11 ms·
>>There is another side of this that the article doesn't touch on: home ownership. Oh boy. There's so much I can say about this topic, and none of it is positi
by enraged_camel 14y ago
>>There is another side of this that the article doesn't touch on: home ownership.
Oh boy. There's so much I can say about this topic, and none of it is positive.
Basically, the way our culture mindlessly promotes home ownership is insane. Absolutely insane!
Every time I hear people complaining about "throwing away money" by renting, and how they would rather put that money into a house, I want to hold them by the shoulders and shake them violently. It's like the housing market crash did not teach anyone anything!
It comes down to this: a house is a terrible, terrible means of investment. It's a fixed asset that, contrary to popular belief, is not guaranteed to always go up in value. In addition, people don't really take into account the negatives. Primarily, a house ties you down. You have zero mobility as a labor market participant if you own a house, and this significantly reduces your leveraging power when it comes to negotiating salary. Besides that though, houses have a ton of expenses, and as fixed assets they are subject to a lot of uncontrollable risk (fire, floods, earthquakes, the neighborhood depreciating, etc.).
Instead of having that money tied down on a house, people are much better investing in the stock market, which has, over the past 100 years, gone up by 7% annually.
The only time a house makes sense is when raising kids. The stability of the environment has a lot of positive benefits for their growth. It also makes social integration easier.
/rant
- kens 14y agoOne thing that puzzles me is that rising house prices are treated as inherently good, and falling house prices are seen as inherently bad. But for most things, it's the exact opposite - rising prices are bad. Is this just because newspaper articles are biased towards the perspective of real estate agents and homeowners? Or are high house prices good because houses are investments? Would cheap 3-d printed houses (hypothetically) make the country better off or worse off economically?
- nostrademons 14y agoIt's because 2/3 of Americans are homeowners, so for a majority of Americans, falling house prices are bad. It's the same thing for most goods - the price mechanism is inherently value-neutral, and then whether it's better if prices go up or down depends upon how many people are potentially on each side of the transaction. Falling wages are seen as a bad thing, because most Americans identify with labor and not capital. The social security crisis is seen as a bad thing, because senior citizens (who get the payouts) vote in much larger numbers than young adults (who pay the taxes). Falling stock prices are seen as a bad thing because most Americans own stocks, even if indirectly. Falling CDO prices are seen as a good thing because most Americans do not own CDOs.
- drcube 14y ago>It's because 2/3 of Americans are homeowners, so for a majority of Americans, falling house prices are bad. Why? Those homeowners shouldn't care what the price of their house is. While they're living in it, it doesn't matter, and when they sell, presumably their next house will be cheaper too. The only time home prices should matter is in comparison to the overall market. If your house got cheaper while other homes got more expensive, that's a problem for you. Otherwise, the price of your home is mostly irrelevant.
- sukuriant 14y agoHouses are an asset in people's minds. This means that you can sell your house if you need to get extra money and you're in a bind, or to downsize from your current house to a cheaper-to-maintain one. Let's say you bought a house for $400k with 100k down and have so far paid 50k towards the remaining 300k (plus interest, since it's a loan). The housing market has gone down, and your house is now worth $200k. (These sort of drops happen). Okay, so your house is worth $200k. You need to get out of there, but you've only paid 150k towards your 400k loan. You sold the house for 200k, so now you still owe 50k to the bank for a house you just sold for less. This does not help you out of your current situation, which was to sell an asset to pay for things, or to survive easier. Edit: Note. This is a VERY simple and slightly inaccurate review of how paying for a house works. The intent of it was to explain why lowering prices are bad for people that already own homes.
- joezydeco 14y agoIf you're stuck in your home like in sukuriant's example, you can't move if you find a job somewhere else. You're stuck in the town you are in and you'll need to find something locally. This is part of the problem with the American labor market at the moment.
