15 ms·
NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 days
- mschuster91 14y agoI really hope this works out! But the real question is: could this be used for atmospheric thrusters on Earth?
- rurounijones 14y agoBased on the amount of thrust it produces for the weight of the machine, not a chance. Only works in an environment with very low friction. i.e. space
- mschuster91 14y agoWhat is the thrust it generates, anyway? The article and the NASA homepage didn't state a value
- exDM69 14y agoThe article didn't mention numbers about the expected thrust of the engines, but it gave some ballpark figures to do estimates with. The engine fires for three days to set up a mars transfer orbit. Contrast this with the trans-lunar injection with the S-IVB rocket that was used in the Apollo program, which fires for 350 seconds. Mars is a lot farther away than the moon, but this was the only figure I could find with a quick wikipedia search.
- Someone 14y agohttp://www.nasa.gov/pdf/636883main_FDR_talk_NIAC_2012_final.pdf http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/636883main_FDR_talk_NIAC_2012_final...., slide 15 says 0.38 kg/kW for a 30 day trip (some hand waiving included) That sounds powerful to me. However, they also talk of pulse rates of 14s to 3m (slide 19). I guess you will have to divide that power output by some duty cycle (corrections welcome; I only browsed the PowerPoint, and wouldn't understand it, anyways)
- stuff4ben 14y agoThanks for that link! Very good info on there about the mission parameters and the actual science behind getting to Mars using this propulsion technology. After reading Red Mars (thanks to whomever recommended that book in a previous HN post) I'm stoked that we are THIS close to getting a mission to Mars. If someone like Elon Musk (you knew someone was going to mention him) could fund this...he has the rockets to get to the space station, he could build the ship to get to Mars from there...
- james4k 14y agoWhy not? Aren't rocket-fueled thrusters much heavier due to the weight of the fuel alone?
- mschuster91 14y agoThe four engines of an Airbus A380 provide 311 kN of thrust each, so roughly 1.2 MN or 100 tons of thrust, where the aircraft itself weighs ~500 tons (MTOW-payload). Biggest weight point is the fuel with 320 tons... I wonder how much fuel is needed for the same energy output as the A380 engines.
- WhaleBiologist 14y agoPretty much. More mass to lift = more fuel = more mass = more fuel etc., plus burning fuel isn't the most efficient way of getting kinetic energy into the thing you are lifting. I would say it is unsuitable for atmospheric engines because of the way it runs. Earth to Mars in 30 days will need you to be travelling at almost 90 km/second. The engine has to fire for 3 days straight because the delta v you need is retardedly high, so it pulses the engine once a minute so that the passengers don't die and the ship doesn't break up due to huge g-forces. Lifting something into orbit needs to be done fast, because most of your energy is spent counteracting gravity, not air resistance. A slow pulsing engine would not be enough to get you up.
- omegant 14y agoThree days of hammering impulse is not going to be fun!
- mschuster91 14y agoI guess you won't feel the pulsing that much...
- danielbarla 14y agoThere's a trade off between how efficient a thruster is, and how much power it produces over a fixed amount of time. (Good reading is the specific impulse article on Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_Impulse http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_Impulse ) At any given point, our technology allows us to create highly efficient but relatively "weak" engines (e.g. ion thrusters), or "powerful" but inefficient ones (e.g. rockets). Actually, both use Newton's second law to generate thrust, i.e. some kind of material has to exit the engine in the opposite direction, in order to get things moving. So, even ion drives and similar designs carry some material for the purpose of being ejected, it's usually just on a completely different scale to rockets. Energy also needs to come from somewhere to facilitate this, with rockets, it's the chemical energy from the fuel itself. With ion drives, it is usually some form of electricity, generated with a solar panel or nuclear power plant, etc. So in reality, even the efficient drives also have to carry some way to power themselves. To get more thrust, they need to have more power. If you run the maths, by the time they have enough power to overcome Earth's gravity, they need to have an entire solar farm worth of panels (which are heavy), or a rather large nuclear power station on board (which is also quite heavy). So, unless we find ways to make more powerful sources of energy, or even more ridiculously efficient drives, the thrust coming from these will not be able to overcome near-Earth gravity.
