9 ms·
Why Redfin, Zillow, and Trulia Haven't Killed Off Real Estate Brokers
- asah 14y agogreat article, and wonderful validation for those of us choosing to minimize disruption in our startups.
- msandford 14y agoIf someone would come up with standard terms for sale and purchase (like Fred Wilson at AVC is doing for VC) and it wasn't tied to a real estate agent but rather to a license fee (a few hundred dollars) then you might see this thing get legs. A lot of what the other companies did was standardize a transaction (through their website, with a credit card) and that's what real estate needs.
- quesera 14y agoNot sure what you mean. Every US state I've transacted in has a standard P&S or equivalent form. No state has required an agent, although I have chosen to use one in some cases. I suspect, but have not tested the theory, that all states require closings to be conducted by real estate attorneys.
- msandford 14y agoIn my experience there's a bunch of stuff that goes with it. For the actual purchase/sale yes there might be a standard form. But what about the mortgage? What about refunds/credits after the sale to help finance big repairs that need to be made? There are more things involved in a a total transaction than the act of transferring the title from their bank to your bank.
- quesera 14y agoAll of that paperwork involves other parties and is not strictly necessary. Your secured loan paperwork is just between you and the lender. The state has nothing to do with it. It might not exist. Refund/credit after the sale? Like a warranty? I've never considered offering or requesting such a thing, but it would be ancillary to the sale, not required. There's a federal (FHA) form to enumerate all of the costs, which is a required part of the paperwork. Numbers come from seller, lender, local tax authorities, etc. All(?) states have disclosure requirements, though they vary greatly. I've seen four-inch thick binders of disclosure in San Francisco, to a few boilerplate sheets with checkboxes and initials in Boston (maybe the federal minimum?) I agree that there is a lot of variation in the transaction process, mostly variable by state law. But that's a problem many businesses on the web have to navigate. It's a challenge, but not The Roadblock to modernization of the industry.
- msandford 14y agoWhen a homeowner sells a home some kind of semi-serious problem is often discovered during the home inspection. I.e. a new roof is needed, foundation settling, etc. Often when you're buying all your readily available funds are being used to satisfy the down payment. In that case the seller and buyer agree to "discount" the house by $x in the form of a post-sale rebate where $x is roughly appropriate for the repair. That way you don't move into a house that's badly in need of repair at a time when you're exceptionally cash-poor. The better situation is to have the seller perform the repairs prior to the sale but often times the house is already under contract and you're expected to close on a certain date and it's easier to decide how much would be appropriate for the repairs and let the buyer handle it with their preferred contractor after the sale.
- quesera 14y agoRight, well those are attached as riders to the P&S, again in a very standard (and legally simple) form, since the contract was contingent on the acceptance of the inspection report. Anyway, I agree with you that the process is unfamiliar and can be overwhelming for most buyers. The sea of forms and signatures induces glazed eyes, for sure. I don't think nationally-standardized forms would help there (and it's very likely to be impossible anyway). Any RE attorney can make quick work of the problem (hire your own, don't use the seller's!). It would be unwise to transact with any set of forms without an attorney or equivalent experience.
- imroot 14y agoAnd most of those forms are copyrighted -- one of my former employers did electronic real estate forms, and the threat of a lawsuit was always on the horizon (until we either came to an agreement with an area, usually).
- ck2 14y agoReminds me how much I miss Google real estate on maps. I wonder if there is any chance they will bring that back. “Real estate, by far, is the most screwed up industry in America,” Only a person who didn't need medical or dental care in the USA without insurance would say that.
- twoodfin 14y agoBecause relatively few people have real dental insurance (not dental "discount plans") vs. health insurance, the dental care market in the U.S. is actually fairly competitive. Nobody's going to go bankrupt from uncovered dental expenses as long as they're careful to budget for an average of, say, $500-$1000 annually (depending on your history) and are willing to shop around.
- ck2 14y agoAre you kidding? A root canal is $500 and a crown for the root canal maybe twice that depending on the tooth.
- twoodfin 14y agoBut how many root canals do you have per year on average? Surely something like .25 at worst? And I suspect most patients paying for regular cleanings already have fewer of them.