- snowwrestler 14y agoLet's say I take out an $80,000 mortgage to buy a $100,000 house--which then appreciates to $120,000. If I sell the house, I walk away with $40,000 in cash, which I can keep tax-free (a special privilege accorded the capital gains on your primary residence). Now let's say I want to buy a home the same size--it's $120,000 too. But I only need a down payment of 20% to secure the mortgage--that's $24,000. So now I'm back in a house the same size as I had, but I have $16,000 tax-free in my pocket.
- stretchwithme 14y agoIf you see the mania and avoid getting involved, patiently waiting until sanity returns, you can buy more cheaply. But you are still stuck paying for these insane policies, which cost hundreds of billions. But we are avoiding that too, borrowing a trillion plus bucks a year. We will ultimately face the music and it will be when all the wiggle room is gone, because they wiggle as much as possible without regard to long term consequences.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoA house is a very useful durable good. Like automobiles and refrigerators.
- enraged_camel 14y agoIt's funny you mention automobiles, because nobody buys automobiles as a means of investment (since they lose a ton of value quickly). As a useful durable good, sure houses have value, but renting accomplishes the same purpose (of giving you a place to live).
- tks2103 14y agoi think he was being sarcastic
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoI wasn't being sarcastic. That was my point: houses are a durable good, which means they're not an investment at all and shouldn't be treated as such.
- walshemj 14y agoReally some houses are built to last :-) I was looking to buy a place (before I got made redundant) built in the 1790's (Listed building mentioned in peveinser no less) and the farmhouse next to my parents house is 1500's/1600's John Bunyan preached there back in the day
- rdouble 14y agoCompounding this problem are the facts that in many, and I would argue, most, US cities, renting is expensive, the there is a social stigma against renters, and the rental properties available are very undesirable.
- bluedino 14y ago> Basically, the way our culture mindlessly promotes home ownership is insane. Absolutely insane! It's really the older generation that promote this. If you're 35 years old, chances are your dad walked out of high school into the same large company that he retired from. Why would they need mobility when they had jobs for life? The only younger people I know that share that view are close-minded and never see the point of leaving Smalltown, USA.
- nilkn 14y ago> The only younger people I know that share that view are close-minded and never see the point of leaving Smalltown, USA. To be fair, if you can find a way to make good money in a small town, you'll be living a more comfortable life than most people in big cities. If the attractions of a big city don't actually attract you, then sometimes moving to one is, economically, a bad decision. My parents have a big house in a small town and for over a decade they owned and operated a local gas station. They were "rich," even though they didn't make a lot of money by NYC or SV standards. Do you know how much the house cost them? A little over $100k. Just let that sink in.
- rdouble 14y agoThe only younger people I know that share that view are close-minded and never see the point of leaving Smalltown, USA. Only if you include metros like Atlanta in your definition of Smalltown, USA. Most American cities are geared towards home ownership.
- ry0ohki 14y ago>The only time a house makes sense is when raising kids. It really depends where you live. Here in Pittsburgh you can buy a decent house for $150k. Meanwhile, rent in that same area is $1000 for something similar. In this case, even if there was zero appreciation, the amount you pay on interest, repairs, etc... is less then the amount you would have spent on rent, but everyone should take the time to make these calculations for themselves. There was no amount of math that made a 1,500 sqft house in Calfornia at $1 mil (during the boom) better then renting. I should also mention the area I'm thinking of has high demand for rent, so your mobility isn't really limited as you'd be able to rent out at a profit almost immediately.
- jdietrich 14y agoIt's a very simple mathematical error - people compare the cost of a mortgage payment with the cost of a month's rent, failing to take into account that only a tiny fraction of the mortgage payment actually becomes equity. If they actually sit down and work it out, most people are astonished at how much flexibility they sacrifice for that small slice of equity.
