (or is/was/will be, in our poor contorted chit). Yet my subject's not, as etymology'd posit, mere beast of straight assignment, But another way to subtlety, word choice and thought alignment. Its operands, once affixed, are viewed in context and kind, Just as yoga might work limbs and flesh: en-route to still the mind. Younger, I gave a speech on her: those notions of 'to be', Through an ancient Chinese philosophical school - Logicians, mon cheri! Their language one of ambiguity and subtleties aplenty, Compare our Indo-Aryan pauper writ, with so few words for "empty"! And of languages designed now for an audience of machines, They cannot seek to replicate our great linguistic genes. Of Daoists we did not take heed: fighting nature, reaping pain Now as never we need a champion, to help disembark this train. "Without further ado!" I shall then move for a humble nomination Of the synonym as an ailment for our present day conflagration.
- computator 14y agoHere's a quiz for you: Put the jumbled adjectives in the correct order: I have (CANADIAN ATTRACTIVE WRITING FOUR WOOD LONG) tables. I've tried this quiz with a bunch of people who never studied grammar, and I've found if you are a native English speaker, you'll arrive at the same answer. If you have doubts about the order of a certain pair of words, just try using those 2 words alone, for example, ask yourself if "ATTRACTIVE WOOD table" is better or worse than "WOOD ATTRACTIVE table", and the answer will be obvious. I also found it fascinating that there are 720 possible ways to order the adjectives (because 6x5x4x3x2x1 = 720), but just one sounds correct.
- computator 14y agoSpoiler: The answer is http://decode.org/?q=SbheNggenpgvirYbatPnanqvnaJbbqJevgvat http://decode.org/?q=SbheNggenpgvirYbatPnanqvnaJbbqJevgvat (Rot 13 encoded. See the blue text -- for some reason my eye doesn't immediately see the decoded text.)
- semiel 14y agoInteresting! I actually get a slightly different answer: http://decode.org/?q=SbheYbatNggenpgvirPnanqvnaJbbqJevgvat http://decode.org/?q=SbheYbatNggenpgvirPnanqvnaJbbqJevgvat No one you've tried it on has produced my version?
- anatoly 14y agoI reached your answer (but I'm not a native speaker).
- nollidge 14y agoHm. I put LONG one word to the left of where you did. But I suppose that only makes sense with a comma after it. Yours feels more correct if no commas are allowed.
- T-hawk 14y agoThis is fascinating indeed, can we break down some actual rules from that example? "Writing table" is idiomatic, you need to understand that the table's purpose is for a writer, not that "writing" is a verb meaning the table is authoring something. As an idiom, it's very close to an atomic construct to reason about, so that places "writing" last and closest to the noun. One of those adjectives (Canadian) modifies another (Wood) rather than the ultimate noun, so they go together. (Maybe that adjective could be forming "Canadian writing"? That's silly, but why is it silly? You need contextual knowledge, to know that a table's characteristics are invariant for any kind of writing, to eliminate the parsing of "Canadian writing" as nonsensical. The syntax alone can't establish that. Context is required. If the noun were "anthologies" instead of "tables", then "Canadian" could modify "writing".) Similarly, another adjective (Long) implicitly modifies both the ultimate noun and the wood that it's made of. It would be nonsensical to have a long table made of not-long wood. So "Long" goes outside (before) "Canadian Wood". Context is necessary again here, to know that wood is a material for making tables. "Four" goes outside everything else, as it's multiplying the entire final construct. "Attractive" remains, and I'd argue that there isn't a single answer for it, as two other child comments already illustrate. It could go either before or after "Long", and could even convey meaning by that placement, indicating whether the length contributes to the attractiveness ("Attractive Long") or is just an incidental quality ("Long Attractive"). "Attractive" could even come after "Canadian Wood" if the speaker wanted to indicate that the material is not part of the attractiveness. That construct feels slightly unnatural, but it should because so is the thought.
