4 ms·
I'm a little old fashioned here - but sampling is about as simple copyright breach as you get - its cut and paste. However, if I were a record company and the
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I'm a little old fashioned here - but sampling is about as simple copyright breach as you get - its cut and paste.
However, if I were a record company and the top google search for a day was a skinny kid who has audiences full of screaming target demographics, no amount of cocaine on prostitutes would be too great till I had him signed in a contract Fautus would consider a bit on the restrictive side.
Mumbling about how unfair it is to not be able to copy other people's work without paying them is a bit disingenuous, but if I owned those copyrights then this guy is a great way to get more out of the back catalog.
- nthitz 14y ago> In the UK, one producer sued the dance group MIAIRIRIS for sampling his work. Although the song was a top ten hit, he had no idea it sampled his song until a member of MIAIRIRIS mentioned it on the radio. It had been manipulated beyond recognition. I don't think it's always a simple cut and paste. The article mentions Puff Daddy's "I'll Be Missing You" sampling the Police, or The Beastie Boys sampling Led Zeppelin or the Beatles. You might listen to some of these songs and have no idea about the original. One time I was at a party and Kanye's 'Harder Better Faster Stronger' came on. I remember saying "I didn't know Kanye sampled Daft Punk" and someone replying something along the lines of "nah this is all original Kanye"
- 286c8cb04bda 14y ago> the dance group MIAIRIRIS That's not 'I', it's '|' -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MARRS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MARRS
- nthitz 14y agoOh thanks! I just c+p'ed from the article, goes to show you, it's just not that simple! :)
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI was trying to emphasise that there is a qualitative difference between copying by children in bedrooms and copying by professionals or wannabe professionals. Alter copyright law is probably never going to happen in time, but market driven compromises will fix a lot of things
- rdouble 14y agoOne time I was at a party and Kanye's 'Harder Better Faster Stronger' came on. I remember saying "I didn't know Kanye sampled Daft Punk" and someone replying something along the lines of "nah this is all original Kanye" And Daft Punk sampled the hook for Harder Better Faster Stronger from unknown Edwin Birdsong's "Cola Bottle Baby" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wals6HONqxk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wals6HONqxk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJPdVVOmbz4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJPdVVOmbz4
- nthitz 14y agoCrazy, didn't know that, thanks for sharing! It's samples all the way down!
- 8ig8 14y agoIf you want to get a sense of all the samples that go into a Girl Talk song, I recommend the following which provides real time info of each sample as the song plays: http://readyrickshaw.com/toob/node/63 http://readyrickshaw.com/toob/node/63 -and- http://alldaysamples.com/ http://alldaysamples.com/
- dublinben 14y agoI think this is presented much better on MashupBreakdown. They also have more artists. http://mashupbreakdown.com/ http://mashupbreakdown.com/
- Daishiman 14y agoYou're not a little old fashioned; you seem to have missed the last 25 years of musical development. Go look up Soundcloud and see that most likely a third of the tracks being uploaded are remixes and edits of existing tracks, all of them innovative in their own ways. There are entire genres of electronic music that exist due to sampling. Dub, Drum n' Bass, Electro, Latin American EDM, electronic Balkan, way too many to mention here. There are literally millions of hours of recorded music; its market and creative value are far, far lower than what the big recording groups claim on the simple basis of the volume of production out there. Ironically, I have never heard of any of the (tens of thousands of) independent labels bitching about people remixing their tracks or uploading edits or playing them at gigs. You sound like a person that purchases his or her music and listens to it mostly from radio or commercial sources. That's less than 1% of all published music, and its a world of great much depth and complexity where copying samples the a social norm. That copyright law in the last twenty years has favored the large, visible majority has little effect on the ethical implications for the rest of the artists. And seriously, if a sample is so egreriously illegal as you claim, then I hope that in your world half of all rock music, R&B, and the entirety of blues be declared illegal, since the song structure and chord progressions are in general less creative than the spins electronic produces make on their samples.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI'm an electronic musician whose entire setup is oriented around my sampler, and I wholly agree with him. Don't project all your frustrations with the existing music industry onto his comment, you're blaming him for things he never actually said.
- Daishiman 14y agoThen as an electronic musician you know very well that 90% of the current acts in dance music scenes would never be capable of clearing an album because of the overhead in licensing. Really, I see nothing particularly special in a 4 or even 40-second section of music to warrant an unusually high level of protection. Most samples are completely unrecognizable, and when present and recognizable they are honestly a minimal fraction of the creative output in a song. And really, what makes samples so special over riffs, or even FX? The fact that you agree with him doesn't change the fact that current situation is a historical anomaly that greatly limits the publication of creative content, and that the negotiation rates are basically a form of economic oppression as they stand.