- pchivers 14y ago>failing to take into account that only a tiny fraction of the mortgage payment actually becomes equity. What percentage of a mortgage payment actually gets converted into equity? (coming from a genuinely curious person who has never owned a house)
- quesera 14y agoIt depends. The interest portion is very high in the beginning of the mortgage and very low at the end. In a typical 30yr mortgage, you will make 360 monthly (roughly equal) payments. If your mortgage payment is $1000/mo, payment #1 will be approximately $950 interest and $50 principal. Payment #360 will be ~ $50 interest and $950 principal. Most people move every five or six years (historical, might not be true with current RE market), so they complete about 20% of their total mortgage schedule. However, because of this ramped apportionment, most people still owe the lender much more than 80% of their initial purchase price. The first time I did the math on this, I thought I had discovered a huge consumer-hostile scam. But actually it's quite reasonable -- mortgages are designed to keep payments equal over the term of the loan, so there's really no other way to do it.
- jquery 14y agoI just bought a home and 40% of my payments are principal from day 1. That's at 3.5% interest. If you get a conventional loan instead of a jumbo, you can do even better than that. Mortgage interest deductions make the calculus even better. Plus tax-free capital gains. It was quite the slam-dunk easy decision to make where I live (San Francisco), considering how hot the rental market is. My house rents for $1k more than the monthly mortgage!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nbouscal 14y agoEarly in a mortgage you're paying what, 25% principal? Probably less? And that's not even taking into consideration property taxes, mortgage insurance, etc, etc. So no, you're not getting $1k back from every month.
- benjiweber 14y agoI guess it depends on the rental vs purchase market where you are. Here in outer London, rental prices are pretty much in line with the interest payments on a mortgage. So you're "throwing away" the same amount whether you're renting or not. I'd have thought this would become a natural equilibrium in most places. If rental prices are significantly more than the interest payments on a mortgage then owning will seem more attractive. Mortgage still has value in that it gives you the opportunity to invest that in a house if that's something you want to do.
- natrius 14y agoAnyone deciding whether to purchase a home should play with this calculation of the tradeoffs first: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/business/buy-rent-calculator.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/business/buy-rent-calcula...
- hexedpackets 14y agoYou wouldn't get $1k a month in equity. First of all, you can't ignore interest as its a huge part of what you pay on a mortgage. Depending on your down payment and rates, you could end up being over half the cost of the actual property in interest and property tax. Then there's maintenance, insurance (much more costly than renter's insurance), and so on.
- riggins 14y ago"at worst, it depreciates by 50%, you still get $1k back from every month you paid off the mortgage" Not sure what you mean by 'get $1k back from every month you paid off mortgage' Here's rough justice. $300K, 6%, 30 yr fixed mortgage. Annual payment is $22K(about your 2K/month) for the life of the mortgage. Avg int over the first 5 years is $17.5K. So after the first five years you've accumulated $22K in equity. If your house goes down 50% you own a $150K house with a $278K mortgage.
- nilkn 14y ago> Instead of having that money tied down on a house, people are much better investing in the stock market, which has, over the past 100 years, gone up by 7% annually. Just to be clear, that 7% is after inflation. The historical performance of the stock market is closer to 10-11% pre-inflation. > The only time a house makes sense is when raising kids. Retirement is of course another scenario where it makes sense. Mobility won't be nearly as important (indeed it may be totally irrelevant), and you won't have any rent or mortgage payments if you own your house. The thing is that I don't plan to retire in San Francisco or NYC. I plan on retiring in the south or midwest. Housing is so "cheap" there compared to salaries in tech hubs that as long as you're saving a reasonable amount of cash (say $1k minimum) every month (on top of retirement accounts and investments in stocks and bonds), you'll easily be able to just go buy a decent house in a cheap area for cash when you're ready to settle down in retirement. Is it absolutely the most efficient path, financially? I don't know, but it sure does make everything simple, as you'll have maximum mobility during your career. I can't tell you how many people I know who have basically stunted their careers due to buying homes. Money is certainly not the end goal in life, not even close, but lots of people I know could double their earnings if they weren't locked down to one location.
- mgkimsal 14y ago"but lots of people I could double their earnings if they weren't locked down to one location." Likewise, many companies could have lower labor expenses if they'd embrace telecommuting and locate branches (or HQ) in lower cost of living areas.
