2 ms·
Nice post. (For the record, the simplification is understandable...I got my PhD in this stuff, so I'm not exactly the target audience.) I agree that convergen
by timr 18y ago
Nice post. (For the record, the simplification is understandable...I got my PhD in this stuff, so I'm not exactly the target audience.)
I agree that convergent evolution of protein folds seems unlikely to have happened frequently, but I'm not willing to dismiss it as impossible over the course of evolutionary time-frames. More importantly, I'm not willing to extend that idea to the conclusion that all protein folds must have been extant at the beginning of evolutionary history. There are simply too many ways for new protein folds to be produced -- and not necessarily by stepwise point mutations through stable intermediates.
You're right that PFAM isn't a structural classification system per se; they do what you describe a bit later, and build massive sequence profiles to detect homologies. But at the sequence identity levels used to build PFAM, you can safely assume that any sequence within a family that has a solved structure will probably share that structure's overall fold. The details will be different, but the fold will be conserved. That's really the point of PFAM (and why it has a symbiotic relationship with SCOP).
But here's the problem with drawing too many structural conclusions from sequence analysis: with state-of-the art algorithms, we can detect structural homologies out to about 25-30% sequence identity. Beyond that, we just don't know how to call two structures "similar" or "dissimilar", without having the structures themselves.
Point being, you can't really say that those 800-1300 "roots" of the evolutionary tree are independent starting points. All you can conclude is that our tools aren't good enough (or there isn't enough data) to trace back the evolutionary tree to the point where those "roots" may have converged.
For the record, I'm not trying to be pendantic or argumentative. This is one of those few fun debates that makes the field interesting. ;-)
- jballanc 18y agoThanks. I'm always game for a good debate. As I mentioned, my thesis-in-progress (T-minus 3 months...fingers crossed!) is in a related field (evolutionary dynamics/computational biochemistry), but I used to be more involved in protein structure/bioinformatics back in the day (worked, for a time, in the lab that maintains ecogene.org). The last debate I had regarding convergent evolution of protein folds got rather heated. This is one of those classic problems that can't be approached without some amount of hand-waving, and depending on which way you wave, you can arrive at different results. In some respects it boils down to Levinthal's paradox, except with evolutionary moves in place of topological ones. The one big unknown that you would need to find before you could make any sort of educated approach at the issue is what fraction of all possible protein chains of a certain size have stable, fast-folding structural minima. If that number is high, then short hops from one to the other could very likely result in convergence. As for the SCOP/PFAM part of the story, the 25-30% "twilight zone" for sequences yielding related structures has a counterpart with structures that are topologically related but with low (or I've even seen cases of essentially no) sequence identity. That is, if you look at a group in PFAM, then take all of the members with structures in that group, gather all of the corresponding SCOP groups, add the members from the SCOP groups, then for each of those look for related PFAMs or other sequences...essentially, what you're doing is a structure informed PSI-BLAST (sort of what ESPRESSO is to T-COFFEE). Now, if you attempt to fill the gaps from lack of structures by running each of your sequences through something like Skolnics TASSER threading algorithm, and using the best predicted folds to grow your group, this is how you can use distant sequence and structure homologies to construct "master" fold groups. This is, roughly speaking, how the 800-1300 number is arrived at. Admittedly, the more structures we solve and genomes we sequence, the better this sort of technique will get. In many ways, this is biology's analog to cosmology and the big bang: we can look further and further out into space, but at some point, we can know what happened any earlier than some small time after the big bang without recreating those conditions. Likewise, we can sequence and solve more structures, but I don't doubt that at some point we will hit a wall and need to start attempting to recreate abiogenesis. Interesting times!