8 ms·
Tesla messes with Texas over how to sell its electric cars
- wroman 14y agoOf course Tesla still looking out for own interests and not attempting to enable directo-to-consumer for all vehicle types.
- blktiger 14y agoThere is a good chance that a bill enabling direct-to-consumer for all vehicle types would not pass.
- wroman 14y agoSure and I'm not suggesting that Tesla should pursue such a goal. My point was merely that Tesla has its own interests at heart, just like most businesses.
- thezilch 14y agoOf course, indeed. How many impossible feats do you expect Tesla -- Elon Musk -- to tackle on behalf of humankind? I can't imagine why you think Musk should fight for an industry he does not believe in, of course!
- wroman 14y agoEveryone involved in the game is selfish; none of this has to do with altruistic goals.
- eswangren 14y agoWhat a ridiculously naive comment. First, why should tesla take up this cause? They're trying to run a bush was, it makes no sense to do/spend any more tha. They have to. Second, you obviously do not understand the practicalities involved in passing a piece of legislation. If it doesn't pass then you gain nothing. Better to fight a battle you can win.
- cobrausn 14y agoMore accurate title would be 'Tesla and Elon Musk work with state lawmakers to enable direct-to-consumer auto sales', but alas, the link bait must flow. Either way, I hope this works. I would seriously love to see some Teslas on the road here.
- Flemlord 14y agoActually it's pretty much a Tesla-only bill: the new bill is pretty narrowly specific for a company like Tesla. [The bill] permits U.S.-based companies that make 100 percent electric cars (so no hybrids) to sell directly to customers.
- protomyth 14y agoThis would be the only reason I would want it voted down / vetoed. If you enable this for electric, it should be enabled for every other car manufacturer.
- thezilch 14y agoAre you opposed to iteration? Opposed to the bill passing -- believe dealerships would let it pass? Tesla has to potentially wait orders of magnitude longer while a battle they don't care about ensues -- dealerships versus gas-automobile manufacturers?
- protomyth 14y agoI'm opposed to treating manufactures of automobiles and the automobiles themselves[1] differently. So, I guess that means I would want it to apply to all (since there are other ideas for alternate energy cars) or none. 1) I am still waiting for the equivalent of a "gas tax" on energy used by electric cars to pay for the roads
- thezilch 14y agoLet's be clear that I and likely Musk -- Tesla -- are not opposed to equal things being equal. I honestly don't know the history and the inner-workings of why automobile manufacturers are barred from selling their goods directly to consumers. If I can liken the music/movie/etc industry to the automobile industry, I can understand why Tesla would not want to wait years, decades, forever? to stave off dealerships, if they don't have to. In all likelihood, the gas-automobile manufacturers are just as likely to be OPPOSED to this bill, if they think it will make Tesla go away and they can continue to get kickbacks from dealerships.
- scragg 14y agoWhy is there a law the prohibits sales of any product directly from the manufacturer to the customer?
- pc86 14y agoBecause every car dealership in the country would immediately go out of business and cars would be a decent percentage cheaper. Not saying that's a good reason, just pointing out there's a lot of money and interest in keeping the status quo, as there always is.
- old-gregg 14y agoActually I believe the law does not prohibit the manufacturers to sell directly to consumers, it requires the seller to be located in Texas. A subtle, but important difference. I believe the original reasoning for this was to prevent sales tax avoidance by purchasing cars out of state. This was pre-Internet.
- vonmoltke 14y agoNo, they do prevent exactly that. In Texas, car manufacturers are not allowed to have company stores, only franchisee-run dealerships.
- bd_at_rivenhill 14y agoStates will typically enforce payment of use tax at the time of vehicle registration for vehicles which were recently bought in another state and for which no sales tax was paid. This happened to me when I moved to Pennsylvania right after I purchased a car. This is one of the few places where use tax laws are not simply a laughable attempt to shame people into paying sales tax on out-of-state purchases. Texas has better tools to prevent sales tax avoidance in this case; the laws exist to protect dealers from having to compete with manufacturers. I suspect that a seller located in Texas may also not be a wholly-owned subsidiary of a company based in another state.