- RobertHoudin 14y agoMost people can't afford to pay for regular cleanings, and 1 root canal every 4 years is not "worst case" for many of those people. You really need to check your socio-economic privilege here.
- viggity 14y agoLet me preface this by saying my mom is an incredibly successful real estate agent. I think people underestimate how valuable a good agent can be. They know problem signs when buying a house, they know the market and they know how to negotiate. My mom helped us by a townhome and then build a house and it was an incredibly eye opening experience. I was used to my mom being the sweet, nurturing woman I grew up with, but when it came to negotiating she turned into a pitbull. When we bought our townhome, she knew the market, she knew what areas were better. When we built our house, she was able to guide in a way to maximize the bang for our buck. Things that were cheap and add a lot of value to do when building, but not cheap to retrofit. Thinking that using a site like redfin or zillow is going to make up for the depth of experience is just frankly silly. Would you negotiate a Series A with a bunch of forms from LegalZoom? No, you'd be an idiot to not have an experienced attorney on your side. Edit: The cool thing about real estate agents (unlike attorneys) is that the great ones charge just as much as the bad ones. The takeaway is that if you're going to buy a house, you should pick an agent that sells a TON of real estate and not someone who does it as a way to supplement their income.
- jseliger 14y agoI wonder how novices identify the great ones, however. As with many personal-service businesses, it's hard to distinguish the good ones before you've had the service.
- matwood 14y agoIt may suck for people trying to get their start, but experience is a great first indicator. If you find an agent that's been doing it for 20-30 years you have someone who has seen the ups and down of the market. They should have sold lots of houses. Also, see if you can find someone who sells houses in many price ranges. My agent routinely sells expensive (1M+) houses, but works just as hard for me with a budget that is a fraction of that. I asked her about it once and her response was that one day me or one of my friends would hopefully be buying a house in the millions and I would recommend her then. That type of thinking is not only long term, but also shows the dedication to making each client happy.
- Roboprog 14y agoAnother problem my wife and I have run into is lag time: there is a delay between posting things in the MLS and then onto the internet sites. That delay is usually the time it takes for the better deals to have an offer pending on them. Even though the UI of the "official" MLS site that our agent uses sucks compared to sites like zillow and movoto, you can find the cheaper houses before they go pending. Too bad there isn't a filter on the "status" field in the MLS web search (such as, filter out the 1/2 to 2/3 of houses that are already pending???) That said, Zillow is a wonderful tool to check price/sales history.
- jpdoctor 14y ago> you can find the cheaper houses before they go pending Which tells you the value of realtors: They don't wait around to get the highest bid (a commission in the hand is worth two in the bush.)
- cabinguy 14y agoA commission in the hand is worth two in the bush...but a purchase agreement submitted by a potential buyer can have a time limit attached to it. If the seller wants to wait around, they may lose out of the initial offer, which is (most) often the best offer.
- jpdoctor 14y ago> which is (most) often the best offer. I assume there is deep research on this factoid from the non-realtor community, because then the right thing to do is use the MLS API to be first and submit a lowball offer with a one-day fuse. But I gotta tell you: It sounds like the standard realtor spiel, and it works on people with little experience in buying/selling things with large asset values (like companies or houses).
- Domenic_S 14y agoRealtors get around this by giving you an offer review date: "we're looking at offers this Monday". It induces all the offers to come out of the woodwork and encourages bidding wars.
- Apreche 14y agoThe problem is that there is too much bureaucracy involved in buying a house. You can't get around the real estate laws the way Uber gets around taxi regulations. Buyers and sellers don't know how to buy or sell a house, as most of them do it very few times in their lives. Real estate agents do it every day. If you want to make real estate as easy as eBay, you have to change the laws.
- mooreds 14y agoDisclaimer--I work as a software dev for a real estate brokerage. That said, I've spent some time thinking about whether just changing the laws would have an impact. I think the issue is bigger than this. I think that there are lots of marketplaces have sprung up via the internet, but as far as I know, the significant ones all offer products that have one of these characteristics: * the consumer buys them often [for some definition of often] (airplane tickets) * the product is fungible (books, cars) * the product is relatively cheap (stuff sold on ebay, amazon) All of these characteristics lower the risk of purchase. Housing has none of these characteristics. And I don't know how it could, short of a real manufacturing revolution or more houses built out of shipping containers.