- nilkn 14y agoIndeed, if I could find a very stable, long-term remote development job paying $80k-100k (which is quite a bit lower than the going rates in NYC and SV), I'd seriously consider moving to a small town and just buying a home for $100k. Pay it off completely in a few years and live a really, really comfortable life afterwards. I'm just starting my career, but one of my big goals is to achieve the above either through a traditional remote development role or through independent consulting. The problem is stability--the most stable tech companies don't tend to hire remote devs, and consulting is inherently unstable, although I suppose if you work hard at the top of your game it wouldn't be much of an issue.
- rcirka 14y agoI agree that home ownership is not a good investment. Between mortgage interest, property taxes, home owners insurance, and maintenance, the ROI will be negative. Not to mention most homes barely appreciate beyond inflation. People say that with rent, all your money is going out the window. The same can be said for owning a home.
- Caerus 14y agoThe piece that I see ALWAYS neglected is maintenance. I rent and pay nothing additional to maintain the place. Washing machine breaks - landlord fixes it. Carpets wearing out (minus things that are obviously my fault) - landlord replaces it. Everyone I talk to who owns is constantly upgrading or replacing or fixing something in their house. It seems, on average, home maintenance is about 66-75% of my rent check; and that isn't money they get back. It just prevents their home price from falling.
- walshemj 14y agothe landlord then retains your deposit for "spurious" cleaning or do US landlords not do this nasty little scam.
- rdouble 14y agoIt depends on the landlord.
- xamuel 14y agoJust write the deposit off and if you get any back, consider it a blessing. It's odd that you give it so much weight when it's usually less than a single month's rent.
- _delirium 14y agoIt varies a lot; in California the legal maximum is two months' rent, and it's fairly common for landlords to demand the maximum. That can be a significant hit unless you stay in the same place for years.
- andyking 14y agoIn Britain these days, the deposit is held by an independent agency, not the landlord or letting agent. They have to give a good reason to have money deducted - and you can then dispute this if it is spurious. I recently moved, and the landlord (who was broke) was trying to keep money for all sorts of non-existent faults, most of which were due to his shoddy DIY work before I moved in. I raised a dispute and eventually got the vast majority of the money back. Just make sure you keep pictures of the state of the house before you move your stuff in.
- nostromo 14y agoA few things you're not accounting for: * Leverage. (The most you can leverage a stock investment is 2x. For homes people can leverage their money up to an insane 20x, for example: by buying a 500k home with 25k down. The proper comparison is not to compare buying a 500k home vs 500k worth of stocks; it's buying 25k or 50k worth of stocks vs a 500k home.) * Mortgage deduction. (Imagine if you could invest 500k in the stock market with only 25k, and then the government let you deduct your interest payments!) * Inflation. (I've heard of people living in Manhattan in apartments they bought in the 1980s that pay a mortgage of $500. Inflation has reduced their mortgage debt to negligible levels. Time has in a very real way erased much of their debt.)
- kalid 14y agoYou can effectively leverage 100x with stock options. You can by deep in the money LEAPs (long-term options, expiring 18 months-2 years out) and effectively have the risk profile of the stock itself. You can then sell and roll those over to longer-term expiring options every 6 months or so.
- jngreenlee 14y ago+i for the inflation comment. This is a big driver for my current investment approach. The opportunity to pick up a large, real asset at rates below the inflation I personally experience (US gov't published inflation rate is lower than mine), in market with significant appreciation due to positive population metrics (Austin TX) Note that you should always spread risk in your portfolio, but housing at nominally negative rates should have youngers investing if they can. Buy something small and close to the city core.
- jngreenlee 14y agoOne additional negative to home ownership is transaction costs. Real Estate agents, laywers, lenders, title companies all get you comin' and goin'. They love churn! I like redfin.com as a market changer in this space. Check them out!
