8 ms·
Arguably we've had "fusion drive" for spaceships ever since Project Orion. Very simply, build a ship with a big shield in the back, throw nuclear bombs out beh
by rdl 14y ago
Arguably we've had "fusion drive" for spaceships ever since Project Orion. Very simply, build a ship with a big shield in the back, throw nuclear bombs out behind the ship, detonate, the shock and radiation hits the plate (some ablates, but it's still fairly study and safe), and some kind of shock absorber system pushes the spaceship forward. Repeat. You can feasibly get to 0.10c with this, using 1960s technology, and really big ships.
I think most of the earlier designs involved fission bombs, but there's no reason you couldn't use fusion bombs, and maybe even some kind of laser or magnetic means of initiating fusion. Which seems to be exactly what UW is talking about here.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsi...
A lot of the engineering and physiological problems of a Mars mission go away if you have the ability to move huge masses between Earth and Mars fast. You can skip the low energy launch windows and just go for a short on-Mars trip, rather than needing to loiter for a year or two between windows. You don't need to worry about supplies in space and radiation issues for a year-long transit. etc.
- n0mad01 14y agoand you think that getting x nuclear bombs into orbit is safe? and even when all bombs go into space without incidents, having them there until start is no risk neither? i think something more conventional would be better, even when less economically ...
- arethuza 14y agoI don't think anyone thinks it's a particularly practical idea these days - for the reasons you identify. However, it seems a bit of a shame that for all of the 2000+ nuclear weapons tests and tens of thousands of nuclear weapons built we never did anything as constructive as flying an Orion.
- berntb 14y agoYou can pack materials so that a failed launch will not create leaks. The real problems for the Orion are political and frying of satellite electronics, iirc.
- rdl 14y agoMostly political. You could presumably do the detonations with the moon in between for a while, and it's not like space outside the Van Allen belts is particularly low energy, either, so GEO satellites are shielded.
- daliusd 14y agoWell, combustion engine in my car is not very conventional either by XIX century standards. Maybe we should ride horses? Why you make assumption that bombs must be delivered to space vs constructed there from resources mined in asteroids?
- jff 14y agoPlutonium ain't easy, so you'd probably want to ship pre-made pits into orbit (we've got plenty already made), preferably one at a time so we don't get a big critical mass of plutonium sitting in a desert in case the rocket crashes.
- CapitalistCartr 14y agoPlutonium is a synthetic element, requiring a nuclear reactor to create, then must be purified. Uranium is currently unknown in asteroids, and even if it were found would require refining with thousands of large centrifuges. Converting uranium to uranium hexafluoride, centrifuging it over and over, then converting it back requires massive industrial facilities, currently impossible in space.
- daliusd 14y agoWhat about moon? I'm pretty sure that smart people will figure out the solution. I just wanted to point out that most probably we can find solutions that are safe enough and the only limiting factor is our imagination (or lack of it specifically).
- ewolf 14y agoWhy wouldn't it be safe? Nuclear bombs don't just explode by accident or when they are hit by something, they need to be deliberately triggered, so I wouldn't estimate the danger of this to be very big. Furthermore, nuclear weapons have been sent to space before, both for regular long-range missiles and for EMP-like tests.
- jerf 14y agoAs others point out, nuclear bombs do not spontaneously go off. If they were that easy to accidentally trigger, building them would be no big deal and we wouldn't be talking about nuclear vs. non-nuclear countries to this day. Furthermore, everything is space is already a weapon. The very act of being in space and not falling back to Earth means you are loaded up with enough kinetic energy to be going several miles per second. You don't need nuclear bombs to be a weapon in space, a bucket of sand is a deadly weapon. Militarization of space refers to things other than merely putting "big bombs" in space, where they are surprisingly useless. (Even the EMP is less useful than you'd think; space is already a sea of radiation so everything up there is already hardened against it.)
- ars 14y agoYou won't have an EMP in space - the EMP is generated by the motion of intensely electrically charged pieces of atoms acting against the magnetic field of the earth, and by electrons that were launched from atoms by the gamma ray pulse. There is a solar magnetic field, but it's much weaker, so wouldn't make much of an EMP, and there is no atmosphere is space so the gamma rays don't accelerate any electrons.
- schiffern 14y agoYou won't have EMP in deep space. Earth orbit is still "space". High-altitude nuclear explosions (which produce the most intense EMP) work better above the Kalman line: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:High_altitude_EMP.gif http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:High_altitude_EMP.gif There are also special EMP weapons that don't require nuclear explosions.
- ars 14y agoThat graph tops out at 300km, but even LEO is 2,000 km. (Although you can orbit as low as 160km - why would you for this?) And I've never heard of a Kalman line and google comes up with nothing.
- 14y ago
- podperson 14y agoSurely that's like saying we've had nuclear submarines since Jules Verne wrote "20,000 leagues under the sea" insofar as Project Orion was little more than science fiction and didn't involve fusion drives ("atomic bomba" would be fission). (Verne's Nautilus was powered by primitive batteries.)