- tantalor 14y agoWouldn't it be a lot cheaper to hire a real estate attorney to handle the tricky bits than a real estate agent? Speculating, the agent knows the laws, but also pays some of her commission to an attorney who does the real work. The agent is a middle man.
- bane 14y agoIt's funny, my neighborhood has a great relationship with a couple local dedicated Agents, we've all been concerned about the housing prices, our tax assessments and even more importantly, the low estimates Zillow keeps showing in our neighborhood (compared with every other source of assessments)...they both agreed that pretty much nobody in the industry in our area even pays attention to Zillow anymore the estimates are so far off the actual value. edit just checked, my house for example, sits on the same block as two recent home sales, neither one is reflected in Zillow and both sold for far higher than the "Zestimate". The townhouses a few blocks over (which originally sold for about 70% of my home's price and are about half the size) are full of recent sales that are within 10-20% of the "Zestimate". The much smaller single home facing mine is "Zestimated" at a few tens of thousands higher than mine, but sold originally for 80% of my home's price. It's basically nonsensical.
- steven2012 14y agoZillow's estimates are absolutely garbage. I'm not sure how they determine estimates but they are too low by about 30%, at least in the Bay Area. If anyone from Zillow is reading this thread, they really need to do a better job with gathering their estimates by doing things like weighting most recent comps better, and taking a notice of how much newer sold houses are being overbid on. They've been around for a few years now, and their estimates are still a joke. They can calibrate their estimates by finding houses that are currently pending, making an estimate, and then seeing what they end up selling for once the deal closes. It appears they don't even bother doing any sort of backtesting on their estimates.
- xradionut 14y agoZillow's data is very, very bad. It doesn't reflect the market or the tax assessment records in my area.
- smackfu 14y agoIt's a very hard problem. * The price data isn't reliable. I see random sales for way under market price in my area, probably family sales. Tax evaluations should be reliable, but they are often years out of date. * The input variables aren't reliable. This condo went for less because it has really high condo fees, but the condo fees aren't in the listing. This other house says it has lakefront AND beachfront AND water views. These two houses have "decks", one is a tiny front porch, the other is a huge thing. These two houses have the same lot size, but one is all grass and the other is straight down a hill. * There isn't much data volume. You are trying to come up with an accurate price for every house in a neighborhood, but only a few percent sell each year. So the one or two houses that sell determine the prices for all the rest, but the data for those houses is unreliable due to the previous two factors.
- steven2012 14y agoAs someone who is currently looking to buy a house in the crazy Bay Area, I can tell you exactly why Redfin doesn't quite work. The Redfin real estate agents themselves aren't as dedicated to the clients as a traditional real estate agent is. Sure, you can see places, they will give you advice, and place orders for you. But with a dedicated agent who is getting fully commission, you are getting a lot more soft services than you would with a Redfin agent. Case in point: I have a friend who was looking strictly through Redfin, and whenever he found a house he would like, he would talk with the Redfin agent, and they would get a bid together. He was getting nowhere, and what was more frustrating is that even though they had the Redfin agent, they still felt alone and frustrated. I suggested my real estate agent. She went to his house, talked to them about what they wanted, and then proactively started looking for houses for them, in addition to him scouring MLS at the same time. She would actually suggest different areas of the Bay Area, instead of just SF because it looks like $850k won't buy you a decent house in a decent area anymore. The other thing that is really helpful in today's market is that she encouraged my friend to submit multiple offers at the same time, ie. bidding on 2-3 different houses. This is something Redfin actively discouraged. It's a bit grey area, but in this market, you can't afford to pass up any opportunities since the probability of getting a house is so low. As well, she works for a large brokerage, so she is always trying to get the inside scoop on new houses that are about to hit the market. They still haven't gotten a house yet, but they are less frustrated by the process and they feel a lot better knowing that they are getting good guidance from someone who is dedicated to helping them getting a house. If you are a sophisticated real estate buyer, and all you need is an agent to do all the documentation for you, then Redfin will likely work for you. But most people aren't, and in a broken market like today in the Bay Area, Redfin will be less successful, because what you really need is someone that knows the tricks of the trade and will help you bend the rules a bit.