- mcguire 14y ago
- daniel_solano 14y agoThis is the same state where car dealerships are only allowed to be open one day of either Saturday or Sunday. There was recently a proposal to get rid of this law, but it failed. Who was one of the biggest proponents of the status quo? The Texas Automobile Dealers Association. It's yet another example of where government is used to protect special interests.
- jlgreco 14y ago> only allowed to be open one day of either Saturday or Sunday. Hmm, jewish-friendly blue law? I understand (and disagree with) "closed on sunday" laws, but how did that sort of law come into being?
- danielweber 14y agoBecause auto-sellers don't want to work both days of the weekend. Let's say I run a liquor store. I get together and collude with all my liquor store running buddies and pass a law that says liquor stores can't be open after 5pm. Ta-da, we all get to go home at 5pm. We don't lose any sales to people open after 5pm, because no one is allowed to do that. And if someone wants alcohol after 5pm, fuck 'em.
- qdog 14y agoTexas had a bunch of restrictive laws about Sunday called blue laws, the last one left is for liquor sales. Used to be you couldn't sell cars at all on Sunday, but they added this "either or" clause a few years ago for some reason. Dealers claim having to be open 7 days a week would drive up costs...go figure. http://www.texastribune.org/2011/03/11/why-cant-i-buy-a-car-or-liquor-on-sundays/ http://www.texastribune.org/2011/03/11/why-cant-i-buy-a-car-...
- geon 14y agoIt always baffles me how The Land Of The Free (TM) has laws that are so clearly anticompetitive. Same thing with Uber and the special taxi law, or the city sponsored DSL monopolies that seems to be the norm in the US.
- rayiner 14y agoIn the U.S., except for a relatively small stretch around the turn of the 20th century, freedom has never overlapped much with libertarian economic "freedom." The whole concept largely post-dates the founding (remember, Adam Smith was a contemporary of the founding fathers, and his ideas wouldn't turn into modern free-market principles until much later). I'm sure at some point it was perceived that it was beneficial for Texas to force sales through Texas franchises rather than allow out of state car manufacturers to sell directly to Texas citizens. The state-affiliated monopolies are a different situation. They exist because state and local governments wanted something for nothing. They wanted taxi services to serve poor people and far-flung parts of cities, and they wanted telecom services to do the same. In a free market, all these service providers wouldn't do that--they'd focus their efforts only on the most profitable areas. So the governments reached a bargain: the companies agree to serve everybody, and in return they get a monopoly. That's why Uber isn't allowed to "compete" with the local taxi companies--those taxi companies get a monopoly in exchange for their willingness to venture into the Bronx. Take a look at airfare. It's dramatically more expensive to fly from Richmond, VA to Eugene, OR than from New York, NY to San Francisco, CA, even though both trips are roughly the same distance. But cab fares are uniform (per mile) throughout a government's service area, as are utility rates usually. How does this happen?
- yason 14y agoWhy can't they establish a dealership company of their own that sells only Tesla cars? If the dealership company must not be owned by the car maker they can certainly arrange the owners of the Tesla dealership to be something else. Am I missing something?
- dsfasfasf 14y ago>>Am I missing something? Yes. Tesla would have to license to other dealers which is what it doesn't want to do.
- eumenides1 14y agoWhat an intersting proposal. The car dealerships should technically oppose it, because what this creates is a hole in their monopoly. It's not a big hole, but its enought to drive a car right through :) Also, the proposal also creates another monopoly for Tesla. Until there is another fully electric car maker, Tesla is the only dealership is town. If Tesla can generate enough sales. Who can take them on in Texus without offering a fully electric car? If Tesla can't generate sales, then who cares about electric cars.