3 ms·
The fact that someone was recommended by a chain of people doesn't mean that good, or even competent. Perhaps the old CTOs weren't competent to judge or didn't
by MBCook 14y ago
The fact that someone was recommended by a chain of people doesn't mean that good, or even competent. Perhaps the old CTOs weren't competent to judge or didn't have enough experience to have a proper baseline.
It's quite possible that I could judge someone at some task (say cutting & laying intricate tiles), and think they're quite good. They may seem fast to me because they're doing something that would take me forever. But if you brought in a real professional, they may laugh and say worker is going to slow.
The author said that the coder in question didn't show any improvement after 2 weeks of coaching. The developers at the previous firm he mentioned were slowly improving, that's why he kept them. From my reading I got the impression that if the PhD candidate had improved, he would still be there.