- smackfu 14y agoI'm not sure how valuable it is to build a system that works well in a crazy market, considering how many more markets are not crazy. Yes, there are markets where speed is the most important feature, and properties tend to have multiple offers and go above the selling price.... but that is a pretty far edge case.
- pdovy 14y agoWhen I was looking to buy my first house a year ago, I was pretty interested in the deal Redfin is offering, which is basically that they take a smaller percentage in exchange for more of the burden being on you during the buying process. It took quite a while for me to find what I was looking for, so I ended up using both Redfin agents as well as talking frequently with a normal agent. I have to say even though it cost me slightly more, in the end the house I bought I found on the Redfin site but bought through the normal agent. As others have pointed out, good properties can go fast and having someone who you can call and have on the case immediately is a real asset. In my case my agent did the legwork to find out who else had seen the home and pushed the sellers to negotiate in time to edge out a competing bid - well worth a few thousand extra on the sale price. I get the point about misaligned incentives, but I view that more as a reason to ask around and get recommendations on good realtors, rather than a reason to avoid them.
- taude 14y agoI equate real estate agents to recruiters. They have a bad rap, because most of them do suck (there's virtually no barrier to entry and they have a large lobby in the U.S.). However, when you find the right one, with the right experience, they actually can provide a good service and make their fees worthwhile. The thing that's semi scary about all these under-qualified real-estate agents is that they're in charge of most expensive/binding purchase in most people's lives.
- kyrra 14y agoThere is at least some entry to it. I'm not sure about other states, but I know Arizona and Texas both required 100+ hours of classroom (which arguably isn't that much). Plus you have to renew every couple of years. Both also require you to pass a state run test. Sure, it's not high, but it's still more than a lot of jobs out there.
- jtreminio 14y ago> “We will never be a point-and-click industry,” says Phil Faranda, who runs J. Philip Real Estate, a 14-agent brokerage in Westchester County, N.Y. “You will always need a trusted adviser to ensure that you get the best terms possible. The stakes are so high. If you want to do a do-it-yourself project, build a hovercraft.” This poor man will be blindsided when someone finally gets the formula right.
- prawn 14y agoFaranda's slogan should be: "Faranda. At the forefront of housing."
- cs702 14y agoThe prospect for disintermediating real estate brokers looks to me about as realistic as the prospect for disintermediating investment bankers who provide M&A advice for fat fees. I say this because the services provided by real estate brokers on the purchase and sale of properties are similar to the services provided by investment bankers on the purchase and sale of whole businesses. Just as no two companies are the same, no two properties are the same (even when they have the same square footage, style, location, etc.). Just as every industry is different, every neighborhood is different. Just as every M&A negotiation has its own unique cast of characters, every negotiation for the purchase/sale of a property has its own unique cast of characters. Just as every M&A transaction must accommodate for unique circumstances, so does every real estate transaction. Just as large M&A transactions (e.g., sale of a multinational corporation) can be very complex, the acquisition of large properties (e.g., sale of a skyscraper with thousands of tenants) can be very complex. Most people are too busy with their lives, and they're not in the business of buying and selling properties, so they need expertise to navigate all this complexity.
- tokenadult 14y agoIt's very hard to check out the reputation of real estate brokers. Neither personal recommendations nor years of experience fully do the job (although both are useful at the margins). More than forty years ago, I was in school with a boy who was, I discovered, a pathological liar. He would make up elaborate stories to play practical jokes on classmates. About a decade ago, I was startled to see his name (very unusual) and face (three decades after I had last seen it) on a billboard in town. You know what occupation he pursues now. He seemed to have some visibility in our town as a successful business person during the height of the real estate bubble. He is still in the same line of work (but now just with lawn signs, not billboards) after the bubble popped. I wonder how any person shopping for a real estate broker could distinguish brokers like him from any other kind of broker.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jonknee 14y agoHe may have turned into a great real estate broker...