- wam 14y agoA subject near and dear to my heart. In college I was briefly obsessed with cross-linguistic adverb ordering. I wish middle school science included some linguistics. The empirical data are already in our heads, so it's a great vehicle for teaching the scientific method -- look at data, make a hypothesis, check its predictions against other data (no equipment needed!) and refine it until it encompasses the counter-examples.
- dllthomas 14y agoIn a number of the cases, it's not so much "awkward" as "means something else". Consider the difference between "first 50 dates" and "50 first dates".
- tokenadult 14y agoOne point to bear in mind in discussing this issue is that not all natural human languages reach the same result in ordering adjectives. For example, speakers of Chinese (Cantonese, specifically) have to be taught English adjective order http://www2.elc.polyu.edu.hk/cill/exercises/adjectiveorder.htm http://www2.elc.polyu.edu.hk/cill/exercises/adjectiveorder.h... and it is generally familiar to persons who have had a strong first-year linguistics course at a university or who have studied a modern foreign language in depth that adjective order varies from language to language. So the one thing we can be sure about here is that the grammatical sense of native speakers of English (or native speakers of Chinese, etc.) does NOT reflect some kind of underlying universal rule of human thought. The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language http://www.amazon.com/Cambridge-Grammar-English-Language/dp/0521431468 http://www.amazon.com/Cambridge-Grammar-English-Language/dp/... is an expensive reference book well informed by worldwide investigation of English as it is actually written and spoken. It is a useful tool for informed discussion about the interesting issues brought up by the Stack Exchange question kindly submitted here.
- snake_plissken 14y agoI ponder this often because the order of words changes the interpretation and my understanding of writing: "green great dragon" - the dragon is green and happens to be great "great green dragon" - the greatness of the dragon comes from the fact that it's green
- rafcavallaro 14y agoSnake Plisken? I thought you were dead! Seriously, in English "green great dragon" is simply wrong - there's no semantic distinction here. Size before color, so it's "great green dragon." Just in case anyone is wondering "great" has the literal (non metaphorical) meaning "large in size."
- vacri 14y agoA great dragon is distinct from a komodo dragon or, from a eurocentric view, a Chinese dragon. 'A green great dragon' makes perfect sense used in the appropriate context.
- grey-area 14y agoThis question is fascinating but absurd - word order varies to provide emphasis or poetry (adjectives are particularly flexible in this respect), living languages are not constructed on a rational basis but organically in use, and different speakers may well differ on word order without one of them being correct in any meaningful sense.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kevinpet 14y agoI remember something in David Friedman's writing to the effect of how no layman ever argued with him about anything in physics (where he has his degree) but everyone feels qualified to argue with him on economics (what he is professor of). I think linguistics is similar. I only took a couple courses, but I frequently see people offering up opinions as if their instincts were a valid counter argument to well established science (like whether people have a conscious grasp of the grammar of their native language).
- barumrho 14y agoAt Starbucks, whenever I ask for "Grande Iced Americano", they repeated the order by saying "Iced Grande Americano". It's interesting to see that I am not the only one confused about the ordering.
- drucken 14y agoEnglish object-noun adjectival order (left to right): Quantity > Quality > Size > Measure > Shape > Age > Color > Origin > Material > Purpose. Easy to remember because the stronger an adjective is tied to what the noun is, the closer it is to the noun. This is why, for example Age is closer than Shape.
- JohnMM 14y agoDeterminers (the, an, that...) Observation (pretty, nice, awesome...) Size and Shape (big, huge, great(usually)...) Age (new, young, fourteen years old, antique...) Color (blue, black, pale...) Origin (French, American, Asian...) Material (woolen, jade, metallic) Qualifier -- this one can seem tricky. It's an adjective that has become part of a set phrase with the noun. Like "book cover" or "rocking chair". Those have to stay right next to the noun or it messes up the phrase (a rocking blue chair has a wobbly leg; a blue rocking chair is doing what it should). A "great dragon" is very dangerous and amazing, not just big. There are also a few English phrases with postmodifiers, like 'mother-in-law' or 'attorney general', but they are few, and you learn them one at a time. It isn't really logical, and every language has, more or less, its own order, but English is more firm in its adherence to its set order than most. It just sounds right to us!