3 ms·
First thought: "Necessary but not sufficient" Second thought: "Minecraft rather undermines the 'necessary' part." Flippancy aside - there is a place for incre
by andybak 14y ago
First thought: "Necessary but not sufficient"
Second thought: "Minecraft rather undermines the 'necessary' part."
Flippancy aside - there is a place for incredible graphics and I'd be the last person to want progress to halt in that direction but many games wade through the uncanny valley and the immersiveness(?) suffers. Others refuse to even play that game and seem no poorer because of it.
I rate Doom (original), Journey on the PS3 and of course Minecraft as amongst the most captivating gaming experiences I've had. Food for thought.
- JamesMcMinn 14y agoDon't mistake the graphics part of what he said as simply referring how realistic the graphics are. Minecraft is the perfect example of the game where the graphics are integral to how the game plays. The blocky style of Minecraft is part of what makes it so great and fun to play.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- TillE 14y agoMinecraft really should have been the end of anyone saying that graphics are more important than gameplay. It's the definitive example of how you can make a game with graphics that are not only simple, but often quite ugly, and still capture a huge and diverse portion of the market with engaging gameplay. Honestly, AAA games are getting more boring every year. It's all graphics and story, with no appreciation of the unique power of games (like Minecraft or Dwarf Fortress) to give players the tools to make their own stories.
- adventured 14y agoNo, Minecraft has graphics, and a very specific style of graphics, without which it would have failed miserably. Minecraft's graphics were critical. The simplistic graphic style was required to grab basic gamers by literally assisting the gameplay. The '8 bit' looking block building style makes it dead simple for almost anybody to play the game and build things. The graphics in Minecraft are like having a guide rail.
- arrrg 14y agoThat’s all gameplay and has nothing to do with graphics. Anti-aliasing and all that tech, better (professionally) drawn textures, etc. – all that could be done without affecting gameplay. I agree with you that the 1×1×1 meter block is of central importance to the game’s success. It creates a game that strikes a perfect balance between giving you power to manipulate the world and giving you simple enough tools to manipulate the world. 3D editors exist but only very few people find playing around and creating worlds with them to be fun. Minecraft is much less powerful than a 3D editor (since it restricts you to those 1×1×1 meter blocks), but by reducing that power it is able to give you accessible tools. (There is obviously also a technical reason. Making the basic unit smaller than those blocks makes the worlds more computationally intensive.) Yeah, having 1×1×1 meter blocks restricts the graphics, but that’s a consequence of a gameplay decision. That’s the causal link there. I think the graphics played some role in Minecraft’s success, but only insofar as they were serviceable and not completely terrible.
- vacri 14y agoMinecraft doesn't really undermine it. Minecraft's inspiration was Dwarf Fortress, which is an ANSI game. Minecraft's most significant contribution which made the game feasible was the addition of graphics. All the non-graphic 'cool elements' of Minecraft are found in abundance in Dwarf Fortress, (and then some (and then some)). Graphics made that style of game accessible to the masses.
- eurleif 14y agoSome graphics are necessary. Pretty graphics are not.
- vacri 14y agoDF has some graphics, it's not a text-based game (as in Zork et al). It uses planar ANSI graphics, not 3D graphics, that's all.
- lutze 14y agoI thought Minecraft's inspiration was Infiniminer?
- speeder 14y agoMore or less. When creative mode was made, the intention was emulate infiniminer and grab the fans of the abandoned game, but the survival mode, that is mostly a copy of dwarf fortress, was planned from start. Minecraft is dwarf fortress with infiniminer interface.
- coldtea 14y ago>First thought: "Necessary but not sufficient" Second thought: "Minecraft rather undermines the 'necessary' part." Minecraft? What about all the text adventure games? Some where massive hits well after we have widespread color graphical games... Even as far as early nineties. (And people enjoy them even now, but I digress).