- psaintla 14y agoThere is a reason for that, real estate is an extremely high turnover occupation with an extremely low barrier to entry. I know this because when I was 18 (a very long time ago :-) ) I wrote and eventually sold the rights to real estate inventory and CRM software to a small real estate company in NY to pay for my college education. Before I wrote the software I wanted to gain domain knowledge in the industry so that I could write an application that actually met the needs of the real estate industry and also so that people would take me seriously as a "kid". So I went to get my real estate brokers license which required I take a course that was a few hours, a course exam and then a state exam. It took less than two weeks for me to be qualified to help people make the biggest financial decision of their life and I learned much less from the course than I did from a few books I picked up from the bookstore.
- lifeisstillgood 14y ago5.4% commission ! Are you kidding me. I negotiated hard down last time, outraged at the 2% charge.... No wonder there was a housing crash
- shawnee_ 14y agothe average commission paid to the buying and selling brokers was 5.4 percent of the price of a home in 2011, up from 5 percent in 2008. (The seller’s agent collects the commission from the seller and then splits it evenly with the buyer’s agent.) That’s considerably higher than the median rate in markets abroad, where there may only be one agent involved in the transaction, such as the U.K. (a 1 percent to 2 percent fee), Germany (3 percent to 6 percent), Israel (4 percent), and the Netherlands (1.5 percent to 2 percent), according to a 2007 report by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. <snip> They found that there’s ... collusion in real estate that separates it from industries like stock trading and air travel. So the most "consumer-friendly" solution to this problem is obvious. Make the collusion illegal. Make it a LAW that buyers and sellers are not obligated to pay any agents any specific percent of anything. (6 percent is hard-coded into most real estate transaction paperwork, and never fully explained to consumers.) Draw consumers' attention to the fact that Realtors should be competing with each other based on their service, not coercing consumers into signing contracts that write their percent commission in stone. The problem is that consumers don't know these things should be negotiable. Collusion should always be illegal, but the lobbying forces of the NAR are pretty evil and powerful; it's going to be tough (but not impossible) to change.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 14y agoWhere do these sites get their real estate data from?
- crucialfelix 14y agothe brokerages willingly and desperately send them data feeds. some of the sites charge money, all of them have premium and featured listings programs. sometimes the brokerage pays, sometimes the individual agent does. also NYT charges a truly obscene amount for real estate ads. it pays a big part of their bills. [I am CTO for one of the NYC brokerages]
- kozikow 14y ago1. Negotiations - why there are no online auctions for flats? 2. Knowing the area - Google maps/foursquare probably know as good as the best real estate agent. Just embed this info in the website. 3. Viewing the flat - photos of flats are very inefficient today - why not push landlords to post Sphere views and 2d plans of the flat? It's definitely cheaper to do it than pay 5% commission for estate agent. When I was searching for a flat majority of flats I viewed could be dismissed only on online profile if it was complete enough. More informative online profiles == less viewings == less estate agents. 3. Agent searching for you - it's another problem with these real estate sites. This is one of the areas, where algorithm could do better than real person. Just specify conditions you like in the flat, or rate on a scale 1-10 flats you are viewing, or go through past 50 deals and rate them (advantage of past deals is that you know the price it went for). Then website will send you weakly digest for flats that are potentially good for you or urgent alert if something awesome shows up.
- bornonmars 14y agoOkay, here's a thing - how about developing a more accurate risk profile assessment and pricing structure than any other broker out there (just like some lending platforms doubled the accuracy in evaluating credit ratings in comparison to large banks and built their business around that technology) and then buy in advance low risk properties, while charging relatively high fees? You'd have to keep the asset on the books (while knowing the average time required to sell it for a low commission) till it's gone, but eliminate the pain number 1 for consumers, as in most cases they're ready to be charged more to get rid of the property asap. Just throwing it there. Crazy enough to make sense.
- tantalor 14y ago“Needing two agents to cooperate in a transaction allows a full-service agent to punish discount agents,” Syverson says. “It also allows full-service agents to punish other full-service agents who cooperate with discount agents.” As a result, an agent can steer clients away from for-sale-by-owner properties or from homes represented by discount brokers. Is this legal?