4 ms·
It would have been discriminatory if there was no reason to charge them for being obese other than the fact that they are obese. This is different - it literall
by gambiting 14y ago
It would have been discriminatory if there was no reason to charge them for being obese other than the fact that they are obese. This is different - it literally costs the airline more to fly if you weight 50-60kg over the average. Your car uses more fuel as well, that's why he gave this example - roughly 0.5L/100km for every additional 50kg inside the car. It's not a discrimination thing, it's just technical fact that the airplane uses more fuel the more you put in it.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoYou are conflating unfairness with discrimination, but they are unrelated concepts. E.g. you might want to discriminate between smokers and non smokers in assigning health insurance premiums. This would be fair, but it would still be discrimination. Not discriminating would be unfair in that smokers are more likely to have health problems.
- mpyne 14y agoI think you're correct, but I also think that the comments you were replying to were taking "discriminatory" in the sense that it was actually meant in the original comment, which complained of this being "unnecessarily discriminatory".
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoWord choice makes it very difficult to determine what the original comment means, which is why I brought it up.