- stretchwithme 14y ago
- anigbrowl 14y agoSpeaking as a homeowner, we didn't buy the house as an investment asset (though naturally we hope it doesn't depreciate too much). We bought it to live in, and are not paying huge amounts or over very long periods. Of course there are risks. That's why we carry insurance.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>Of course there are risks. That's why we carry insurance. Which also has a cost... You are not negating risk by buying insurance. You are simply offloading it to another party and paying them money on a regular basis. At the end of the day, it's still an expense.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat's right. It's economically more efficient for me to pay someone $1000 a year in order to be covered for most eventualities, because I estimate my annual risk at a bit higher than 0.3%.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- medinismo 14y agoI so agree with this argument that I think it should absolute, ie no provisos for "The only time a house makes sense is when raising kids." Long term, stable rental income is the dream of any landlord. Families provide that. So capitalism work just fine here too.
- jngreenlee 14y agoAddition to the other factors to consider put forth by nostromo: -Mobility. When you need to exit a house and relocate, you can do so without waiting for a lease to expire. If you are in the right market, you can rent the first home out while you migrate, then sell it once the dust has settled.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>Mobility. When you need to exit a house and relocate, you can do so without waiting for a lease to expire. Yeah, instead you need to find a buyer, which in most places is not an easy task, especially in a housing market flooded with cheap foreclosed homes. In addition, you have to hope that the house has not depreciated in value during your ownership - which can happen due to factors totally outside your control (such as foreclosures in your neighborhood). In other words: if you need to move, don't count on having the ability to sell your house quickly and without loss.
- gcheong 14y agoThe only time a house makes sense is when raising kids. I don't have kids but one benefit I get from owning a house is I can do pretty much what I want to it without having to get permission for it from a landlord and it affords more space for entertaining friends and allowing me to build things so I think that statement is a bit short-sighted. You are right though about the mindless promotion and the dubious investment potential. Unless you specialize in real estate investment, houses are primarily a place to live and you have to determine the value that you would get out of it from that standpoint.
- pmorici 14y agoEvery place is different but in some places there are huge advantages to buying that most people don't probably realize. In the state of Maryland for example It's my understanding that property taxes on the first $300k of assessed value for primary residences are adjusted based on your income[0] for households making less than $60k per year. (for reference 300k will get you a pretty nice place in a trendy part of the city) The end result is you could be living in a $300k house and pay zero or near zero property tax. So you could for example buy a place straight out of college rent out the spare rooms to pay off the mortgage at a very accelerated pace and then if you wanted to you could live in that house basically property tax free once the mortgage is paid off so long as you didn't make too much money. I'm not sure if you've looked at your living cost structure but once you knock out mortgage and property tax you have an extreme amount of flexibility in terms of how much money you need to make to live comfortably and the types of career risks you could take w/o having to worry about ending up on the street. You have to be smart about what you buy and at what price of course which is where most people fail at smart decisions when home buying but if you do it right it really can be a no brainier. [0] http://www.dat.state.md.us/sdatweb/htc.html http://www.dat.state.md.us/sdatweb/htc.html
- luser001 14y agoGiven your last point re: kids, how is it "insane" that people want to buy houses? Most people have/want to have kids. Btw, I don't agree with your last point. It's pretty much possible to stay in a rented apartment for 5 years at a time quite easily. And kids go through wrenching changes every five years on average (home->kindergarten->middle->high school). You make good points about the drawbacks of buying a house. However, the ability to lock in your housing expenses for the next 30 years (i.e., no impact of inflation) shouldn't be underestimated. IMHO.
- b0rsuk 14y agoHere in Poland, you can't rent a flat even if you want. There are extremely few offers, partially because there's a culture of owning. Renting is frowned upon.
- rsheridan6 14y agoI'm in the process of buying a house. My monthly payment will be ~$300 less than what I'm paying for rent now for a similar house, and I could probably break even (taking into account maintenance) if I had to pay a property management company to rent it out in the even that I needed to move. And in 10 years, who knows what rent will be? I know what my house payment will be, modulo possible changes in tax and insurance rates. Not all markets are like that, but in some cases it does make sense to buy a house.