- mchouza 14y agoProject Orion was much more than science fiction (http://www.scribd.com/doc/28668567/Nuclear-Pulse-Space-Vehicle-Study http://www.scribd.com/doc/28668567/Nuclear-Pulse-Space-Vehic...) though it was much less than operational. Very big Orion spaceships would have used fusion explosions (http://galileo.phys.virginia.edu/classes/321.jvn.fall02/Dyson.pdf http://galileo.phys.virginia.edu/classes/321.jvn.fall02/Dyso...), but not the relatively small ones that were subjected to detailed analysis.
- podperson 14y agoYou say "conceptual design" and I say little more than science fiction. Potato, potato -- some kind of solid fuel rocket is going to lift a shield strong enough to protect a crew with 90 days of "emergency" supplies from small stomic bombs going off... Right. And this is for a lunar mission! There's more detailed stuff out on the warp drive NASA has funded study on, meanwhile the grandparent made it sound like someone had built one of these things (only with fusion bombs) in 1952 and it was rusting in a shed somewhere.
- opminion 14y agoBy the way, it's worth pointing out, to those who want to make a judgement on the reasons project Orion could not be implemented nowadays, that nuclear detonations are effectively a modern tabu. This tabu is effective, has proven extremely useful (no detonations of nukes in a war since 1945) and thus cannot be considered the sign of a scientifically ignorant society. Having said that, Orion would be quite cool.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- panacea 14y agoDo you mean 'taboo', as in something that's considered off-limits due to cultural sensitivities? (Wondering out loud if the etymology is similar to voodoo and related suspicious stuff)
- rdl 14y agoWe've had hundreds (or thousands, if you count sub-design-yield) detonations since 1945, including several in space (Hardtack Teak and Orange, and USSR equivalents). And lots of them were for purely posturing purposes, with little scientific or direct weapons-testing value. The US probably could have pulled off something like Orion in the 1990s or maybe even today, since there's not a direct cold war threat. Domestic politics probably kill it, though, but if it were branded as "nuclear pulse drive" with sub-10kT pulses, it might be possible.
- btilly 14y ago
- duaneb 14y agoThen we've basically been on the moon for centuries now. Just because we can theoretically build something with known physics doesn't mean we have e.g. the material knowledge to actually construct the spaceship. Also, there's this issue of slowing down, and of how to get that spaceship with that much fuel out of the atmosphere, and how to get that spaceship back.... I would say we have a long way to go before claiming we "have" a fusion drive in a spaceship.
- lifeformed 14y agoIt's pretty much like rocket jumping.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y ago> Arguably we've had "fusion drive" for spaceships ever since Project Orion. Very simply, build a ship with a big shield in the back, throw nuclear bombs out behind the ship, detonate, the shock and radiation hits the plate (some ablates, but it's still fairly study and safe), and some kind of shock absorber system pushes the spaceship forward. Repeat. You can feasibly get to 0.10c with this, using 1960s technology, and really big ships. I never understood how the blast alone can propel the ship. Don't you also need to eject mass from a nozzle to move forward - in which case, it's just like a regular jet, you just replace part of the fuel with nukes?
- cma 14y agoPart of the mass in the fuel in the bomb is converted to photons; photons are massless but carry momentum.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoI would never have thought about that. That just this is sufficient to push the ship forward is amazing.
- zalzane 14y agoThere's also the fissile material involved, but I couldnt tell you what proportion of the energy is disappated through heat and what proportion is dissapated in light. Everyone has seen the videos of the atomic bomb going off - that massive release of heat and energy that literally vaporizes mass that is close to the epicenter. Now imagine that reaction in space where the heat can't be disappated through atmosphere, water, or earth. All of that energy has to go somewhere, so it's all stored in whatever fissile material is left after the bomb goes off and dissapated through light and radiation. I really wish I had some numbers for how hot that remaining material would get - even thinking about all the heat released in an atomic bomb concentrated into such a small amount of mass absolutely boggles the mind.
- Groxx 14y agoNozzles are basically just a more efficient version of this, since they don't waste as much energy which would escape out the sides (it's instead contributing to internal pressure, which pushes everything out the open end more quickly). Burning rocket fuel expands it rapidly, which is essentially all a bomb does. The downside to a nozzle is that you have to keep the internal pressure low enough that it doesn't rupture. This is far less of a problem with an Orion-style ship. Think of an explosion. They produce moving walls of compressed air that flings stuff around. Though this is just because it's in air, it's a lot of energy. The same amount of energy is still being released if you blow it up anywhere else. (ignoring bonus 'free' energy from e.g. burning the air itself) Take the explosion out of air, and you still have a 'shock wave' from the material which made up the bomb, and electrons / photons / whatever else materialized from that much energy being released in a tiny space. And it's all moving very quickly. When it hits your ship's back-end, it gives it a kick. Obviously far less than the total energy released (whatever % of the sphere of expanding energy which your ship covers), but still something. If the explosion is big enough, or close enough, you are still talking an immense 'kick'. And since you have no relatively-fragile nozzle (just an arbitrarily big, thick wall), the force can be many many times greater than a normal rocket. So to make it survivable, you probably need a big ship and some kind of impact-absorber to take the shock out of it, and / or lots of small bombs that won't kill everyone due to acceleration. Or just get rid of the squishy humans and crank up the proximity / bomb size to whatever you feel like.