- lutusp 14y agoSomething is rotten in Denmark. If this project achieves a sustained fusion reaction as claimed, that represents a huge breakthrough, and not just for space propulsion, but for the general topic of fusion power. If it succeeds, it would sweep away all present fusion reaction prototype methods, including the well-tested but so far ineffective( * ) tokamak and laser-fusion approaches. * By "ineffective" I mean none of them has reached the break-even point, that point where more energy is released than is required to initiate the reaction in the first place. The article doesn't say whether the prototype device has actually succeeded in igniting a sustained fusion reaction. If it does, it would quickly move beyond its present goal of producing a more effective source of space acceleration and would answer some longstanding questions about fusion power itself. The fact that this isn't being discussed leads to my statement above -- something is rotten in Denmark. Either the project is overselling its possibilities, and/or it can't really achieve fusion break-even. Speaking hypothetically, if the device could produce a sustained fusion reaction with substantial power, it could be scaled up and used to propel a spacecraft to Mars in much less than 30 days. Assuming a sustained acceleration of 1 g, the hypothetical craft could accelerate for 1/2 the trip, turn around and decelerate for the other 1/2 of the distance, arriving at Mars with zero velocity. Apart from minimizing travel time, this hypothetical profile would prevent the bone loss that accompanies sustained time at zero-g. Making the above assumptions, and assuming that Mars is at a close approach point in its orbit, the travel time could be as little as ... wait for it .. 50 hours. Derivation: 1. Distance d (meters) for acceleration a (m/s^2) and time t (seconds): d = 1/2 a t^2 2. Time t for distance d and acceleration a, assuming 1/2 acceleration and 1/2 deceleration: t = 2 sqrt(d/a) 3. Result for Mars close approach (7.834e10 meters) and acceleration of 1 g: 49.64 hours. Again, speaking very hypothetically. I still think something is rotten in Denmark.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThe FDR is one of only ten projects to get Stage Two funding from the program. This $600,000 award will provide the proof-of-concept FDR system over the next 18 months, and a working spacecraft would be ready as soon as 2020, Pancokti predicted – but if NASA wanted to throw money at the project, this timescale could be cut. There's a lot of people on HN who could double that budget without blinking, he hinted.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoReading lutusp post, anyone on HN who got sufficient funds to double the budget, would also have learnt to look very closely at extraordinary claims with only ordinary evidence. Be nice if it was true, and one day I am sure it will be (I mean the Sun DES this all the time and not even a single Phd was involved)
- vectorjohn 14y agoI'm not saying this FDR is guaranteed to work or be the best idea, but I'm pretty sure lutusp is trolling or something. He is clearly not understanding any of the issues. Repeatedly he talks of needing to create a steady reaction, and talks about needing to meet the same requirements of a fusion electric generator. Neither of these things is proposed by the FDR project. It is pulsed, and it generates only kinetic energy (much like an H-bomb, relatively old and proven technology). Further, he talks of ion thrusters as an alternative, which would take months to get to Mars, whereas this is talking about 30 days.
- nnq 14y agoMaybe I misunderstand everything, but why couldn't such a system be use on Earth as fusion power plant? (it seems to produce more energy than is consumed to produce the fuel, right?)
- lutusp 14y ago> Maybe I misunderstand everything, but why couldn't such a system be use on Earth as fusion power plant? That was my question also (see my other post in this thread) -- if they really achieve fusion break-even (i.e. produce more power than they require to start the reaction) then they have done something that many decades of fusion research have so far failed to achieve. If their device can really do what they claim, it has implications far beyond the described project.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI am not validating these sources but suggest that there is a known approach that collapses aluminium over a core deuterium tritium. It is not self sustaining, but it generates some net positive energy, thus enough I guess to throw a pellet out the door http://www.alternative-energy-action-now.com/general-fusion.html http://www.alternative-energy-action-now.com/general-fusion....
- lutusp 14y agoIf this method actually worked, I think we would all know by now. Achieving break-even in a controlled laboratory fusion reaction is the "holy grail" of fusion research and would produce instant worldwide headlines, not unlike the (ultimately false) claims made by Pons & Fleischmann, who thought they had achieved room-temperature fusion some time ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_fusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_fusion So I don't think so. It's a matter of how much a positive result would completely change the fusion research landscape. It's something that people would know about right away.
- emp_zealoth 14y ago
- dchichkov 14y agoLove to watch (and support with my money) all these low cost space propulsion projects. This kickstarter project http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2027072188/plasma-jet-electric-thrusters-for-spacecraft/posts http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2027072188/plasma-jet-el... was particularly amazing to watch. Best donation / entertainment money spent ever. And I hope B612 foundation would result in some great fun as well ;) Or not :) And another thing. And advice for kids looking for summer internships. Don't do these 'iPhone games' startups. Try something real, like NASA or Lockheed, or whatever. If you good, who knows, maybe a few lines of your code will have a chance flying into space.
- quahada 14y agoFormer aerospace, current iPhone app guy here. Each career path has its pros & cons. Working at a place like NASA or Lockheed lets you work on some very cool projects, often times you are working on some project that never sees the light of day (canceled due to budget cuts and what not). Also, the bureaucracy at large aerospace organizations can be stifling. Having said that, Space X seems like it offers the best of both worlds.
- dchichkov 14y agoI should have been slightly more precise, the advice was specifically about taking an internship in aerospace as a kid. I don't have any advice about having a career in aerospace industry... Haven't had one. I only had a short internship as a high school student at aero/space R&D company back in Russia. But that [aero/space R&D, not Russia ;)], I can highly recommend. I think actually, a more general advice is to take an internship in any high tech industry area in which a cost of software or design failures is very, very high.
- rdl 14y agoArguably we've had "fusion drive" for spaceships ever since Project Orion. Very simply, build a ship with a big shield in the back, throw nuclear bombs out behind the ship, detonate, the shock and radiation hits the plate (some ablates, but it's still fairly study and safe), and some kind of shock absorber system pushes the spaceship forward. Repeat. You can feasibly get to 0.10c with this, using 1960s technology, and really big ships. I think most of the earlier designs involved fission bombs, but there's no reason you couldn't use fusion bombs, and maybe even some kind of laser or magnetic means of initiating fusion. Which seems to be exactly what UW is talking about here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsi... A lot of the engineering and physiological problems of a Mars mission go away if you have the ability to move huge masses between Earth and Mars fast. You can skip the low energy launch windows and just go for a short on-Mars trip, rather than needing to loiter for a year or two between windows. You don't need to worry about supplies in space and radiation issues for a year-long transit. etc.
- n0mad01 14y agoand you think that getting x nuclear bombs into orbit is safe? and even when all bombs go into space without incidents, having them there until start is no risk neither? i think something more conventional would be better, even when less economically ...
- arethuza 14y agoI don't think anyone thinks it's a particularly practical idea these days - for the reasons you identify. However, it seems a bit of a shame that for all of the 2000+ nuclear weapons tests and tens of thousands of nuclear weapons built we never did anything as constructive as flying an Orion.
- berntb 14y agoYou can pack materials so that a failed launch will not create leaks. The real problems for the Orion are political and frying of satellite electronics, iirc.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoHmm, a little goggling gives a hint this may not be BS after all. I am unclear on the exact methods, but there appears to be existing research into generating a plasma "pinch" via compression of aluminium around a core of detrinium-tritium. This generates a massive magnetic-flux (which seems to be a result of actual fusion during the compression) and if it is held in a magnetic cage with an out at the back, you have propulsion. (1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinch_(plasma_physics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinch_(plasma_physics) (2)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compression_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compres... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compression_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compres...
- omegant 14y agoWhat kind of residues leaves that kind of engine? is it gas or solid? because small solids at that speed will surely make the earth orbit in a quite dangerous shooting range in no time. What is the expected coherence of a gas cloud flying that fast? Is it going to be dangerous? or will simply dissolve in to space. Would the material expelled fly away from earth orbit?. Sorry, too many questions..
- kristianp 14y agoMy guess would be that the products would be gases. Pinching a little ball of deteurium would make it very hot, and vaporise the metal that squishes it.
- omegant 14y agoAre gases dangerous at 30km/sec?. I mean, of course they are, but are they still dangerous in space?. Will the cloud keep more or less cohesive or will it disperse?
- chad_oliver 14y agoIt will disperse. Gas is made up of atoms going in many different different directions; even if some gas doesn't seem to be moving that's just a statistical average. Thus, in space all those different particles will fly off in different directions at 30km/sec. They'll be harmless in microseconds.
- ars 14y agoEven if it was solid, it's moving at 30 km/s - it won't stay in earth orbit - it won't even stay in solar orbit. But it's not a solar - way way too hot. It's a gas, mainly helium, and it's highly charged so it will just join the solar wind (which is moving at 400km/s).
- iwwr 14y agoThis is very early, preliminary research. Actual fruits of a manned or otherwise fusion rocket to Mars may be decades ahead. Even at NASA's slow pace they could get there by the 2030es (or 2020es if they listen to Zubrin). Edit: at 150 tons payload for low orbit (early estimate) it's not exactly easy to launch. If you can do that on a man-rated rocket you're all ready for Mars on just chemical propulsion (in a Mars-direct/Mars-semidirect scenario).
- quahada 14y agoNot even the Saturn V could launch 150 tons into LEO (though it could come close). No current rocket even comes close.
- Aardwolf 14y agoAlright count me in for this trip. At least if it includes a return ticket :)
- blisterpeanuts 14y agoIf it's in the 2040s or 2050s, and I'm into my dotage and pushing 100, I'll spring for a one-way. They can fill my return slot with someone younger, or bring home an extra 150lbs of Mars rocks.
- jbattle 14y agoThe once a minute firing of the engines feels like it'd be a very unpleasant sensation - I wonder what the momentary acceleration experienced would be. Also - this craft sounds perfectly suited for laser-transmitted power (rather than carrying a large solar array) - have one or more earth-orbiting lasers beaming energy to the craft. Though I'm not sure if we have the technology today to aim & focus a laser at that range (?)
- jes5199 14y agoI saw George Dyson give a talk about the Orion project - where they were planning to set off conventional atomic bombs in a series to propel spacecraft - and he had found a paper that had done the math and claimed that the crew of the spacecraft would only feel low-frequency sound, like the bass at a loud rock concert.
- elboru 14y agoColumbus took almost one month to pass through the Atlantic Ocean, who could imagine something like this even one century ago?
- Vivtek 14y agoFrom the article: Given the tight financial strictures of the US government this is unlikely This is what pisses me off about the last decade. Plenty of money to bail out the richest people the planet has ever seen. Plenty of money to kill brown people. Making a fusion drive? Making sure we all have medicine? Sheesh, we're not made of money!